So why did she not tell the rest of the crew the plan thus preventing all the unnecessary deaths?

So why did she not tell the rest of the crew the plan thus preventing all the unnecessary deaths?

Other urls found in this thread:

vanityfair.com/hollywood/2017/12/star-wars-last-jedi-laura-dern-admiral-holdo-listen-to-women
twitter.com/AnonBabble

She doesn’t need to explain herself to a MAN, silly

She's a military commander, she doesn't owe subordinates an explanation for orders. Poe didn't respect the chain of command, and Poe's spergout was insubordinate and retarded and cause so many more people to die. Leia and Diane were completely right about how dangerous he was.

Because Disney needed to shoehorn in a "Poe is a hotshot who has to learn to lead" aseop and did it by ruining the characters of everyone involved in the plotline.

> Resistance leadership is completely run by women.
> Resistance fleet is completely obliterated and the only rebels left can all fit on the Millennium Falcon.
> They still need a white guy to help them escape.
Powerful.

Because she's a cunt

Am I the only one that wants to give mummy cummies?

Because it was her turn now turn off your brain and fuck off flyboy

Yes

She caused a mutiny that alone would show that she did not have the respect of here subordinates who thought they were basically just gonna die, would it have been so hard to say what was happening when her crew had guns to her instead of just saying "there is a plan, I'm totally not gonna get us all killed guys trust me".

>She's a military commander, she doesn't owe subordinates an explanation for orders
Leia is not anymore yet she barged in and just immediately shot Poe

Rewatch the battle on Endor. Rewatch the exchange between Akbar and Lando.
Look how rational and respectful are they.

But that's the entire point, she didn't give any orders. She didn't tell anyone to do shit until they were evacuating. How can you follow a plan you don't understand?

If she'd told everyone what her plan was the finn/chink casino adventure never would have happened and then benito wouldn't have leaked info that caused the transports to get blown up.

>akbar got killed offscreen so we could have this cunt

Why did she say that she liked Poe after all his shit? A mutineer is just packed onto the transport ship with smiles and laughs.

after the rebels get tracked through hyperspace, something they thought was impossible, shouldn't their first thought be a mole? i'm pretty sure that possibility was never even brought up. if they were suspicious of a possible mole, that could explain why holdo didn't want to tell everybody what the plan was.... but they never bothered to bring it up. instead, they went for a GRRRL POWER XD moment at the expense of poe and finns characters. which is a shame, because john boyega was by far the best thing in TFA, and it was a bummer to see his character completely wasted on a bullshit plot that went nowhere.

>>akbar got killed offscreen so we could have this cunt
This is what hurts me the most

Because she is a pervy old woman that wants his young pilot D.

>poe works to try and save everybody on board along with all their weapons including the capital ship
>Commander Tumblr decides to run away but its ok because that planet over there has a bunker we can hide in
>oh shit they figured out our plan and they're destroying our people in their defenseless little transports
>better ram them with the biggest material asset we have
Arguably the most poorly written character.

bump

You have a skeleton crew and all of the veteran leaders have been killed (more or less) you are facing total annihilation, you are running a skeleton crew whom you have no rapport with (she is a literal who to everyone on the ship but the aforementioned leaderhsip) and you do not want to explain the very simple plan of escape.

The cruiser was totally fucked either way

The sin there was that she didn't immediately ram them as soon as everyone was off rather than waiting for them to destroy the transports

To be honest, it's Finn, Rose and Poe who are in the wrong, with Holdo being their superior. For once in Star Wars defying your commander yielded negative results

Except Holdo was being a total retard and refused to explain why she was doing what she was and let them believe they were basically just going to commit suicide ergo she's a retard and the only reason that she exists is for the purpose of plot subversion like you said. Unfortunately that makes it a worthless addition.

>For once in Star Wars
??

Horse fucking shit. Bad leadership is not communicating your plan to your subordinates. Military officers are trained and evaluated on their ability to communicate missions so that everyone is on the same page. She didn't even correct Poe when he said that the escape pods would mean certain death. Poe was completely justified in taking every action he did, and that bitch sabotaged the entire operation.

The problem I had is that she's presented as doing nothing, then it turns out she had a plan all along and if poe had just done nothing it *could* have succeeded, but was by no means guaranteed. Poe is to the resistance what Luke was to the rebellion at the end of ANH. Not only a war hero but squadron leader for the entire ship (and his demotion doesn't change that fact). And she didn't tell anybody her plan as far as we see. There are several bridge officers that side with poe during the mutiny, so she wasn't just keeping him in the dark, but the whole ship.

This is wrong. Under no circumstances are junior officers required or expected to follow possibly insane commanders into certain death, which is what they were doing. If Holdo hadn't insisted on rusing everyone there would have been no problem.

Digits confirm

coz she's a woman thats afraid to be judged

She was unironically the best girl in the movie
Even better than hermione corfield

>use cruiser to destroy largest enemy vessel only after you've lost all of the support craft
>supposedly they evacuated the personnel to the cruiser
In a writing sense I can see why they did it because the cruiser would probably have more room for fuel so they could drag the retarded chase scene through the whole movie. But why is that an essential part of the movie in the first place? Why get dogged and chased relentlessly only to just sacrifice what you were trying to protect?

is this a jewish hat from the future ?

As the superior officer it was her responsibility to maintain command of her own subordinates and ensure that their morale and loyalty did not waver. It was ultimately her failure to communicate (or at the bare minimum ensure that Poe would not become a liability by throwing him in the brig or something) that lead to to the mutiny. It is 100% her own fault that things went the way they did.

anyone else want to fuck her

I seriously couldn't stand the anti white male propaganda:
>Luke is somehow responsible for creating the villain and became a pathetic hermit who refuses to take responsability for his mistakes
>Hux is still an anti-white carricature : laughable, petty and sadistic
>Ben is immaturity personified with his anger fits and multi-daddy-issues, and has proved himself unredeemable by the end of the movie

It isn't much better for the 2 white latino men:
>Poe is portrayed as irresponsable and is treated with earned condescension by his 2 much wiser female bosses
>DJ looks like our last hope, despite his apparent cynicism... then he stabs the heroes in the back.

That plus the fact that a little girl kept kicking my seat through the movie made the whole experience unbearable. But I had to stay through because I ordered middle-row seats and I couldn't walk out of the theater without incommodating at least 2 dozens of people.

holocaust halo

>manshaming

Sentient life doesn't matter as long as it's hurr turn!

One fetish I have that's pretty hard to find is flat chest/small tit titty-fucking. Tit fucking is already such a questionably effective way to get your rocks off that it just means the dude is super horny. But you gotta be some supreme level of horny to try and tit fuck a girl who has no tits. I love that.

It would have been awesome to see Admiral Alahu Ackbar train Poe in military strategy and leadership

Can somone explain to me the scene where the small ships are left behind one after another. I didn't get what was happening there. Did they take the fuel out of the small ships and put it into the big one when they were running away? Why did that captain of the small ship stay behind to die? He only says "evacuation complete" or some crap and then stays behind and dies. Why didn't he evacuate too? Did the small ship have no auto-pilot?

I can smell he pussy from over her clothes, and it's driving me fucking crazy.

So why didn't she get a nose job?

Because mansplainers like Poe need to sit down and be humble.

#TheForceisFemale


vanityfair.com/hollywood/2017/12/star-wars-last-jedi-laura-dern-admiral-holdo-listen-to-women

why did she wear a ball dress while acting as a military commander?

>The film’s progressive ideology is already ticking off some calcified corners of the fandom—the kind of fans who dismissed Ridley’s heroic Rey as a too-powerful “Mary Sue” after the last film. But just because some Star Wars lovers are out of reach for the message this movie delivers, there is still hope for a new generation. Just like that kid at the end of The Last Jedi, holding his broom aloft and wearing the resistance jewelry left behind by Rose, an entire generation of young Star Wars watchers will remember the brave, smart, capable women of The Last Jedi—and the consequences of doubting their leadership.

Are you threatening me, Master Jedi?

Deliver us from this awful trilogy Sheev.

>this is about demoralizing adults, and indoctrinating children

Because women don't speak up and that's why it was unrealistic for her to be an Admiral in the first place.

He is hispanic you piece of shit crusty ass white boy

B-but user... Are you implying women are retarded, inferior creatures who are controlled by their irrational, emotional outbursts and fail to use logic and common sense at any cognitive level?

Because she's a liberal and wanted to abort her own family.

They need competent women in fiction because they sure as fuck don't exit irl.

>Because women don't speak up
Women talk CONSTANTLY. What are you on about?

>vanityfair.com/hollywood/2017/12/star-wars-last-jedi-laura-dern-admiral-holdo-listen-to-women