Ask a dirty commie bastard anything

Give me the worst you got

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=0blscnNK-Wc
youtube.com/watch?v=-9jASLItfkk
necrometrics.com/20c5m.htm
youtube.com/watch?v=K4kHiUAjTvQ
hawaii.edu/powerkills/NOTE4.HTM
youtube.com/watch?v=uwgJidatmH8
youtube.com/watch?v=Y021WAdUlW8
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

No

fair enough

...

Why is commie culture so shit? Why do they insist on destroying traditional culture?

I don't have any questions for you, I simply ask that you leave and don't come back here.

Your government is a constitutional republic. You are a republican (lower-case R).

What do you think about your ideology being the cause of death for over 100 million people?

If you are speaking about multiculturalism then I am not for it in a lot of cases, but I want a society without nationality. Borders only divide us and nationalism is in fact the leading cause of pointless wars. Though, you can find Stalinists and Maoists who advocate for natiolism and the preservation of culture.

Explain why you think a hypothetical thought experiment that doesn't account for humanity could be implemented as a legitimate political ideology.

That's dumb. That's like saying someone born in Nazi Germany can't be anything, but a Nazi.

I'll take that into account

I would love to see some sources for this, please :)

The classic humanity argument. I don't think its against human nature to want to aid your fellow human being. Human nature is also built on empathy. What separates us from other animals is our deep empathy for others. That when children are still young, they see the world with empathetic views. It is the bitterness of the capitalistic system that teaches people that one's own self is more important than that of the rest of the world or nation.

Every citizen of a republic is a republican.

I don't think that is correct. It also had nothing to do with my political belief. If you insist that I am a republican, then I am a communist republican.

>I am a communist republican
You can call yourself peter pan, that still won't change your government.

You really aren't making a lot of sense dude. I understand that I am a citizen of a Republic, but that does not make me a republican. A republican would be one who actively participates in the Republic and believes in it, but I do not do that, so...

"lol or classic argument"
Which you still don't have an argument for.
How do you intend to multiply the family unit by several millions without pushback?
How do you intend to stop parents from wanting as good a life as they can possibly manage for their children often at the expense of others?
How do you intend to combat simple greed, jealousy and desire?
How do you intend to ensure that nobody takes on a leadership position and reaps the benefits of such?
How do you intend to remain competitive on the global stage?
How do you expect to succeed where every single other attempt at communism or socialism (save for national socialism which was the only successful model but you lot disown that one) has failed from the major ones which you consider "fake" like the USSR to the smaller hippy communes which function exactly as you believe communism should but yet they still fail?

Answer these questions without literally saying that the supporters of your ideology are children as you just did in your post.

Also me and my children matter more than anyone else and I will behave as such because I am a human being, please convince me that my children and I as the father of my children don't matter and that I should subscribe to your collectivist bollocks as a result.

>A republican would be one who actively participates in the Republic and believes in it, but I do not do that, so...
Do you not live here?
Are you not bound by the laws of this land?

You can think you're Abraham Lincoln, you're still a republican.

Thoughts on Jordan Peterson's criticisms of Marxism?

Ever read the Gulag Archipelago?

Ever read the Socialist phenomenon?

Why be a commie?

Are your parents Socialists?

Do you think communist/Marxist-Leninist death tolls are propaganda?

Why do you continue to live in a capitalist state instead of one that is already socialist?

>You can call yourself peter pan, that still won't change your government.
Are you high?

There is no "already socialist" state. The simple idea of a socialist state is nonsense, as socialism will be stateless.

why can't any of the commies I meet be upright but slightly less murderous stalinists instead of trotcucks who want free gibs

To be fair portugal bro, most of the idealistic friendly gibs commies get executed in the revolutions by the Stalinistic types.

It keeps happening, and Yuri Bezmenov alluded to this in his talks on Ideological subversion(his idealistic and nice friends were targtted for assassination post revolution)

Thoughts on Jason Unruhe?

youtube.com/watch?v=0blscnNK-Wc

youtube.com/watch?v=-9jASLItfkk

I'm subbed to him, and other gommies, for a good laugh

why do jewish supremacists call themselves communists instead of jews?

>republican
>bound by the laws of the republic
This is not what the word means.

What % Jewish were the bolsheviks?

fuck it, liberals deserve to die, I'm down with the proles when that shit goes down

Ever read Capital?

here's an easy one, if the labor theory of value is fake doesn't that invalidate the rest of the shtick?

Marx was a fantastic historian though

Has real communism ever been accomplished?

Why haven't you fucking killed yourself

Communism has never worked

No.

How do you feel about the fact that despite Marx saying the revolution would take place in industrialized societies at the hands of the workers, it actually took place in primarily agricultural societies at the hands of the peasants?

Le evil caste system argument

Dominance hierarchies are older than trees, and are found in every fucking living thing. Why go against evolution?

How hard is it for you to get laid?
And a follow up, on a scale of 1 to 10 how much of a faggot are you?

Why do we live in the wealthiest period in history and why it's because of capitalism?

If - as history has shown - "true" Communism can't be implemented without turning into mass murder purges and starvation, then why is it even worth pursuing?

Its a thought excersize, not a valid practical system of government. Its a pipe dream.

Only Useful Idiot college kids become (briefly) Communists, and a few older people who stuck with it who inevitably have mental instability or psycho-sexual issues of some kind. Tell me I'm wrong.

>The simple idea of a socialist state is nonsense, as socialism will be stateless

>There is no "already socialist" state.
>what is France

>Why do we live in the wealthiest period in history
Because of capitalism.

>and why it's because of capitalism?
Because capitalism socialises production to some extent.

Does it ever bother you to imagine Joseph Stalin sitting at a table in St. Petersburg, feasting on suckling pig and roast beef, as tens of thousands of good little leftists like you died shrieking and begging for their lives in Finnland?

Because that war was just to steal more suckling pig for Joseph Stalin. Stalin probably stole more of the fruits of the working man's labor than any other leader in history, and he objectively did it for his own personal gain and nothing else.

Imagine them, all of those good little leftists, begging and begging as actual working-class fins broke their fingers and pulled their teeth out, looking for gold fillings. Imagine how they must have screamed as their genitals were sliced off, and their eyes gouged out. Meanwhile, back in Moscow, Joseph Stalin pours himself another cup of vodka, and tucks into his pie. Imagine how satisfied he must have felt with his warm, full belly, as a hundred thousand brave little red soldiers froze to death and starved, pleading to the God they had renounced to save them.

And why did they die? To steal from other people. They were literally thieves, every single one of them. And led by the king thief, who stands in front of your picture! Do you identify with them, those pleading thousands, or with him, the man who ate suckling pig drenched in their blood while they died?

Someone post the response to this

Do you really think that communism is possible or you just believe?

Do you think USA can and should become communist?

Don't you think even the theory of communism lacks arguments?

>But the means of production have been seized.
If that was true, that would make it a dictatorship of the proletariat at best. Not socialism.

>But people have elected a socialist government.
Communists do not take part in elections.

The response is to make something up about how hierarchies don't form naturally and then to claim incorrectly that classless and stateless aren't oxymorons, then to post a bad meme about a dictator who murdered people to steal their stuff while wearing a star on his arm, to disprove your own point entirely.

Are traps gay, OP?

10/10 post

>classless and stateless are oxymoron
That would make socialism impossible, and therefore Venezuela all the less socialist.

here you go you peice of shit

necrometrics.com/20c5m.htm

>what is France
A capitalist country.

You are misusing the term Socialism. Anarcho-Socialism is a very specific subset of Socialist theory which became contested ground between Marx and Bakunin. Simply pretending that Authoritarian Socialism didn't exist is laughable. State ownership of the means of production is a form of socialism.

The fact that Anarcho-Socialism doesn't exist (and it doesn't) mostly BTFOs Marx and to an extent Bakunin, but Marx was already BTFO'd by history when the global communist revolution simply didn't happen because Capital did what he said they wouldn't do and agreed to compromise with labor for mutual benefit.

Capitalism is best! You're a big dummy head!

What class are you from? Why do entitled children of the petit bourgeois try so hard to be comrades? I can't wait to unleash red terror on you soft gay hypocritical college educated fucks.

Socialism, for a Marxist, is the first phase of a communist society. No more, no less.

And we have no problem with authoritarianism.

All first worlders excluding the homeless are petit bourgeois

So what do you invision your role in the communist system to be?


youtube.com/watch?v=K4kHiUAjTvQ

Lenin was a rich Jew.

No. Maybe proletarian aristocracy, but not petit-bourgeois.

Do you accept evolutionary psychology and race realism as fact, or are you a creationist of the mind like most leftists?

Go visit China sometime and see how much empathy most of humanity has for each other fuckface.

>I can't refute this so can someone else do it for me

Yes but look at the context he was using it in.

Have you actually read the works of marxist intellectuals such as Gramsci, Althusser, Lukacs, and, obviosly, Marx? Cause it seems that most of self proclaimed communists just take in account the basic idea of "equality", yet they do not bother about studying the ideology in a deep way.

all bets are that if he got his way, he would be disillusioned after seeing what his "communist social justice utopia" means in practice, and he will be the most critical of the regime. but this new regime does not tolerate dissent. he will simply be lined up against a wall and squashed like a cockroach.

many people get rich by writing a book criticising the us government, but nobody in the communist system is going to pay him nothing for his beautiful criticism of the regime.

...

why did you starve the 6million in ukraine

>Gramsci

And different colors of cats tend to be better at catching mice than others, if you know what I mean.

>dictatorship of the proletariat
>Communists do not take part in elections

Pierre pls

if you dont believe that,
hawaii.edu/powerkills/NOTE4.HTM

Why do you think you could ever stand a chance against our glorious Capitalist system?

It's irrelevant.
Jesus Christ this better be b8

Are you aware these whole identity politics is founden on the frankfurt school and critical theory to implement marxism?

What? These are basic tenets of Marxism.

SAVAGE
A
V
A
G
E

...

>implying high marxist ideals will not be thrown out the window as soon as the economy goes to shit, which it always does under such a system

Parliamentary democracy sucks.

youtube.com/watch?v=uwgJidatmH8

Dictatorship of the proletariate does not necessarily mean a literal dictatorship system.

A democracy would be fine.
The dictatorship of the proletariat means that non-proletarians cannot govern.

Democracy is naturally compatible with socialism/marxism as it seeks to distribute the means of production and power.

I'm not saying this has appropriately happened historically but thats the theoretical application.

>wants workers to keep what's theirs
>supports exploitation of labour

I've only read excerpts of The Gommie Masturbefesto. I didn't like what I read.

I haven't touched Das Kapital

Great post. Mao was even worse.

Does that make you a gommie or a fashy--I can't tell at this point.

communism exasperates every problem it intends to solve

I'm sure Russian peasants would agree with that statement :^)

I'm a neoreactionary anyway

The Manifesto are Marx's shitkid years.

Das Kapital is where it is at.

The way you throw Socialism, Marxism and Communism around interchangeably suggests you have no idea what you're talking about.

>Ideals
You should read Marx.

>The dictatorship of the proletariat means that non-proletarians cannot govern.
Which completely contradicts the democratic myth.
Moreover, the dictatorship of the proletariat does mean a literal dictatorship of the communist programme, embodied in the party.

can you lend me your ear?
youtube.com/watch?v=Y021WAdUlW8

Do you consider yourself to be a filthy anarcho-com or an un-cucked, top-left of the political compass, real commie?

>He thinks the natzees were socialist

TANKIES GET OUT

I need more rope. Cunt.

You can't quite understand what is in the manifesto and why if you haven't read Capital.

No not true, there is a real class of working poor.
And it's funny because we despise communism, but given the chance I will gleefully knock some entitled college kiddies teeth out with a hammer and take his wealth.
Because that's what he wants to do to me.
These kiddies spit on my kind, the working poor bogans and they preach to us about the virtues of communism, top fucking kek.

whatever's convenient, I'm in it for the ride