Sidonia no Kishi

Robert Thompson
Robert Thompson

What the fuck did I just read?

Why wasn't I warned?

All urls found in this thread:
http://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2016/05/09-1/tsutomu-nihei-publishes-one-shot-science-fiction-manga-ningyou-no-kuni
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UKXKUT4RWN4
Tyler Hall
Tyler Hall

I can't believe I wasted my whole day reading this garbage.

John Mitchell
John Mitchell

You should have felt a severe quality drop after the first 2/3.

Xavier Brown
Xavier Brown

Such fragility.

Jackson Kelly
Jackson Kelly

I did, but hindsight is 20/20. I seriously don't think I've ever been this angry at an ending, it's just so nonsensical

Nicholas Nguyen
Nicholas Nguyen

The end was crap but I have the feeling the only ones making a big deal out of it are Izana shippers and a few Yuhata waifufags. Sidonia started going to shit long, long before the final chapter was released.

Logan Flores
Logan Flores

It's not even that, it's just so fucking incomprehensibly stupid.

I love the penis tentacle
Penis tentacle dies
comes back to life as a human
has a HUMAN BABY
Yuhata is now a dude and banging Izana

I don't understand how anyone could think that makes any sense whatsoever.

Nolan Sanchez
Nolan Sanchez

I think the ending was fine.
Shippers can fuck off and cry to their mommies about how their favorite dickgirl lost against a tentacle monster.

Nathaniel Thomas
Nathaniel Thomas

Penis tentacle dies
comes back to life as a human
That one was cheap as fuck. From the way she died to how she was reintroduced.
has a HUMAN BABY
I want to believe that she was born in a lab.
Yuhata is now a dude and banging Izana
Yuhata wanting to bang Izana has been foreshadowed many times, Yuhata turning into a dude certainly is possible, Yuhata wanting to turn into a dude came out of nowhere.

Anyway, I wont' be buying the latest volumes.

Noah Cruz
Noah Cruz

I guess I'll read this just to figure out what the outrage is about

Logan James
Logan James

Yuhata wanting to bang Izana

Because she touched Izana's hand twice? Shitty foreshadowing if you can even call it that.

Isaac Evans
Isaac Evans

Fucking don't. Save yourself while you still can.

Zachary Lewis
Zachary Lewis

Not my fault you can't read subtext.

Jayden Taylor
Jayden Taylor

Forced happy end.

Jace Lee
Jace Lee

They had like 5 conversations throughout the entire series, at least two of which were when they were fighting over Nagate. Hardly subtext.

Xavier Gray
Xavier Gray

But user, I was making a fuss about the manga going to shit AND the ending.

Ryder Carter
Ryder Carter

Slow pokes don't deserved warning

Adrian Lewis
Adrian Lewis

did you rike it?

Jason Hill
Jason Hill

No

James White
James White

NO FUCK YOU NIHEI

10/10 troll though

Jason Ross
Jason Ross

How I imagine rushed endings like this.

Easton Gutierrez
Easton Gutierrez

Was being such a troll part of your plan?

Kayden Howard
Kayden Howard

Nihei confirmed troll

Asher Jones
Asher Jones

You didn't like the comedy penis, user?

Isaiah Diaz
Isaiah Diaz

Comedy penis should have stayed a comedy penis

Jaxon Hall
Jaxon Hall

Is this a meme? I really don't understand why people act as if Sidonias ending was some hellish trollfest.
MC gets his waifu back
secondary characters end up together
happy end
ASDFDF RAAAGE FUUUUUUCK
Seriously wat

Austin Gray
Austin Gray

see

Explain how that is competent storytelling.

Daniel Bell
Daniel Bell

Tsutomu Nihei can't end his stories.

Christian Lee
Christian Lee

I liked Blame's ending.

Daniel Wood
Daniel Wood

Tsutumo Nihei.
ASDFGHJKLÖÄ'

Daniel Reed
Daniel Reed

So you really can't read into subtext and needs shit to be spelled out to understand something.

Brandon Cox
Brandon Cox

I am not saying that the last chunk of Sidonia was some masterpiece but does it really justify all the overreaction it gets? Nihei played it save and went for a generic happy end, sure Yuhata turning into a dude was weird but why would you care after the initial 'wat'.

James Howard
James Howard

Because she was some anons' waifu.

Now they're gay.

Luke Perez
Luke Perez

WHAT, comrartie high got axed? thats a load of bullshit

Robert Jones
Robert Jones

A generic happy end is one thing, a nonsensical asspull that is nothing short of an insult to readers is another. I feel bad for the poor fucks who actually bought the tanks.

Juan Thompson
Juan Thompson

implying the entire manga wasn't a series of asspulls
come on brah

Jeremiah Butler
Jeremiah Butler

spelled out

No, if you're gonna go a certain way with the plot, at least give some basis for it happening. Suddenly making two characters who had no romantic interest in each other a couple (much less changing the gender of one to fit your asspull ending) is not good writing. Nor is it "subtext." It's just fucking stupid.

John Jenkins
John Jenkins

UCHIKUDAKE

Cameron Gray
Cameron Gray

Spelled out just for you.

Samuel Perez
Samuel Perez

NAITTSU OFFU SHIDONIA

Aaron Morales
Aaron Morales

How will you rate Nihei's next work?

http://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2016/05/09-1/tsutomu-nihei-publishes-one-shot-science-fiction-manga-ningyou-no-kuni

See pic related

Isaiah Reyes
Isaiah Reyes

I just hope the art is better than late Sidonia and the BLAME redraws.

Xavier Hall
Xavier Hall

We had the manga dump thread yesterday.

Zachary Johnson
Zachary Johnson

gets an alright ending
complains about it
Why would you do this?

Adrian Lopez
Adrian Lopez

alright ending
In what world do you live in?

Gavin Young
Gavin Young

I though MC was banging the captain. What the hell.

Wyatt Bailey
Wyatt Bailey

no build up or explanation
They did have that one scene, though.

Dylan Thompson
Dylan Thompson

Yet another nonsensical plot point that was overshadowed by the stupidity of the ending

Evan Cox
Evan Cox

DROPPED. Just like most of the interesting developments.

Isaac Wilson
Isaac Wilson

Is this inspired by Sealab 2021? Thats what the OP image makes me think

Jackson Jones
Jackson Jones

People misinterpreted that. It was never stated or shown in the series. A bunch of people just bought into a meme and assumed it was fact.

Jacob Mitchell
Jacob Mitchell

It was pretty heavily implied in the manga, user.

Owen Hall
Owen Hall

THREE DAYS

Parker Bell
Parker Bell

Changed to MANY DAYS in the tank.

Juan Sanders
Juan Sanders

And people still say Izana and Yuhata came out of nowhere even though Yuhata pretty much outright stated her attraction.

Aaron Cruz
Aaron Cruz

Yuhata pretty much outright stated her attraction.

Chase Brooks
Chase Brooks

What, you thought she was referring to Nagate in that scene?

Jaxon Martinez
Jaxon Martinez

You read a mangaka trolling his entire fanbase.

Zachary Hughes
Zachary Hughes

robots just don't get enough love
Absolute fact

Matthew Rivera
Matthew Rivera

You people can headhunt him at SDCC then.

Justin Parker
Justin Parker

People misinterpreted that
I remember some people misinterpreting Tanikaze kissing Tsumugi as "missing his step".

Dominic Gomez
Dominic Gomez

Everybody was winning so why can't you be happy about it?

Hunter Richardson
Hunter Richardson

"missing his step"
Yes, he did miss his step. But a clumsy kiss is still a kiss, like those teen movies.

Eli Mitchell
Eli Mitchell

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UKXKUT4RWN4

Leo Gomez
Leo Gomez

How will you rate Nihei's next work?
failed for art, Nihei forgot how to shade.

Any translations out yet?

Caleb Hall
Caleb Hall

I want to shake his hand and thank him for giving us so much Izana shippers butthurt.

Christopher Bennett
Christopher Bennett

Why wasn't I warned?

You didn't read thoroughly.

Christian Ortiz
Christian Ortiz

You see, I can kind of see the argument for Yuhata wanting the Izana. I don't agree but I can see it. What I don't see is any local reason for Izana to be into it. It feels like she's going along with it because everybody needs to be paired off, which is a problem when she's the most fleshed out character in the series.
That was an interesting couple of days. I think those reactions were more disbelief than anything.

Alexander White
Alexander White

I want to believe that she was born in a lab.
It is possible that Izana is the surrogate mother as well.
Yuhata wanting to bang Izana has been foreshadowed many times, Yuhata turning into a dude certainly is possible, Yuhata wanting to turn into a dude came out of nowhere.
Many here prefer a lesbian end. But a hetero end should be fine and expected within Niheiverse, shouldn't it?

Gavin Perry
Gavin Perry

It's not a matter of lesbian or straight, itsy just a gigantic thing to drop out of nowhere in the last three pages of a series with no buildup.

Angel Cox
Angel Cox

It had buildup, shithead, you just focused on Izana > Nagate instead of noticing how Yuhata's feelings were shifting in What's an asspull is the reciprocation but then again the same argument could be said about Izana and Nagate because Nagate has never indicated feelings for Izana beyond being his best friend.

Xavier Phillips
Xavier Phillips

Please user, show me the buildup for Yuhata wanting a cock and Izana wanting Yuhata's cock. I'm waiting. I have a feeling I'll be waiting a while.

Zachary Morales
Zachary Morales

So the problem isn't that Nihei wrote a shit ending, the problem is that the readers were a bunch of harem protagonists?

Juan Scott
Juan Scott

No, Nihei did write a shit ending.

Alexander Davis
Alexander Davis

fuck his new artstyle too

Aiden Williams
Aiden Williams

Can't you read? The asspull was the reciprocation. Yuhata had feelings for Izana but you can't even understand basic English so why would you understand subtext in visual storytelling.

Cooper Hernandez
Cooper Hernandez

My favourite character lost to a penis
Not even in the H-Manga manner either
Is now getting mating pressed by a cute girl that suddenly grew her own penis to combat the talking penis
He's not even hot, letalone cute anymore.
My second favourite died already. Like near the start.

I don't even one if I want to finish this anymore.

Elijah Allen
Elijah Allen

comrartie high got axed?

Like 10 years ago bud
axed 2006

Landon Adams
Landon Adams

Yuhata had wanted Nagate's cock for a while til she realized she couldn't beat Penis-chan.

Izana just wants a good man.

Ian Brown
Ian Brown

I amdit being an Izana fag but the story did degrade a lot since it started focusing on Tsumugi a lot. Sure, Nihei doesnt explain stuff but there were a lot of wasted character and moments and that skip to fairytale ending was just horrible.

Daniel Butler
Daniel Butler

How will you rate Nihei's next work?
/m/thread/14213115#p14213115

Connor Mitchell
Connor Mitchell

set in a snowy planet
Another lame excuse to use less black ink again.

Jeremiah Clark
Jeremiah Clark

It was dumped on Sup Forums a few days ago.
Wasnt it an one shot?

Dylan Diaz
Dylan Diaz

He could have set it in a desert and it would be the same.

But nope, snow.

Kevin Miller
Kevin Miller

Pretty much Smoogy + Tsunbot

Carson Sanders
Carson Sanders

Everything starts as a one-shot.

Joshua Parker
Joshua Parker

robots just don't get enough love

I like you, tsunbot.

Isaiah Cruz
Isaiah Cruz

This is the exact point where quality dropped. Nihei just stopped having ideas and simply padded, padded and padded again.

Benjamin Wood
Benjamin Wood

The Giant Sho arc was alright though.

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page