Why aren't they fucking voiced by KIDS??!!!

why aren't they fucking voiced by KIDS??!!!

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=1YQX-TcV7bI
youtube.com/watch?v=5CmGUBS3LRU
youtube.com/watch?v=glv37o9A5yQ
youtube.com/watch?v=dprop3wGRDE
youtube.com/watch?v=Wu0kqEN2iFk
twitter.com/NSFWRedditVideo

I hate the girl
she used to be the shy weak spot of the team

They should have hired Psychicpebbles to voice all three brothers. His nasal voice would work well for disney ducks.

Meh, why care lots of kids in cartoons are voiced by adults, usually girls Like Tara Strong. It honestly doesnt bother me because kid voices are fucking annoying.

kid voice acting is overrated, it usually sucks, prove me wrong

Kids grow up, hit puberty and their voices change.

Adults pretending to be kids is consistent.

You can't push children as much as adults.

>she used to be the shy weak spot of the team
why would you ever want that shit back

okay, I'm going to be super autistic here and ask why there's no black shadow under the chin when they have them under other spots on the body

Kids are usually shit voice actors

Probably ends up looking shitty, like they all have soul patches

because kids voice are annoying as fuck. Do you really want 90's to be back so badly?

Almost no kid cartoon characters are voiced by actual kids. It's almost always a woman. Child actors are 95% among the worst things on the planet.

too expensive to animate

Forget kids. They should of gotten Ducks!

They never have been

>she used to be the shy weak spot of the team
>Actually liking this

Came here to post this.

They can turn Bob Ross talking into singing they can turn Duck quacks into talking.

Should I watch the classic Duck Tales before this one starts?

Huey seems like a shota with a "genki" personality type and those are usually the best ones in anime.

I'm confused, why is this considered a legit criticism?

What are your motivations for watching this series again?

they weren't even kids in the old series

Its not, its just the only criticism some have right now. Gravity Falls had this complaint to

if you are interested you could watch the movie,it was ok,but the whole series sound a little too much

/r9k/, please leave.

Are we getting it?

Why is American voice acting so shitty when compared to the Japanese?

Because no kid character ever should ever be voiced by an actual kid.

Kids can't fucking act.

Nah doesnt seem necessary, for one all the kids have different personalities, which already kinda makes the new one better.

underrated post

Have you ever heard children voice act? It's fucking awful.

Most kids can't voice act well, their voices change unexpectedly as they hit pbrty, tempramental.

Eh?! BOKU WA... BOKU WA...

MAMURO KOTO

Fuck the trash cartoon and read the comics.

if you want to watch the old one for the shotas I don't recommend it much as the highlight to that one is Scrooge, but the new one definitely stepped up its game in terms of shota I agree
if you wanna talk cartoon shotas there's a thread on /cm/

Japanese voice acting is fucking shit what are you talking about?

Actual kids often can't into professional voice acting because they're still only fucking kids. Also actual kid voices tend to be annoying and too high

Because you dont understand Japanese

Fuck you man the cartoon was good on its own, kill yourself purist comicfag

And it was the weakest fucking part of the story.

Shirly temple coulda ct.
But she was a massive outlier.

Oh it's good (on its own) but it doesn't even compare to the comics. All it really does is take Bark's most memorable stories and turn them into watered down versions with Webby shoved in. Ergo, it's trash in comparison.

of all the international voice acting that exists on this planet, the Japanese one is basically the most shitty you can find
one of the best ones is italian though

god, I hope so

Yeah but no one asked you for a comparison with the comics, some people prefer cartoons, some people don't like to read, there's nothing wrong with that

I kinda have to second this
it feels like now all girl characters in cartoons are more or less written as Mabel from Gravity Falls, which isn't a good thing

I hope I'm wrong and we've just gotten the worst of her scenes

American Voice Acting isn't shitty, it's just shitty when it comes to dubbed anime for some reason. When you actually consider a lot of great Western cartoons, the voice acting is pretty good. Think of Recess, Avatar: LoA, Rugrats, Ducktales and all the other great cartoons of our time.

Even in Ghibli dubs, like Spirited Away or Howls Moving Castle, it's great. Then look at all the Disney movies with the great VA's.

Mostly it comes down to anime dubs being cheap as chips and thus low quality. As well as established in house company VA's that will never leave (looking at you, Chris Sabat).

>As well as established in house company VA's that will never leave (looking at you, Chris Sabat).

That's everywhere though, even Japan the land of Anime and 20 minute Idols seems to use the same VA's over and over again

Peanuts
Gumball

Not like they were voiced by kids in the original cartoon.

Because it's a bad idea. Don't work with children if you don't have to. They can't work that long. They are worse actors and you have to change them after 2 years because they get older.

I want so bad for this to be real, but I'm waiting an official announcement because I don't want to be dissapointed

Gumball I'll give you but fuck peanuts

Because kids will grow out of it. I'm more upset that none of them are even trying to sound like kids.

Are we talking his own show? Because that would be cool to have an actual animated Duck verse.

I hate her voice =/

Still better then original webby's voice

Also Harvey Beaks

Still I'm worried she's going to get the opposite treatment, if they turn her into an overachieving asshole it's not going to be any better.

Good fucking question. I blame Star Vs.

Hey Arnold had probably the best kid voice acting period. Some of them completely unbelievable in how professional they were, like Lila and Helga.

Only the first Gumball's voice was good. The second one was godawful and the new one is lame as fuck. Darwin sound like an annoying nigger now

I just loved her adorable uncuh scwooge
Voice, everytime she would do something sweet I tear up. That's thanks to the sappy cut music that came along.

Why was she so unbearably precious.

>tumblr attacks this post because they're triggered by anyone even SUGGESTING that a girl be feminine
Kill all tumblrites.

Arthur.

not loving a sweet adorable character that actually make situations dangerous and not handled by a bunch of mary sue ducks

yeah feminism can really ruin shows.
I don't mind if they invent their own show and make the females like this
>SU for example
but taking something that already existed and turning it into this... is just sad

They're gay/women. Both have mental problems.

I've been surprised, the kid who does Gumball nails his role, and each replacement kid just steps right in like nothing changed.

>All these retards saying kids can't voice act well.
youtube.com/watch?v=1YQX-TcV7bI

>each replacement kid just steps right in like nothing changed
Yeah that is that a lot of people dropped the show when Logan Grove was replaced

i hate this so fkn much when they ask the voice actors what kind of a person their character is.

Because of this simple thing called puberty, do people actually forgot why we always get 40 year old women doing kids voices?

That's stupid though, every actor was good at playing him. The one that replaced Logan was actually a funnier Gumball.

>kid can voice act well
>he gets replaced by some kid who can't voice act
This is why adult VA are better.

>That's stupid though
Why is stupid? The new kid got and annoying voice.

>The one that replaced Logan was actually a funnier Gumball.
TOP KEK

Labor laws

It is made by the former crew of Gravity Falls after all. So yeah, every cartoon wants a Mabel now.
Cartoonists forgot how to make girls. Girls like Gosalyn.

No wait, that's actually terrible.

Because 99% of kids can't act. Most child characters in cartoons are voiced by adults.

Because its hard to convince and persuade children to do an adult's job


Children should be studying and playing at their age

>>I hate girls
>>They make me feel small, and weak

hating on Kate Micucci...
i don't like you

You really want a Hey Arnold situation where they have to change voice actors every year cause the kids go through puberty?

i forgot my pic

youtube.com/watch?v=5CmGUBS3LRU
this couldn't happen anymore because teapartys are for little girls
youtube.com/watch?v=glv37o9A5yQ
or this
she was strong despite being feminin
now she is the fourth triplet
or this
youtube.com/watch?v=dprop3wGRDE
but wow gz you trade her for this shit
youtube.com/watch?v=Wu0kqEN2iFk

>It is made by the former crew of Gravity Falls after all
D E A D
I N
T H E
WATER
A
T
E
R

Manlet makes another kill. Another mousketeer bites the dust

Because kids are fucking awful voice actors.

I don't understand where the problem is. She seems more capable for an action/adventure type show now and she won't be the annoying sideline character she was for most of the original series. If anything I think Mrs Beakly is the real victim. She was supposed to be the mother figure and a regular housemaid in the originals, but now they've literally turned her into a male (female) bodyguard.

> Based Tennant as Scrooge

Can't fucking wait

don't get me wrong i like old webby too. she saves the day from the yeti in the Ducktales game by being sweet.

i just don't mind new extreme webby either. you do make me realize that they might be losing something by removing the sometimes being nice can save the day element though.

and i thought this thread was more about VAs than characters

How many good kid VAs are there?
How many Gumballs and Darwins have we had to adjust to?

Why not avoid those issues and just go with adults?

Kids have school schedules. Kids go through voice changes. Kids are retarded.

Femme Brock Sampson can hold me anytime

There's a lot of very good voice acting in games. Their animation though is so constricted and provides so little scope for acting that it's not even worth comparing against anything else.

Sour grapes.

This has never been a valid argument and it never will be.

>How many good kid VAs are there?

Ashley Peldon was 13 when she did Darla Dimple, she was good. Francesca Marie Smith was 11 when she voiced Helga Pataki. Do those still count as kids?

the real question is why dont they have their original duck voices

Not to mention child labour laws.

It's easier to make them their own characters instead of a bunch of interchangeable molecules.

Manlet isn't working on this.

Eiter will be fine.