Person points gun at you

Logan Gomez
Logan Gomez

person points gun at you
shoot him
self defense

Nazi chants in your neighborhood
punch him
not self defense

Explain this Sup Forums.

The person pointing a gun has not committed an act of violence just like the Nazi so why are you allowed to shoot him, but not the Nazi?

Logan Lopez
Logan Lopez

person endangering your physical safety
compared to
person endangering your feelings

really makes you think

Parker Torres
Parker Torres

Because what he says cant hurt you, you retarded leftshit snowflake: you literally just evoked Bush's argument for pre-emptively attacking Iraq, you fucking idiot.

Isaiah Murphy
Isaiah Murphy

They’re both rational judgements about the future. Neither have yet attacked you. You can assume both pose a threat to you.

What’s the difference?

Jaxon Allen
Jaxon Allen

Explain this Sup Forums.
The person pointing a gun has not committed an act of violence just like the Nazi so why are you allowed to shoot him, but not the Nazi?
stix n stones
may break my bones
but words
WILL NEVER HURT ME

show me certified instance of a person dying from hearing another person's words
mfw idiots can't tell the difference between a dangerous opinion and a deadly weapon

Brody Gomez
Brody Gomez

you cant be this fucking retarded. a gunpoint is a physical threat and is not protected under 1A and paltry verbal language is protected under 1A. Do i agree with it? no. But that doesnt mean it isnt free speech you clueless fuck.

Elijah Morris
Elijah Morris

he literally just shot me with the word nigger
This is why the world is laughing at you right now.

Brody Foster
Brody Foster

I’m saying is we have to make a judgement whether or not it will inflict future harm and merit self defense.

You cannot know for sure whether a gun pointed at you is a physical threat, you can only make a judgement.

You cannot know if a Nazi is not a physical threat, you can only make a judgement.

Both are present judgements of the future,

Zachary Scott
Zachary Scott

It’s not the imminent threat of a shout that we’re judging it’s the future possibility of judgement based on his thoughts and beliefs.

Mason Morris
Mason Morris

Thanks TMNT

Michael Adams
Michael Adams

Now this will never be a reality

Charles Perez
Charles Perez

niggers think they have to kill you because you talked shit
Maybe this is why nigger crime is multiples higher than other races, and why they don't belong in advanced white societies where people have protected free speech.

Charles Miller
Charles Miller

So why is it illegal to threaten to kill someone?

Leo Watson
Leo Watson

Why'd you punch him then?
What's that going to do?
If he's so dangerous you'd have to kill him

Aaron Cox
Aaron Cox

I think muslims want to kill me
muslim shows up at my door
shoot the muslim in self defense

this is how stupid you sound.

Jeremiah Cook
Jeremiah Cook

Ok, let's assume you have a point; however, by your logic, the anti-goyim sentiments in the Talmud justify the pre-emptive extermination of all Jews, and the anti-white statements of black panthers and other radical afro-centrists justifies the extermination or expulsion of blacks from white countries. Are you still sure this is logic you want to endorse?

Jackson Young
Jackson Young

By that same logic, I should be able to shoot-up every SJW and cultural Marxist event near me, because I'm a white male.

John Campbell
John Campbell

Are they Islamic terrorist Muslims chanting Allahu akbar death to all Jews?

Connor Evans
Connor Evans

because there is literally one century of legal precedent backing up the fact that we're right

going around pointing guns at people
vs
saying shit about how whites are superior
these are two totally separate things
the only time it crosses the line is when Nazis openly argue for the extermination of the Jews and try to convince people to do it. then that's a call to action which is, legally, a crime.

Benjamin Powell
Benjamin Powell

You cannot know for sure whether a gun pointed at you is a physical threat
What the fuck else could it mean you nong?
It's a gun not a fuckin birthday cake.

Jayden Edwards
Jayden Edwards

No. Jews never threatened anyone they only suffered under the holocaust.

Jayden Cruz
Jayden Cruz

threaten to kill someone
That's kind of the irony of our times, isn't it: whites say "you will not replace us" and you hear "lets kill all the niggers", then you think you're justified engaging in violence. Most of you are two stupid to see the leap you've been indoctrinated to make, because you're more racist than any white person ever will be.

Evan Lee
Evan Lee

tfw you will never virtue signal so hard that you draw a ninja turtle punching hitler while screaming "for the millions!"

Henry Evans
Henry Evans

Well it could be unloaded and therefore not a threat. You’re making a judgement of a future event.

Leo Jones
Leo Jones

I remember these comics. They were set something like 10 years or so in the future with edgier, more adult versions of the turtles.

Isaiah Ross
Isaiah Ross

No. Jews never threatened anyone

You dishonor Thoth with your lies, Schlomo.

Juan Scott
Juan Scott

fpbp /thread.

Sebastian Moore
Sebastian Moore

Jews never threatened anyone they only suffered under the holocaust
Obvious bait thread.

Cooper Collins
Cooper Collins

for the gorillions

Jaxson James
Jaxson James

2/10
C'mon buddy I just handed you a golden opportunity to crank the doublethink trolling up to 11 and you arsed it.

Noah Powell
Noah Powell

Israel doesn’t have enough nuclear weapons to destroy Europe.

Europe has enough nuclear weapons to destroy Israel.

Jace Jackson
Jace Jackson

Was everyone in the right wing rally calling explicitly for anyones death?

Brandon Rogers
Brandon Rogers

no. any muslim. a muslim comes to my door to preach about their religion and i shoot them in self defense because i think it will blow up.

Samuel Rogers
Samuel Rogers

Since they have exponentially more rallies, I fully support this.
OP you're a faggot btw. No (you). Just a sage.

Dominic Garcia
Dominic Garcia

Well it’s obviously wrong most Muslims are very peaceful people.

Kayden Martin
Kayden Martin

person hits your car with a bat
you run him down
not self defense
Really jogging my noggin

Nicholas Perez
Nicholas Perez

someone explicitly pointing a gun at you and threatening you
Vs
you assuming what someone maybe wants to do who is not called for death

By your logic Eric Harris committed self defence because he thought the entire school was out to get him

Jeremiah Smith
Jeremiah Smith

person intends to kill you
vs
person speaks

The only time speech is limited is when you are literally, directly inciting violence. Not supporting a violent ideology. Not insinuating violence. Actually saying that individuals or groups of people should be harmed or killed. This does not mean that speaking about ideologies or their talking points is illegal. It means that if Joe is up on the podium speaking to a crowd of people, it would be illegal for him to tell them that they ought to kill Tyrone, or that they should go kill every nigger they see. However, Joe is free to say that he thinks all niggers should be killed, because Joe isn't actually going to kill all niggers.

The law is this: your speech must present an imminent and likely danger to violate the law. You cannot tell people to go rob the 7/11 on Main Street if it's likely that they will do it. You cannot tell Frank to shoot Bob if it is likely that he will do it. You can say that you're going to gas every Jew on the planet because it's pretty unlikely that's going to happen any time soon.

A Nazi is as much protected in his free speech as a Republican, Democrat, or Communist, and while they may hate each other, they are all equal under the law because our government's purpose in free speech is to be as objective as possible because the limiting of a person's speech is immoral, no matter how much you might disagree with it.

Also, your bait thread is shitty, your posts are WAY too obvious, saying shit like all muslims are peaceful and Jews dindu nuffin. I know you'll just reply to me with another bait post, but I just want you to know I see right through you.

Jace Bailey
Jace Bailey

Israel threatened to nuke Europe
Europe has the right to nuke Israel now
Your own logic, friendo.

Nicholas Garcia
Nicholas Garcia

I guess they were right because he did really kill them. So they were acting in self defense because they rightly predicted his intent.

Cameron Barnes
Cameron Barnes

Speech isn't a wepaon you sperg

Samuel Perez
Samuel Perez

Your personal freedom ends where my feelings begin.
Also Hurt Feelings>Physical Violence

Jack Ross
Jack Ross

thats not the point. you dont attack someone for differing views. this isnt a complicated concept.

Eli Scott
Eli Scott

Should we be able to kill communists preemptively because of mao, stalin and pol pot?

Carson Moore
Carson Moore

I’m just wondering why inciting violence is a crime when they’re only words and you’re not committing violence yourself.

How can you place blame the actions of an individual because someone said something to him?

Julian Myers
Julian Myers

I guess you have to decide for yourself.

Josiah Ross
Josiah Ross

call everyone right of Bernie Sanders a Nazi
Hooray I get to punch everyone

Tyler Bennett
Tyler Bennett

it depends on how much you let words hurt you I guess

Gavin Gray
Gavin Gray

Pointing a gun at someone is a serious threat. Saying words you don't agree with is not.

Saged.

Connor Russell
Connor Russell

It’s a threat only because you believe you can predict the future.

Henry Miller
Henry Miller

If a speaker has a crowd of people in front of him that he's been getting riled up, and then tells them to go down the street, and drag people out of their homes and stab them to death, how has he not committed some fault? He's obviously played some part in those people's death, if not the major part.

Isaac Powell
Isaac Powell

no because he is a white man that has genetic instincts about the art of a duel

Mason Scott
Mason Scott

every time I start I fight I correctly predict that the other person is about to fight me

Jaxon Martinez
Jaxon Martinez

By calling others to action to commit illegal acts you are showing legal intent to commit a crime, with the assumption that you are willing to follow up on it.

Laws exist to punish anti-social actscombined with anti-social mindsets. Telling a room full of people to lynch the first nigger they see is a combination of both; telling a room full of people that it is your opinion that niggers by lynched is not illegal because there is no anti-social call to action.

William Stewart
William Stewart

Because there’s no causal relationship between the speech and the crime.

X committed speech
Y committed crime

Unless X forced Y to commit the crime it should solely be the fault of Y.

Justin Smith
Justin Smith

So we agree that speech is a predictive measure of future intent and that punching Nazis is justified.

Matthew Adams
Matthew Adams

Let's compremise and agree that you're retarded. Tell you what. Next time you see a Nazi in the street and he specifically points at you and yells to his friends "KILL THAT CUMM-GUZZLING FAGGOT", you're justified in defending yourself. If he's minding his own business in his SS uniform you aren't justified because that isn't how laws work.

Robert Jones
Robert Jones

Does the nazi have a gun?
NO
Does the other example have a gun?
Yes
So unless bad opinions can kill you, and they cant. You my good sir have a false equivalency on your hands

Good day

Michael Johnson
Michael Johnson

I’m not sure how the double-think works on this forum.

First speech can’t justify violence
Now speech can justify violence

I think you’re on a slippery slope.

Jaxon Perry
Jaxon Perry

Jesus you are fucking dense. YOU CAN ONLY INVOKE SELF DEFENSE WHEN SOMEONE IS ACTUALLY MAKING AN ATTACK ON YOU (Or causing others to do so). Someone looking scary IS NOT an attack on you.

Isaiah Ramirez
Isaiah Ramirez

also
forum
Back to r/socialism

Anthony Watson
Anthony Watson

MSW shoop

Jaxon Lee
Jaxon Lee

The act of pointing the gun is illegal, the chant is not.

Isaiah Howard
Isaiah Howard

How can speech cause someone to do a violent act?

Is it a magic hand of God?

Chase Cooper
Chase Cooper

Nazi chanting doesn't hurt anyone fucking dumbass

Landon Gray
Landon Gray

X says kill Y
Y kills Z

X is responsible for the death of Z?

What happened to free will and personal responsibility? How can speech make you kill someone?

Daniel Ross
Daniel Ross

ITT difference between make-believe and reality!

Isaiah Walker
Isaiah Walker

Lefties chant about massively migrate millions of third world people into you're country
shoot them
self defense because it threatens my well being in the future

Antfa shouts for revolution
shoot him
self defense because it threatens my well being in the future

BLM shouts "what do we want? dead cops! when? now"
shoot them
self defense because it threatens my well being and protection in the future

Make a peaceful demonstration against demolishing a memorial, then some commie punks come and chants about killing you
shoot them
self defense because it threatens my well being

Practically i agree with your autistic(anarchist) animal response to everything.
That's why i should kill every lefty in this country (because they threatened my well being in the future)

Dylan Lee
Dylan Lee

Nazi chants in your neighborhood
punch him
not self defense

The idea that Nazi Germany can happen anywhere at any time and that everyone must be eternally vigilant is retarded. It shows that you have not even the most basic understanding about what happened and the opposing forces that were at play, or the German political history prior to the period.

Besides, if I wanted to be disingenuous I could use and the same faulty reasoning to punch the first person I see supporting communism.

Julian Gray
Julian Gray

brandishing a weapon is a criminal act, pointing a loaded weapon at someone is even moreso, and our justice system deems it acceptable to act in a preventative capacity so long as the person defending themselves acts in a reasonable manner.

shouting unsavory chants at someone is not criminal, nor does it pose any physical threat to anyone, and therefore makes it unacceptable to retaliate with physical force. If anything, the act of physical force is violating someone's civil rights by intimidation.

Try again, as the label of master baiter eludes you.

Evan Garcia
Evan Garcia

Because that's some "guilty until proven innocent" type shit. Why should you not be arrested right now? You may be a criminal later on, might as well take you in before it happens.

John Garcia
John Garcia

Your family unit begins where my dicc ends. Raise my kid, whiteboi.

Caleb Phillips
Caleb Phillips

Threatening one's life with a gun equals to chanting ideological ideas in the street.
Suck a dick and choke on it, faggot. Even tumblrinas screeching landwales can't get this retarded.

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page