How would you adapt Tsukihime into an anime?

Jeremiah Williams
Jeremiah Williams

How would you adapt Tsukihime into an anime?

All urls found in this thread:
http://tmdict.com/en/ro.roa
Kayden Jones
Kayden Jones

Spend 2000 years in Autodesk Animator.

Eli Adams
Eli Adams

12 episodes of Ciel and Arc tearing each other's clothes off!

Wyatt Jenkins
Wyatt Jenkins

I'd rather not, to be honest.

And I am sure type-moon feels the same way. Why waste money on this when they can add a new Saber/Rin clone to their gacha garbage game and roll in dosh?

Aiden Ross
Aiden Ross

No way of doing it without upsetting fanboys and getting a lot of negative backlash. Even if you do everything right, it'll still be shit on.

Alexander Kelly
Alexander Kelly

How would you adapt Tsukihime into an anime?
First you need to remake it into Fate franchise.

Jayden Cruz
Jayden Cruz

Even if you do everything right, it'll still be shit on.

Why so cynical?

Ryan Perry
Ryan Perry

Adapted by Sup Forums in powerpoint using badly done mspaint drawings

Grayson Roberts
Grayson Roberts

It's how the fanbase works, it's not being cynical. Even the updated visuals for the remake like the picture posted above has been getting a lot of flack. You are not going to please the fanbase no matter how you approach it unless it's literally a carbon copy of the VN, and you can't do that with anime because they are two completely different ways of telling a story.

Joshua Kelly
Joshua Kelly

Why does everyone hate Ciel again?

Nathaniel Evans
Nathaniel Evans

Worst girl in a cast that's already host to several bad girls. Her backstory is so hilariously fetishized you can't take it seriously. Curry shits.

Alexander Foster
Alexander Foster

I like her but you can't really take her seriously. It doesn't help that her route is basically a canned Arcueid route from what I can remember.

James Carter
James Carter

Either the manga (which would not be the complete story) or a few OVAs for each route. They're just too many and too short.

Michael Howard
Michael Howard

People seem to like the manga well enough.

Asher Wright
Asher Wright

no more comfy Tsukihime threads
no more comfy Melty threads
Take me back to pre-F/Z anime, Sup Forums.

Carter James
Carter James

Her design in the original game is pretty ugly. She looks a lot better here.

Kayden Fisher
Kayden Fisher

I've fapped way too much to the Ciel sex scene.

Isaiah Wright
Isaiah Wright

don't complain if you aren't making the threads

Evan Nguyen
Evan Nguyen

Why does Type-Moon hates Tsukihime?

Jacob Brown
Jacob Brown

I wonder if there could be some way to delete Fate/Zero from history, but keep Strange/Fake and CCC

Luis Scott
Luis Scott

Who says I haven't?

Ian Brown
Ian Brown

Even the updated visuals for the remake like the picture posted above has been getting a lot of flack

Why do you think that is?

Christian Hall
Christian Hall

They don't hate it, it's just an irrelevant franchise that wouldn't make them money.

Connor Bell
Connor Bell

It doesn't print money.

me

But seriously, is there really anything to even discuss at this point? Any Tsukihime threads made now would just be shitty image dumps. I'd enjoy Melty Blood threads where we set up games but I'm really shit at it.

Juan Turner
Juan Turner

It doesn't make any money

Xavier Green
Xavier Green

Everyone told me I should do Arcueid's route first, so I concentrated fully on her, but ended up on Ciel's fucking route anyway. I'll never forgive her for that bullshit.

Noah Lewis
Noah Lewis

Let's play right now. Do you have the Steam version?

Grayson Morgan
Grayson Morgan

You can do either first. Ciel's route is better unless you want to see Shiki rape Arc.

Bentley Hill
Bentley Hill

I don't have it installed anymore but it wasn't the steam version so yeah. Sorry m8

Easton White
Easton White

There were so many Tsukihime and Melty Blood threads because of Carnival Phantasm and Type-Moon festival inspiring people to check it out.

Oliver Reed
Oliver Reed

23 minutes of "Read the VN" printed on the screen.

Kayden Reyes
Kayden Reyes

Arc and Ciel have far bigger tits than that.

They're both straight though. Tsukihime was before Nasu got a Bisexual fetish and shoved them everywhere.

Angel Evans
Angel Evans

Carnival Phantasm is popular on Sup Forums
the amount of "Do I have to watch F/SN or Tsukihime first?"
watch
people watching series just to bandwagon on the currently popular one
implying anyone played Melty Blood just for Carnival Phantasm and weren't just a bunch of secondaries

k

James Smith
James Smith

That's not a good adaption now, is it?

Asher Williams
Asher Williams

Look at the manga, basically.

Josiah Thompson
Josiah Thompson

In all 3 of Arcueid’s story modes, Ciel always appears as part of the main dialogues, just so everyone knows how gay she is for Ciel. (She even appears twice in Archetype Earth’s story mode…)

Meanwhile, Arcueid only appears in Powerd Ciel’s story mode as Warcueid, who proceeds with her casual flirting. And in regular Ciel’s story mode, she is only briefly hinted while Ciel secretly wishes to coexist with her (which connects with regular Arcueid’s scenario with her, where Ciel wants to straighten out their convoluted relationship).

Brayden Jackson
Brayden Jackson

What does the manga do right?

Josiah White
Josiah White

Really forgettable route with a really forgettable heroine.

Aaron Sanders
Aaron Sanders

She's a hierophantic bitch who's always trying to kill everyone over "muh inquisition" bullshit, and her personality other than that is pretty much just "senpai with glasses". She'd be a good side character, but she had no business being one of the main heroines.

Logan Lopez
Logan Lopez

It's better than the anime in every way. It really only covers the Arcueid route though. I'd recommend it to anyone who wants to get to know Tsukihime but doesn't have the time to invest into playing the VN with the hope that it interests them enough to one day play it.

Carter Perry
Carter Perry

It's the Arc route but Vol. 4 features Ciel and Akiha, Vol. 6 features Ciel and Roa and Vol. 10 features an epilogue with Shiki and Arc reuniting.

Jace James
Jace James

Turn all the girls into lolis and have them kiss a lot.

Kayden Russell
Kayden Russell

I first heard about Tsukihime after I found Melty Blood in an arcade, and I went for Ciel's route first cause I thought she was a qt. So glad I didn't play Arc's route first, otherwise I would have felt Ciel's route was shit.

Hunter Sullivan
Hunter Sullivan

So Near Side routes are trash, Far Side is the way to go?

Jaxon Robinson
Jaxon Robinson

Is the Steam version not compatible with the non-Steam versions?

Landon Sullivan
Landon Sullivan

Staying home rather than going outside to the scary world is always better after all.

Logan Ramirez
Logan Ramirez

Pretty sure it isn't. The Steam version has much better networking anyways.

Michael Cruz
Michael Cruz

It already had one, and it was good enough to spawn the Type Shit fanbase we have today. If you don't believe me, find that blogpost from the guy who started the tranlations crediting the tsukihime anime.
inb4 that dumb meme everyone hates by now

Anthony Ward
Anthony Ward

Not that guy but I swear one day if I stop being a NEET ill get a real controller and we'll set up a game on the steam one.

Andrew Martinez
Andrew Martinez

Sure.

Gavin Kelly
Gavin Kelly

What if it had another adaption that wasn't compressed or abridged?

Ian Bailey
Ian Bailey

Adapt the manga
Then adapt the other routes (except for Ciel's).

Wyatt Myers
Wyatt Myers

tfw remake never ever

James Stewart
James Stewart

The manga already added the Ciel and Roa scenes from her route.

Samuel Lewis
Samuel Lewis

You know the challenges with this. It's the same thing people complained about with DEEN's adaptation. They aren't going to want to adapt just one route because they know they can get better viewership by incorporating elements of each route and making a more "complete" version.

Andrew Morgan
Andrew Morgan

Acquire Nasu's notes on unreleased route and adapt that one in cooperation with him

Hudson Green
Hudson Green

Probably adapt near side while either removing elements from far side or transplanting them into near side
Also make ending into Ciel good end

Connor Taylor
Connor Taylor

make them servants and magi in a holy grail war.

Wyatt Evans
Wyatt Evans

take great girl
paint her blond
get best girl

Asher Campbell
Asher Campbell

Exactly.

Liam Russell
Liam Russell

TM did NOTHING on April's fool again
rip

Oliver Williams
Oliver Williams

They did more FGO shit, like the FGO Pokemon GO ripoff.

Kevin Powell
Kevin Powell

What about Aniplex doing UBW and HF individually?

Justin Price
Justin Price

tfw no translations for 10 years anyways
tfw not fluent enough to read it anyways

Nolan Davis
Nolan Davis

Also make ending into Ciel good end

What about Arc True and Ciel True instead?

Lincoln Davis
Lincoln Davis

melty blood gets a new manga
nobody cares or bothers to translate it

Asher Hernandez
Asher Hernandez

Common complaints go down the path of Arcuid having a shorter skirt, arcuid looking too much like saber, complaining that things don't look like a literal potato anymore. Just the fact that the type-moon artstyle has evolved since 2000.

Lincoln Collins
Lincoln Collins

Yup.
This and last year, thanks FGO.
We will never have a TMitter again, we will never have another Nero NicoNico stream, we will never have another game with Yumizuka as final boss, we will never have another wrestling showdown between Rin and Luvia.

Type-Moon's soul is dead.

Jacob Roberts
Jacob Roberts

What? Fate/Zero anime made Tsukihime relevant again for bringing up the dead apostles with Kiritsugu's backstory.

Zachary Wilson
Zachary Wilson

Turn best girl into a seibah clone
Turn best imouto into a Rin clone.
Turn best meido into a wormslut clone
All other girls are fandisk bait
"Sacchin? Who is this Sacchin I keep hearing about?"

Done

Jacob Allen
Jacob Allen

Just animate the manga but sacchin dies like in farside

Thomas Edwards
Thomas Edwards

One of Tsukihime R subplots is tied to FGO, so.

Matthew Wright
Matthew Wright

Tsukihimefags literally aren't intelligent enough to solve this

Colton Lopez
Colton Lopez

You absolutely should go through Arcueid's story, but yeah the Far Side routes are everyone's favorites because they have a lot more emotionally going on.

Jordan Reed
Jordan Reed

That was a minor improvement followed by a massive setback because F/Z brought in faggots that don't care about TM as a whole to the threads so they could shitpost about their new favorite anime series.

William Davis
William Davis

I don't "hate" Ciel, but I never got what reason she and Shiki have to be attracted to each other in her route.

Arc falls in love with Shiki cause he's the first person to treat her as a person rather than a weapon, and hanging out with him was the first time she ever did stuff for fun.
Akiha and Hisui both fall in love with Shiki cause they were childhood friends; and Akiha has a further bond with him as a result of saving his life.
Kohaku falls in love with Shiki cause seeing his face beckoning to her to come play was the only bright spot in the endless torture that was her childhood.

But Ciel? What reason does she have to like Shiki? She flat out admits to him that spending time with him was only a ruse so that she could kill Roa. She changes her mind after getting to know him, but I find it hard to believe she would fall in love with him in only a span of a week.

I also don't understand why Shiki views hanging out with Ciel as one of the happiest times in his life. All they did was eat lunch together and talk in the tea ceremony room a few times. Again, maybe they would have fallen in love eventually from spending time together like that, but within a week?

I also don't get why Ciel views Shiki as so special. I understand Arc, Hisui, and Kohaku viewing Shiki as special since they are all so isolated from other people. Akiha is less isolated compared to them, but again, she and Shiki have a special bond. As for Ciel, she has been an undead assassin for a few years admittedly, but she was still a normal human once. So she shouldn't view stuff like eating lunch together as so special.

Basically, one week seems like too short a time for Ciel and Shiki to fall in love; and unlike the other heroines, there's nothing special about Shiki's and Ciel's relationship which should drive them together so quickly. The lack of a bond between Ciel and Shiki can be seen in how Shiki still likes Arc in Ciel's route, and how Ciel's good end is the only harem end.

Jayden Fisher
Jayden Fisher

Done

Justin Nelson
Justin Nelson

route with This Chair
forgettable

Near side routes beung similar till nero dies isnt a problem with ciel, its a problem with arc because everything if value besides deito and some a+ shiki one liners is in ciel route

Kevin Davis
Kevin Davis

Adapt Ciel
Adapt Hisui (Saori Gotou HAS to voice her since no Miyu ;_;)
Don't care about the rest

Joshua Nguyen
Joshua Nguyen

So why do people hate Akiha redesign?

Michael Rivera
Michael Rivera

It was a short apk with riyo chibis you can capture for free.
Roman waving goodbye at the player before the servers shut down in the end with sad music box ost music specially composed for that scene became the number one twitter trend in Japan. Blowing the fuck out Granblue event and BD releases.

Nasu just added more fuel to the fire.

Julian Hall
Julian Hall

Over 80% of the current fanbase doesn't care about TM Vns. Nasu said so.

Jaxon Torres
Jaxon Torres

I don't, I think my waifu looks pretty good

Jonathan Nelson
Jonathan Nelson

I absolutely love it. I don't remember anyone hating it other than pointing out that she had a black hairband rather than a white one in the promotional thing.

Andrew Phillips
Andrew Phillips

Disgusting.
Fuck FGO.

Blake Hernandez
Blake Hernandez

Ciel relates to shiki as a previous roa and those boring moments drinking tea and shit are the only normal things shes done in literally decades

Meanwhile shiki just has ciel as his type

Julian Collins
Julian Collins

How did we go from this..

Ian Sanchez
Ian Sanchez

to this?

Isaiah Evans
Isaiah Evans

It was only after Fate proved to have a really strong fan base

Brayden Reyes
Brayden Reyes

Shiki had a super boring pseudo-neet life with the arimas and a genuinely pretty shit one before that, his standards are oretty low

Hudson Peterson
Hudson Peterson

That was the only memorable moment. Generally speaking, the mindfuck scenes get old after a while.

If they kept that, and every other character's color schemes like they did with Hisui and Kohaku, they would have been just fine. That being said, Ciel's redesign came out as the best looking one.

I don't even understand what the point of Ciel's route was or even Ciel herself. It's really more like a Roa route then a Ciel route.

Aaron Nguyen
Aaron Nguyen

Yeah, that's the current fanbase. Which is post F/Z. That wasn't the case back then.

Easton Lopez
Easton Lopez

It's really more like a Roa route then a Ciel route.

Kinda like how UBW was an Archer route than a Ciel route?

Bentley Anderson
Bentley Anderson

So how long would Satsuki need to be at servant level anyway?
Two decades?

Landon Howard
Landon Howard

decades

Has it really been decades since Ciel was made undead? I thought she was Roa's host immediately prior to Shiki, and thus it's only been several years.

Colton Adams
Colton Adams

If you skip Ciel's route you'll miss out on a lot of fairly important character development and exposition, not only for Ciel, but also for Roa and Shiki, not only Tohno but Nanaya too. I'd even argue that Arc gets more interesting character development on Ciel's route than her own. That being said none of those characters (besides Shiki) really matter on the Far Side, so it's not like you won't understand what's going on if you skip it, but I've always considered Ciel's route to just straight up be a better version of Arc's route once you get to the point they stop overlapping, even if you like Arc more than Ciel.

Kayden Rogers
Kayden Rogers

Both are my least favorite heroines. This explains a LOT.

Jose Jackson
Jose Jackson

Shirou x Redman would have been so good. Shame we didn't get it.

Jordan Morgan
Jordan Morgan

Doesn't Roa only overlay onto people that aren't born yet?

Ian Myers
Ian Myers

Because that's a recolor of the actual redesign.

Jayden Phillips
Jayden Phillips

Yeah, but Tohsaka isn't boring.

Eli Smith
Eli Smith

Shiki raping Kohaku or jacking off while choking her isn't memorable
Pretty sure that's the origin of the whole "rape the maids" meme.
Also facing the previous heroine as final boss was pretty damn cool.

Jeremiah Moore
Jeremiah Moore

I thought people liked UBW the best because it didn't have any romance or 'love' scenes like Fate and HF did with Saber and Sakura.

Kayden Cooper
Kayden Cooper

Saber and Caster contribute more to UBW than Rin does. She's more of an ally type of character then a love interest even in her own route.

UBW had the worst kind of writing. Rin arbitrarily decides to go in a date for no fucking reason, knowing they are in danger because war where there was no rush about it (if was Shirou with Saber, at least it made sense). At least Fate/HF didn't have that shit.

Justin Jones
Justin Jones

Ciel was roa in the 70s, thats how arc and ciel built up their relationship, they kept hunting roas

Liam Williams
Liam Williams

http://tmdict.com/en/ro.roa

Remember, Roa loses part of himself every time he bodyswaps. Why? Because he takes in parts of the host. Why else would he choose a wealthy host if he wouldn't retain any of his memories?

Jack Edwards
Jack Edwards

Rin arbitrarily decides to go in a date for no fucking reason
I cannot read between the lines

Adam Lopez
Adam Lopez

Who said love? Shirou just needed to cum inside him to help keep him alive for the final battle.

Kayden Ramirez
Kayden Ramirez

I didn't say she was the smartest or the most capable. She makes mistakes, quite a few of them actually, and that's a-okay.

Gavin Turner
Gavin Turner

Shiki raping Kohaku or jacking off while choking her isn't memorable
Pretty sure that's the origin of the whole "rape the maids" meme.

Those scenes are memorable, but they're still horribly written because Nasu decided to change what should have been a dark, horrifying scene into fap fuel midway through the scene. He tried to make it simultaneously horrifying and hot, and failed at both. Not even the "rape the maids" meme we got out of those scenes redeem them imo.

Thomas Collins
Thomas Collins

non-virgin
tries to kill you
ugly glasses
smells like curry

Hunter Turner
Hunter Turner

I found it appropriately gave the feeling of how completely fucked up Shiki was at the time. Maybe you're just a sexual predator, user.

Nolan Richardson
Nolan Richardson

Is Hisui the only girl that doesn't try to kill Shiki?

James Lopez
James Lopez

I found it appropriately gave the feeling of how completely fucked up Shiki was at the time. Maybe you're just a sexual predator, user.

You didn't find the CG of Kohaku being fucked from behind and then the text describing Kohaku as starting to enjoy it to be fetishized?

I found the scene prior to the above to be very horrifying and it did indeed give me a sense of how fucked up Shiki was. But when the CG popped up, it gave me the sense that Nasu was now trying to shoehorn in his rape fetish, and it completely killed the previous mood.

Grayson Rogers
Grayson Rogers

There were indeed a lot of little moments in Ciel's route, but for the most part, it's boring plodding story and its Nasu's writing at it's very worst. It's just...not as good as the other routes, by far.
No pun intended

Jonathan Ramirez
Jonathan Ramirez

Tsukihime is a psychological horror story, user

Aaron Phillips
Aaron Phillips

Unless you count her cooking, then yes.

So an extra point in Hisui's favor, but I still view Akiha as best girl.

Jackson Fisher
Jackson Fisher

Which is post FGO
Fixed it for you. FZ was popular, but FGO is bigger than anything Nasu ever did. Nasu was expecting 100k players at most.

Jason Myers
Jason Myers

non-virgin
tries to kill you

So you hate Kohaku too?

Jack Young
Jack Young

If you think FGO is when things went to shit, you're sorely mistaken. FGO just accelerated the process a hundredfold.

Adrian Scott
Adrian Scott

Didn't Nasu plan it as Fate/Apocrypha but it burned so he turned it into a book series?

John Price
John Price

pretty much all of the heroines except arc were bad. hisui was ok but her route was awful.

Hudson Lewis
Hudson Lewis

Hisui route
awful

Brayden James
Brayden James

shiki spends half the route stuck in his bed going insane. only near side was good. far side is overrated as hell.

Jace Gutierrez
Jace Gutierrez

only near side was good. far side is overrated as hell.

please explain

Adrian Wright
Adrian Wright

near side is simple chunni with cool stuff like arc and powder curry and nrvnsqr. far side is nothing but shiki and all of the heroines being complese mental cases.

Anthony Stewart
Anthony Stewart

arc
good

pick one

Joseph Scott
Joseph Scott

Yes, but he and Takeuchi had no idea what they were doing and only expected 100k players at most.

Zachary Williams
Zachary Williams

some random screenshot

Adam Powell
Adam Powell

I wouldn't. If you don't want to read Tsukihime the visual novel, you are not worthy of it.

Logan Peterson
Logan Peterson

I love hisui and you should too

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page