/leftypol/ anarchist memeball thread- non retarded edition

Since most of you still think an anarchist is your average Hillary Clinton supporting drone warrior, it's time to give you plebs a noggin' floggin'.

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=0XxYwWg7F8I
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Territory
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchist_Shinmin
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolutionary_Catalonia
youtube.com/watch?v=crQWHvovJYg
youtube.com/watch?v=eGMS_QvbH90
youtube.com/watch?v=8HzlOASkiLA
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

>Since most of you still think
50-year old here, I've seen more real "anarchists" than you've seen trap porn mp4s. They tend to be black-and-olive-drab clad vegans with straggly facial hair who stink of patchouli oil, BO, cheap rolling tobacco, and muslim's cum in their obligatory dreadlocks.
Look and you will see the sartorial formula hasn't changed much over decades, except that they all wear "Gordon Freeman" glasses now.

>youtube.com/watch?v=0XxYwWg7F8I

you leftists are so cringy when you try to meme

...

...

...

...

I'm ready, when ever you are OP, to view your evidence of these "multiple functioning socities". Please do not refer to works of fiction like Swift of whatever...

Just a few? Ukraine Free Territory, Spanish Catalonia, the Shin Min Autonomous Region.

Lil meme tip 4u

Less words

Pfft. Spanish Catalonia was BTFO'd by pic related, who are the other niggers?

Franco was just Adolf's bottom. And Adolf was just Henry Ford's bottom. The real threat to Revolutionary Catalonia was Stalin, the """commie""" faggot. Even stole all their gold reserves. Plus you bongs took a Naval policy which favoured fascism over the anarchist revolutionaries.

See

Evidence, faggot, stop fermenting there in your puddle of brown KY jelly and show us your anarcho-utopias

Where's your Spanish "anarchists" now? And didn't General Franco live a long, happy and celebrated life after kicking their unwashed arses?

See But don't use silly words like Utopia user. It makes you look like a silly billy that's up to all manner of chicanery.

marx said despotism was a necessary step towards "real communism", however when that was tried, the despotism became self serving and self perpetuating

you will need a plan different than the one outlined by marx

Are you going to post something or not

I live on the left coast and I can assure you every stereotype Sup Forums has of anarchists/communists are completely true.

They generally hang around Whole Foods or Indie shit-holes.
>Furries, traps, Antifa, etc.
They all have a few major hubs where they talk in public.

They are some of the most disgusting, ugly, subhuman tier "people" I have ever laid my eyes upon.

And for the record they all support Hillary and are generally dumb as fuck collage leftshits. They all speak the same and have the same mannerisms.

Please; if you care for the evniorment or anything having to do with the continued survival of Earth: collectively kill yourselves.

Even as I type this I feel bile in the back of my throat from the very image of you degenerate fucks.

Where are they now? Beating the shit out of Brit bong tourists :^)
But Catalonian independence is currently less rooted in anarchism and a Scottish-type push for sovereignty. Now is not the time anarchism. That comes later.

>need a plan
Nigga there have already been anarchists societies with millions of citizens. Read George Orwell's "Homage to Catalonia". He went there. He fought against Franco's Hitler-cucks. He experienced the city of Barcelona under anarchist control (for lack of a better word) and loved it. Knowledge is your friend.

Utopias refer to idealistic political schemes that can ONLY exist within works of fiction, and I consider "anarchy" to be like some excerpt from Gullivers travels or pic related.
Is this one of your "multiple functioning societies" - drunks fighting other drunks when there's no cops around?

Reasons why leftists can't meme
>no sense of self-irony

The fuck do you want faggot? Wikipedia links? Fine. Fucking mouth breathing bong.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Territory
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchist_Shinmin
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolutionary_Catalonia

And today, Revolutionary Rojave in Kurdish Syria is being run very much along anarchist/mutualist principles. One of the main Kurdish guerrilla leaders was heavily influenced by Murray Bookchin.

this is good video of them

youtube.com/watch?v=crQWHvovJYg

>Support Hillary
>Anarchists
Pick one nigga. Sounds like those cucks know about as much about anarchism as you do. Maybe less.
See

>We don't need no system
Goes to (((Wikipedia)))
Nice try fsggot

...

>Muh youtube evidence coz muh proud yellow and black anarkists rule the """free""" marketplace of muh ideas like seasteading which is definitely not retarded and will work, plz gibs to muh seasteading patreon so we can make this happen f.a.m, it's not a handout if you're as gullible as I am and think it will work
I am so going to violate the NAP if we ever meet

Fucking ISIS cocksucker. Mighta guessed. You a pedo too, or am I being islamophobic?

>He experienced the city of Barcelona under anarchist control
how much did it last? because the main criticism of anarchy is its instability

nobody compares anarchism to orwellian society, thats communism

...this ... this was meant to be some sort of argument, wasn't it? A crowd sourced but otherwise free, non academic database of knowledge. Wow. Can someone get this nigga some helium?

That's a big png for a little nip-cuck. That yellow is very vibrant though, like your "yellow taxi" women. Very easy for white men to get into ;P
Just kiddin' I know you're a LARPing weeb faggot.

...

>en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolutionary_Catalonia
>trade unions were de facto in command of most of the economy and military forces.

>Receives evidence
>Goes off the deep end to distract from obvious embarrassment
>B-but Alex Jones told me this anarchism thing was just unwashed Hillary supporters
>I d-didn't expect to be shown facts contradicting my obvious controlled opposition media

...

I'm a HUGE FAN of anarchy and I've used the anarchist flag on Sup Forums (it's the ONLY ideological flag I've ever used on Sup Forums, but ONLY ONCE since I'm against ideological flags on Sup Forums). People think that anarchism is only for edgy teens, but I'm 29 and I'm against edginess simply for the sake of edginess. Anarchism does NOT mean 'without rules', it means 'without RULERS' - which means that anarchism is a system where we are TRULY FREE (as opposed to 'free-range', like we are now). I dream of a world without governments, Jews, niggers, Muslims, borders, religions, flags, countries, money, human-made laws, weapons, courts and wars. I dream of a world where everyone has raw vegan organic alkaline food, unfluoridated water, shelter, clothing (unless they want to be nude like me) and unindoctrinating non-compulsory education. I dream of a world where everyone can joyfully, peacefully, truthfully, freely, independently and unconditionally lovingly explore both inner space and outer space together - forever.
In a perfect world that was morally and spiritually advanced, there would be NO government. But without the moral and spiritual advancement required to handle anarchism maturely, the best type of government would be a minarchist government. We could use minarchism to transition into peaceful anarchism.

inb4 peaceful anarchism doesn't exist

Peaceful anarchism DOES exist, don't fall for kike lies.

max par

ok ben

I bet you grew up middle class, failed at school, have a shit job or no job at all and resent the system you failed at while people who barely speak the language thrive in it because its so fucking easy

t. executive who grew up dirt poor but worked hard

>Spanish Catalonia

Remember how they burned nuns alive?

most of the times leftists take things too seriously so the sense of humor suffers in the process.
on the other hand, they're closer to reason which is kind of the point, not being funny

You know that the memeball is supposed to mock that political ideology right?

>Free territory
Collapsed in less than 3 years after spending the majority of its life under the control of the white guard

>Spanish Catalonia
not ever really under anarchist control, had an anarchist influence but that was even more socialist/syndicalist at best.

>Shin Min
less than 3 years in existence and was plagued with massive problems

It seems like every time there is an attempt at a stateless society it dissolves in less than 3 years and is conquered by the closest army. Anarchism is a transitional period, not a stable society.

i'm not even an ancap this is just the closest flag to hoppean monarchism that exists, i believe in war blood and slaughter

>Instability
You mean it's inability to withstand attacks from bloated violent super states like USSR and """communist"""" China.
In that sense, you should also be against Europeans because when confronted with speeding trucks bearing the religion of peace their frail pink bodies prove to be quite unstable also.

youtube.com/watch?v=eGMS_QvbH90

Oh you've totally just proved us wrong! What a stinging blow to my arguement!
In fact; let's just send all of Antifa/Communists to the Middle East to fight ISIS. You're a genius, Harry.

Nothing to lose but our chains, comrade :^)

>SS
>complains about violence

>this thread

>you should also be against Europeans
indeed, fuck these cucks

Only through anarchism can we ever be truly free (as opposed to free-range, like we are now).

That's a lot of effort for such a shit-tier response. lol

I'm sure you'll make a cool sounds when your body impacts the Earth.

You seem to be flagging an issue here. Anarchism is anti-government, not anti-governance. It's almost as if you had no idea what you were talking about when you showed up here. But your jpg shows that you are a supremely knowledgeable gentleman not afraid to enter into the """free""" marketplace of ideas. Unless people ask you to give a historical example of """anarcho""" capitalism or a demonstration of how it will work today without calling Kevin Costner out of retirement for Waterworld 2: This time it's a voluntary trade between two consenting parties in an abstract scenario devoid of any relevance to real human economic interaction.

franco was soooooo ooo ooooo oo o shit, even hitler looked at him in with shame
>couldn't have acomplished anything without the help of germany and italy's artillery and aviation
>he was hardcore christcuck
>would bend over and take pope dicc
>wahaha fucking fremasons amerijews and kikes
>loses war and procedes to be gigacucked by the us
I can go on but it's seriously so cringeworthy this fag

>Spanish Catalonia
"The fact that these forces were distasteful to some anarchist leaders only emphasizes the cleavage between doctrine and practice. If, theoretically, the CNT and FAI were opposed to the state dictatorship advocated by the Marxists, they nevertheless established in countless localities, with the aid of vigilance groups and revolutionary tribunals, a multiplicity of parochial dictatorships, which they exercised in naked form not only against priests and landowners, moneylenders and merchants, but in many cases against small tradesmen and farmers."
-Burnett Bolloten "The Grand Camouflage: The Spanish Civil war and revolution". page 76
Blood of Spain page 146 Juan Miravitlles, an Esquerra representative on the militia committee, which was the high command, protested to the "libertarians" on that committee about the terror. He reports: (page 146)
Day after day we found ourselves on the committee repeating "why these assassinations?" [...] A man was killed because his sister was a nun. [...] They called a man a fascist simply because he went to mass. President Companys said "you are drowning the revolution in blood" [...] "Tell Companys not to come here again" Durutti said to me and Tarradelas. "If he does I will fill him full of bullet holes."
Miravitlles continues, page 150

Their leaders on the committee said the libertarian movement was not responsible for the assassinations: "It's the armed worker patrols. Some of the members are assassins." But in my view, they couldn't confront this type of people who represented for them their own ideology. With the notable exception of Durutti at the front, the CNT was always plagued with indiscipline and didn't know how to deal with it [...]
Ronald Fraser then describes these worker patrols as follows
These acted as a revolutionary police force, and were made up of 700 men - 325 of the CNT, 185 of the Esquerra, 145 of the UGT, and 45 of the POUM.

Memeballs are mockery not flattery.

leftists can't meme

I aint readin' all dat shit my dude

Anarchism is about self-government. Anarchism is about the right to own your own body. We have a word for not owning your own body, it's called 'slavery'.

that's the joke

It's just standard leftist memes bro.

Cont.
Ronald Fraser Blood of Spain, page 367, quotes Fernando Aragon, who describes the peasant collective where he was forced to remain.
Three or four of the peasants with larger holdings tried to leave the collective, but the committee controlled all the seed and fertilizer. [...]
[...]
The committee members went around with pistols in their belts looking, but not working, like revolutionaries. [...] But what was even worse was that the committee members were lining their pockets: all the best food ended up in their pockets.
[...]
One of the twins fell ill with a kidney complaint. [...] They told me to walk. [...] "What sort of equality is this? You ride around in cars when I need to take my child to the doctor". They still refused.
[...]
There was great discontent. The women talked about it. We went out to work in the fields - and it was right that we should. But why didn't the wives of the committee members have to go? [...] I wanted to leave but I could not. We had no money, no means, Moreover the committee had guards posted on the roads. It was terror, dictatorship.
[...]
We could not get rid of those committee members. They had the arms.
Ronald Fraser summarizes:
For detractors of Aragon collectives, Fernando's experience was more or less typical: For supporters exceptional, but undeniable

>Anarchism is anti-government, not anti-governance
you must be desperate if you are falling back to dumb word games

>People think that anarchism is only for edgy teens, but I'm 29

Yes but an immature 29

>Anarchism does NOT mean 'without rules', it means 'without RULERS'

That is like a school with no teachers. whether we like rules or not we need them and a way to enforce them. Imagine if you had to take a test and cheating was forbidden but there was no consequences for cheating. People would cheap. What do you think riots are? A brief amount of time when the state cannot intervene

>I dream of a world where everyone has raw vegan organic alkaline food

Take a single agriculture class. Just google agriculture. ORGANIC FOOD = LOWER YIELD PER ACRE that is why it is more expensive you idiot. If we went organic then even if we used modern farming techniques we couldn't feed the world.

>lovingly explore both inner space and outer space together - forever.
If I could steal a spacecraft I would, without rules I would. Who is going to fund this in a taxless society?

> NO government. But without the moral and spiritual advancement required to handle anarchism maturely

Wifebeating is common, most people arent nonviolent or mature.

Faggot.

THREAD THEME: youtube.com/watch?v=8HzlOASkiLA

Cont.
Burnett Bolloten, in "The Grand Camouflage" page 41, quotes Diego Abad de Santillan, La revolucion y la guerra en Espana p.176

It is possible our victory resulted in the death by violence of four or five thousand inhabitants of Catalonia who were listed as rightists and were linked to political or ecclesiastical reaction."
First Ronald Fraser sets the scene: Massive violation of libertarian principles. Blood of Spain, page 349

There was no need to dragoon them at pistol point: The coercive climate, in which "fascists" were being shot, was sufficient. "Spontaneous" and "forced" collectives existed, as did willing and unwilling collectivists within them.
Forced collectivization ran counter to libertarian ideals. Anything that was forced could not be libertarian. Obligatory collectivization was justified, in some libertarians eyes, by a reasoning closer to war communism than to libertarian communism: The need to feed the columns at the front. Macario Royo, an Aragoneze CNT leader, believed that collectives were the most appropriate organization for ensuring that a surplus was made available for the front.
He then quotes Macario Royo, speaking in favor of forced collectivization:

If each peasant had kept what he produced and disposed of it as he wished, it would have made the matter of supply much more difficult.
Fraser then paraphrases Macario Royo as saying

And revolution always meant imposing the will of an armed minority "In this case an anarcho syndicalist minority"
He then quotes Macario Royo at length in a footnote.

Revolutions are made by force. Everything that is imposed by force has to be maintained by force. The outcome may be communism but it is not libertarian. If it were, it would not be communist, for the simple reason that the mass of the people are not communist. Libertarian communism could be established only if the majority of the people already supported communism and then started to organize that communism freely.

This. At least make it fucking funny. This is just saying some bullshit.

>i love beeing a cuck
the /thread.

In Spanish Catalonia leftists started to genocie each other read Orwell you little bitch

>not only against priests and landowners, moneylenders and merchants, but in many cases against small tradesmen and farmers."
made me fucking laugh, if you can't understand why that is retarded I'll help u
protip:anarchism

Fuck off, you statist butt-sniffer. Go suck the government's cock.

Cont.
Burnett Bolloten, in "The Grand Camouflage" sets the context for Juan Peiro's remarks:
Page 70:
Although CNT-FAI publications cited numerous cases of peasant proprietors and tenant farmers who had adhered voluntarily to the collective system there can be no doubt that an incomparably larger number doggedly opposed it or accepted it only under extreme duress.
Page 72:
As a consequence, the fate of the peasant owner and tenant farmer in the communities occupied by the CNT-FAI militia was determined from the outset; for although a meeting of the population was generally held to decide on the establishment of the collective system, the vote was always taken by acclamation, and the presence of armed militiamen never failed to impose respect and fear on all opponents.
Page 74: Burnett Bolloten quotes Juan Peiro, one of the foremost leaders of the CNT, writing in Llibertat, September 29, 1936:
Does anyone believe [...] that through acts of violence an interest in or a desire for socialization can be awakened in the minds of the peasantry? Or perhaps that by terrorizing it in this fashion it can be won over to the revolutionary spirit prevailing in the towns and cities?
The gravity of the mischief that is being done compels me to speak clearly. [...] The first thing they have done has been to take away from the peasant all means of self defense [...] and having achieved this they have robbed him even of his shirt.
[...]
If today you should go to different parts of Catalonia to speak to the peasant of revolution, he will tell you he does not trust you, he will tell you the standard-bearers of the revolution have already passed through the countryside: In order to liberate it? In order to help it liberate itself? No. They have passed through the countryside in order to rob those who throughout the years and throughout the centuries have been robbed by the very persons who have just been defeated by the revolution.

This guy summed it up quite well and I thank him for it, looks like you are sucking shit again, OP, you got no evidence for "multiple functioning societies" at all.
Ask yourself - whose policy presided in the long run? WHO WON? BASED AS FUCK GENERAL FUCKIN' FRANCOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!

Not middle class, working class. Didn't fail at school, left school but got a degree in late 20s just coz. Job is... kinda shitty? I like it though and will keep working here for now.
Kind of hits and misses. Not bad for a fucking leaf.

Based af t.b.h, Christ cuck Storm fag.

You got a degree in dreadlock maintainance and advanced fellatio?

Meme response. Nothing but a baseless meme response. At least git gud at history faggot coz intellectual honesty is clearly beyond you.

>This is the intelligence of anarchists

Yeah man, you'd definitely make it far in a state of anarchy

franco got ultra cucked by (((USA))), and he couldn't have acomplished anything if it wasn't for the fact that he got help from german aviation and artillery, all he had was a bunch of spics, and the motherfucker brought them to spain to pillage and rape...
christian... this manlet faggot piece of shit

when I grew up it was the left that had the monopoly of humor and the right that couldn't be funny even if they tried.

funny how things work.

in 10 or 15 years from now, the counter culture will be leftist again and it's going to be funny to see all you kids confused about it and not understanding why the values you cherished for so long are being mocked so viciously.

I rest my case. You are an immature adult. You may be 29, but you act like you are 13.

Grow up, adopt a real political ideology

Cont.
Blood of Spain page 152, Ronald Fraser summarizes the testimony of Maria Ochoa:

There was a festive enthusiasm in the streets [...] At home her father talked more about local politics than the war, not that the latter was forgotten, but local politics seemed more important. He was particularly hostile to the masses of people flocking to join the UGT - "opportunists without any political background" he called them. Soon, however a black cloud appeared over the festival. A workers patrol set up in a house on the corner of the street. It was guarded by two militia women. Each night a car drew up and sounded its horn.
Maria Ochoa says:
We soon discovered what it meant. People were being taken to be shot on the other side of Mount Tibidabo. It was horrifying, oppressive, The car would begin to grind up the hill and we knew the fate of the occupants. My father did not like it. He thought it quite normal that half a dozen big bourgeois exploiters should be liquidated, but not that all these others were being taken to their deaths.
Blood of Spain page 140 Joan Domenech, the most powerful civilian minister in the CNT (in his own opinion) speaking:
I said "You are the employers [...] right now if we felt like it we could load you into a lorry and that would be the end of it" You should have seen their backsides wriggling on the chairs!
The reference to a lorry, similar to Stalin's reference to boxcars, again indicates specialization of labor in the mass production of murder, not spontaneous violent action by small groups. If it was just small group action they would just leave them by the side of the street, the way the semi unofficial death squads in Latin America do.
Blood of Spain page 183 Juan Andrade of the POUM executive committee:
I don't believe that this alone was the major cause of the PSUC's growth. The CNT was the reason. The latter terrorized so many people that in reaction they came to consider the communists as the party of order.

>"Attention do not question your beliefs, stay obedient"

blatant propaganda yo

shut up snek

Address all of this then you daft cunt, I'm giving you fucking history here, now fucking act on it and give a response.

Holy shit, you couldn't be more of a fucking faggot if you tried.