Why didn't they get Shaft to adapt it

Julian Howard
Julian Howard

Why didn't they get Shaft to adapt it. What the fuck man?

All urls found in this thread:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NbElewFH464
Logan Cooper
Logan Cooper

SHAFT

I'd rather Gonzo.

Austin Ross
Austin Ross

Gonzo

I'd rather Bones.

Adam Flores
Adam Flores

Bones
I'd rather KyoAni.

Jeremiah Barnes
Jeremiah Barnes

KyoAni
I'd rather Shaft.

Ryder Rodriguez
Ryder Rodriguez

Busy with animating true masterpieces like March comes like a Lion which won relevant manga prizes.

Aiden Phillips
Aiden Phillips

replace lack of speech with even more head tilts

Aaron Bell
Aaron Bell

Shaft
I'd rahter DEEN

Daniel Howard
Daniel Howard

Good. We won't end up with a Powerpoint Presentation claiming to be a movie, then.

Ian Carter
Ian Carter

Better question: why did he draw her neck like that?

Ryan Peterson
Ryan Peterson

If she's deaf how can she read and write?

Gavin Cruz
Gavin Cruz

user pls

Parker Wright
Parker Wright

SHAFT can't adapt drama like this.

Connor Nguyen
Connor Nguyen

Can't wait to see how they ruin it.

Nolan Mitchell
Nolan Mitchell

They can't afford SHAFT.

Brandon Jones
Brandon Jones

shaft's slaves can't afford to lead a production committee like kyoani
FTFY

Brandon Perry
Brandon Perry

I don't think it would fit their style.

Daniel Miller
Daniel Miller

That fat fuck was so useless to the plot, hope the completely remove him in the movie.

Zachary Moore
Zachary Moore

Deaf people have guide dogs to teach them

Cooper Price
Cooper Price

Long necks are a universal sign of beauty

Chase Bell
Chase Bell

Ueno ruined the manga

Aaron Reed
Aaron Reed

It's the perfect match for KyoAni and their love for melodramas.

Shaft has better stuff to animate.

Bentley Gray
Bentley Gray

SHAFT
Animate

Niceme.me

Jacob Thomas
Jacob Thomas

How are they going to butcher this one, boys?

Julian Stewart
Julian Stewart

that would be fun

Xavier Bell
Xavier Bell

SHAFT is also doing a melodrama this fall. I read some of it and it wasn't nearly as interesting as Koe no Katachi, though.

Jaxon White
Jaxon White

Zaregoto
by shaft
NISIOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Why? White fox did a great job with this style, is shaft becoming Nisio?
Is white fox kill?

Hunter Cruz
Hunter Cruz

He was okay for a while but I was hoping he improve but never really did. Of course the author let a lot of the characters get away with shit like Kawai.

Ryan Jones
Ryan Jones

It isn't a melodrama at all, especially the kind KyoAni loves to do with big emotions and all the exaggerated and overblown stuff.
March Comes Like A Lion is on a different league in story telling and characterization.

There is nothing wrong with the way KyoAni does stuff, so Silent Voices is the perfect anime for KyoAni and people should be happy that it gets animated by KyoAni.

Mason Foster
Mason Foster

with big emotions and all the exaggerated and overblown stuff
Sure thing buddy. Try reading it some time.

Luis Thompson
Luis Thompson

I guess you don't know what a melodrama is.

Ian Brown
Ian Brown

muh I'm so lonely and broken
muh I'm such a gary stu
muh no one understands my pain
muh cute girl(s) make me feel like I belong somewhere

A1 already adapted that same plot once. But keep pretending 3-gatsu is on a different league.

Wyatt Walker
Wyatt Walker

It isn't a melodrama at all
The denial is strong.

Matthew Roberts
Matthew Roberts

At least you were able to hide the fact that you are a troll for two posts.

Dylan Torres
Dylan Torres

I've literally never seen people discuss 3-gatsu here, and when a thread comes up it devolves into studio wars, it kinda says how uneventful the manga is

Julian Johnson
Julian Johnson

people crying = melodrama
wew lad

Alexander Howard
Alexander Howard

kill yourself, asshat

Cooper Phillips
Cooper Phillips

Gets proven wrong
Backpedalling

wew lad

Juan Murphy
Juan Murphy

I've literally never seen people discuss 3-gatsu here
That's because Sup Forums can't handle a real literature.

Jayden Bennett
Jayden Bennett

Literally nobody gave a shit about the manga on Sup Forums until it was announced Shaft was doing it.

William Martin
William Martin

March comes in like a lion is like a prime example of a typical slice of life story.

Sebastian Phillips
Sebastian Phillips

Why are these characters crying? If they were rational like myself, they would solve their problems without resorting to petty emotional displays.

Ayden King
Ayden King

March comes in like a lion is like a prime example of a typical melodrama.
ftfy

John Harris
John Harris

It's more of a sports anime with melodrama than a SoL.

Easton Morgan
Easton Morgan

i'm just FULLMETAL PANICKED right now

Are you fucking serious?

Justin Hughes
Justin Hughes

You're retarded.
Melodrama = forced emotion

Nothing is forced in Sangatsu

Owen Jones
Owen Jones

Thread starts out with a SHAFTfag trying to troll KyoAnibros
Turns into KyoAnibros trolling SHAFTfags

Christian Perez
Christian Perez

And what is forced in KnK?

Dylan Thompson
Dylan Thompson

Lesbianism

Daniel King
Daniel King

Not Gatoh's best work, that scene.

Daniel Garcia
Daniel Garcia

When the fuck will the KyoAni FMP reveal be?

Cooper Gomez
Cooper Gomez

2 months

Hunter Perry
Hunter Perry

mangafags have been reading this long before the meme studio announced the adaptation.
can't wait until you faggots ruin this one too, just like shigatsu. the shigatsu manga was great

Hudson Foster
Hudson Foster

Because
1. Shaft is shit
2. They didn't "get" anyone, they were seeked.
3. KyoAni has the buck to pay for other companies' material.
4. Shaft is shit.

Caleb Mitchell
Caleb Mitchell

Shaft just has no variance. Why do they live?

Camden Perry
Camden Perry

Why does Shouko make my dick so hard?

Xavier Davis
Xavier Davis

To adapt Nisio works of course. Same with Ufotable and Type-Moon garbage

Michael Gutierrez
Michael Gutierrez

Low standards.

Levi Morales
Levi Morales

the manga sucks

Brandon Walker
Brandon Walker

Cause shaft is garbage

Anthony Harris
Anthony Harris

Only reason I will care is if it has an anime original ending, and not that blue-balling cop out ending

Josiah Butler
Josiah Butler

kissfags

Elijah Jackson
Elijah Jackson

Nothing makes me hate humanity faster than reading this shit. Well done author.

Samuel Smith
Samuel Smith

She is deaf, not paraplegic. Save your neck breaking animation.

Elijah Moore
Elijah Moore

animation
It would be a bunch of stills.

Ryan Howard
Ryan Howard

He just seemed to fill space. Which really shouldn't be hard for someone his size.

Jordan Perry
Jordan Perry

Rude

Matthew Long
Matthew Long

I don't remember finding him that bad. Why do some people hate him.

Ryan Hernandez
Ryan Hernandez

Because Kyoani always finds a way.

Asher Clark
Asher Clark

I think the author intentionally made almost all the characters static. The only exceptions I can think of are the MC and the deaf girl's mom and sister.

Kayden Barnes
Kayden Barnes

Kyoani has a more compatible animation design

Ryder Hernandez
Ryder Hernandez

So Ueno will be Mio 5.0?

Adrian Hernandez
Adrian Hernandez

Wait, what business does a Japanese studio have with adapting a western VN developed by Sup Forums of all people? I mean, I love Katawa Shoujo but this is being too hopeful.

John White
John White

Nishimiya did this first.
I hate myself but I love everyone

Justin Rogers
Justin Rogers

Ueno is a combination of Shinka and Homura though.

Nolan Gray
Nolan Gray

Shaft will be busy with Fate/Head Tilt

Adam Evans
Adam Evans

Design wise I feel like she'll be more Mio than Shinka.

Isaac Williams
Isaac Williams

Shaft
Being faithful to Source Material
Don't make me laugh, user. I'm not Kyoani cultist or anything but All shaft works are complete shit outside PPD & SZS.

Sup Forums and /r/anime completely overestimating Shaft, quality wise. I wonder if redditfag really leaking to Sup Forums.

Liam Bailey
Liam Bailey

It says more about /a/'s almost complete lack of knowledge about manga. 3-gatsu's probably the best ongoing series.

Austin Green
Austin Green

Keep telling yourself that.

Wyatt Harris
Wyatt Harris

I've seen very obscure manga being discussed here and nowhere else, so you're definitely wrong. 3-Gatsu is very popular, even more than Koe no Katachi was, yet it barely gets any threads here, maybe because it doesn't really match the tastes of the average Sup Forums user, not because they didn't know it exist.

Jonathan Gray
Jonathan Gray

I've seen very obscure manga being discussed here and nowhere else, so you're definitely wrong.
Not really. A manga's popularity in Japan correlates only weakly to its popularity on Sup Forums. Something that sells like shit can become a big flavor-of-the-month hit here, but the overall lack of knowledge comes in because most people don't read very much besides those few flavor-of-the-months, some things with anime, and a battle shounen or two.

Oliver Morgan
Oliver Morgan

Spoken like a true newfag.

Adrian Hall
Adrian Hall

Says Sup Forums only talks about popular manga
3-gatsu one of the most popular and best selling manga in the past 5-6 years
/a/ doesn't even talk about it other than when having SHAFT threads

Gabriel Ortiz
Gabriel Ortiz

sangatsu's bullying arc kills the entirety of koe no katachi

it aptly outlines the difference between seinen and shounen

James Green
James Green

Says Sup Forums only talks about popular manga
I didn't.

Gabriel Howard
Gabriel Howard

6/10, at least made me laugh.

Liam Murphy
Liam Murphy

Why didn't they
they
Who?
fucking who?
It's kyoani who asked the author, shaft didn't give a fuck. There's no they in the process

Lucas Carter
Lucas Carter

Spoken like a true Pornogatarifag.

Aaron Sullivan
Aaron Sullivan

What do you expect from Aniplex little doggy, user?

Logan Rodriguez
Logan Rodriguez

Let's all be real here. 3-gatsu will flop.

Dorama slot? Housewives don't watch anime, they'd rather have live action drama.

Kid slot? 3-gatsu will bore them to tears.

I don't see this fitting anywhere but in the 2:00-4:30 slot that gets the lowest ratings. It'll probably have even worse viewership than recent Boku Hero Academia episodes, and their BDs will not sell at all. And since it's an NHK anime it will probably be publicly funded, which means 0 budget.

Jace Gomez
Jace Gomez

literally powerpoint the studio

I wouldn't trust shaft to animate the story of my life and all I do is sit in the basement and come on Sup Forums

Aiden Ross
Aiden Ross

This

Luis Watson
Luis Watson

damn this manga was dull shit

Jose Taylor
Jose Taylor

March comes in like a lion is like a prime example of a typical slice of life story.
Yotsuba, you mean.
March is melodrama + sports.

SoL stories don't care about dramatic moments, it's all about atmosphere.

Nathan Rodriguez
Nathan Rodriguez

I'm sorry to hear that you have terminal shit taste.

Ryan Hernandez
Ryan Hernandez

Wait, did people seriously not like Ueno? She was one of the best characters.

Tyler Watson
Tyler Watson

Sucking Anipleb dick

Andrew James
Andrew James

overrated studios: the thread

epic meme everyone

Colton Johnson
Colton Johnson

I'm sorry to hear that you have terminal shit taste.

Julian Richardson
Julian Richardson

Their relationship reminded me on a crazier version of these two.

Jonathan Smith
Jonathan Smith

99% of the story she was bad for the sake of plot. in the end, she becomes a tsundere.

Ian Brooks
Ian Brooks

I'm sorry to hear that you have terminal shit taste

Benjamin Rogers
Benjamin Rogers

mfw she ends being Sahara's bitch

Oliver Bailey
Oliver Bailey

Everyone was happy until she showed back up. She ruins everything. She sucks.

Angel Smith
Angel Smith

You need some plastic villain for melodrama. It isn't her fault.
Hatesex with her must be great tho

Brayden Parker
Brayden Parker

She was one of the best characters though

Jacob Moore
Jacob Moore

Melodrama
More like melo-make all the other characters feel like shit cuz shes a bitch. I wouldn't even hate sex her she makes my dick shrivel and depress back into my body

Gavin Gray
Gavin Gray

THIS.
/Thread.

Benjamin King
Benjamin King

She was very hateful little shit.

I don't even remember how she redeemed herself.

Austin Sanders
Austin Sanders

damn

Alexander Scott
Alexander Scott

Gifted with by* a deus ex machina.
Atleast get your shitty copy pasta right

Charles Stewart
Charles Stewart

Please guys everyone knows A-1 is the way to go when it comes to forced drama.

Jacob Scott
Jacob Scott

That's wrong.

In This Corner of the World is a text book SoL manga series although the main protogonist must deals with the second world war.

Andrew Barnes
Andrew Barnes

people think SoL are only their cute four girls nothin happens bullshit series

Colton Butler
Colton Butler

I'd rather KyoAni
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NbElewFH464

Tyler Sanchez
Tyler Sanchez

Because Kyoani is the better studio.
Also fans want an actual anime and not a fucking presentation.

Nolan Foster
Nolan Foster

What did she mean by this?

Carter Nguyen
Carter Nguyen

The best doujin are the ones that are the high-quality ones that show genuine love and appreciation for the work they're based upon. This is one of those doujin.

Gavin James
Gavin James

He was good when he was introduced. He found Ishida's bike in a field and brought it back to him. He was also genuinely friendly to Ishida, even if he came out a little strong. But it becomes more and more apparent that he's never had friends, and he comes across as annoying. He's clingy, jealous, and self-centered. I don't think the readers of the manga really gave a shit about the movie subplot because of him, when it was supposed to be a touching moment near the end. He just kept forcing it over and over, making it feel out of place. If the movie came about naturally and progressed naturally before the big bridge fight, it would have felt a lot better to see it at the end.

Caleb Barnes
Caleb Barnes

Because other studios would actually animate it instead of shoehorning in ebin headtilts.

Jeremiah Evans
Jeremiah Evans

Berserk doujins are funny as fuck

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page