If Fate Shirou defeated Berserker, then how the fuck did Archer lose to Berserker?

If Fate Shirou defeated Berserker, then how the fuck did Archer lose to Berserker?

Don't question it

Caliburn's a giant asspull and the biggest Fate/ plot hole to date. It's impressive enough that Archer managed to take off 6 lives.

don't think too hard about it

Why didn't Archer trace Caliburn too?

Nasu is a hack

Because Nasu freely admits that he wrote himself into a corner with Shirou vs Berserker and had to asspull something. He's gone on record saying that if he could, he would re-write that entire segment. Archer didn't use Caliburn because Nasu hadn't asspulled it yet.

Archer is a hack.

How the fuck a single strike could kill someone 7 times over? That kind of defeats the purpose of God Hand isn't it? The point of having multiple lives is so you can survive getting overkilled and renew with full HP bar.

It diminishes Herc's NP to just a really really long HP bar, which isn't that special at all

>Because Nasu freely admits that he wrote himself into a corner with Shirou vs Berserker and had to asspull something.
Can we stop doing this thing where we randomly go
>Nasu said in an interview...
And then never post source?

Maybe he didn't dreamed about it and saw it like Shirou did in his past.

>Nasu says this Nasu says that
Every Fate thread. Can we at least come up with a rule that whenever quoting Nasu someone needs a source?

"Nasu says ..." is as empty as when politicians says "the American people wants ... "

Shirou hogged all the plot armor so none was left for Archer like a greedy little shit.

Fuck he already had Saber's plot armor lodged in his rectum.

If you want to get technical, Saber defeated Berserker in the Fate route. Shirou traced Caliburn, but it only worked because Saber was wielding it with him. When it is in Saber's hands, it gets a major buff to an A rank NP. Even if Archer had traced it in his fight, it would still be a C? rank NP.

what's wrong with his finger.

Chronic Wanker's Cramp

loled. thanks user.

God Hand wasn't active anymore after Herc was tainted.

Nasu is a hack.

Herc wasn't tainted in the Fate route

Archer commenced operation "fight like a little girl"

Does anyone still have that comic, it appears to have just vanished from the internet

He should've just trace Shiki

>implying either of them could defeat Berserker solo
Shirou had help from Saber and Rin.

only retard think the second part is funny

Because Berserker doesn't regen lives fast enough for it to make a difference. Archer killed Berserker like five or six times.

Also because he couldn't give any projections he made like, let's say, Caliburn, to any other Servant that could have potentially used it better, like, let's say, Arturia.

Apparently Herc's own Nine Lives ability that Shirou copied is the ultimate counter to any form of regeneration.

Source: GO Materials.

Most people are retards.
>native speaker think correct and right have same meaning

Also wasn't Archer still crippled going into that battle?

The number of Servants that have beaten Berserker Herc onscreen solo is exactly one: Gilgamesh.

The number of Servants that could conceivably beat Berserker Gil solo is pretty short.

>Berserker Gil
Berserker Herc, I mean.

I'm dumb.

He said he was fully healed a few days before.