WE WUZ ECONOMISTS N SHEEEEET

Arabs invented capitalism before Adam Smith. Whites BTFO

I don't even need to state it.

But I will.

(((Krugman)))

mesopotamians had a credit system and a tax system, its clear as shit that adam smith didn't just invent a system where the incentive is to get more money in exchange for products and services

(((Keynesian)))

The idea of capitalism itself is nothing advanced, so this isn't surprising. The arabs made several contributions to fields that are relevant today, such as algebra. Krugman's a Keynsian shit-mouth though

Krugman is a piece of shit.

He was fucking berber.
Most of the niggers from North Africa arabized as in identified as Arabs.
Ibn Battuta, ibn khaldun etc.Arabs didn't invent shit.

Khaldun was based. He wasn't arab tho. He despised arabs.

Tell me everything.

Dude, I don't even know where to start.

he's worth reading

le muslims invented everything face

>xDDD breaking windows makes bidniss for da window man!

and just being a Jew who writes on economic topics that have nothing to do with the actual phd he got.

arabs stole all their tech from indians, persians, and geeks

they have no natural talents

Ibn Khaldun isnt arabic, he is north african

fpbp

My kosher detector is going through the roof

stop the arabization for north africans

Capitalism is a system in which money making and crass materialism take front stage, and all higher values are relegated to the private sphere, where they whither and die, leading the to death of people/culture/civilization that transitioned to capitalism. I'm happy to let the Arabs take the "credit" for this one.

I recognize that name!
Is this the same guy that buys twitter bots to boost his nyt articles every sunday morning?

Adam smith applied enlightenment morality to economics

It doesn't change shit.

>1 Post by this ID

FUCKING COME ON FAGGOTS.

SLIDE THREAD, MOVE ALONG.

>ARAB'D
Kinda funny tho berbers here wilfully define as arab they hate there berber descendance

Master's in economics here.

This is, maybe, like 25% true. He did note what Smith called the division of labor, but did not use that phrase.

Here's the thing about Smith: a lot of what he wrote was already known. It just so happens that Smith wrote 1200 fucking pages and published it. Understand?

Thomas Mun, for example, could be the "founder" of economics with his England's Treasure by Foreign Trade. He wrote a good manuscript on how to aquire bullion through mercantilism. Smith critiqued a lot of mercantilism in his book however essentially by talking about the free flow of capital.

Anyways back to Ibn. It doesn't take a genius to figure out that "you do this and I'll do that" is more efficient than two people doing the same task at the same time. Ibn simply wrote about it passively where Smith REALLY laid out the process with his pin factory example and calculations.

Any questions happy to take.

>false narrative
So kikes are using our vocabulary for their revisionist history?

>"But why do we need a new narrative, rediscovering our past? The answer is simple: to avoid such superficial beliefs that Adam Smith (or Ibn Khaldun) is the father of economics, the development of economics started in the New Age to culminate in neoclassical thought, Khaldun already invented the Laffer-curve, the financial market effectively regulates itself or a big government is always bad for the economy – among others. Economists have to exercise self-reflection: the crisis of 2008 proved that gaps in the mainstream transform easily into policy mistakes."
This is a quote from the article. It actually makes me rage.

Also the article keeps referring to Smith as a neoclassical economist which is not true at all. He was a classical political economist. Neoclassicism didn't arise until the late 19th century. REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE.

this

Arabs did most of the world's science up to the renaissance, not sure what you're trying to imply, retarded OP

It was a way to get out of paying Jiziah, Arabs continued to make non-Arabs pay Jiziah even after they converted.

>Arabs did most of the world's science up to the renaissance, not sure what you're trying to imply, retarded OP
>implying economics is "science"
Oh, boy. You can't be this retarded, can you?

How many Jews were in your Economic classes?

No, he self-identified as Arab, you might be thinking of Ibn Rushd (Averroes)

>make non-Arabs pay Jiziah even after they converted.
There's no jiziah (yet) here they just think arab is cooler is my guess

then how would be be able to scientifically measure IQ through economic statistics?

HNNNNGGGG where can I get more of this?

Capitalism is the natural order of man, nobody fucking invented it.

This is so beyond pathetic
I cant imagine someone who has actually read the wealth of nations demeaning it to so low of a level
Especially a noble prize economist

>implying economics is "science"
Yes, it is, my retarded burger friend. It's a social science.

He's right though

>LMAO DUDE XDDD, ARABS INVENTED CAPITALISM BECAUSE SOME BERBER SAID THAT PEOPLE SHOULD SPECIALIZE IN SPECIFIC FIELDS OF LABOUR XDDD

>LMAO DUDE XDDD. THE CHINESE INVENTED SNIPER RIFLES BECAUSE SOME CHINESE SOLDIERS BLEW THEIR HANDS OFF LIGHTING FIREWORKS AIMED AT MONGOLS XDDD

>LMAO, DUDE XDDD. BLACKS WERE MASTER CLASSICAL COMPOSERS BECAUSE MOZART ONCE FARTED IN A NIGGERS FACE XDDD

This is honestly how the leftist mind works. Everything is by association when it's advantageous to non-white, Christian, straight men with disposable incomes.

Stop giving them the attention they so desperately require. Krugman is a fucking hack who hasn't done a fucking thing in the field of economics since 2008.

Berbers are garbage. That's why

>Arabs did most of the world's science up to the renaissance, not sure what you're trying to imply, retarded OP
Most science was still made by Byzantine Greeks, but yeah, Persians and Berbers in the caliphate did a great job back in time

free market and free trade creates the most growth in countries compare chile to venezuela and hong kong to other countries. search up the heritage foundation

They "reinvented" (stole) ancient greek sciences, you goatfucker

Why are you so mad, semenface

How does one "steal" science, semenface

>NO WE WUZ

Was Ibn Khaldun /OURGUY/?

Why do your people fuck their cousins en masse, pray to a pedophile, and wipe your asses with your left hands?

Serious question.

BASED MUSLIM

By conquering the areas that house all of the records previously controlled by the Holy Roman Empire you yank fuck.

They stole shit, but it wasn't just the Greeks. They were stealing from the Phoenicians, Romans, Persians, and Anatolian's.

By taking credit for other peoples work, you fucking mongoloid. Tell me, are you retarded, user? How come I have to tell you how you can steal science? Are you really that fucking dense? Holy shit, american education everyone!

Why do your people let blacks fuck their wives, raise daughters to be literal prostitutes, and inject heroin all day

Serious question

And if Islam and the Islamic world are so fucking fantastic. How come nothing of value came out of that region for the next millenia after that so called "Golden Age" of Islam.

A few.

Wut. You can use statistics for a lot of things? Are you talking about econometrics.

Oh my... he did it. He posted it. """Social""" science. Just like every subject in the humanities, right? Sociology must be a science too according to you.

...

>Every Arab country a literal bombed shithole

>"He's right though"

So by your logic I'm stealing science by learning something somebody else found out

Literal semenface logic

Muslims acknowledge that they inherited knowledge from the Greeks though. What have your cuck tundra people invented or contributed to civilization besides oil

What use did these sandmonkeys have to us? Oh, that's right, none. Or we'd have remembered him. Thanks for nothing Muslims. We uplift you from the era this nigger lived in and you try to rewrite our history as if we're stupid enough to think you and I share any relation in development or that you helped us in any way.

>Most science was still made by Byzantine Greeks
No, it wasn't, Greek philosophy was banned in the whole of Christiandom, Arabs/Muslims were the only ones utilizing it in their work.

>They "reinvented" (stole) ancient greek sciences, you goatfucker
You obviously don't know shit about science history, snownigger

Not all social science is equal, and considering that "science" was not yet invented back then (it was still called "philosophy"), your argument is moot.

>Holy Roman Empire
>Muslim conquest
Burger education at its finest.

>Nobel
>Hejerdal
>Nansen
>Ibsen
>Bjerknes
>Sophus Lie
Those are just the top of my head

Who you vote for?

Yeah lots of bombs dropping on Dubai, Riyadh, Manama, and Casablanca lately

Why do whites raise their daughters to literally be prostitutes though. Do you guys turn your girls out super young or something. I honestly don't get it

Do Muslims acknowledge that if not for our charity they'd be living in the dark ages? No. They simultaneously brag about turning Eastern Rome into the asshole of Earth and complain their countries are so dogshit then move to our countries.

HOLY SHIT! All these sandniggers REEEEEEEEE'ing because we call them out on being spineless thieves hahaha! Just like how they get all ornery when you call them out on dat dere pedophile warlord
Go fuck a toddler, Abu Hajar

>literal whos: the post

Getting rowdy online now that you're getting more than 2 hours of sunlight a day are we, nils

is a good example of,

Ibn Khaldun was our guy and pretty based. That said he didint really say the same stuff as Adam Smith

Arabs weren't black.

Yet, it's your daughters who are the ones who get ass raped by their uncles and fathers before the age of 4.

Interesting.

>arabs stole all their tech from...geeks
wtf i totally love star wars now

Adam Smith didnt invent anything he merely articulated his observations of economic system as he saw it.

>our charity
Yeah charitable bombings and supporting terrorists. I'm sure they can't thank you enough

Is this the best your meth addled brain could come up with

Okay, I'll lay it out for you since the average IQ of Egypt is 81.

You said, "Arabs did most of the world's science up to the renaissance," in reference to OP's original post which has a picture of Ibn. Economics (what we would call today), classical political economy (Smith's time), or whatever system Ibn was describing... none of it is science.

Are you really that retarded? You know we have ids on this board right?

Why do whites rape their daughters at the age of 2 and call it some rite of Odin or some other gay shit like that

Also why are whites so keen to push sexual degeneracy on everyone

>Paul "the internet is going to have as much economic impact as the fax machine" Krugman
If you want a case study of jewish nepotism he's it. straight up marxist tier economic illiterate

Listen, you people terrorized Western civilization for 1400 years. You faggots were raiding the Mediterranean for over a thousand years, slaughtering and enslaving any infidel traders you came across. You made life difficult on the all of Europe forever, and invaded it repeatedly. I personally haven't done shit to you, but I wish we'd bomb your fucking people to glass you worthless fucking faggots.

>literal whos
>Ibsen

Go read a book once, instead of watching dat dere netflix all day

>Muslim subhuman worships a literal pedophile
>Tries to call others pedophiles

>The arabs made several contributions to fields that are relevant today, such as algebra.
Not really. Most contributions that muslims have made are over-hyped shit. And what little "the Golden age of Islam" actually did invent, most of those were made by non-muslim communities living under muslim rule (muslims have since destroyed those communities however)

Mongolians 300 years prior took the idea of paper cash from the Chinese.

goatfuckers BTFO!!!!!!

>average IQ of Egypt is 81.
Yeah honestly these are super outdated measurements from a time where nutrition and access to education in the developing world was absolutely abysmal

This is no longer the case and it's the reason why whites are now losing so badly in globalization

Every """"""""""""""""""contribution""""""""""""""""""" wasn't even of Islam, or Arabs, it was all Persians, who had a better civilization before Islam.

American education: the post

>doubling down on his literal whos

>white heroin addict worships pornography and first person shooter games
>is talking trash online

Mongols assraped them, but western Europe was saved by a miracle. If there is a god, he clearly likes us better.

At least use a proxy you cuck.

Literally none of the innovation of the islamic Golden Age came from Arabia. After Muhammad, Arabia developed into a shithole. All the insights and works came from Persia, Spain, Near East, and sometimes in North Africa.

>Not everything in the islamic caliphate created by Persians, Assyrians and Berbers

Arabs literally didnt do shit in the caliphate and collapsed pretty quickly militarily, then the Turks and Persians regained control of these empires and caliphates.

adam smith did not invent capitalism! fucking retard (((krugman))) He just explained thoroughly how it functioned. and made a few recommendations

>cuck
>coming from a literal Arab who thinks he's european

>>white heroin addict worships pornography and first person shooter games
the difference is that you cant objectively know that whereas we all know mohammad is a pedophile. Hilarious how you say whites spread sexual degeneracy considering your pederesty and the fact Iran is 2# in the world for sex reassignment surgeries

>doubling down on his ignorance and retardation
Yes, good goy, keep consuming braindead media, remember to buy a fidget spinner and never think for yourself

>Arabs literally didnt do shit in the caliphate and collapsed pretty quickly
Arabs were the military caste and the caliphate lasted for some 800 years

How you can be this insanely stupid while putting forth falsehoods so confidently is truly baffling

Source? Rashidun, ummayids and Abbasids lasted for like 200 years.

Then you should have specified NATURAL science, you fucking retard.

You got butthurt quick.

I can actually ascertain with greater certainty that you're a porn addicted video game player than you can say big mo was a pedo though, cletus