GIve me one reason why a fully fledged communist society wouldnt work

GIve me one reason why a fully fledged communist society wouldnt work.

Protip: you cant.

Who cares, fuck off.

fuck off mate u just saying that but u haven't lived in one. No sane man who lived under comunism wants 100% to go back to comunism.

GIve me one reason why a fully fledged national socialist society wouldnt work.

Protip: you cant.

Communism is against human nature

Define needs and wants
Personal and private property

It didn't work in the past , it can't work now

Only on a planetary scale.

The lack of freedom would cause a revolt, not to mention any form of greed will make it no longer equal, and that being the basis of its retardation, you'd just fuck up.

Because nobody is gonna give u one more try

Do the world a favour: move to Venezula and starve to death.

Because communism is dumb as dogshit. In theory it works in small communities / tribes, but on a country-wide scale it's fucking stupid.

Doctors and highly educated people getting paid / earning the same as a somalian refugee who's unemployed and doesn't speak the fucking local language is absolutely fucking retarded, and you should be shot for thinking otherwise.

Suck a fuck and eat a shit you commy cunt.

Reason: Clash of national interests. Communism, on the other hand, is international.

It can work if it can stomp the hordes of your own population which wants more food, money and individual rights

corruption

Communism does actually work.
You just need to realise that it's supposed to bring about mass starvation, corruption, oppression and murder.

Remember: Whenever communism failed in the past, it was not REAL communism.

Shouldn't you be in your shed Sven?

what's up with all these swedish shills recently on this board? it's like they want us to hate them all.

Because the ideal commie society would be classless and stateless.
But in the process of achieving this trough revolution you have to essentially wage war and create an authoritarian state to wage this war.
This state will never give up control therefore it will always be a distopian hellhole with autocratic rule.
Which means people will still rule over other people and exploit them.

Millions of immigrants will sit with no jobs bringing the entire population to the ground. Just as they do in capitalist societies, just communism would be inherently worse.

>Swedish shills
Nah m8 this is just how swedes think

nobody cares sweden, you do you. we will watch your collapse in smug satisfaction from a distance.

Not just immigrants, if you get rid of private property, no one has any incentive to work because you'll only be benefitting the dindus and mudshits who are much more used to gibmedats. In a world wide communism, humanity would collapse within a generation.

To be honest China works and isnt real communism

Swedish education

Actually believing that the leaders of a communist party would be living with the exact same conditions as you are as neighbors, how naive.

R U S S I A

Define "fully fledged". Even the fully fledged commienation will easily collapse on itself without any form of tribalism/self-identity.

Hell, even Stalin understood that.

Because it would be the end of you, but that might just be a good thing.

because people don't like their stuff being stolen from them, one dissenting citizen and it all falls apart.

USSR,Cuba,North Korea

I said you can't.

even Canada thinks you're cucked. Sort yourself out sweden.

Read: The Gulag Archipelago, if you have the mental fortitude and capacity. Then come back and tell us why communism is even worth the energy to think about, much less try.

Protip: you can't

You should really go try out North Korea first. If you are retarded enough to actually invite communism onto yourself and your people, particularly after your excursion into feminist-socialism has obviously failed you miserably with your women being fuck dolls for shitskins, your men unable to stand up and be men and stop it, and your entire country too scared of being called "islamaphobic" to admit that anything is even wrong, then you deserve everything you get. The gene pool will be decimated by gulag and political "extrajudicial killings", the ones that survive will be little brown swede slaves that cant question or think because of the resulting drop in iq across the collective country.

Do you shitnozzles really believe that is worse to be called an islamaphobe than to stand up and speak the truth about what is happening to your people? The muslims that are raping your women are giving you something honorable tofight for, to die for, and you shrink into a corner like a fucking bitch. you are done.

one reason? see ussr.

Nyet communist is fine. Have job for everybody, local police, gulag police, even guy who shoot prisoner in head for livink. Work in factory 14 hours per day husband work in factory 14 hours per day girlfriend even babushka work in factory 14 hours per day. Toilet paper line is five blocks long, is good day praise glorious communism.

Because it is nearly impossible to determine the incentives of millions of people. All the free market is the default organic model that people like to use when interacting with others. When you try to suppress the free market it just turns into a black market.

>USSR
Strictly looking at the numbers and industrial development, irrespective of the "human cost" so to speak, Stalin's system worked extremely well, achieved rapid growth, industrialization and near full employment in a country that was by and large very underdeveloped and damaged from the 1917 revolution and following civil war. Economically speaking, the USSR started going down hill the moment Khruschev's economic "liberalization" replaced the strict centralized policy of Stalin. Stalin also had serious penalties in place to combat problems systemic to a planned system, (ie. the lack of incentive to work or maintain property that you have no vested interested or ownership stake in, and the desire to "personally" profit [eg, theft, fund/resource diversion]). If you engaged in any of these behaviors you were shot or thrown into a gulag under Stalin.

I am not arguing that it is superior to capitalism. I am merely stating that it can "work", albeit at a large human toll.

Commies BTFO

>Communism didn't work because we didn't include the next town!
>Communism didn't work because we didn't include the next state!
>Communism didn't work because we didn't include all the countries!
>Communism didn't work because we didn't include the ayys!

God damn why are commies so fucking retarded.

yes, basically enslaving a massive population is fairly effective. china did it too.

M8, I can achieve full employment too if I got all the unemployed people to dig holes and fill them in again. Or in the case of a real communist utopia, digging graves for their buddies who died in the gulags.

...

I really suggest you check OP, the reply you replied to and your reply. Try to find the flaw in your logic.

I'll be waiting.