Where is Haruhi on this list? She's magical and a girl.
Luke Ramirez
Looks like elevens truly love her.
Brandon Hernandez
>3. Sakura Kinomoto (Cardcaptor Sakura) What is Sup Forums's opinion on this series anyway? I've not seen the fucker in like a decade.
>16. Punie Tanaka (Magical Witch Punie-chan) I should make her my waifu.
Jacob Taylor
>Best
It was for most attractive magical girls in anime.
Blake Williams
>5. Illyasviel Von Einzbern (Fate series) Pretty based
Robert Barnes
>shitty horribly incomplete list Fucking kill yourself, if you had every precure in existence I might spare you, but even then that's not nearly enough. Get educated.
Easton Ross
I do not understand how people can like Homura after the movie.
Jaxson Lewis
>Ilya on the list >Mami in the top 10 >Fate lower than Ilya and fucking Homura
Drop another nuke.
Sakura gets weekly threads.
Luke Brooks
>Mami in the top 10 She should be at least in the top 3
Joseph Anderson
Shitty taste in magical "girls" Creepy lesbians not wanted.
>8. Dorie Goodwyn (Ojamajo Doremi) Why is that the only one using a dub exclusive name?
John Butler
Including all seires together regardless of the target demo makes the list seem sort of odd. Doremi being between Fate and Sayaka for example is just weird. How do I read this compatison? It makes more sense to me to read this as two lists, separating the actual shoujo series from the seinen. Then you get Sakura > Doremi > Usagi whicih I can at least form an opinion about now:
That opinion is wrong and shit. Doremi is the best magical girl, and the only precure is from the currently airing snorefest season. She's just a cute retaard that's been around in literally every other precure already. They put a precure on the list and it wasn't Nagisa, at the top of the list, so they're really dumb. They got the megucas in the right order at least, but they don't all deserve to be so high.
Maybe nips really like the dub? I heard it was shit though.
Lucas Morales
>ITT: butthurt MadoMagi haters I'm laughing at you guys.
Robert Wood
FUCK OFF M8
Mason Stewart
But yeah, 魅力的 doesn't exactly translate by "best".
David Smith
Madoka and Homura both actually deserve to be high on a list of seinen magical girls. The others not so much, at least not compared to other top tier MCs like Nano/Fate or Illya. Kyouko, Sayala, and Mami are more like plot devices than characters when compared to Madoka and HomuHomu.
Owen White
ACCURATE
Caleb Robinson
>Sayaka >plot device Madoka was much more of a plot device than Sayaka. Sayaka had a full arc dedicated to her and was the pivotal point of the whole narration.
Jason Torres
It's not surprising PMMM is represented in that list. It is surprising that all 5 of the girls are there, and in that order.
Henry Cox
I just don't get Japan's love for Madoka. Can anyone explain it?
Parker Hall
>Mami over Fate >Madoka over Homu >Lina at 13 Sorry, I don't believe this list.
Dominic Carter
Recency bias. Adults don't watch anime and kids haven't seen classics
Cooper Gomez
Homura did nothing wrong.
Jonathan Watson
It's really good in pretty much every way. Concept, drawing, writing, directing, music, design, etc.
And then they marketed the ever-loving shit out of it because Japan.
Chase Ward
I meant the character, not the series.
Daniel Taylor
Madoka is the only plot device in PMMM.
Sayaka was the only character that felt real.
Kyouko only existed as a foil to Sayaka.
Mami was just there to open the world of the mahou shoujo's tragedy.
Homura is the legit best character. Became even better after the Rebellion story.
Christian Gomez
Oh, she's like super cute.
John Brooks
>Kyouko lower than Mami, Sayaka and Madoka >Madoka first I'm disappointed at Japan's shit taste.
Daniel Bennett
Sakura deserves the top spot.
Carson Mitchell
>Became even better after the Rebellion story.
Leo Williams
It was a valid direction for her character to take.
Christopher Morales
I'm more disappointed at your shit taste. Literally this.
Justin Butler
Male：65.2% Female：34.8% Between 10 and 20 years old： 63.6% Under 30 years old： 36.4%
Isaac Gomez
Why? I genuinely can't remember why CCS was good.
Jose Perez
Homura > Madoka > Kyoko > Mami > Sayaka
Ethan Clark
...
Colton Powell
>I don't understand the movie. That's a shame user but it was probably meant for an older audience. Try again once you read at least 1 piece of classical literature. and eat shit, you fucking faggot
Joshua Roberts
This needs to be a meme. Whenever someone asks for a H-anime recommendation, we should say CCS.
Parker Hill
Why is it that japs like cute kind girls so much? Is it the whole yamato nadeshiko thing?
David Jenkins
ya mean kyouko is the best magical girl. Your opinion is worthless
Carter Bell
>Female voters have better taste
Carson Rodriguez
So many people say this, and yet she took the easy way out chasing after her waifu in a plan that she herself recognized was hopelessly foolish.
Don't get me wrong, I love her edge but c'mon.
Asher Wilson
Seems like the majority of voters only watched Madoka and Prism Illya. Otherwise how can Madoka with her blandest personality be higher than Nanoha, Usagi or Lina, or be the best magical girl at all I'm suprised to see Punie and Hikaru there though
