Which is more cancerous?

Which is more cancerous?

Right definitely.

By threads, Madoka.

I don't know, right now the guy who keeps spamming that garbage goblin slayer threads every day seems the most cancerous

OP

It's a 50/50 split

Daily fuck shaft/monogatari/madoka threads are way more cancerous

Madoka.

Monogatari threads
>Everyone has a good time
>talking about the plot, what happened and what will happen
>talk about girls objectively, pros and cons of each
>one or two shitposters who can't stand everyone having a good time

Madoka
>half the posters bitching about some tripfag
>90% of the thread is just people dumping yuri fanfiction
>"IF MADOKA COULD WISH FOR TO BE A GOD SHE COULD WISH FOR TO BE HAVING MORE WISHES!?!/11/11?!"

...

Shaftfags in general are the worst. Pornogatari is also worse than Madoka because it shows fanservice and pedophilia and it's otaku pandering trash with pseudo intellectual pretensions which is the worst fucking mix you could get. Then again Madokafags are way worse than Pornogatarifags.

>pretensions
It's like im in 2009.

Everything that they did.

KyoAnus fags are worse

(you)

I like Madoka a lot but I filter madoka threads out on sight.

...

Right. It is thecusual shitty self insert harem LN .

If you're going off of Sup Forums threads, then Madoka no question. The only fanbase that can compare is Eva with the constant Asuka vs. Rei waifuism and general shitposting about the show.

...

I actually like Madoka more than Monogatari, but the Madoka threads intolerably more horrible than Gatari threads.

Attack on Titan.

nice try monogatari faggot

Madoka threads are the prime example of why generals are cancer. It's nothing but IRC with yuridumping. Those threads should be autosaged or moved to /trash/.

Madoka threads are complete shit full of tripfags circlejerking. As a show itself Monogatari because it's nothing more than harem garbage with a self insert dense main character that people like to pretend it's deep and the best thing ever.

>tfw there will never be another anime as epic as Madoka

Fanbases are cancerous, anime are not.

Shaft is so shit they are responsible for the two worst fanbases in anime history

Literally the only people who say monogatari is deep are the shitposters. Or retards who can't follow words.

The deconstruction of madoka is the cancer, and monogatari has better reaction iamges.

I'll deconstruct your anus, faggot.

Monogatari as a show is the most cancerous. Someone should fucking kill Nisio Isin for writing garbage.

You.

Madoka threads are fucking abysmal, and I hate it.
I have literally no place other then here that I like to talk about stuff on, and I'm sure as hell not going to reddit or somewhere just to talk about a single anime.

In terms of fanbases? Madoka easily.

Personally I have to say Madoka just because it's one of those anime I regret showing to other people.

I told a friend about it, convinced him to watch it with me, and then he told other people. It was like some disease spreading across my network of friends. It eventually ended with said friend buying me a Madoka shirt which I wore once out of respect and have since closeted for all time.

at this point Madoka is just yuri shipping and fan arts cause no one has anything left to talk about. At least Monogatari threads talk about the actual show cause it still isn't finished yet

also don't talk shit about my two favorite shows >:(

There's walpurgischan.

What the fuck is monogatari even about now.

talking

I feel like nobody likes math on this board and it makes me sad

>DeadFish

Neither, stop having shit taste faggot

but there's one airing right now

...

Left, and I dont even like Monogatari

...

If you keep an eye out for them, there's usually an actual non-autistic Madoka discussion thread that'll accidentally float on to Sup Forums amidst all the cancerous clutter about once or twice a month.

Can I say both?

gg is ded fgt

...

I would have to say Madoka with the shipping.

...

...

Madoka easily, Monogatari fags at least sound like they aren't completely retarded

I know this is supposed to be an argument against the series, but it actually makes it look good.

...

Damn, this is a hard one OP.

This

Updated version

Both because they're made by SHAFT

I'll have to go with Madoka. Any magical girl anime that dares to not be light-hearted are always compared to Madoka. Its fans are effectively putting Urobutcher and that overhyped shit on a pedestal.

...

...

Let out a heartily giggle.

Forgettable seasonal waifubait trash.

Monogatari, it's way more gimmicky.

>one shitposter complaining about tripfags
Fixed.

People like OP.

Madoka EASILY

OP

...

Madoka threads are ruined by the same spammers every thread. I don't think it's fair to judge the entire fanbase based of those few people.

The Madoka thread that's up right now actually has a lot of good discussion.

...

Right might be more normalfag and entry level than Dragon Ball, so I go for right.

...

I'm sure normalfags are very into loli fanservice.

Right, and it isn't close

whats with Sup Forums hating anything that is popular,
like even things it likes initially but then becomes popular and then they pretend they never liked it in the first place.

I prefer madoka as a show (haven't really liked much of monogatari past bake)

both types of threads are cancerous though

It's not supposed to be an argument against the series though.

...

>why is Sup Forums one person
Go back to stalking children at playgrounds, subhuman

why do you faggots keep posting those images? the source is a youtuber who actually rated nisemonogatari 8/10 so it doesn't make sense to post them in a monogatari hating thread

They're out of date anyways since shaft doesn't make much money

...

anything kyoanus related is already terminal.

...

This.

When an anime adaptation influences the industry in a bad way it can be cancerous. This is the case with Shaft, specially with Monogatari because it proved that a studio can get away with producing half assed animation and still get away with it because the stupid otaku will keep buying their BDs.

Honestly Shaft fanboys are overdue for a roasting so I'm fine with it for now.

This honestly. The current anime fanbase just wants waifus and to have fodder to talk shit at each other all day about them so the industry responds in kind. It's not like anime is entirely forcing people to act like complete braindead idiots all the time, it's just been gradually whittled down in quality and content to the level of it's most visible and vocal online fanbases. IMO the internet era is what really ruined just about everything to do with media.

Don't forget whenever anything goes wrong in a show he's running it's all someone else's fault but when things go right it's 100% thanks to this guy and his "inherent writing genius" which all prolific visual novel writers apparent have in spades according to modern anime fanboys.

We're talking about a guy that has constant writers block over stuff that really shouldn't be all that hard to write about and who usually just works on commercial shit for conglomerates at the end of the day anyway and half the time is just added a huge preinstalled fanbase for a franchise that is easy to be successful in like Godzilla, Kamen Rider, Fate etc. I'm not saying he's awful but the way people put him on this pedestal for what he's actually contributed to the anime industry which is a couple hits, a couple flops and a few mediocre action shows should put him on about the same level as any other contemporary writer. Not that it matters much currently as he's practically out of doing anime now

It's more like people are finally starting to come around on some stuff that's been massively overhyped and stealth marketed down people's throat for years and it's kind of ugly and over the top. Sup Forums can't really do things that don't involve extremes.

It's more likely the fact that SHAFT hasn't come out with anything worthwhile in over 5 years, so most people have already jumped off the bandwagon, leaving only the most extreme of autists to obsess over shows that came out years ago.

because they're funny, user.

The series that stole everything from Kamen Rider Ryuki.

Kyoani

Came here to say this

Madoka fans for sure. I gotta say that Re:zero fans are worse than both combined.