This is what the middle east would look like as nationalist nation-states. No Afghanistan. No Pakistan. No Syria

This is what the middle east would look like as nationalist nation-states. No Afghanistan. No Pakistan. No Syria.

Be honest Sup Forums, would it still be shit?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=jpxWzXopukE
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

As longs as there is oil and islam, the middle east will be shit.

>Afghanistan part of Persia
LOL. You forgot about pashtun nationalists
>Islam
No lol, it was even shittier during Jahiliyah while it knew great times under Islam

>dividing based on sects and ethnicity
>Israel untouched
hmmmmm

t. Jamal al-parisi

But the saudis would be snipped to their natural homeland. No Mecca for them, and Medina will be part of a ba'athist superstate. They can try lobbying wahhabism when every neighbour is a stable nation-state with good standing armies, popular support, and no legitimate cause for war. There's no oppressed separatists that can be shilled into destabilizing.

Pashtuns are just trash Iranians. You don't think Tehran would integrate them pretty quickly (assuming the central govt. would be Persian and not shiite)? It would be much more appealing to be a persian than a pashtun. If anything, it would contribute to making shia-sunni relations more like modern day catholic-protestant relations.

Israel is populated by jews nowadays my friend. Regardless, a mighty christian Lebanon (with shia cucks) and an even mightier sunni Arabia would be an Israeli nightmare. Not to mention the west bank would have an extremely strong army, and the Gaza strip would be an egyptian border town.

Don't underestimate Jewish ethnic and religious schisms though.
Map is nice but too balkanized imo, I think that Arabia should be unified and not divided like that

Not true, Israel is against shias and Iran specifically, they are even friend with Wahhabis who like to pass as Sunnis.
Not only did that map divide Arabs it also added kurdshitstan who are Israeli and US proxies

>Kurdsitan
>Iraq being this small
fuck you kurd loving faggot

shia are better than sunni you faggot

If it was unified the jews would have a reason to try to balkanize. The Mediterranean port for Arabia was intentional. They are sunni over there, but the real reason they get a med port is so the jews can't try to sell a war against Lebanon to get one.

Also, with Persia being persian and not sunni/shia, and the Saudis just being some desert nutjobs with no legitimacy, the shia-sunni schism will probably die down. Persia would do for islam what the German empire did to protestant-catholic relations.

The wahhabis will have 0 legitimacy. The shias will be neutral to the jews in Lebanon under christian rule. Persia will be neither muslim nor Christian. The kurds only play Israel/the U.S. for money. If they get Kurdistan there is literally 0 reason to have any U.S./Israeli influence and 0 reason to expand. Could you shill Hungary to attack Austria? No. Because Hungarians want a pan-hungarian state. They wouldn't go to war over some nice ski resorts. Likewise the kurds wouldn't go to war for absolutely no reason against a mighty Arab enemy.

>No judea and samaria for israel
Nice try ahmed.

Kurdistan is to end the Kurdistan wars. No reason for war=no reason to accept shills.

Iraq is bigger and just as oil rich as before. Only now they're shia dominated instead of a sykes-picot frankenstein state of people who don't like each other. Imagine if you tried to combine half of protestant Germany with half of catholic france and did the same for the other halfs. Would it make any sense?

There's loads of independent shia states on the map. Shias are still not as good for a stable mediteranean tourist country as christians. Christians should, and will, dominate greater Lebanon. Also the shia/christian mix is so chaotic in the alawi/lebnani areas you couldn't make one shia and one christian mediterranean state anyway.

Schlomo, with the neighbours in that map, you'll be thankful you have a state at all on your stolen land.

Israel and Lebanon should be combined into a jewish/Christian/Muslim Belgium like state. I think that would be an easier pill to swallow for everyone.

Ok america thank u for expertise how is the war in syria going

It would be better, but India should not be unified

>Kurdistan
You're not an Arab, are you

>Persia/Iran could have been a dominant and westernized country in Middle East
what a shame

youtube.com/watch?v=jpxWzXopukE

Might be reasonable but India is at least fairly stable as is.

Kurdistan makes sense. You want more shilling and war or less? Nationalism is about accepting the right of others to self rule. If you're not accepting a free kurdistan, you're not a nationalist, you're an imperialist. And an imperialist is close to a globalist, or a new leftist, or worse.

Greater Persia for greater joy. Also they would be able to clean up persian "Afghanistan".

Only Persia can resist and fight the Jews and puppets.

>Iraq (Shia)
>Includes several countries that are primarily sunni.

Goat herder wahabbists killing and terrorizing midfle east only make it essier to conquer, look how many nations went to get a piece of midfle east fue to isis, even china, russia etc..

Look at a map ya dip. The Iraqi borders follows the shia dominance borders. The map is based on ethnic lines. The only remotely sunni part there would be Kuwait which is a rough 50-50 split of shia and sunni, and Kuwait has to be added for continuity and oil.

Persia would be pretty fierce but they'd be persians not shia proxy warriors so they wouldn't even care about Israel. The shia militants would be in Lebanon and they'd be under Christian rule. The sunni militants on the other hand...

Wahhabis? Persians? How?

Israel should become a buddhist ethnostate

Vatican should just buy Israel, declare it the holy Christian land and ship out all the Jews to Madagascar.

...

Unstable and multi-ethnic just like (((they))) want it!

East land is absolute barbar with no civilization.

Best situation is trying to rehabilitate wahabbist tards and goat herders in persian schools, and then all middle east be annexed by persia/islam nation.

>all that land given to kurds
What for? They never owned most of it. They are fucking nomads. Giving them any land is like giving European land to refugees. Nobody likes kurds for a reason: they are fucking insane cunts. And their territorial claims are pure madness. Take a look at Armenia, for example. Their historical territories were given away by the Soviets to the Ottomans less than a century ago, and those are the territories they are trying to get back, which sounds reasonable. Now take a look at kurds again: they come to occupy someone else's land and then they demand it be theirs. I say they don't deserve shit.

This map is all sorts of fucked up, but it's still better than what we have now being honest. I'd take it.

If it wasn't for the undisputable wahhabi dominance, I wouldn't have given the wahhabis their coast. But I made the map based on fair nation states+common sense. But personally I think the wahhabi lands should just be split between the neighbours and their inhabitants just shoah'd.

They live there. You give them the area they live on, they stop waging wars. It's not about 'deserving' shit you imperialist shit. Nationalism is about the formation of nation-states to end war and promote trade for mutual benefit.

It's not at all. The only places that are not following ethnic lines would be Kuwait (50-50 shia sunni split but for continuity gave them to shias), Armenia (gave them their traditional coastal strip despite it being inhabited by t*rks since the genocide to avoid landlocking Armenia), and the pashtu iranians being part of persia and not their own shithole because seriously a taliban ridden landlocked resource free desert can not survive anyway. Pashtuns just speak a retarded form of persian so who cares. Also the small strip of Persia going into the tajik lands would just look silly without the pashtuns.

>It's not about 'deserving' shit you imperialist shit. Nationalism is about the formation of nation-states to end war and promote trade for mutual benefit.
What a great idea, shithead. What are you gonna propose next? Releasing all the criminals from prison and giving them jobs to improve the economy?

Shut the fuck up you small dick imperialist cuck. Respecting the right to self-rule for all peoples in the area they currently inhabit if they no longer have direct ties to their previous area is nationalism 101. It's how to build a stable, non-shilled, non-jewed, prosperous planet. It does not matter for 1 fucking second if you think these people are stealing your women. The only way to end jewish shilling is to end imperialist retardation with it. Give the kurds the land they live on (some fucking mountains no one cares about) and they will have no reason to fight anyone, no incentive to get shilled, nothing. Every fucking war, every fucking disaster, throughout the history of our species is small dicked shits like you trying to take what isn't yours like some communist of the ethnicities. Just leave the kurds to their land and you to yours, which I assume is somewhere in west Africa Jean-Pierre Mbungo.

>t. k*rdshit

t.k*rd

Yes what a shame they didn't let foreigners "westernize" them lmao
Good on them for defending their Islamic culture and identity.
Watching diaspora we wuzzers cry about it is always entertaining to watch

>persians
>their islamic culture
>their
Riiight
it's a depressing 3rd world shithole now so good on them!

This map is alright but we should get south Lebanon, shitteys can go to persia and there isnt even enough Christians for all that land k thx

Kurds are Persian.