Would you rather read a comic with shit writing but good art or a comic with...

Justin Young
Justin Young

Would you rather read a comic with shit writing but good art or a comic with good writing but shit art?

All urls found in this thread:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VkwGeMlB_4Y
Joshua Baker
Joshua Baker

I'm blind so I'd prefer the good writing.

Ryan Stewart
Ryan Stewart

Basically DC movies and Marvel movies

William Hill
William Hill

The second one by far. I read for the story. Morrison's JLA is amazing, but the art is horrid. Same deal for that Kingpin mini that came out last year.

Camden Campbell
Camden Campbell

good comic with shit art

I would rather read Gillen's Uncanny X Men drawn by Land, than the last Civil War event written by Bendis but with nice art.

Lucas Jenkins
Lucas Jenkins

I'm an artfag so the first one.
Most comic writing is pretty mediocre anyway

Jack Edwards
Jack Edwards

I would rather take a 3rd option, since it actually exists in the real world.

Cooper Long
Cooper Long

Story over art
It's easy to overlook shit art if the story is fun, just like reading a book
It's harder to overlook shit story, even if the colors are pretty

Jacob Reyes
Jacob Reyes

good writing
applicable to either of those

Grayson Cook
Grayson Cook

Good writing is rarer than good art so definitely the one with good writing
Also dumb frog poster

Michael Gomez
Michael Gomez

Shit art.
I prefer Mob Psycho to Civil War II.

Asher Watson
Asher Watson

if it was good writing wouldn't it be just a novel?

Henry Bailey
Henry Bailey

Good writing/artwork but always late
or
"Okay" writing/artwork but always on-schedule

Joseph Collins
Joseph Collins

Why do you think the term graphic novel exist

Nathaniel Cox
Nathaniel Cox

I'd rather read a comic with good story and shit art, but if I'm gonna be honest - waaay more likely I'll start reading something with good art. I'm sure there are tons of gems I just passed over because they weren't immediately appealing to my eye

Sebastian Richardson
Sebastian Richardson

Well played

Adam Flores
Adam Flores

I would rather read neither of those.

Levi Campbell
Levi Campbell

Good writing but shit art. I can look at good art in screencaps on the internet, but if I don't care about the story then there's no reason for me to read the book.

Owen Nelson
Owen Nelson

"Good writing can save bad art, but good art can't save bad writing"

Nicholas Evans
Nicholas Evans

Unless it's porn

Juan Collins
Juan Collins

He doesn't jerk it to erotica fiction

Brandon Sanders
Brandon Sanders

good art with no writing

Jaxon Cruz
Jaxon Cruz

I need both to be at leadt adequate or I am out.

Or old with good artwork and solid stories. There is a liftimes worth of readingbthat fits that category.

Daniel Thompson
Daniel Thompson

GW + GA

Gavin Wright
Gavin Wright

Good writing, shit art. The writing needs to be really good though.

I'll be honest, if a comic has amazing art and mediocre writing I'll still follow it. However, if a comic has mediocre art and mediocre writing, I'll just drop it instantly.

Grayson Mitchell
Grayson Mitchell

I already read plenty of webcomics that have shitty art, so the latter. Unless I'm fapping to it, and even then I can only take so much shitty writing before I decide to just forget about it.

Aaron Gomez
Aaron Gomez

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VkwGeMlB_4Y

Anthony Reyes
Anthony Reyes

Good writing, bad art if it's a shared universe superhero comic book.

Bad writing, good art if it's a stand alone story.

Joshua Hughes
Joshua Hughes

this desu

Michael Gonzalez
Michael Gonzalez

Good writing. Tails Gets Trolled and One Punch Man beats Bendis writing with Curt Swan art.

Wyatt Gutierrez
Wyatt Gutierrez

As I am on Sup Forums board instead of /a/, it looks like I would rather read comic with good writing but shit art.

Blake Howard
Blake Howard

I would say good writing is more important than good art but art certainly helps.

I can't help but feel the Darth Vader comic would be improved tenfold if the art wasn't traced bullshit. The writing is good but the art is hideous.

Hunter Kelly
Hunter Kelly

Morrison's JLA is amazing, but the art is horrid

There is absolutely nothing wrong with 90's Howard Porter.

Jace Peterson
Jace Peterson

Does your computer screen have brail or something?

Leo Thomas
Leo Thomas

Text to speech?

Justin Bailey
Justin Bailey

all these writerfags in a primarily visual medium
stop reading superheroes and start reading stuff with good artists

Christian Hill
Christian Hill

you ever watched a porno and stopped masturbaiting because the story is really good?

Brandon Myers
Brandon Myers

I prefer Mob Psycho
he think One is a bad artist.

John Rivera
John Rivera

Yes
I call it a boner of the heart

Adrian Bell
Adrian Bell

You might as well be reading a book and using your own imagination for the latter choice.

Jaxson Flores
Jaxson Flores

thats basicly it

Landon Wilson
Landon Wilson

I sometimes think One is better than he's letting on.

Brayden Johnson
Brayden Johnson

Good story. Sandman had shitty art for a few arcs but it was still brilliant.

Daniel Adams
Daniel Adams

Those two end up being the same in the end

Jason Anderson
Jason Anderson

Comics are a visual medium, so good art and shit writing easily. Anyone that says otherwise is a pleb

Camden Allen
Camden Allen

Good plotting > good art

Parker Wood
Parker Wood

Comics are a visual media, so the art should be pretty important, but at the end of the day a comic book is about a story being told and that's what the writing provides. So ultimately I'd take good writing and shit art.

Carter Long
Carter Long

People might say the second, but they all mean the first.

Jaxson Powell
Jaxson Powell

Always thought the same thing, although the inker was part of the problem too

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page