So Sup Forums

Jonathan Ortiz
Jonathan Ortiz

So Sup Forums

What anime of this season are you :
-enjoying
-following
-dropped
-didn't watch

Christopher Mitchell
Christopher Mitchell

-enjoying

Habanero of the Iron Fortress
Re:Zero
Boku no Hero Academia

-following

Joker Game (not bad, but not my tastes. Might drop soon)
Luluco
Kiznaiver (probably going to drop soon)
Kuromukuro (haven't watched since episode two, but keep downloading each week)

-dropped

Terraformars: Revenge (what the fuck happened to this show?)
Haifuri (garbage show for garbage people)
Bakuon!!
Seisen Cerberus

-didn't watch

everything else

Brayden Moore
Brayden Moore

These kind of threads are stupid why do people curious about this? Everyone just posts lists and say your taste is bad.

Oliver Moore
Oliver Moore

Everyone just posts lists and say your taste is bad.

That's the whole point. You also sometimes get to congratulate others on their patrician tastes.

Liam Gonzalez
Liam Gonzalez

Confirmed afraid of his bad taste.

Jackson Baker
Jackson Baker

you have shit taste in threads user

Zachary Martinez
Zachary Martinez

It's either for the "I'm a newfag and still can't tell which shows are good so please spoonfeed me" crowd, or the blogposting crowd. Take your pick.

Noah Anderson
Noah Anderson

Still watching:
Sansha Sanyou
flying witch

Dropped: none

Stalled partway / delayed / backlog:
Netoge Yome
HaiFuri
Pan de Peace
Bakuon
Kuma Miko

I like to save up part of a season before catching up with Sup Forums. Probably get around to them before the end of the season.

Tyler Bailey
Tyler Bailey

Enjoying
JoJo
Kuma Miko
Dropped
Basically everything else

Lucas Ward
Lucas Ward

It's incredible. Even in one of the better seasons in years, you managed to not pick up a single half decent show.

Xavier Bailey
Xavier Bailey

Favorite shows this season are Luluco, Kabaneri and Haifuri

dropped
Bungou Stray Dogs
Sakamoto

Gavin Morris
Gavin Morris

Oh, and forgot to add that I dropped Sakamoto and Bungou Stray Dogs.

Gavin King
Gavin King

Enjoying:
Joker Game. I'm really liking the episodic format.
Luluco. AoTS.
Sakamoto desu ga?
Anne Happy. I'm getting Gochiusa vibes from it, it's nice.
Super Lovers.
Flying Witch.

Following:
BnHA. Out of obligation.
Endride.
Kiznaiver. Mixed vibes from this one.
Haifuri.
Bungou Stray Dogs.
Tanaka-kun IAL.
Kuma Miko.
Mayoiga. The OP has grown on me.

Dropped:
Bakuon!!
Pan de peace or whatever.
Shounen Maid.

Didn't watch.
Anything that's not featured above.

Kevin Lee
Kevin Lee

It's just mindless fun. Don't think too hard about it.

Joseph Reyes
Joseph Reyes

Not really a lot of show that I follow this season, Luluco, Kumamiko and Jojo do it for me.

Sebastian Hernandez
Sebastian Hernandez

I started this thread because a lot of show starts with bad episodes but continue with something better.
So I'm curious to see if people enjoy some anime that I overlook.

-Enjoying
Boko no
Flying Witch
Kuma Miko
Tonkatsu

-Following
Bakuon (I love bikes but it's boring)
Bungou
Kabaneri
Kiznaiver
Netoge (will probably drop)
Sakamoto
Space Patrol

-Dropped (or will drop soon)
Big Order (1st ep was meh, will watch 2 and 3)
Endride (1st was shit)
Hundred (1st was meh)

-Will start
Joker Game
Re Zero
Seisen
Shounen
Sousei
Tanaka

Jaxson Reed
Jaxson Reed

As someone who hasn't started any of the new shows this season I find it useful as a recommendation thread.

Jaxon Kelly
Jaxon Kelly

Enjoying
Luluco's the unexpected AOTS for me
Jo-Jo, Kaberni and Joker game are swell too. Flying witch is just comfy tier

following
Kiznaiver and Re:Zero are both decent, but I have mixed feelings. This and Mayoiga, but Mayoiga is mostly for the shitposting.

dropped
Ace attorney pretty fucking hard

Didn't watch
the rest

Jordan Howard
Jordan Howard

enjoying
Jojo
Mayoiga
Sakamoto
Flying Witch
following
Bakuon!!
Joker Game
Luluco
dropped
n/a
didn't watch
Everything else

Michael Barnes
Michael Barnes

only watching luluco and kiznaiver, kiznaiver is alight. Almost forgot kagewani.

Kevin Rivera
Kevin Rivera

dropping big order
You've made a mistake user

Ayden Smith
Ayden Smith

If you are watching more than two anime per season.you have shit taste.

Bakuon/kumamiko master race.

Andrew Reyes
Andrew Reyes

Pan de Peace
Kuma Miko
Bakuon!!
Netoge
Anne Happy
Haifuri
Flying Witch
Sansha Sanyou

REMINDER: If you are watching any anime but these Sup Forums approved anime, pic related.

Jace Butler
Jace Butler

It's always fun seeing moefags get prematurely defensive because they know their shits are taste.

Justin Lewis
Justin Lewis

bakuon-kumamiko
moe

Damn, son.

Isaac Butler
Isaac Butler

enjoying
Kiznaiver (Favorite of a weak season)
My Hero Academia (entertaining but very slow)
Space Patrol Luluco (Trigger at it's best)
Bakuon!! (Better than your average "cute girls doing manly things" anime)

Following
Kabaneri of the Iron Fortress (Still not sure how it's gonna turn out)
Sakamoto desu ga?
NetoYome (lots of squandered potential)
The Lost Village (mostly shit but I'm morbidly curious)
Pan de Peace! (Fully shit)
Crane Game Girls (Something worse than shit)

Haven't dropped anything because I'm a glutton for punishment and love watching bad shows

Matthew Hughes
Matthew Hughes

The end of the 1st EP was really bad, I'll see with 2 and 3.

Nathan Morris
Nathan Morris

are you straight up retarded?

Juan Bennett
Juan Bennett

/out/

Samuel Ortiz
Samuel Ortiz

In bakuon one of the girl is definitely going to end up shooting heroin and kumamiko is literally PTSD the anime.

Asher Lee
Asher Lee

-enjoying
Kuromukuro
Sansha Sanyou
Flying Witch
Sakamoto Desu Ga
Shounen Maid

The last two are the shows I didn't expect to like so much.

-following
Mayoiga - Retarded writing as per expected of Okada, only following for the threads
Bungou Stray Dogs - Boring plot but the style and character designs are neat.
Big Order - Clusterfuck writing but Yuno v2 tingles my penis
Bakuon - Not interested in bikes, and it's more /o/ than cute girls. Wish they showed more of Autistic Helmet Girl being Autistic
Boku no Hero Academia - standard shounen shit but it's entertaining enough to get through
Anne Happy - Fun show but the gags get tiring after awhile. I have to pause a bit throughout the show.
Joker Game - Love the WWII setting and premise but that's all there is to it. Can't really get attached to the characters and most of the stories are mediocre at best.
Kabaneri - Love the triple layer shading, dislike the cringey writing. Some of the premise feels like something a kid in middle school would write.
Kumamiko - It's surreal how much bullying Machi goes through. Flying Witch already has LOTS anyways.
Hai Furi - started off strong then it just became anticlimatic. Hated how they set up a cliffhanger at the end of the episode only for the characters to forget it afterwards.
Kiznaiver - Biggest disappointment of the season. Trigger hasn't made a good show since LWA.

-dropped
Tanaka-kun - couldn't even make past the first episode and the visuals are boring

-didn't watch
Everything else, nigga.

Connor Reyes
Connor Reyes

You faggots have always been the cancer, you're jsut too stupid and conceited to realize it.

Hunter Howard
Hunter Howard

Also forgot to add that I dropped Netoge, which is standard haremshit and not worth watching for any of the generic characters.

Schwein a cute design though.

Lincoln Brown
Lincoln Brown

-enjoying
Ansatsu Kyoushitsu
Kabaneri
Re:Zero
Kiznaiver
Sakamoto
Mayoiga (threads delivers most of my fun)
Tanaka-kun
JoJo
Luluco
Concrete Revolutio
Sailor Moon Crystal III
12-sai
Tonkatsu DJ Agetarou

-following
Hero Academia
Netoge no Yome
Joker Game
Sousei no Onmyouji
Flying Witch
Big Order (TV)
Kuma Miko
Kuromukuro
Super Lovers
Bakuon!!
Shounen Maid
Macross Δ
Nijiiro Days

-dropped
Endride
Ace Attorney
Haifuri (military moe is not my thing I hoped for Sora no Woto 2)
Anne Happy
Sansha Sanyou

yet to watch
Bungou Stray Dogs
Magi: Sinbad

Carter Ward
Carter Ward

Quit forcing this shitty reaction image that only you post.

Kevin Lewis
Kevin Lewis

enjoying
Habanero
Mayoiga
Kuma Miko
Luluco
Tanaka-kun
Sailor Moon Crystal
Jojo
following
Bakuon
Anne Happy
Joker Game
Sakamoto
Kiznaiver
Sansha Sanyou
dropped
Boku no Pico Academia
Bungou Stray Dogs
Re:Zero
didn't watch
the rest

Adam Ward
Adam Ward

-enjoying
Re:Zero
Kabaneri
Boku no Pico Academia
JoJo
Mayoiga
-Following
Joker game (kinda wished it had a more continuous plot, but entertaining nonetheless
Haifuri (mind conrol rats a shit)
-Dropped
Flying Witch (Not Typically into into SoL anime, but tried a few episodes
kuma Miko (Didn't even really watch the first episode.)
Netoge (watched a few episodes it didn't really hook me. Might pick it back up but probably not)
Kiznaiver (Thought it seemed interesting, but got bored pretty quickly
-Didn't watch
All the others

Considering Luluco and Sakamoto (assuming sakamoto isn't just fujoshit)

Ryder Gomez
Ryder Gomez

-Dropped
Hundred - Gave it about fifteen minutes just to figure out what it was about and dropped it the instant I realized it was an Infinite Stratos rehash.
Delta - Same as above. Get your fucking magical girls out of my fucking Macross!

-following
Ace Attorney - Never played the games, wishing I had now. This shit is golden.

Literally nothing else this season looks even vaguely interesting.

Noah Brooks
Noah Brooks

nice rec thread

Levi Taylor
Levi Taylor

enjoying
Luluco
Flying Witch
Boku no Hero Academia
Sakamoto desu ga?

following
Kuma Miko
Re:Zero
Kabaneri
Kiznaiver
Mayoiga
Joker Game

dropped
None

Nicholas Nguyen
Nicholas Nguyen

-enjoying
Hero Academia
Kiznaiver
Kabeneri of Iron Fortress
Netoge no Yome wa Onnanoko ja Nai to Omotta?
Space Patrol Luluco
Kuma Miko
Flying Witch

-following
Mayoiga
Shounen Maid
Macross Delta
Ace Attorney

-dropped
Really close to having dropped Ace Attorney
Ragnastrike Angels
-Plan to watch later
Re: Zero
Sakumoto Desu Ga?
High School Fleet
Pan De Peace

-didn't watch
Everything else

Jeremiah Fisher
Jeremiah Fisher

Enjoying
A lot. Hero Academia, Re:Zero, Concrete Revolutio, and Flying Witch are my favorites.
following
Not sure how to define this, but I'm keeping an eye on Kiznaiver threads for the chart and the discussion. I occasionally stop by the Mayoiga threads but I'm already sick of them.
Dropped
Doesn't look like I'll drop anything this season but I've committed to Endride because its so bad but I'm not enjoying it. I only watch it when absolutely obliterated by alcohol though, so it evens out I guess
Didn't watch
Most S2s I couldn't get around to catching up on and stuff like Pan de Peace or 12-sai I just wasn't interested in.

I'm watching like 24 shows this season when I usually average out about 12-15. This seasons pretty great.

Hunter Gonzalez
Hunter Gonzalez

Mayoiga threads at this point are just memes and 2 people having discussions. Then again that's usually how it goes so...

Liam Morris
Liam Morris

The "dropped" and "didn't watch" lists are the best way for autists to strut their stuff, and plebs to show just how fucking plebbish they can be.

The mods should permaban the OP for instigating this faggotry.

Aaron Hill
Aaron Hill

watching and enjoying
Flying Witch
Habanero
Kumamiko
Macross Delta
Kuromukuro

Kevin Scott
Kevin Scott

Enjoying
Hero Academia
Kiznaiver
Kabaneri
Kuma Miko
Flying Witch
Mayoiga
Haifuri
Jojo Part 4
Bungou Stray Dogs

Following
Joker Game
Sakamoto
Sousei no Onmyouji

Plan to Watch
Kuromukuro
Re:Zero
Tanaka-kun
Magi Adventures of Sinbad
Macross Delta

Dropped
Big Order
Ace Attorney (I'm just replaying the games right now instead)

Been a good season for me so far

Jack Morris
Jack Morris

Are you the fag that was just shitting up the Barakamon thread? You get around, don't you.

Kayden Russell
Kayden Russell

-elder god tier
luluco
mayoiga
-enjoying
macross
boku no hero academia
re:zero
jojo
-following
kabaneri
terraformars
kiznaiver
-dropped
big order
bakuon
flying witch
joker game
-didn't watch
anything else, i planned on watching hai-furi but never got around to it
i have nothing to do all day yet i can't seem to find the time to watch six episodes of an anime

Hunter Bennett
Hunter Bennett

-didn't watch
All of them. I only watch shows when they are fully out, rarely before they get a full BD release.

Cooper Garcia
Cooper Garcia

watching
Concrete Revolutio
Flying Witch
Jojo
Tonkatsu DJ Agetarou
Uchuu Patrol Luluco
Usakame

dropped
Boku no Hero Academia
Bungou Stray Dogs
Joker Game
Kiznaiver
Koutetsujou no Kabaneri
Kuma Miko
Kuromukuro
Macross Δ
Mayoiga
Netoge
Re:Zero
Sakamoto desu ga?
Sansha Sanyou
Sousei no Onmyouji
Tanaka-kun wa Itsumo Kedaruge

Summer can't come soon enough.

Joseph Thompson
Joseph Thompson

enjoying
Luluco
Flying Witch
Macross Delta

following
Kabaneri
Kiznaiver

dropped
Joker Game

didn't watch
everything else

Hunter Roberts
Hunter Roberts

I am only watching

Luluco
Kumamiko
Tana Kun
Flying Witch

Luis Jenkins
Luis Jenkins

enjoying
Kumamiko (KUMAMIKO DANCING DANCING)
Unhappy (PUN PUN PUNCHI PUNCH)
Kabaneri (LO MUERTO VIVO)
Tanaka-kun (charming and relaxing)
Bakuon (motabike?)
Luluco (I don't know why but hell i'm enjoying this)
Haifuri (little girls driving big machinery? Sign me in!)
Mayoiga (I think that half of the fun is watching it with Sup Forums but still pretty good)
Phoenix Wright (leaving episode 1 aside it's been a pretty good adaptation and I can't help but scream IGIARI with Nick on the court)
Sakamoto (Simply awesome)

following
Sansha Sanyou (Godakobo, what happened?)
Pan de Peace (it's nice and short)
Kiznaiver (every week I want to drop it but I just can't)
Crane Game Girls (it's a short... I really don't know)
Terraformars (the manga is one of my favorites but I can barely stand the anime)
Hero Academia (jumping into the bandwagon)
Dragon Ball (who isn't?)
Netoge (my dick approves)

dropped
Flying Shit (arguable worst anime of the year)
Hundred (into the backlog to give it a one go marathon later)

didn't watch
What I didn't watch, huh.

Robert Ortiz
Robert Ortiz

Luluco is definitely worth a watch if you enjoy Trigger being Trigger in it's purest form. Sakamoto didn't feel at all like fujoshit when I read the manga but I'm getting some strong fuckin' vibes from the anime.

Gabriel Hernandez
Gabriel Hernandez

enjoying
Boku no pico macademia
luluco
kuromukuro
habanero fortress
following
macross
didn't watch
everything else

Lucas Harris
Lucas Harris

-enjoying
Boku no hero academia
Netoge (a surprise)
-following
Ace Attorney
JoJo Part 4 (Surprised it's been bad)
-dropped
Nothing yet
-didn't watch
Everything else

Pretty shitty season honestly.

Brayden Carter
Brayden Carter

enjoying
Anne Happy
Bakuon!!
Boku no Hero Academy
Flying Witch
Haifuri
Jojo Part 4
Kabaneri
Kuma Miko
Mayoiga
Netoge no Yome
Onigiri
Re Zero
Sansha Sanyou
Wagamama Hgih

following
Ace Attorney
Big Order
Bishoujo Crane Game
Bongou Stray Dogs
Joker Game
Kiznaiver
Pan de Peace
Sakamoto
Shounen Maid
Sousei no Onmyouji
Tanaka-kun

dropped
Nothing.

The SOL is really strong this season.

Andrew Mitchell
Andrew Mitchell

Flying Shit (arguable worst anime of the year)

(You)

Xavier James
Xavier James

Epic.

Ayden Gutierrez
Ayden Gutierrez

watching
everything

enjoying
everything other than endride, cerberus, ace attorney, and ushio s2

dropped
dropping anime

didnt watch
concrete revolutio s2 is the only thing i skipped this season

John Flores
John Flores

-Enjoying
None

-Following
None

-Dropped
None

-Didn't watch
Everything.

Feels good brothers.

Brody Foster
Brody Foster

Enjoying
Concrete Revolutio
Flying Witch
Kuma Miko
Re:Zero (just caught up on, glad I watched)
Tanaka-kun (Surprisingly my favorite SOL/comedy this season)

Following
Boku no Hero Academia
Jojo
Mayoiga (enjoy it for the wrong reasons)
Sansha Sanyou (s'alright)
Luluco
Usakame (these aren't my teekyus)

Need to Catch Up On/Try
Joker Game (watching now)
Kuromukuro
Kabeneri

Dropped
Sakamoto (I think I'll just read it instead)
Kiznaiver (I only watched 1 ep, I'm just prioritizing the above tier)
Shonen Maid
Netoge

Didn't Watch
The rest.

Need to catch up with Kabenari, Kuromukuro.
How are those?

Blake Wood
Blake Wood

still watching/enjoying
tonkatsu DJ
dropped
flying witch
kuma miko
kabaneri
haifuri
mayoiga
tanaka-kun
sakamoto
sansha sanyo
luluco
bakuon
shonen maid
anne happy
pan de peace
kiznaiver
joker game
ace attorney
haven't watched
the rest.

Typing this really made me feel like a stuck up cynic. I feel like a lot of shows were almost good enough to keep watching. Some of the shows this season are downright painful though.

Jonathan Wright
Jonathan Wright

Am I the only one who thinks Kuma Miko hasn't really delivered after the first episode?

Jackson Ortiz
Jackson Ortiz

It's been weaker since, but still good.
Ep 2 with the chair-bike was great, and I liked ep 5 (though ep 4 as a set up for that was pretty boring)

Isaiah Thompson
Isaiah Thompson

Enjoying:
Re0
JJBA 4
Quality line------
Spicy fortress
Kuma Miko

Watching:
Asterisk
Hundred
Hero Acedemia
Quality line---------
Luluco

Dropped:
Bakuon

Christian Campbell
Christian Campbell

The last episode was really good.

Why is the newest one taking so long to come out?

Nicholas Sullivan
Nicholas Sullivan

enjoying
Macross
Mayoiga
Flying Witch
Luluco
Sakamoto
Haifuri
Kabaneri
Bakuon
Kuma Miko
Kuromukuro

shit
Onmyouji
Boku no Academia
Joker Game
Re Zero
Kiznaiver

Nolan Walker
Nolan Walker

What about your backlog....

Angel Williams
Angel Williams

I'm surprised that kabaneri is so popular. The premise seemed cool, and the pilot was okay, but... I don't know how to say this nicely, everything since has seemed really bad.

I was about to go into detail here but thinking back on the show actually made me really angry for a moment. I don't know how I can have such a physical reaction to this show, but I just find it extremely annoying.

Jeremiah Collins
Jeremiah Collins

Basically. I think it's delivered almost every episode. It seems like you were a "comfy" fag.

It's got cute, lewd, atmospheric, bullying, romance and comedy pretty balanced with each other. Good shit.

Sebastian Smith
Sebastian Smith

-enjoying

Re:Zero
Flying witch
Onigiri
Netoge
Kabaneri
Tanaka-kun

-following

Wagamama high spec
Joker game
Bungou stray dogs
Anne Happy
Kuromukuro
Luluco
Shonen maid
Asterisk 2nd season
Boku no hero
Sansha sanyou

-dropped
Haifuri
Cerberus
Kuma miko
Bakuon
Hundred
That yuri anime with bread
Sakamoto desu ga
Endride
Mayoiga

-didn't watch

Everything else

Lincoln Nelson
Lincoln Nelson

seems like you were a "comfy" fag
Not really, the humor in the first episode is the main thing that I thought was better in the first episode. Of course, that's entirely subjective so I'm not surprised if nobody shares my POV

Blake Stewart
Blake Stewart

You sound like an anti-mumei fag. I think she's fine but I can understand having a character that does stupid shit getting under your skin.
Personally I've really enjoyed all of it. The flip flopping citizens are poorly handled but not exactly unrealistic. Mumei is getting as told off as she is doing the telling off and the series is progressing nicely.
A lot of people in threads are bitching about pacing because they expect the story to address how to "KILL ALL THE KABANE" or answer "WHERE DID THEY COME FROM" however I think those are shit storylines. A slower story about survival that teases a deeper world is perfectly fine. In fact it's better than fine given most shows are about heady, ham-fisted ideology clashes.
That's just my patrician taste though.

Jackson Bailey
Jackson Bailey

Enjoying
Sailor Moon Crystal S3
Aikatsu Stars
Following
Macross Delta (I feel obligated to watch just because it's Macross)
Kagewani S2 (it's not as good as S1)
Dropped
Kabaneri (might pick it back up, I dunno)
Haven't watched
Everything else

Oliver Adams
Oliver Adams

Yeah now that you mention it, I did see it going a different direction when I'd finished the first episode. More trying to acclimatise to city culture comedy hijinks less using the city obsession as a premise for unusual situations and then discarded just as quickly.

Lucky for me I was also okay with the tone switch that happened in episode two. A lot of the episodes seem tonally different now that you mention it. I wouldn't say the quality is inconsistent but the show (or more likely, the source) can't decide what it wants to do. It'll probably smooth out around now with any luck

Wyatt Wilson
Wyatt Wilson

Kabaneri is my AOTS, but your mileage may vary because there seems to be a few people that really dislike it, mainly because they think it's popular. The art alone makes it worth watching though, the show is gorgeous and they animate really well when it counts. Also a couple of the characters are pretty great, even the background ones. I highly recommend giving it the three episode test.

Kuromukuro has garbage CG and bad mech designs. The show itself is ok, and I liked how they mixed up the expected dynamic with the MC girl, but I still dropped it because of the CG. Not sure how it's been since episode three, though I doubt the CG got better. Watch if you like mecha enough to stomach even the worst visual mecha experience.

Do you even like anime? I don't understand people like you.

Oliver Nguyen
Oliver Nguyen

enjoying
Joker Game (AOTS)
JoJo part 4 (I got impatient and I read the manga in the meantime, I shouldn't have)
Asterisk S2 (it's quite bad though)

following
Kabaneri, Kuromukuro (didn't watch past episode 1 of each but still following)

dropped
Kiznaiver (watch Kokosake instead, it's the same thing without cringey dialogue)

Jeremiah Young
Jeremiah Young

mainly because they think it's popular.
Fuck off. I like it a lot too but there are more than enough factors that people mightn't gel with.

Eli Flores
Eli Flores

I don't understand what you think is bad about it, and I have yet to see somebody field any valid criticisms that actually hold water. Aside from the still screen pans (that nobody really mentions anyways), which I don't mind because they save up for cool action scenes, there really isn't much to criticize about the show.

Hunter Wood
Hunter Wood

Enjoying/watching: Jojo's mayoiga
Dropped: none

Nathan Myers
Nathan Myers

field any valid criticisms that actually hold water
Then you're an idiot. Did you think everyone hated SnK purely because it was normalfag bait too?

Aaron Cooper
Aaron Cooper

Virtually every post saying Kabeneri is bad is one of two flavors:

it's not SOL moe idol shit so it's shit
completely inaccurate comparisons to other popular anime disliked by most of Sup Forums, and accusations that it's normalfag bait (read:popular)

Those are both valid reasons to dislike the show personally, but not valid defenses for claiming it's a bad show. All memeing aside, most people on Sup Forums seem to legitimately be unable to separate their own subjective feelings towards a show, and the objective quality of a show. To them, their subjective feelings are literally the only thing that matters, regardless of things like sound and music, animation, character designs, story cohesiveness, pacing, etc.

People mainly hate SnK (aside from its popularity) because the story went to utter shit after Eren became titans, especially because it was out of left field. At least they did before the anime aired and it happened in the manga; I never picked up the show since I knew the story was shit beforehand. And the few people who still thought it was good after that mostly changed their minds after it was revealed everything was titans.

Cameron James
Cameron James

it's not SOL moe idol shit so it's shit
Yeah that's totally what everyone says and not just your typical manime-bullshit rhetoric

Oliver Jackson
Oliver Jackson

You seem really unnecessarily assblasted over this.

Ryan Rodriguez
Ryan Rodriguez

most people on Sup Forums seem to legitimately be unable to separate their own subjective feelings towards a show
Neither can you. It's all about craft. While most of those elements you listed are predominately craft would you know the objective criterion for an artistically valid character design? Or are you merely have a subjective opinion on character design and using its technical status to falsely substantiate your opinions by playing them off as objective measures?

Elijah Nelson
Elijah Nelson

enjoying
Koutetsujou no Kabaneri
Bakuon
Joker Game
Luluco
Bungou Stray Dogs

following
JoJo
Kiznaiver
Usakame

dropped
Nothing

didn't watch (but thought about it)
Flying Witch
Mayoiga
Netoge
Kuromukuro

Might drop Kiznaiver if I catch up and its still not that interesting.
Might pick up Flying Witch since it looks cute.

Noah Gonzalez
Noah Gonzalez

enjoying
-Kabaneri
-Kiznaiver
-Joker Game
-Kuromukuro
-Mayoiga
-Bunghole

following
-Sousei
-Haifuri
-Hundred
-Big order
-Tanaka
-Endride
-asterisk

dropped
-Netoge
-Seisen cerberus

downloaded but probably won't watch
-Flying witch
-Kuma miko
-Sakamoto

Eli Hughes
Eli Hughes

Neither can you

Fair enough, after reading your comment. I still feel like there should be a distinction made between whether you liked a show, and whether you thought a show was well made or not. For example, I hate K-ON, but there is really no question that it was a pretty well made show. It had good sound, decent character designs, and it all came together into a quality product.

People on here should meme less and think more when it comes to the actual quality of a show and how they feel about a show.

Cooper Ward
Cooper Ward

Oh, and the PV was bad enough that I dropped Ace Attorney without even seeing an episode. At least it reminded me to start playing the games again.

Adam Harris
Adam Harris

Kabeneri is both objectively and subjectively shit

Easton Thomas
Easton Thomas

FUN TIMES
Jojo, Kiznaiver
ENGAGING
Joker Game, BNHA
WILD RIDE
Re:Zero, Luluco
CUTE
Kuma Miko, Flying Witch
DROPPED
Mayoiga, Hundred
GONNA WATCH IF THE ENDING DOESNT SHIT OUT
Kabaneri
GONNA WATCH ON A RAINY DAY
Sakamoto, Netoge

Kayden James
Kayden James

Color me spoonfed. If there's something in one of these threads that is really popular but I had sort of rejected out of hand, I'll sometimes reconsider checking it out. I don't want to just reinforce my own taste, I'm interested in experimenting with stuff that's outside of my zone that might be good.

Parker Bailey
Parker Bailey

For somebody who claimed to like Kabaneri a lot, you certainly are really insistent on disliking it.

How is it objectively shit?

John Cooper
John Cooper

Mostly because it takes itself too seriously

Easton Campbell
Easton Campbell

So it's bad because it's not fun and "comfy" enough for you? What a stellar criticism, I better stop watching, thank you.

Brayden Baker
Brayden Baker

I make the distinction when discussing shows often. Not so much on Sup Forums. While discussion about particular shows is present you get few oppurtunites for actual, decent, cross show discussion. In fact, even in threads like this the main appeal is to flaunt your rather than discussing the quality and enjoyment in more detail.

People will occasionally jibe about liking bad things "if you like it then you don't really think it's bad" but I totally agree that you can like bad things and hate good things while understanding that there are inherently good or bad qualities beyond your enjoyment.
Enjoying shitty B-movies is usually the perfect example. Everyone knows they're shit but some can be so bad they're good.

Jace Roberts
Jace Roberts

enjoy: Macross, Kuromukuro, Luluco
following: mayoiga, kiznaiver, kabaneri, jojo's

Angel Cook
Angel Cook

everyone who responds to me is that last person I replied to
What are you, new?

Hunter Green
Hunter Green

-enjoying
Haifuri, not what I expected at all
Mayoiga, I don't know if it's actually good, but it's a wild fuckin ride
Joker Game
Flying Witch

-stalled
Bakuon!

-didn't watch (but will probably pick up)
Kuma Miko
Some other shit

Samuel Cruz
Samuel Cruz

Who said you have to stop watching? I'm just saying I think it's shit, what you do on your free time couldn't interest me less.

Tyler Richardson
Tyler Richardson

Enjoying
Anne Happy / Unhappy
Big Order (it's one of those terrible trainwrecks that I can't stop watching)
Bungou Stray Dogs
Flying Witch
Kiznaiver
Kuromukuro
Re:Zero
Sakamoto desu ga?
Sansha Sanyou
Space Patrol Luluco
Tanaka-kun wa Itsumo Kedaruge
Tonkatsu DJ Agetarou

Following
Bakuon
Boku no Hero Academy (Haven't watched past first ep yet, but I liked what I saw)
Gakusen Toshi Asterisk S2 (why didn't I drop this garbage during the first season)
Haifuri (close to enjoying-tier)
Joker Game
Koutetsujou no Kabaneri (Haven't watched past first ep yet)
Kuma Miko
Mayoiga
Netoge
Pan de Peace
Ragnastrike Angels
Ushio to Tora S2
Wagamama High Spec

Dropped
Hundred
Seisen Cerberus (that blue haired girl was a total semen demon, but not enough for me to keep watching past ep 1)
Sousei no Onmyouji

Didn't Watch
Everything else (am I missing anything I should try?)

--

First season in a while that I've watched this many shows to this far into the season.

Luke Foster
Luke Foster

It's fun to pull the whole "My tastes are good, yours are shit" stupidity sometimes, but when it colors all discussion on here it gets really tiring. It stops being fun when people late to the party actually think it's true rather than just fun.

Enjoying shitty B-movies is usually the perfect example. Everyone knows they're shit but some can be so bad they're good.

That's half the appeal of many anime for me. I know they're really not that good, but for various reasons I like them anyways. Lucky Star is a prime example.

Joshua Jones
Joshua Jones

Reminder that if you actually enjoy Flying Witch then you are a faggot past the point of no return.

Andrew Long
Andrew Long

It interested you enough to make multiple posts telling me how bad the show is. If you weren't trying to convince me then why bother sharing your unsolicited opinion to begin with?

Hudson Richardson
Hudson Richardson

enjoying
Unironically Mayoiga. I've also grown to actually love the cast despite all the stupid shit going on.

Also Kiznavier. The art is great and the characters are odd in their good way.

following
Sakamoto because I loved the manga (and still do)
Lulu Space Patrol

didn't watch
The rest

Alexander Long
Alexander Long

Kiznaiver and Macross are the best, but it's a pretty solid season.

Lucky Star is really that good.

Gavin Ortiz
Gavin Ortiz

Enjoying
Netoge
Tanaka-kun
Shounen Maid
Re:Zero
Flying Witch

Following
Mayoiga

Dropped
Hundred
Anne Happy

Didn't watch
Everything else

Now that school's out I'm gonna try to catch up with Sakamoto and Kuma Miko, interested to see how those are.

Mayoiga. The OP has grown on me.
I really like the ED too, it's good to have something comfy after all the suspense

Hundred just struck me as pretty mediocre, I generally like harems but the premise and everything seemed blah.

Shounen Maid turned out to be quite good I thought. Comfy and funny but some good emotional parts too.

Lucas Perez
Lucas Perez

Why bother sharing any opinion on Sup Forums? Because I have nothing better to do.

Leo Wood
Leo Wood

Enjoying
JoJo
Tanaka-kun
Luluco
Anne Happy
Kabaneri

Following
Kumamiko
Mayoiga
Sakamoto
Haifuri
Kiznaiver

Dropped
Joker Game

Really loving this season.

Alexander Bennett
Alexander Bennett

Lucky Star is really that good.

It's terrible, but I liked it quite a bit anyways.

Adam Miller
Adam Miller

Actually YOU'RE terrible, also gay.

Ian Torres
Ian Torres

mainly because they think it's popular

Are you even following the threads? People are getting more and more disillusioned with it, and clearly this applies to people who want to enjoy it but are having difficulty doing so. The plot of "do the peasants trust us" and "oh no we have to fight zombies" and "our train has to go somewhere" are wearing thin with time and that's causing its strong initial impression to wear off for me.

Benjamin Bell
Benjamin Bell

emotional maturity and a willingness to consider opinions other than your own

Christopher Fisher
Christopher Fisher

eagerly anticipating each week
Tanaka-kun
Flying Witch
Mayoiga

enjoying but with less enthusiasm
Anne Happy
Kuma Miko

feel like I should probably start watching
Re Zero
Boku no Hero
Kiznaiver

dropped
HaiFuri
Kuromukuro
Bread Lolis

Aiden Hernandez
Aiden Hernandez

Enjoying
Kabaneri
Flying Witch
Bakuon!!
ReZero

Watching for the qts
Netoge
Onmyouji

Still watching due to sunk-cost fallacy
Asterisk

Dropped
Bungou Stray Dogs
Haifuri
Hundred
Joker Game
Anne Happy
Mayoiga

Not the worst season in the world but nothing really stands out besides Kabaneri and ReZero.

Carter Carter
Carter Carter

Oh and I guess toss Kiznaiver under
Watching because Trigger and maybe something will eventually happen

Robert Williams
Robert Williams

Keit-ai.

Juan Lee
Juan Lee

enjoying with passion
Shounen Maid
Tanaka-kun
12-sai
Anne Happy
Sansha Sanyou
Haifuri
Kiznaiver
Kuma Miko
Mayoiga (the threads)
Re: Zero
Sakamoto Desu ga?
Nijiiro Days
Pan de peace

following
AssClass
Flying Witch
Sousei no Onmyouji
Netoge
Kabaneri
Asterisk
Stray doges
Boku no Hero

dropped
End this ride
Bakuon (might pick up again)

didn't watch, but want to because I know they're good
Joker Game
Macross Δ

John Lee
John Lee

enjoying
Koutetsujou
Luluco
Flying Witch
Kiznaiver kinda I guess

following
Mayoiga

dropped
Bungou Stray Dogs
Joker Game

John Morales
John Morales

Enjoying
Jojo
Kiznaiver

Following
Netoge
Hundred (both of these i only watch for cute girls)

Dropped
Ace attourney

Gavin Foster
Gavin Foster

The only things I'm still watching are Kabaneri, Flying Witch, Mayoiga, and Netoge. Everything else I was either too lazy to start watching in the first place, like Kuma Miko or dropped after 1-2 episodes.

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page