Would you watch it?
Game of Thrones anime
/tv/, go back to jerking off to young girls.
No because muh anime girls must be cute virgins
Fuck off already.
This coming from Sup Forums of all places
Akame ga Kill
If it's loyal to the books, then yeah.
besides my 3d waifu sansa would be better if she was 2d
Yes, as long as it strictly followed the book's plotlines without diretor interference like the fucking series.
fuck off /tv/
The closest comparison would be Supernatural. So... no. I wouldn't watch that shit.
Would it be hentai like the original?
Your butthurt is quiet but palpable bookfags
If it stays more faithful to the books rather than take the TV show's shitty departures, sure.
Only if it features the Cleganebowl
Only if they actually show us the 20 good men, and each one is a character from a different series.
You musn't ever let the hype die
Only if they don't rape Stannis like D&D did.
Hey some of those girls are still virgins. The best ones at least.
20 good men would just be the boss ladder at the end of the series like any shounen arc.
Reminder that Jaime fucking confirmed it
fuck off already /tv/
Only if it's hentai. GoT is boring.
second or third episode starts with ToJ
get to see Robert in his prime bashing in some Targ faggot's breastplate and cuts to old fat Robert riding into Winterfell
GoT will never be remade
fuck off to reddit if you want a circlejerk
What's your problem? We are having a discussion.
I would watch everything as anime. I need outlines in my series.
you'll never see a prequel depicting Tywin's rise to power and Robert's rebellion
Couldn't be worse than Dumb and Dumber's abortion of a show.
Dedicating this thread to Daenerys Kitchenborn of the House Targaryen The First of Her Size, the Unburnt, Queen of McDonalds, Queen of the Dressing and the Cheesy Potatoes and the First Bakers, Khaleesi of the Great Cola Sea, Breaker of Crab Legs, and Mother of Burgers.
go talk about your shitty tv show in your shitty board general
don't enjoy the taste of shit
Read the title of the thread dipshit. Were discussing what ASOIAF would be if it was adapted into anime, which last time I checked, is related to the topic of anime. If that bothers you, find a different thread to shit up.
But the question revolves around anime you mook, Sup Forums is for anime and autists, a category you clearly belong to
She's my 3d waifu too. I finally dropped the shit show after they raped her.
Who should voice Tywin?
but it's not so go talk about it on /tv/
Except that it is you illiterate fuck.
normalfag of thrones
no thank you
The TV show is bad enough.
Did you cry like alfie cried in that scene?
This has nothing to do with Sup Forums. You could literally take any off topic subject and say "what if it were anime". That doesn't make it on topic.
It's like saying "What if this subject were on topic, now let's discuss it".
Sup Forums created the term normalfag newfag, the people that get redirected to /r9k/ are the ones that use normie.
Game of Thrones
Except that anyone who uses the term normalfag/normie seriously is a fucking autist.
Fuck off newfag. Go back to whatever board you came from.
The last two weeks I started watching GoT because I was bored and wanted to watch something that wasn't anime. I'm at almost the end of s5 and I must say that the series are well made, but are really overrated and the plot sometimes doesn't make sense and just feels like the author want the edgemaster audience with blood and tits.
Keep using those buzzwords to make yourself sound cool you basement-dwelling leech.
Fuck off you cancerous shit.
The show doesn't follow the books properly past the first season and has to account for making up a plot as it goes by covering everything in blood and lewd.
First season was great but anything after was ok at most.
Go find your safe space and cry about it you manchild.
Go back to complaining about SJW on youtube you cancer.
Wakamoto is the obvious choice.
Rikiya Koyama for Ned?
I know that the source is usually better, but I expected something more because everyone seems to love that series.
Nobuhiko Okamoto for Ramsay.
With the amount of asspulls and mary sues in the show/books it would be right at home as an anime.
fuck off /tv/
Who would voice Littlefinger?
Sorry for liking the original medium instead of enjoying a butchered sack of shit.
At least it would lead to tons of doujinshi with many different fetishes.
FUCK THOSE GOD DAMN subs WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU DOING!?
I would watch Scrubs anime. Oh the slapstick.
Why isn't this a thing?
Only the show has asspulls and mary sues.
HBO Now subtitles are really behind the times compared to Hulu and Netflix. It can't be helped
Unless you're talking about yellow subs. Yellow subs are best
You could literally take any off topic subject and say "what if it were anime"
Which happens all the time.
As long as people are actually discussing a hypothetical anime and not just using it as an excuse to talk about the source material, it's perfectly fine.
People loved season 1-3. Now I just think most are watching it since they are so deep into it.
I know I am, it's still alright though. This episode was pretty neat.
No but I would watch The Sword of Truth anime.
why Supernatural and non of the other failed marvel startup anime?
Would rather watch anything Forgotten Realms stuff than this.
Now I just think most are watching it since they are so deep into it.
Dipshit normies still think the newer seasons are good.
But who would be the director?
what if it my dick were an anime? Would you watch it?
it's anime related because im talking if were an anime
What has your dick to offer and why should I watch it instead of other anime dicks?
What if these dubs were anime?
I just can't bring myself to watch such a short series.
I would also like a loyal to the books Dresden Files
God yes. It would be a million times better than live action.
It's actually pretty shitty if compared directly
Plot got butchered left and right and became pure fanfiction by now.
The legions of characters got cut down to sizable chunks so established characters constantly have to be in places and roles they shouldn't be in (Hello Bronn)
I could go on but that's the wrong board for it.
Hell yeah, especially since we'd get some Jon and Sansa incest action.
jump into trash and set yourself on fire.
This I would watch.
Only if it is airing on BBC. No LWD shows allowed.
Why did they ruin it so much?
This coming from Sup Forums of all places
Drawings are not real people, fitting that a chemically unbalanced pedophile is incapable of making the distinction.
It was not choking, it was poison.
The setting fits quite well in the books, and I think anime would be a fine medium for it
Arya best girl
Because Dabid & Dan are hacks, and wether you want to believe it or not, having to appeal to an incredibly large audience as the series grew more popular really hurt the writing quality.
Any more comparison pics?
Too bad she can't see your dick. Or anything else, really.
Why are the faggots that try to call others normalfags always newfags or normalfags themselves?
I tried it but I can't watch the series. I only like the books and I imagine everything I read as 2D.
I already knew that, thanks.
Thing is, the show would have been 10 times as interesting, if it followed the books, and still appeal to the average watcher.
Close enough to Berserk, I guess.
She can go by brail
Miura will never draw a manga adaptation of GoT
he'll probably die before he even finishes Berserk
At least Japan wouldn't shoehorn feminism on everything.
Your dick has braille writing on it?
Wheel of Time would work out better as an anime
REEEEE YOU WATCHED THAT SHIT UNTIL S5
don't worry user, I'm happy you finally left that shit behind I abandoned it after what they did to the mannis and his ugly daughter
fuck, I need to re-read the books. the show has been so underwhelming that I forgot why I loved the books in the first place
Implying any one of us will outlive Berserk
Friction is a bitch
I only read the first book and it was so very much full of schadenfreude goodness, will I enjoy the others?
No, just superior nipponese steel folded thousand times swords that cut through everything. Also bushido and ninjas.
Once I finish the series, I will satisfy myself with the books
M-muh Valyrian swords
Yes, very much so
There will never be a proper adaptation of Arya's time with the brotherhood
the anime designs could be as stupid and outlandish as GRRM originally planned
no pink boltons
no colourful braavosi
D&D made everything so grey and shitty I'd forgotten
still sounds like a better deal.
you would get gundam women
a song of ice and fire
not utter and irredeemable shit
Cut by nipsteel katanas.
I would make it my life's purpose to shitpost Dany to death.
Crannogmen are now ninjas
Basically nothing is affected
Out of place references to Nippon dishes and jokes
I would still love it
I can't even believe how they made the Dorne storyline into such cringeworthy feminist pandering
LE STRONG WOMEN KILLING LE WEAK MEN XD
Is Dany the worst tripfag on Essos?
Is this some kind of /tv/ raid? Fuck this thread, sage.
Read the books, they were decent reads. The show was pretty great in the first season, second season was OK. It's been pure dogshit since the third.
It can't get much worse than Dany getting an army of 100k for free this episode.
100k raping, pillaging illiterate raiders
Yeah, that's how it works.
We could make this a weird hybrid of Sup Forums, /tv/ and /lit/, but we need more /a/nons participating instead of sperging about it not being Sup Forums. It would be worth it
The only good threads like that are /a/ces threads where Sup Forums, /k/, and /v/ peacefully co-exist.
Remember how Ser Barristan just randomly died in the show having served no purpose as a character?
The show really is nothing more than the meme death roulette that normies treat it as
Only if they call the Miura (Berserk) to do the visual design of the characters.
What about /a/ncient rome threads? Those are great
The violence and sex I can actually buy since if you're ambitious enough and surrounded by death you probably stop giving a damn about human life.
I read the first four books, but don't remember much and want to get around to rereading them at some point. I'll admit that if I tune into to watch the current series it's pretty much for the violence.
ASoIaF has a lot of characters I'd like to see in fetish stuff, but it seems stupidly hard to remain faithful to the source material at the same time.
Ser Barristan's actor tried to appeal to the producers to not have his character killed off, since he was still alive in the books and it was fucking retarded
"THAT JUST MADE US WANT TO KILL HIM MORE LOL" - Dabid and Dam
I hope this thread gets nuked soon. It's hard enough to avoid spoilers from the shitty show, I don't want to deal with it on Sup Forums.
All because it's taking that fat fuck forever to finish the books.
A DOZEN GOOD MEN
The only way you'll avoid the big kill or tweest of the season is getting off the internet entirely.
GRRM let us down. But he hasn't had a record of doing otherwise in a fucking decade.
he hasn't had a record of doing otherwise in a fucking decade.
ADwD was pretty good in my opinion
Just ctrl-w and move on.
I meant in terms of releasing the books.
ADwD took me 6 months to finish because I kept stopping myself from skimming
Well I was talking about fetishes in general not specific fetishes. Everything can be a fetish be it white hair, age- or size gap, female warriors, incest or whatever.
Hahahahahahahaha How The Fuck Are Spoilers Real Hahahaha Nigga Just Walk Away From The Screen Like Nigga Close Your Eyes Haha
Anime could actually get right how Cersei looks in the books.
Cersei is huge
Looks too much like a porn star
Would probably be great with an anime face though
Dorne is introduced early with a brief foreshadowing frame of Darkstar
Darkstar's VA happens to be the narrator
nips go crazy for Darkstar
Dorne is introduced early
3 Seasons of Darkstar filler
Darkstar merch everywhere
GoT anime is cut at S4 but Darkstar gets a spinoff LN series edited by GRRM
Replace Darkstar with Jaqen H'ghar and I'm all for it.
you basement-dwelling leech.
Where the fuck do you think you are?
Darkstar is voiced by Sugita
Darkstar/Arys doujinshi overpower all the others from the series
No, I watch enough garbage as is from anime. Can't bother to watch one more trashy series.
Literally a gyaru.
But it's already an anime.
The last two seasons have been anime original since they ran out of source material.
I haven't even seen the series, can't really watch live acting. The books are nice though but it's the second Berserk regarding slowness.
GoT is the reason I refuse to sit down and read Berserk in its entirety.
Can an ASOIAF anime surpass LotGH?
In my opinion, if it follows the book pretty close, and has nice budget, it definitely can.
That's too many ifs, user
making me want things I'll never have
Yeah, you should wait another few years. Or decades. Or just watch the new anime; it's CGI but it might be the only chance seeing some conclusion, maybe.
I could actually imagine this done by the same guys who did LotGH back then. But most of then are probably retired or dead by now.
Alright men, this thread has reached a level of shit that cannot be measured in ounces or inches.
The time to derail this fucker has come.
Come my brothers, post best girl from any series and we shall berate each others taste accordingly.
ASOIAF better than LOTGH
The delusion is strong in this one.
Stannis was the character ruined the most by GoT. Instead of being a pragmatic ruler who endures Melissandre's loonies because they are useful and a stern but just person he is turned into a religious fanatic who is easy to manipulate and simply does crazy shit.
Books Stannis is a prime candidate to be posted in Did Nothing Wrong threads if it were an anime.
but we have already fate/zero
he doesn't watch Western movies at the very least
animeonly retards are literal trash
If they followed the books Stannis would be beloved by most of Sup Forums.
S-Since my reports aren't working I'll have to sink this thread with shitposts
LOTGH is literally overrated.
Well then, if that's the case.
Let's wait for the sumikafags to crawl out of the woodwork.
aye aye captain
What the fuck are you talking about?
LotGH is literally the best anime of all time, and everyone with some culture agrees on that matter.
Eh, some of those are the weak definition of fetish.
the trailer for it was good, wish I was a fujo
Too much cheap shock value to be a real contender.
LotGH is literally the best anime of all time
Name a better anime than LotGH then.
Inb4 some moeshit or SoL garbage.
Closest you'll ever get.
How much user semen do you think that image alone has obtained?
I haven't read the books, are they that good?
I don't see the problem.
I decided to finally delve into LotGH, really loving the music and animation.
We're talking enough to correlate with any claims of the icecaps melting. It's less global warming and more global wanking.
They're just covers
Thing is, the show would have been 10 times as interesting
They probably wouldn't even be stuck with their orginal ending tier finale if they followed the books, it's all the little content they keep cutting that makes the series what its really supposed to be.
That's a lie, Martin is the Miuria and Togashi or America.
That's not very hard
"The books split into parts"
Fucking hell, no wonder light novels are a big thing, they can't dedicate to a full book.
It just gives us more covers. I wonder if they have illustrations inside too
At least you manage to make me laugh, I'll give you that.
That Tyrion is horrifying
Closer to the book than the TV series version. He's supposed to be an abomination, not a handsome midget with a scar.
Tyrion is supposed to be a horror to look at.
This Jon is everything you'd expect of nips+Jon
It's a lot more understandable now why pratically nobody likes him. I wouldn't want to be anywhere close to that little monster
Imp aside these covers are beautiful. Maybe once GRRM finishes the books they'll do a manga adaptation.
Who is the one on the right?
Jaime, I figure.
Jaime. Looks like Kingsguard armour.
The "imp" thing makes a lot more sense with the book version of Tyrion. The worst part is that he's supposed to be pretty hideous to look at at the beginning of the series. Then he ends up getting a giant gash to the face and losing his nose. In the show he's actually fairly handsome, so they really play up the whole "dwarf" aspect of it
Is that supposed to be Sam on the left?
The armor looks like Kingsguard so it could possibly be Jaime. The chest is pretty large though, so it could be a stylistic variation of Brienne
Fat man holding Dragon Glass. I'd guess so.
Who else could it be?
What the hell is the right from?
Ah, didn't see the glass
Some other khal that isn't the best khal. From this season.
being this new
We have book threads all of the time on Sup Forums
Post more covers
Fuck, now I want this so bad.
Can an ASOIAF anime surpass LotGH?
It has potential, but I just can see it.
The books are fine, nothing espectacular, but it should be a good read.
I'm still mad, 10/10 taste .
I used to watch Supernatural and never knew that it had an anime adaptation, might watch a couple of episodes now.
I could even forgive not picking an ugly dwarf to play up his charisma, since people are to retarded to side with him otherwise but they could atleast have slashed his nose, after the character was established, not give him a mere scar and call it the worst thing ever.
Arslan senki is the closest you can get to a ASoIaF anime, and is by the same author of LotGH.
Brienne I'd guess.
Sansa and her poisonous hairnet
Nosy little cripple
Last one I have is one more Jon
Yeah this Jon is better than this
feel like discussing the show with anons
never go to /tv/ but I figure I'll give it a shot and check it out
I made a mistake.
I wouldn't even watch the current series. First season was good, second season was alright, and after that it was just plain shit so I stopped watching.
I just want to see the red hair stark bitch nude already. They had the opportunity to do a nude scene but they didn't show shit and she said she was alright with going nude. Then they faked the queen's over-hyped nude scene by CGI-ing her head onto some random woman that looks nothing like her.
They never miss an opportunity to show penises though.
Probably new recruit vs. LC
Why do people watch this shitty meme show? It's full of edgy dialogue that makes me want to take a shower after just to wash the cringing feeling off.
I've already seen SnK
Madoka, HxH, JoJo
implying 2D lolis are the same as real girls
implying it's spelled "Wee lad"
Welcome to my life but replace GOT with CGDCT shows.
Because it's better than anime?
is there more of these?
Very possible. ASOIAF is better than LotGH in any meaningful way.
All of them are garbage. Enough with the jokes user.
That's almost exactly how they did it in the show
Only if it follows the books.
An anime series would be fucking awesome.
Stop lying user.
LotGH is honestly better, it has better characters, and story wise is superior when compared with ASOIAF.
No. Now fuck off and die.
Tripsfag is harsh.
How would the characters be armoured?
disliking urban fantasy
How much of a retard do you have to be?
Hopefully accurately. I want the Hound to have ugly burns & a fitting helmet.
So what you're trying to say is no Strike Witch spins on the series?
fuck, these are great. thanks
Madoka, HxH, JoJo better than LOTGH
Are you fucking serious right now?
god he looks so bad in S6. literally just Max von Sydow awkwardly standing in a tree
Unfortunately the Supernatural anime is set during Season 1, prior to the character development that made Sam and Dean likable.
The English dub has Sam's actual actor doing the voice work, which is a plus, though it mainly makes the poor Dean imitation seem worse by comparison.
calli on mai waiwaado son
Ribbed for her pleasure.
Jon Snow is the son of Lyanna Stark and Rhaegar Targaryen
Not the best season
go fuck yourself
Sam and Dean were shit at the start, but that's not a bad thing. Good writers should leave room for character development.
Exquisitely true meme
Lyanna Stark was the knight of the Laughing Tree
Honestly just watching it for the memes and shitposting at this point. CIA and like two or three others are the only good characters left.
Anime version would be either amazing or a dumpster fire on top of a trainwreck, there is no middle ground.
It was simple but good.
It goes from
Let's go find Dad
WAHH MUH SAMMY'S SATAN AND ANGELS ARE SHIT
Varys is a merman
Robert Strong = Mountain
Mountain = Cersei's champion
Hound = Gravedigger
Gravedigger = Faith's champion
Cleganebowl = Confirmed
Hype = Get
This one is too obvious. Any hints on Wherever Whores Go?
the Tower of Joy
Naruto. You never said it had to be good
the cook's one and only GOAT scene will never have an anime version
Just kill me now.
the tower of joy is my penis
Le clenage bowl meme
Le get hype
It fits user.
Frey pies will never make it into the show
I bet you think Jon wasn't going to leave the watch after his resurrection because if his vows either.
To be fair, I'd imagine that's more because of budget constraints. The dragons alone must have cost quite a fair bit.
Arya met Tyrion's whore in Braavos iirc
Have Charles Dance learn Japanese and reprise his role.
no wherever whores go
no pieman manderly
still have dany/daario romance subplot
How do you fuck up Book 5 this hard?
One of them is an oscar nominee, the other one is adaptation of literally the best manga in the world, while the last one is famous enough to get a collaboration with Gucci.
What accomplishment does LotGH have? Being a 'best anime' in a cespool of losers?
Pffft. GoT is pretty much on the same level of anime. Can't comment on the books since I don't read them but the show is no better than your typical anime for the so-called 'grimdark mature audience'.
if it doesnt have accomplishments its automatically worse
Confirmed for never having watched LOTGH
grimdark mature audience
I dislike that. Why must being dark & gritty be considered mature? Are all the adult watchers edgelords?
Nah, we have a lot of things better in anime world.
Fuck off along with that piece of shit, faggot and never ever come back!
they have one of the most popular shows ever created on earth
they are just greedy little jews that is
While they do spend millions per episode, I will say that it's strange they put so much into CGI skeletons when they couldn't get Brynden Rivers right.
One of them is an oscar nominee
Irrelevant, the oscars meant nothing, you should know that.
the other one is adaptation of literally the best manga in the world
You're either retarded or a shitposter. HxH is far from being the "best manga in the world"
the last one is famous enough to get a collaboration with Gucci
Yeah, and that's relevant because?
Go and watch LotGH, and then you wiil realize the nonsense you are talking right now.
What they get is chump change compared to the sort Hollywood chuck at special effects etc.Even practical effects (the good kind) takes quite a lot of resources too.
They have a 6 to $10 million per episode budget, but that doesn't mean they don't use whatever cost cutting methods they can. CGI dragons are expensive, and they prefer to save up the budget for the massive finale episodes.
Imagine how much they waste of CGI nudes. Like that entire shame walk scene.
Is this your first time interacting with HxH fags or something? Just drop it. Like One Piece fags, they're insufferable and would be autistic enough to derail threads just because someone tell them it's not masterpiece.
Storm of swords is already two parts you retard
Being the most pirated show on earth doesn't really help with the budget.
Surprisingly, D&D don't think badly of the pirating. They think it attracts viewers to see it on HBO when the pirates can't pirate fast enough.
Why would I watch badly drawn shits from the 80's?
Any anime from before 00's is automatically shit because of how bad the animation is. Only Evangelion is excepted from that because it's a masterpiece.
most pirated show on earth
So, you're saying that people living in countries where they can't subscribe to HBO, i.e. not able to pay them even if they want to, are hurting them. Interesting.
As a Canadian, I got my first ISP letter ever this month. HBO kindly requested that I stop torrenting their shit, saying "it has never been easier to watch HBO programming legally in Canada, and stream HBO on your favorite devices."
Don't forget, the books have even more sex.
Cersei has some lesbian escapades with one of her handmaidens. Martin loves to talk about Danaerys(who starts off 13 and is maybe 17 by the time of Dance with Dragons) bathing with her 12 year old handmaiden and interpreter.
And don't forget all the times Arya(who starts book 1 at 8 years old) manages to get naked in public places.
Meh, you're not even trying anymore.
The live action show already breaks every rule of good writing. If I wanted to watch an anime that does the same shit, I'd just watch a GONZO or Bee Train show.
DrogoxDany was the best OTP
Only if everyone is a cute loli.
Drogo is one of the bust husbandos of ASOIAF. He started to prepare to invade Westeros not for fame or power but because they threatened his waifu.
Only if it's a song of Ice and fire anime.
TV series fucking shit.
One of them is nominated for an Oscar
which one of them ?? Madoka's third film ??
Pff was only one nominated to be nominated, not even close, and if films like frozen, can win an Oscar, then, can we all agree that Oscar has lost much credibility
The other is the adaptation of manga literally the best in the world
ohhh yeahh an adaptation of a manga on hiatus insufferable is the best in the world, and that's a very subjective opinion, so do not count
While the latter is famous enough to get a collaboration with Gucci.
JoJo is very good, and one of the best, if you tell me that a collaboration with Gucci makes jojo, better than Logh, it's like telling me = Justin Bieber is better in the music of John Lennon because the first, makes promotions and models with famous clothing and the other not.
so, user - san ...... you are choosing very bad arguments to defend your good but not excellent taste and all I ask of you, is a thanks for letting me educate you as it should
you're welcome!! user, next time you come back soon !!!
Arya is pure you son of a bitch
This is a new kind of pasta. What shall we call it?
She's got quite a kill count for someone her age. She just killed Raff the Sweetling in a WOW Preview.
Can we all agree that Tywin and Stannis are the best characters?
Tyrion > Tywin.
Stannis is best Baratheon though.
They foreshadowed Manderly to be in this season when Roose counted them among his allies to hold Winterfell against any retaliation from either other Northern houses or Lannisters upset over Ramsey's marriage to regicide suspect Sansa Stark. Not sure if we'll get the pies scene though.
No. Jon and Robb are the best characters.
Ramsay's wedding is already over. Also, I'm not sure where Davos is. I'm not sure if we'll get the same "The North Remembers" feeling.
Why are they blaming D&D for the show though?
muh cheeky quip-making dwarf
i suggest you avoid a certain twow preview chapter then...
not wanting Tyrion to journey to the mystical land of Wherever Whores Go where he'll encounter the God of Tits & Wine who shall send him on a quest to fuck every whore on the planet
The real question is could HBO do a live action LOGH?
It'd need more tits and sex, but it could be pitched to them as Game of Thrones in space.
But who would they cast?
Who could play Yang? Or Reinhardt?
It was just a kiss. She made him pay a heavy price for it.
I live in my mother's attic. Big difference.
read a review of a new anime or video game
"Its just like Game of Thrones!"
Rob is an arrogant shit. He deserved to die.
Is there any Northern Lord more based than Wyman Manderly? What would anime Manderly look like?
I fell for this meme out of curiosity with regards to Akame ga Kill, which I only managed to endure until the episode after the glasses girl got killed off.
I say he could have won the war. Edmure man, he fucked up a lot.
Jack Sparrow holding onto Captain Barbosa's gun
Iseildor's broken blade
Its actually a common troupe. But of course, Game of Thrones ruins it. Like it ruins everything.
most of the interesting characters die early
every episode would be endless exposition that's even worse than usual in anime
I'd watch an anime about a knight and his cute loli squire but not the game of thrones.
a live action LOGH
I prey to God for this to never happen.
This. Death to traitors.
The only reason I never hated Jon with the same fervor was because despite being a vow breaking retard he was going all No Love Deep Cover anyway so falling in with Egrit was technically a good thing. Also unlike Rob he didn't lose sight of his greater obligations to the people of his lands. If the wildlings were all civillians it would be different but as almost all of them were environment hardend warriors bringing them into the fold against a larger threat is the only smart answer assuming you could avoid sedition.
He could have won the war if:
-he didn't marry that bitch from Volantis and stuck to his promise to Lord Frey
-his mom didn't release Jaime
-his uncle followed his orders and lured the Mountain and his army into a trap and killed them
anyone but Theon
get on my level
I want a Don Quixote anime featuring a dojiiko oujo-sama type of knight and her tsukkomi loli squire.
What Jon did wasn't betrayal. The half-hand told him to kill him so that he could gain the wildlings trust and gain information on Mance. If you want to get technical, Jon refusing to kill the horse-breeder was probably the closest thing to betrayal, since he blew his cover and could have easily gotten more information if he stuck with them longer.
Is it called Fate Zero?
Who voiced CIA for the Dark Knight Jap dub?
Fuck you, Robb was our true king.
except Stannis is the true king.
He fucked Egrit dude. That's an oathbreak. Half hand is a non-event, obviously that is for the good of the watch.
Robb broke oaths with his whore too. The difference was Jon could still serve his primary purpose. Robb was like, 'fuck it I'll cross that bridge when we come to it'
Who would voice the Mannis?
Stannis is a kinslayer
Robb was an amazing stragist but a horrid king. Death to oathbreakers who take their people so lightly they would risk the lives of their kin, their friends, their allies and their lineage to get a nut.
If I had a wolf's head picture I could post it.
If him fucking Yggrite counts as treason, then what does killing the half-hand mean? If the vows are set in stone and can't be broken no matter what, then the half-hand wanting to be killed doesn't matter, because its just as treasonous to kill a fellow watcher.
YOU GONNA DIE FOR SUM CHICKENS?
married the Frey
Robb's a King, he's too good for a Frey. If he's going to backstab somebody them then should consider Margaery Tyrell or someone who can bring more men & resources than the Westerlings.
Had he captured Tywin, Jamie would have been a heavy but greatly softened blow.
I say he should have gave Edmure some better instructions. Had Robb's trap worked, he would have captured Tywin & King's Landing would fall. The Tyrells are no friends of Stannis after Robert's Rebellion, they wouldn't go to Stannis.
Karstarks were related to Starks.
Killing half hand was a pragmatic desicion that optimised the chance of a good out come for the watch and thus the south. It was the right thing to do.
Fucking Yggrite is oath breaking and actually falling for is traitorous.
She's still a qt tho. While fucking Yggrite is an oathbreak it didn't ultimately stop Jon serving the watch. Robb having sex with his floozy did directly fuck up his Kingly obligations.
Yggrite stated explicitly that she wanted Jon to break his vows by fucking her. If Jon refused, she would rat him out, he would have be killed, and everything would have been for nothing. Him fucking her was just as pragmatic and just as much a violation of his oath as killing the half-hand.
DON'T EVEN JOKE ABOUT THIS
If only the 3D Arya would look this cute...
I agree. However Jon DID like her and that decision wasn't, nor the resulting decisions, entirely pragmatic and for the good of the watch Yggrite became a factor and priority. He wasn't deep cover he just had a crush on the cutie red head wildling but didn't want to oathbreak.
The only decent post in the whole thread.
How is this not dead yet?
some better instructions
STAY PUT is good enough.
It would be better as a live action series and you know it. It's being held back as it is.
Robb's a King, he's too good for a Frey
As opposed to some random bitch from Volantis.
I would watch the fuck out of this.
mfw bad pussy female death squad sent up against the rozzenritter on all their planet based mission
They'd gut everything great about the series and turn it into mindless blood and tits. And then turn half the cast into women of color because of muh diversity.
The pact was required. Even if he killed her and remarried later. He needed to secure that alliance in the war times. It had been made abundantly clear how integral it was.
Robb deserved to die.
This shit crushed me I when read it. Eddard is depression on legs.
oh my god those shadows
my dick is rock hard
I would agree but considering Edmure, hat wouldn't work. I'd say "DON'T MOVE ANYWHERE NO ATTACK JUST STAY PUT" about a hundred times to ensure he gets the bloody message,
Terrible taste in women too. Why her?
He needed to secure that alliance in the war times
No, he needed the Freys because they had a bridge & were bitchy over letting him cross it. Now that they're past the bridge, they aren't worth too much. The Riverlanders he rescued had plenty more men than the Freys.
Holy shit my sides. That's what they did with the Targaryen crow in the north?
Glad I dropped that piece of shit.
The Winds of Winter fucking when?
You're a fucking idiot. The bridge is a critical position. The Freys could have said fuck it, stay in the south for all we care. You crossed once but you've remarried, have fun with the long way around.
Being able to manage safe supply lines and retreat to safety when required is essential.
You're as dumb as Robb; you deserve him.
I'd prefer an anime of a fantasy like Malazan Book of the Fallen since all the races and over the top magic make a live action version of that practically impossible because of budgetary concerns.
Why must being dark & gritty be considered mature?
But the show really is just pandering for the grimdark. There was zero reason to have Cersei and Jaime rape. Zero reason for the Sand Snakes to kill their Prince brother. No reason to have Tommen being whipped into place with sex by Margery. They just keep adding gratutious edge and sex to keep the show "le mature new fantasy show on HBO, only for mature fans such as my mature self."
Makes complete sense but still unconfirmed.
Was it rape?
What about wherever whores go? Tyrion being obsessed about it ever since he was told the truth? It's been a while since I read book 5.
Tyrion will never make his own House with the silver coins, and 1 gold one upon a red field
Ugh no. One of LOGH's strengths is its slow pacing.
D&D fucking shits
The bridge is a critical position
You mean letting them back North? The reason why Robb listened to their demands was because of the urgency & potential of losing Riverrun. The Freys are Tully Bannermen. Assuming they tried pulling that shit while Robb isn't so desperate, they'd be pissing off Robb & all of the other Riverlanders.
What retreat? They have Riverrun & Riverlanders to take care of. If Robb retreated North, he'd abandon the Riverlanders. This'd be worse than pissing all over the Freys.
Supplies? They brought shit with them but the big problem was Riverland's supplies. Tywin's shit fucked them good. The Riverlands were gleaned rather cleanly. Robb pushed forward not only so Tywin will have a harder time regrouping but also so Tywin won't be able to fuck with the Riverlands.
Jaime, Tyrion, and Kevan are bros.
He made the very terrible mistake of not knowing his subordinates. All of his fuckups are because of that.
I don't care what anyone says, you're my nigga.
Here, have a Piuy.
Poor bloke. Varys admitted he was a good man.
not knowing his subordinates
Truly that was the worst. Roose was plotting behind his back & Edmure was fucking up left & right.
Malazan would make a great anime.
Enormous lore, how much will be shown?
Nah I'd prefer an anime adaptation of Stormbringer. And I want Amano to do character designs.
Who is the most badass yet pitiful character and why is it Sandor?
Jesus Christ why is this still up?
while Robb isn't so desperate,
Which he was, during war time.
If they feared physical rebukes they would just turn to his enemies for help, which they did, and he was killed.
You're an idiot. Stay out of politics and probably managerial positions as well.
supplies? They brought it with them
Then it's poorly written. For massive armies, worse if you include the river lands, you would need a supply line.
Robb was right to let the Riverlands re-cooperate and resupply themselves so as not to tax on his resources but he fucked up with the Freys monumentally.
Here's the reasoning from a noble perspective
retract gift of using bridge
slaughtered by Robb
must avoid dying
side with the southerners
Robb handed Walder the knife to stab his back with. Irredeemable cock-in-hand retard.
Tyrion completely loses it after he kills Tywin.
In the show he recovers after 2 episodes or so. In Dance he never really does.
Then again in the show he never really finds out about Tysha from Jaime, so he's still on friendly terms with him.
Book Tyrion is out for his entire family's blood, to ironically prove them they were right all along.
Because knights are assholes.
Whoever it is, he would have to be a big-name guy.
Going with the douchiebaggiest faggot in all of the seven kingdoms after shitting on his face and expecting not to get fucked up the ass
At least he had the sense to leave his wife behind.
Troid is too busy jerking off to MLP.
I watch everything for 1 episode.
Most of the lore is explained through dialogue and interpretation anyway. It would need like 12 episodes per book, minimum. There were pretty much 0 narrator infodumps, even when I desperately wanted a narrator infodump.
S-surely this year, r-right?
Being this analblasted that the thread is still up
Holy fuck just hide it you sperglord
Oh, that. Well yeah he's broken since he learns about Tysha and kills Tywin. At least he's still functional and continues with his japes.
Fat man cried about not being done last year.
He will cry at the end of this year too.
Okay, now that you mention it this is too much. Both need to be deleted.
That he is sadly. I really fucking hate him. Why did they even let a guy who doesn't even watch anime moderate an anime board? I'm seriously about to try and contact Hiro on twitter and ask him to do something about this
Which he was, during war time
Don't you remember the circumstances? Jamie had Riverrun under seige. Robb was at the risk of losing the Tully men. That was one of Robb's most desperate times. After Robb rescued them, the Riverlanders made up plenty of Robb's number. I'd sooner piss all over the Freys than all of the Riverlanders including House Tully.
If they feared physical rebukes they would just turn to his enemies for help, which they did, and he was killed
You think their cries for help would work? Let's say the Freys cried for help, would the Lannisters help? The Freys are Tully Bannermen, they serve House Tully. Cries for help would be laughed at seeing as the Tullys & Lannisters were at war. The Freys had leverage then but not forever. They knew to make the marriage pact before their biggest bargaining chip lost value.
Then it's poorly written
You want to explain to me how Tywin somehow fed his army through foraging alone? Or how Tywin managed to make it back to King's Landing just in time to save them from Stannis despite the time it took to reach the Tyrells?
He will die before he finishes it
It would be trash. Absolutely trash. They'd remove 90% of all the dialogue replace it with meaningless pillow talk sex scenes, and fast forward the plot to the "EPIC SPACE BATTLES," ignore all the background planning and political maneuvering, and probably spend a ridiculous amount of time spent on ship to ship combat.
Didn't GRRM pretty much give up on it? He got all pissy that people were asking when the next book will be out and said "it'll be out when it's out" and I'm certain he just doesn't give a fuck anymore. He really hates his own characters and just writes to fuck up their lives as an outlet for his emotions.
I'd sooner piss all over the Freys
He didn't need to piss on ANYONE. If he didn't think with his dick he would have won.
If only Edmure married the Frey beforehand. If the war started with Edmure fucking Roslin, they'd still be fucked unless Edmure was too busy fucking to attack Tywin.
spend a ridiculous amount of time spent on ship to ship combat.
I could have accepted a couple more episodes of pilot fighting. It was really nice and they could have done more with it. Just filler my shit up, I guess, but you know, people could just skip it.
I dunno user, he seems like a Dany fanboy to me. Sure bad shit happens to her, but she's in the best situation at the moment. That kahalasar she meet at the end will surely join her.
If he didn't think with his dick he would have won.
The problem wasn't his dick. Fucking some nobleman's daughter wasn't a problem. Trying to mimic daddy and being HONORABLE about it was the retarded faux pas.