Three children approach you with a wooden flute. The three children cannot agree on who is the rightful owner of the flute, so they decide to ask you to choose one of them.
Child A claims the flute is rightfully his because he is the one who crafted it with his own two hands. Child B says he deserves to have the flute because he is poor and has no other toys, whereas the other two children are very rich. Child C insists that he is best suited to own the flute because he is the only one who actually has musical talent, and will therefore make the best use of the flute.
Who do you give the flute to, Sup Forums?
Gabriel Moore
I keep it myself.
Cameron Jones
A, how is this even a question? Unless there is some other information being withheld from us he's the only one with a claim to it.
Caleb Peterson
i sell it to the highest bidder
John Rodriguez
It's mine, I'm bigger than children.
Carson Barnes
Snap it in half and show them my much prettier flute.
Lucas Lee
A, Anyone who says otherwise is retarded.
Josiah Taylor
Child A crafted it, and it is therefore his property.
The circumstances of child B give him no claim on it. Likewise, the talents of child C do not justify appropriating it.
Michael Phillips
B, according to actual ethics
Caleb Price
the one with the best boi pucci
Xavier Kelly
This. /thread
Andrew Harris
A, of course.
One is entitled to the product of his own labour.
Thomas Bennett
A, unless he sold it to B or C. This is retarded.
Brandon Wood
A, (Assuming the children are telling the truth)
David Cox
I'd kidnap the flute and ask for a ransom from the rich kid's parents.
Eli Rogers
...
Jonathan Peterson
Obviously it belongs to the first kid.
Blake Martinez
ask child A to make 2 new flutes together with child B, while child C will teach both of them how to play their flutes for his own one.
all 3 of them will be richer than just having a flute at the end and bonded some deeper friendship.
Luis Smith
Child A. Now if he wants to, he can put it up for sale in a voluntary exchange of goods so that another person may make use of it. Everything has a price, goods are not made for free.
Jaxon Sanchez
A, although I honestly don't think C is a terrible choice.
B is a faggot, though.
Blake Cox
Break the flute in 3, give them each a piece and tell them sharing is better than having nothing.
Sebastian Young
There is only one person who owns it and it's the person who made it. All others are cucks who wanna steal his hard work.
Kevin Carter
>B
The other two kids can just buy or make more flutes.
Jaxson Bailey
flute always win
Oliver Thomas
break the flute over child b's head and tell child a and c to drag him off my property, with haste.
Joshua Evans
First post best post
Colton Martin
Why would the answer not be A.
Jayden Smith
instructions unclear upload reddit tier meme riddle to Sup Forums and wait for (yous)
Grayson Rogers
This. It's not even hard to think. B and C is trying to steal. If one of them payed for the flute it's another story.
Austin Russell
...
Evan Russell
A
Ryder White
Stick it in my asshole. See who laughs. The kid who cries gets the flute.
Mason Torres
Me, since they gave me the flute to give to one of them without a binding contract I can choose to keep it.
Now I sell it.
Cameron Moore
Ahh, typical right-wing, capitalist scum. I respect your opinions, however.
A, he made it and therefore has the sole right to ownership.
This is a retarded question.
Tyler Gutierrez
A, obviously. Anything else is Marxism.
Brody Butler
this is a nice answer
from a realistic pov, A isnt going to give a fuck about his flute a week later B is clearly a nignog C is the only one with reason to use the flute
James Bennett
If I am forced to choose, and the claims of each individual child are not contested by the others, then I'd give Child A the flute.
Elijah Brown
We'll then Aristotle is a faggot.
Kill those who violate the NAP
Sebastian Miller
sorry for the shitty get
Evan Turner
What do you say?
Josiah Nguyen
...
Ian Morris
| |> | |3 |
Have your (you), kike.
Luis Reed
>Call someone scum >I respect your opinions
If he made it he is the only one with a right to it.
What is his justification?
You can fuck off.
Luis Collins
Why can't I tell them all to screw off and keep it for myself?
Austin Miller
It doesn't say that you can't.
Nicholas Gray
Underrated
Parker Moore
A made the flute so it belongs to him. Most likely he will sell the flute to C so he can see his creation being used. Fuck B.
Austin Mitchell
Child B. He is the least fortunate of the group and deserves the flute, as the other two can just purchase new ones.
Robert Sanchez
How can I believe any of them? I just walk away and carry on with my day.
Kayden Miller
The guy who built it
Get your filthy greedy peasant hands off his shit you fucking peasants. Make your own.
Aiden Perez
So everyone less fortunate than I is entitled to my belongings? Whenever I craft something, does a poor person have a right to steal it?
Alexander Wilson
cuck
Leo Robinson
>MINDBLOWN The right answer right here. /Thread
Charles Evans
Said like a true leaf
Josiah Reyes
I don't like children. I'd probably just laugh nervously and walk away.
Matthew Cruz
...
Julian Green
>property owner >gibs me dat nigger >I deserve free college because I'm better then everyone else libcuck
Well this IS a tuffy....
Juan Morales
Whoever is holding the flute.
Benjamin Collins
>steal flute >the flutes parents (kids hands) get scared >his hands pay a ransom >use money to buy three more flutes >hand them out >easy
plot twist
>steal all 5 flutes again and collect another ransom to buy more flutes
Austin Howard
Youngest of 3. I'm top right, the oldest is bottom left, the middle listens to me but doesn't give much of a fuck, so is kind of bottom right.
Parker Rogers
Who gives a shit about a flute I've got 3 new prostitutes.
Christopher Williams
lel
Noah Edwards
>AM I BEING SOLICITED?!?! DONT TRED ON ME
Levi Cooper
Is a man not entitled to the sweat of his brow?
Kevin Cooper
A is a crafter, not a flute player C is supposedly already playing aa specific instrument
Leaves B with the flute. He can help a building better flutes and learn together with C. It's a potential win/win/win situation
Joseph Rivera
child A
Blake Gonzalez
Invite the 3 kids over for pizza and say you think you're hot shit don't cha
Luis Jones
>violating the NAP You push the kids into meth and THEN get them to willingly hand over their bodies for more.
Dominic Williams
Not what I said. When one has great wealth, they can afford to sacrifice some of their belongings to the less fortunate. It's how it works in first world countries.
Christian Reyes
switch top right with bottom right
Ian Ortiz
>force child A to make 999 more flutes >force child C to impregnate 1000 women to spread his musically talented seed >listen to beautiful symphony performed by eugenics children's orchestra while child B starves to death
Angel Scott
They probably don't get along. You are assuming they will cooperate.
You are overthinking it.
If you make something, you ought to own it unless it's been established that you are making it for someone.
Your logic is shit anyway.
A being a crafter doesn't mean he can't own a flute. C owning an instrument has nothing to do with this.
You aren't clever.
Benjamin Wood
...
Camden Scott
Child A. Tell him to make more flutes and sell them and have a giveaway that is predetermined for some of the poor for marketing purposes. Be sure to give flutes to the richest so the poor and middle class want them, too.
Cooper Myers
If you care about B, why give him A's flute. Just buy him another flute with your money, not A's
Nolan Martin
Snap it into thirds and give a piece to each of the children. Throw any of them in the gulag if they complain.
Daniel Wood
You still have to benefit society in some way.
Cameron Turner
God damn it Justin...How did you get past the parental lock?
Wyatt Brown
So what you're saying is Child A already owns it but the other 2 just want it? yeah no fuck off twats make your own flutes
Carter Bennett
I make them fight to death for it.
If any of them decline, then they didn't want it enough.
Whoever kills the others had strong blood and will benefit humanity.
Josiah Garcia
They can afford to make the sacrifice, sure. But that doesn't mean you make a sacrifice for them, you dumbass.
What I said was pretty spot on to what you are saying.
Ultimately you shouldn't get to make the fucking call.
And no, it isn't how it works in first world countries appart from a small amount of tax payer dollars being spent on welfare. That's different than this. In no first world country is your physical property given to someone else because a stupid fucker like yourself wants to make the "right choice" for everyone.
>>>/leftypol/
Lincoln Anderson
...
Aiden Powell
>y-you too,
Isaac Harris
Because there's more to gain and to loose than a flute depending on the decision.
Aaron Fisher
...
Connor Robinson
Child A deserves the flute.
If children B or C desire the flute, they must offer something in exchange for it. One does not simply steal in a right or wrong scenario.
Hunter Jackson
>thinking the children are all white It's obviously an allegory, the white man is the builder, the nigger the poor fag and the Asian the autist who was forced by his parents into flute lessons
Ayden Miller
marxism: those who produce should keep it. a marxist should chose A since giving it to other without consent would be exploitation of labour.
Dominic Sanchez
A
B should have crafted it himself. What the state needs to give him is the ability to craft one himself
C should rent A's, giving him a some of what he earns through performing with it
Oliver Hughes
Stupid fucking question. A
Aaron Bell
Kick B in the ass repeatedly for being a whiny bitch, and tell him to go to work. The flute is A, and he can sell it to C since they are both rich.
David Cox
How it the authoritarian right C?
How?
I suppose it depends but this doesn't sit right with me.
Jose Jenkins
>implying children are people They're just abortions that haven't happened yet, NAP doesn't apply.
Dylan Carter
B can suck a dick
Gabriel Allen
>Child C insists that he is best suited to own the flute because he is the only one who actually has musical talent, and will therefore make the best use of the flute. This is the Sup Forums viewpoint, what with their "muh white IQ" spiel. Prove me wrong.
Oliver Brooks
I can't decide between A or C. B can just die in a ditch though useless piece of shit.