Ask a Marxist anything

Ask a Marxist anything.

Other urls found in this thread:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dry_water
twitter.com/AnonBabble

did you read das kapital?

D'you read Castoriadis ? Highly advise you do so. Made me snap out of it, while remaining a commie.

why aren't you in the marxism/communism general you doughy cunt?

How long did it take the doctors to diagnose your autism?

Will I ever get laid?

Have you read socialism by mises or road to serfdom by Hayek?

How do i improve my country? We were marxists almost 50 years and our country was even bigger shit and poor than now.

Whats being a 36 yo virgin like?

Why do you believe in a political and social ideology that has never existed before, and that's somehow enough to convince you that it's somehow possible? (including socialist states that have fallen, which are supposedly a stepping stone to communism)

eye b0$$ can i habe de PRIVATE PROPERTY AND MEANS OF PRODUCTION pls

Have you tried seizeing the means of production yet?

disregard this it didnt last very long :^)

What's like to be a loser?

how many college freshmen come to your meetups?

Who is the greatest man ever walked on this planet and why is it Stalin?

If marxism/comunism was never implemented could one argue the same for capitalism?

Come to my house and find out

How do you see your viewpoint changing after graduation?

WHO distributes the goods?

...

What are your pronouns

D'you read Polanyi's "Great Transformation" ?

What's your preferred brand of anal lube?

Yes, most of it.

Because I won't get discussion there

I have not, but I intend to

That wasn't Marxism. That was Totalitarian dictatorship, which runs counter to the Stateless, classless society Marx envisioned

No. 19th Century Capitalism is a refutation of this narrative. It had very little government involved, and yet it was as exploitative as ever. Workers were basically slaves in Marx's time

Not much

Why are the lumpen proletariariat such plebs?

How long have you been studying economics?

We should kill all poor people so there will be no more communists

The goods in a Marxist society would be distributed by local communes. The goal is to make distribution as localised as possible so as to prevent shortage (which Marx argued would not occur anyway, as human society even in the 19th Century was so advanced that Capitalism produced far more than anyone needs to consume.)

How is high school?

A few years. Why do you ask?

>Ask a Marxist anything.

Will you please kys?

how does it feel knowing that your ideology has been applied dozens of time but its never worked.

I'm in college. And I'm actually studying something Capitalists tend to value-Electronic Engineering

How do you deal with corruption? Human nature?

When are you going to rebel? I'm getting tired of waiting.

Just interesting what is your IQ? I bet its about 100, don't expect honest answer anyway.

How has being mentally handicapped hindered your everyday life?

Society values that.

But it hasn't been applied. What you have witnessed historically (beyond Libertarian Socialist communes in Catalonia) was Totalitarian. That is anthetical to the Marxist vision

How much wood would a wood chuck chuck if a wood chuck seized the means of production?

why do you hate patriotism, nationalism and morals?
(cultural marxism)

>I'm in college. And I'm actually studying something Capitalists tend to value-Electronic Engineering


You're a fucking spoilt student wanker.

Newsflash. you are the problem. Go distribute your won wealth you stupid cunt.

>Ask a Marxist anything.
What do you think about the fact that Marx, Communism, Marxism and Cultural Marxism is Jewish to the core?

What's the point in having a revolution if you can't dance?

why are you following a system designed by kikes to usher in the cruel destruction of everything pure and holy.
kike

THERE IT IS
>Never been applied meme

>Muh human nature
You do realise that Capitalism only came about two hundred years ago, right? Have humans only existed for two hundred years?

Also, human nature is a social construct. Anyone with a basic knowledge of Sociology can tell you that.

>Corruption
Corruption doesn't happen under Capitalism? In what fucking universe?

114. Not genius, but not retarded either

Communism is stupid because it is literally an ideology that can never come to fruition. People are inherently too evil and too selfish to implement true communism. No body wants to work for someone else's gain.

How's high school going?

>You do realise that Capitalism only came about two hundred years ago, right? Have humans only existed for two hundred years?
Has there ever been a society without religion, property, or trade?

>Libertarian Socialist communes in Catalonia

Nun raping cunts and middle class Dublin students.

YOU ARE CANCER. YOU ARE THE ENEMY OF EVERY IRISHMAN AND WOMAN WHO WORKS AND TRIES TO SAVE AND RAISE A FAMILY AND SAY A PRAYER> YOU ARE THE FUCKING SOFTHANDED OLIGARCY AND THE SOONER YOU COMMIE FUCKS DIE THE BETTER OFF IRELAND WILL BE.

>human nature is a social construct

>114
>not retarded

Morality is relative. It's funny; people who claim morality is objective never seem to provide any evidence.

Stop with the identity politics bullshit

It hasn't, though. Objectively.

How are you even still alive?
oh yeah
(((capitalism)))

can't win 'em all folks, these parasites are kept alive because of us

>it happens in that other system that has managed to help the world more than any other by steadily increasing living conditions globally through unprecedented advancement and trade and technological advancements but our system is still better because muh equality
actually kill yourself, kike

Why did you leave America?

>Nobody wants to work for someone else's gain
What do you think Capitalism is, friend? What do you think profit is? It's theft of your labour and time.

Marxists aren't anti-trade, nor anti-religion.

>Morality is relative. It's funny; people who claim morality is objective never seem to provide any evidence.
what about nationalism and patriotism?

What do you think about migrant crisis in Europe and rise of rapes and crimes because of large number of islamic middle-eastern and african males?

>Morality is relative

People with no morals always thing think that.

Do one start your commie revolution. I have a piece of rope with your name on it.

Increasing living standards? When you still have people on the streets dying of starvation in Capitalist countries while tonnes of excess food is thrown away every day by stores and supermarkets? Oh, that's funny, user.

If it has never been applied has the thought that maybe it is an awful system ever crossed your mind?

what system was it that provided that pc your typing on? who worked for it? who employed them? what allows them to work? what system was it that built the society you live in? the hospitals? Television? roads? restaurants?
capitalism, you commie faggot

why do communist states never experience mass immigration?

We had communists fleeing from the USSR while we were sending aid to the USSR, and people still claim it was a paradise. During the entire cold war we sent aid to poor people in the USSR

>What do you think Capitalism is, friend?

Its not sptu and you wittering middle class government employees parents with your jobs or life fucks stealing from people who work to line your own pockets. Death to the socialist oligarchy and their parasite children.

Both constructs to alienate humans who don't look like you.

And your people don't rape? Every group of humans rape. Why single out one?

>But it hasn't been applied.
>It hasn't though. Objectively.

It has been attempted to be applied. Multiple times, failing almost every single time. Marxism is an ideal, a concept that exists on paper. But the practical application of it shows what happens after a revolution. Chaos that can only be controlled by strong leadership. Guess what happens when strong leaders come into power? Do what they feel is best to stop the chaos. If that means putting people in gulags, shooting officers that disagree with you, and starving millions of peasants to death because they are relatively better off then their neighbors, then thats what they do.

It's funny. Marxists claim to understand history the best, but learn nothing from it and try to find excuses as to why their ideology failed.

>Increasing living standards? When you still have people on the streets dying of starvation in Capitalist countries while tonnes of excess food is thrown away every day by stores and supermarkets? Oh, that's funny, user.


The tallest office tower in Dublin is the SIPU trade union full of fat pricks in suits just like you and your 'socialist' daddy living off taking the fuck out of ordinary Irish people. Day of the rope if far far closer than the likes of you can even imagine.

>check flag
>niggers of the white race
inb4 a fucking leaf

>Stop with the identity politics bullshit
Do you accept or deny that Communism, Marx and Cultural Marxism is Jewish?

If there's literally nothing wrong with being Jewish as I'm sure you Marxists claim, then you should embrace the Jewish roots of Marx, Communism and Cultural Marxism, right?

>Both constructs to alienate humans who don't look like you.
and that's a bad thing?

>Communist States
Oxymoron. That's like saying dry water or non-violent government

>Marxists aren't anti-trade
How can you have trade in a society without property?

millions are able to eat every day, enjoy entertainment, have time for their families, all while working to provide.
show me where this existed in any non-capitalist society and I will show you why you are wrong, commie jew.

kind of like this?
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dry_water

If the proletariat overthrow the bourgeoisie without government, is it still considered socialism according to the communist manifesto?

Why do you want to force people to do things they don't want to do?

I'm not planning on working in the public sector. As I said, I'm getting a degree in Electronic Engineering.

It's failed because the Leninist method was tried every time. Let's take Catalonia for example. There, Libertarian Socialists took over, gave workers (not government) the means of production, and abolished the State.

Is it voluntary?

>It's funny. Marxists claim to understand history the best, but learn nothing from it and try to find excuses as to why their ideology failed.

Ireland neve had an inductrial revolution and due to the penal laws acting as an economic leveller never actually had the class divisions that this shallow little uck thinks applies because he grew up in the well healed home of a 'scoaialist' government employee with a overpaid job and pension for life based on taxing the fuck out of everyone else while they step over the homeless. Here he is a student and he is already planning on stealing the end of what people have to line his own life.

Kill them.

Why is it that when the Soviet Union was exposed 1/3 of real marxists quit world wide and the rest settled with welfaee state capitalism yet you continue with this bullshit?

What did your dads cum taste like?

>I'm not planning on working in the public sector. As I said, I'm getting a degree in Electronic Engineering.

So you have never worked for your own crust in your life?

Try it you soft spoiled fuck.

But the allure of capitalism is that I can make other people work for me, and gain the profits, instead of working for everyone and gaining the same amount of profit. Besides, what's the point of being a doctor in a communist society when I could work fast food and still be in the same economic situation? Why should I go to school and get a degree, if I can take the easy way out and still benefit the same as everyone else?

You've just won a free helicopter ride to the destination of your choice. Where would you like to go out to? You should choose a destination of impact when seen from above.

Have fun supporting Tyrone and Jamal

I think you're mistaking the common definition of private property with the Marxist definition.

Marx defined 'private property' as anything that the Bourgeoisie own but do not use, yet is used to accrue capital (e.g. a factory). Your house, phone, TV or computer do not count as private property under this definition.

The whole point is to DISBAND government, not have total government.

>You've just won a free helicopter ride to the destination of your choice. Where would you like to go out to?

Due to him and his fathers kind no helicopter is available but there is a rope waiting for the wittering Dublin commie cliché all right. That we can save up and afford while paying his student fees and his fat fuck of a fathers pension.

>Your house, phone, TV or computer do not count as private property under this definition
But I can use all those things to accrue capital.

>Marx
Why do you listen to what Jews tell you?

Former marxist, now white nationalist here.

Nothing is wrong with hierarchy. Your allies are neutered, pushover, adult-children

If the proletariat overthrow the bourgeoisie without government, is it still considered socialism according to the communist manifesto?

Funny. That's not how it usually turns out with you commie idiots.

>The whole point is to DISBAND government, not have total government.

I just want to corporally disband Dublin socialists and the cancerous representation o foreign inapplicable ideologies that are destroying the Irish Roman Catholic people, destroying the little they won for persisting in the land wars and catholic emancipation.

You are the cancer. You are the oligarchy. You are the enemy

Because monetary incentive is not the only work incentive. This is the poison of Capitalist economies. People worked all the time before Capitalism. Doctors existed before it. Human labour didn't just begin two hundred years ago

But I'm making money with my computer. So ... is your ideology idiotic or is it idiotic?

Why is it considered a threat for eco-system when someone brings invasive animal or vegetable from other part of the World, but importing large number people with different mindset and cultural and social behaviour is totally acceptable?