Communism has never been tried

>communism has never been tried
Why is it so hard to understand, you fucking brainlets? It's the truth! No, China is not communist and never was. And no, USSR was not fucking communist!
So communism doesn't equal starvation and millions of dead people! It's the capitalism!

Stop trying to larp as a commie your bad at it. you love koch.

so revolutionary catalonia wasn't communist?

Sage hide and report.

Communism is impossible without the world revolution, so no.

well good luck with your proletariat internationalism. dont know how your going to get rid of the ZOG and various other groups that control pretty much all the means of production and labour value

Sage, hide and report.

Wow, what a sad bunch you are. Report for what?

Even your god has blessed me with the numerals, because I'm right!!!

communism is impossible
thats why its never been tried
and thats why it will aways fail

rare

this

Everyone do your part and sage.

communism will be good, but first we will have to kill a lot of people who do not understand, then we kill useless idiots like you, but we will get there. thank you for the help.

...

>communism
>stuff isnt working, people dont listen
>kill?

Leftists, everyone.

Just got done reading Gulag Archipelago a few days ago.

You should consider suicide, you slimeball piece of shit, even if you are memeing.

this picture and message is coming form your local friendly turkroach. Fuck you.

>Communism is impossible
full stop. end of discussion.

Watch me redpill these fucking cucks on communism

...

Even if you except that communism hasn't been attained yet, it doesn't follow that it is important to try.
What motive is there for people to pursue a social organization that they -perhaps wrongly- equate with mass death?
What motive is there for people to pursue a social organization that they regard as inimical to their mode of life?

Communism not only has been tried but it succeed. Marx wrote about forced labour in Communist Manifesto, you can read it.

4 factors must be considered

1) Ethnically Homogenous (Must be all one group otherwise there will be conflict), Multikulti doesn't work.
2) Low population (usually a small village or town, higher populations will eventually fragment into their own groups eventually leading to an us vs them mentality, while a smaller group has to work together and share resources to survive)
3) No Leaders (Leadership can cause distrust as one can be contaminated by the font of power over time)
4) No Central economy (No haves vs. have nots which would lead to conflict)

You have to remove factors that would cause cohesion erosion.

lol communism hasn't been tried because you can't try what's make believe.

I can say heaven is real all day, but the idea of human is impossible for a human to comprehend. So why are you defending a faggot who believes in creating a utopia.

good luck

wow
you really showed them, really makes you think, ya know?

explains a lot huh?

Have you read Marx? It's not supposed to be tried. In his philosophy it's inevitably going to occur as a result of class struggle. We can't know what it would be like because too much of or our thinking is dependent upon bourgeois concepts. He thought the best we can do it try and make the transition less painful. China and the USSR were attempts to do that, and therefore it's fair to say that all those deaths were inspired by Marx's ideas.

True capitalism has never been tried. It's the taxes and welfare.

>communism has never been tried
it has, and it fucking worked for 10,000 years. Except it wasn't called "Communism", it was called "holy shit i really don't want to be eaten by tigers or fucked by the enemy tribe".

Communism works in groups smaller than 100.

Communism only failed because of jews like you, stealing ressources and rerouting them into your own pocket. Go to gulag and stay there for eternity.

>tribalism is communism
If you believe everything that Marx shits out, sure

wew another slide thread
can we just ignore this fuck please

> implying anyone wants to try it in the first place

>get rid of the ZOG
Dude, they are the people who try to establish international communism.
After they have eniugh influence they will abolish capitalism, because they wouldnt need powergrowth anymore and implement comunism so nobody could gain power.

To bad the world consists of more then 100 people.

To bad tribes grow

To bad tribes meet other tribes.

To bad theoretical constructs witch arent based on nature cannot be implemented practicaly.

Honestly, thinking about communistic theory is as usefull as fantasizing how you are doing a spacerace on blue whales against Wladimir Putin

...

...

You are a really bad troll

OP is more of a faggot, than he already is, if he doesnt adress this.

ITT:
>communism is homogenous and not a catch-all phrase for imagined more beautiful worlds
>communism doesn't work because groups of assholes want to fuck other people over
What do you think we'll build gulags for, retards?

Even if that's true, don't you think it's a little weird that all of the nation's claiming to be communist were totalitarian shitholes?

Communism has never been tried because Marx was wrong...lol. Workers in Capitalist societies don't rise up because their standard of living increases as well. Communism is only an ideology of the children of the bourgeoisie who accomplish nothing and want to force their power onto the most vulnerable in the world.
The poor don't need your help. Your kind has been nothing but evil to this world and you keep banging your drum of death.

You will never win because you keep killing people you claim you want to save.

Have some respect for the efforts of your comrades. They did the best they could to implement communism in one country after another. Learn something from their experience: It doesn't work.

Bullshit...

Just cause communism is a failed ideology in modern times and you can't aggregate everything humans accomplished in the past to your stupid belief system to make it relevant. Doing that shows that you're a bullshit artist.

Bullshit aside, your ideology kills people...it kills a lot of people. You are immoral, do nothings that just want power because they are afraid of a world they can't control. You are sad and pathetic excuses for humans.

Those are antisemites, not Antifa btw.

That's not weird at all if you read a history book.

retards

Boi. You must understand that capitalism and communism are the same thing. In both cases the money is employed by people who want to exploit you and don't give a fuck about you. As long as money exists, capitalism will exist.

Why don't you get a good cry about it.

Shut the fuck up, brainlet.

>calls others a brainlet
>cant argue with this

see

people try it every day, it's called robbery, theft, and murder, and usually people go to prison for it or get otherwise BTFOd

...

Shut the fuck up

>real communism has never been tried
uhhh... try again sweety

Socialism is more plausible than full blown communism desu.

>Implying I'd rather be lorded over by a collectivist Jeffersonian mob than an Aristotelian Oligarch
Holy fuck Communists are an embarrassment for the entire Human race

make me, faggot

>only two points taken cared of with a bad arguement of just simply saying "we have gulags for this and for that"

so this is the power of communist intelligence......
......woah.....

I bet you're ugly.

Jumping off a roof and focusing your chi to fly has never been done before. Those idiots that fell to their death just didn't do it right. If they'd have just channeled their chi better.

There's just something classic about a Kraut and a Swede fighting. It's the war of the Cucks. And here I am, a Leaf adding the commentary. What the fuck happened to you Sup Forums

retard

>communism has never been tried
Because even retarded "communists" know full well that there is no way for it to work. It is required that humans act without greed, and it has been proven time and time again that this is impossible. The only way to create a functioning society is through positive use of negative traits. Capitalism takes the same greed that kills communism and it becomes the driving force for innovation.

Communism won't work. Every time you people try it, you disavow that you tried it after the fact. Marx was an unemployed bum, and was no worth to society. I think it is amazing paradox of the "religion" of Marx. Hard work keeps the system moving, but this guy was a bum. Literally a bum.

How can people be so against the holocaust if its never actually been tried?

...

The real retard is you.
Anyone who lived in a ex-commie state would hate to have communism again except stockholm snydrome users.

Holodomor

A
FUCKING
TREE

True, but every-time you try to establish communism with a transitional authoritarian socials government everyone dies. I would be okay with communism if it worked, but it fucking doesn't. It's a pipe dream. Try again in 500 years.

Marx wrote books. Hard work is not a valid value. Machines work harder than you. We will build gulags for "greedy" people. It's funny how you could make a list of 20 points that could defeat any argument you retards ever made.

“Himself a Jew, Marx has around him, in London and France, but especially in Germany, a multitude of more or less clever, intriguing, mobile, speculating Jews, such as Jews are every where: commercial or banking agents, writers, politicians, correspondents for newspapers of all shades, with one foot in the bank, the other in the socialist movement, and with their behinds sitting on the German daily press — they have taken possession of all the newspapers — and you can imagine what kind of sickening literature they produce. Now, this entire Jewish world, which forms a single profiteering sect, a people of blooksuckers, a single gluttonnous parasite, closely and intimately united not only across national borders but across all differences of political opinion — this Jewish world today stands for the most part at the disposal of Marx and at the same time at the disposal of Rothschild. I am certain that Rothschild for his part greatly values the merits of Marx, and that Marx for his part feels instinctive attraction and great respect for Rothschild.
This may seem strange. What can there be in common between Communism and the large banks? Oh! The Communism of Marx seeks enormous centralization in the state, and where such exists, there must inevitably be a central state bank, and where such a bank exists, the parasitic Jewish nation, which. speculates on the work of the people, will always find a way to prevail ....” Mikhail Bakunin

retard

Get a load of this guy

Uhm hello fellow jews? Your commie bot is malfunctioning due to data crashes of it trying to comprehend that communism will never work,it keeps repeating the same old words

hardcore form of communism was tried in Cambodje. google Poll pott u dumb shit faggot. It lasted 3 years millions died of starvation and persecutions.

/thread

accept your overlord Lenez the Fez The Great thelogian of islam and the protector of communism

>same old words
Here are some for your confused mind; you will find them in thousands of YouTube videos you can like and share (don't forget to turn off AdBlock):
>abortion is wrong
>white privilege is a racist and sexist term
>left is homogenous and hates all white men

The failed attempts at communism are enough to make any sane my dearly afraid of "real" communism.

yawn

ITT:

>Communist tries to convince everyone that communism is good
>Everyone else proves that communism is bad
>Communist replies to every point with “Nuh uh”
>Communist thinks he wins

hey hans
i think i found your commie relatives
why don't you hop off of Mohammad's dick and join them.

that's every single debate about communism in a nutshell.

Real communism requires a global ideology that does not have a single jurisdiction of dissent because that jurisdiction will always offer choice and people seek liberty over controlled markets

You would need to conquer the entire planet, against its will, and then indoctrinate everyone, and then ensure that there was a power structure that existed to control everyone, but that power would have no actual benefit

Theres so many contradictions and impossibilites that ill leave it to stoned 13 year olds to figure out

Communism has been tried hundreds of times in a score of countries in the last 80 odd years or so. Yet so far not a single try is considered a true communism, that can grows the conclusion that either communism definition shifts constantly thus the attempts are discarded or communism is unattainable.

>So communism doesn't equal starvation and millions of dead people! It's the capitalism!

Show me your flag and provide me with an address and I will gladly come over to violently and brutally sodomize you, fucking brain dead oaf.

China is more based than you commies.

Do you know why this echo chamber works so good? Beautiful people with aesthetic standards don't come here. Same with YouTube. Your lifes basically=tristesse and you'll never know.

And we all know there’s only one person who can do that. Pic related.

What if I dont want to live under (((communism)))?

>communism has never been tried

Because communism is an adnauseum, self fulfilling prophecy.

>(((people))) are oppressed
>"proletariat" revolt
>prolietariat are oppressed
>not real gobunismb
>repeat

>>>/gulag/

What I find funny about communism is that because its a controlled market the capitalist countries can produce exactly what communist states do, plus other choices

So then the other difference becomes: do you value your freedom of choice or do you value a government made up of """"equals"""" who dictate to you """"their equal"""" what they can and cannot have?

hahaha

Cool. Then I will fight you will all I have so your fucking shit ideology may never spread.

The irrational and inefficient free market capitalism would be utterly destroyed by cybernetic planned communist economy. Free market crapitalism will literally be unable to compete with advanced alien-tier quantum computing cybernetics. It's like trying to race a modern F1 racing car with a cat chariot.

Capitalism is ugly and you don't even realize it even though you live and dress in basically trash. I bet your clothes right now are mostly synthetic fibre, vibrantly colored with huge prints.

Let’s talk philosophy faggot. Name any social structure that isn’t an echo chamber. People tend to associate themselves with other people that share their beliefs, interests, and hobbies. Even with a gaggle of teenage girls at the mall, they are simply an echo chamber of Justin Bieber or the Kardashians or whatever teens like these days. If you went to /leftypol/, they’d all be offering you handjobs freely because you’re echoing all of their sentiments. Don’t come into a group, that you know doesn’t agree with you, expecting them to echo your bullshit. Go somewhere else for that.

...