Why doesn't communism work?

...

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=ZVUyyHYkBHk
twitter.com/NSFWRedditVideo

humans are selfish

Fuck everyone but me.

youtube.com/watch?v=ZVUyyHYkBHk

It's just a theory. And theories don't always work the way intended in practice.

Because we dont do work FOR FREE

Aussie is virgin 4 life confirmed.

Because society will always be stratified due to the fact humans are fundamentally unequal

centralized planning is slower and less aware of needs than an organically responding market.

Because you're just expecting a ruling party to give up their power

>what is human nature

It was never supposed to

unlawful sexual activity and usually sexual intercourse carried out forcibly or under threat of injury against the will usually of a female or with a person who is beneath a certain age or incapable of valid consent—compare sexual assault, statutory rape.

It just doesn't

Bcause its based on false premises

Communists.

We cannot forget the people it was written by where exceedingly wealthy and discuss about fighting "the power"

It involves putting lots of power in the hands of a relatively small group of ppl, and ppl are quite shitty, on average.

and that group right now is pushing for pedophilia to be legalized.

Because people are cunts and will abuse the system, unless some hippy comes into power and controls the goverment

Because communist societies were created by theorists who never held any sort of administrative position before and they didn't allow people with previous experience into government because they saw them as security threats so all you had were incompetent idiots who didn't know what they were doing. If the smartest people in the world wanted to create a communist society and they had the power to do it it would work.

Because "I am" is more important than "We are".

This. Which is also why capitalism works. We all work selfishly toward our own best interest and then trade with eachother.

goto teach em the communist propaganda when they are too young to realize its shit.

Don't be retarded the whole idea of communism is stealing from the poor and farmers.

it turns out giving the government that much power to dictate mass redistribution while making it illegal to privately own the means of production turns everyone into a slave to the state

who would've thought such an outcome was possible?

>siezes the means of production
>Cannot produce anything.

Communists in a nutshell.

You eventually run out of other people's money to redistribute

>ctrl+F "niggers"
>0 results
>ctrl+F "jews"
>0 results

REDDIT GET OUT REEEEEEEEEEEEE

because it assumes someone else is better at deciding what you want/need than you are

this is only true for children and retards

>tfw its legal in my state to catch wild deer to hold in my pens for livestock

Basic math.

Communism requires more than what can be produced to survive, failure is part of it's inherent design.

cuz communism promises a beautiful tomorrow, in which you won't need to take a decision on what to do when you're faced with evil, but the evil is the goverment and you have to obey

Because humans are related to chimps, not bees or ants.

don't forget too all the farmers where executed for being fascists and now "the stupid farmers" won't make them more food.

kys flyover bumpkin faggot

only people in the cities call them fly over states.
>because you are uncultured vermin.

Define "communism" and "work".

Don't be angry now user, deer is a great livestock. Lean healthy meat, many people pay a little extra for deer, the hides are beautiful and can be crafted into something or sold to people. A great way to make rewarding money is off your land and the animals/crops on it.

Because there is more to life than working hard to go nowhere to pay for a small class of rich elite government workers to live the good life.

You'd think people in cities would be more intelligent than what they reffer to as country bumpkins but alas no.

Because humans aren't machines

top kek

because only the individuals with strong possessive instincts survived the natural selection process that happened about a hundred thousand years ago when homo sapiens numbered only in the thousands

in other words, homo sapiens sapiens are possessive mammals, an evident fact that your boy marx could not fucking comprehend and neither did and do the fucktards that find his retarded philosophy appealing

the only fucking way communism would actually work would be with abundance of every fucking resource, which is a fucking utopia because, as you have undoubtedly realized watching star trek, we are quite far away from limitless green energy and matter-energy-matter manipulation

cities are the only relevant and cultured part of any country

the rest of you can keep playing spittoon and racing frogs for all we care

it doesn't crash the country or result in the genocide of innocent people.

Because it hinges on the fact that people want to and are satisfied to work for the wellbeing of the whole community. In real life, most people are cunts. They don't care about the community, their neighbour or anyone that isn't them. Communism fails because it's based on the assumption that people are good and responsible, when we're a bunch of selfish homocidal maniacs

socialism doesn't work because centralized bureaucratic stuff is relatively inefficient and can't respond to fluctuations in the market nearly as efficiently as a freer market. some socialist stuff can work but it shouldn't comprise the entire economic system.

also communism will never be achieved because people naturally seek hierarchy and 100% economic equality is a meme. any stateless society will inevitably become a state again. communism can only occur on a small scale such as hippie communes.

Im in Sydney Australia retard I need to escape to country to avoid large groups of handicapped people dressing like gangsters that do not know what country they are in but know what they are pretending.

I got a good laff

Real answer, Joseph Stalin suffered from insane paranoia that led him to make some shit decisions. Unfortunately, when other communist leaders tried to imitate his system they also imitated his insanity, mistakenly thinking it was just how communism worked.

Just third world retards being third world retards.

Any kind of collectivism has never, doesn't, and will never work.

Two things
1 - ruling party wants to defend their rule.
2 - country wants to defend it's interest in global arena.


Communism won't work if there is conflict of interest.

racing frogs sounds great tho

Price signals

>wanting to keep what you earned through your time and labor is greed

yea fuck off nigger

>tfw you dont see stars in the sky every night

The only people it appeals to are deadbeats, degenerates, drug addicts, the spoiled sons and daughters of capitalists who need a new sugar daddy after their parents cut them off and Bernouts, all of whom have never accomplished anything with their lives. The people who could make communism work are all too busy enjoying their hard-earned capitalist wealth and they sure wouldn't give that up to equalize themselves with bottomfeeders so it's "fair".

So it never worked? Why is that deerman?

He's saying that it is more greedy than giving away all of your stuff. Greed in moderation is good.

At the Mercal, a dozen eggs cost 450 bolivars in December. The official price is now 1,020 bolivars. But Linares said she never finds eggs at the Mercal. So she buys them from street vendors for around 1,500 bolivars -- a staggering $150 at the official exchange rate, or about $1.50 at the black market rate.May 31, 2016

communism doesn't work because its hard to keep the communists alive.

see, it's fucking americunts that haven't even experienced communism giving their retarded opinion on it that takes the fucking cake

in the future, when your astute mind sees a correlation, for example between absolute power and insanity, you may want to ask yourself if the causation effect doesn't fit one direction better than the other

>communism
the only sane method of work distribution

>work
y'know, the important stuff:
menstrual paintings
furry comics
drumpf! protests

All the things which contribute to a well-regulated, wholesome and integrative society.

...

Its funny cause its true

No market, therfore no way to assign true values to goods/services. so value are assigned arbitrarily. Like those Russian sheet steel factories, metric was to produce Xmas tonnes of rolled steel per month. Always hit targets, stellar was like tinfoil. Or factories hitting quotas for sunglasses that totally opaque.

Good ole Communism never change.

This means that more Venezuelans are starving than not. Venezuela has one of the largest oil reserves in the world. ... As a result, the nation's children are starving to death. Current President Nicolas Maduro is more than aware of his nation's crisis and that children are starving to death.


>Communism the political doctrine of starving your own people to death.

Fuck off, I won't be a protester after the revolution happens. I'll be a card-carrying commander of the Communist Party, and you're first up against the wall, kiddo.

Heh... Being a militant leftist is so chic, my facebook friends are going to love this post.

Because it's impossible to determine the optimal production as there's no exact estimate of demand. You can build communism regardless of this but it'll lead to inefficient use of resources and slow economic growth.

Here's examples
>production manager of hats tries to figure out how many hats to produce
>decides to ask people how many hats they need
>people ask for hats they need
>some ask for spare hats (in case they go missing or wear out fast)
>some ask for spare hats to sell or trade to other people once their hats go missing or wear out
>production manager bases the production plan on wrong assumptions
>resources are being tied up in hat producing instead of some other product or service that might need those resources more at the time, e.g. socks

>production manager of hats tries to figure out how many hats to produce
>decides to make as many hats as there are people
>not all people wear or need hats
>the hats might not fit everyone just like that
>production manager bases the production plan on wrong assumptions
>resources are being tied up in hat producing instead of some other product or service that might need those resources more at the time, e.g. socks

t. armchair capitalist

...

any Idea what happens to Party Members friend ?

...

...

...

Because there is special interest, corruption, manipulation, ignorance of the population, food shortages, and war.

Who do you think keeps causing these issues?

>the fucking communists.

stalins thanks, aka .32 to the back of the neck
>Yuo are havnig need of my services comrad?

Well since that was answered my next question is this.

Does pic related look familiar to you ?

Thats right kids what you call suburbia are infact massive gulags.

Exactly. Capitalism goes with the flow of human nature (greed, self preservation, self advancement) instead of trying to shame everyone for being what they are.

Communism, in principle. is great. People get greedy however.

Because (((they))) won't let go of their riches and power. It's understandable on egoistic level, but it has to be dealt with, violently if needs be.

There is a difference inbetween being a communist and wanting the rest of the world to be communists so that way you have a never ending wave of slaves.

The only way communism can actually work is if we have star trek level tech.
>and even then its still an extreme stretch its fucking science fiction.

I live in Florida. We know what communism is.

Indeed I am more concerned over the slave owners than the people that don't realize they are slaves.

>Can free far more people taking out the Master.

No, its even more complex than that. Outside influences, power hungry, manipulation, the population being retarded.

I am the machine

Stalin had to manoeuvre between in-party groups (that weren't defined formally). IIRC, there were three of them and one of them was Jews.

While he does seem as an autocrat, he could quickly lose his position or life if he wasn't careful. Some of the people he had to sacrifice were his close friends.

GULAG! GULAG!

check out
Indeed even in Startrek there was still greedy criminals.
>The greatest example of communism still has the same faults.

A Large scale multi-planet Eugenics war is part of the Lore as well.

Its sad to say we may never break from this manipulation that has been set in stone since 1700s. There are puppet masters who don't realize they are puppets themselves. Even the products we consume and sold are pushed on us for reasons unknown to us, but vital to them. Frightening.

A good politician saves people not sacrifices.

yeah theres an entire break-away civilization in the internationally and we are not even aware of their social customs let alone their hierarchy but they are there.

In the International realm*

cool, i'm the descendant of one of the two people from a family of more than 60 blue bloods that survived the genocide that followed the soviet invasion

considering you can relate to this, how is that florida gulag? i heard it's just awful, especially during spring break

we do know they trade kids though...

>In an amalgam of ye olde king making and political marriages.

We only know what we can glean from the data of their slip-ups.

Talmudic jews, aka Satanists

We have a lot of ignorant burgers thanks to the jews.

Do you think that they will skip Mars and send the people straight to Saturn as a sacrifice?

Some are Ex-Jews sure but not all of them are the underlying thread does infact seem to be gnostic satanism or if you preffer as I do Polytheistic Demon Worship.

>Since that is just one figure they worship and ask for favours.