You have 10 seconds to point out differences in Yamada, Ishihara, and Takemoto's styles

You have 10 seconds to point out differences in Yamada, Ishihara, and Takemoto's styles.

are those animes?

nice thread dude, have a reply on the house for effort

There are too many to type in 10 seconds.

...

Who gives le fuck?

I don't know who these people are

They asked for directorial style differences, not the character designers.

>someone was so butthurt they made this chart

Do you consider everything short of complete apathy butthurt?

Yamada is 'subjective', Takemoto is 'tricky', Ishihara is garbo

Apologise now.

Nope, Chunibyo and Phantom World were bad.

Ishihara was a mistake.

Ishihara did nothing wrong

Early Keyshit was a mistake.

Everything he solo directed was wrong.

Free was a mistake.

Nichijou was a mistake

I think it would be a bit harder to argue that they're all the same.

Which is probably why you simply implied such, without yourself pointing out their similarities.

I don't know about Takemoto but Hibike has proven that there are literally no differences between Ishihara and Yamada.

>but Hibike has proven that there are literally no differences between Ishihara and Yamada.
How?

they all have the sameface

Please don't reply to bait.

Seemed 100% serious to me, but I suppose you have a point.

Can someone explain the "Ishidate is the best Kyoani director" meme? I'm seeing this opinion more and more often

Yamada is the genki, Takemoto is the bro, Ishihara is the meganekko, and Yamakan was the creepy student council president.

It's called false flagging.

Kigami is the oneesama, Ishidate is the tomboy

Because he is

Takemoto the creepy homosexual

But why?

Yamada is the best director
Takemoto is a good director
Ishihara is a mediocre director

>Yamada is the best director
>Takemoto is a good director
Kind of interesting how quickly this turned around. Just a couple of years ago people thought Takemoto > Yamada.

I hope in a few years someone will outshine Yamada.

No he's wrong.

Takemoto is forever the immortal god due to Hyouka.

He can't be topped after directing Kyoani's Diamond.

Who directed Fumoffu, Ishihara or Takemoto?

>Amagi
>High Speed
He's dead, my man
I'm looking forward to Maidragon genuinely

Takemoto

Who is most responsible for Nichijou?

Or Haruhi for that matter?

Yeah he shouldn't have been on Amagi that show was awful.

I liked Free though.

Ishihara for both

A director's most recent work tends to dominate the general opinion.

Amagi was a mistake.

How is he not considered the best then? Haruhi, Nichijou, and Euphonium are the only god tier Kyoanis

Nichijou was awful.

Disappearance is the only remotely good part of Haruhi

...

The better season of Euphonium is mostly due to Yamada.

This is bait

>Who is most responsible for Nichijou?
Depends if you hate Ishihara or not. If you do, it's Ishidate. If not, it's Ishihara.
>Or Haruhi for that matter?
Since nobody hates Ishihara more than they hate Yamakan, Ishihara gets full credit for that one, no matter who you ask.

Yamakan was a mistake.

Yes?

Nichijou
Director: Tatsuya Ishihara
Assistant Director: Taichi Ishidate

Haruhi
Director: Tatsuya Ishihara
Series Production Director: Yutaka Yamamoto

I just realized this is exactly why S2 had less yuri, and more focus on Reina's cock lust. Ishihara outright said in interview that he doesn't like serious yuri, but he was interested in Reina's crush on Taki

ie exactly as it is in the novels

yamada = adolescence
ishihara = moe
takemono = loli

Ishihara was not a mistake.

Was OCs a mistake?

Technically sleepy-chan isn't an OC anymore

TRANSLATION WHEN

They changed Reina and Taki from the novels so there was more focus on the sexual aspect and less on the musical aspect. Ishihara must've seen Taki as his self-insert and slipped in his fantasies while Yamada was away

These tiny eyebrows are so cute.

>Deko
>Touka
>Ruru
>Enigma
Absolutely not

Phantom World had good one-off characters.

Well the thing is, since Hyouka, Takemoto has been doing obvious for-hire contractual work (no matter how much he might enjoy the trashiness), meanwhile Yamada being younger and probably more passionate gets to direct full features

I am completely fine with this.

So he's the one stuck with low cost bum jobs
Truly a mistake.

All those Phantom World characters are OC? What was the novel even about then?

Edgy garbage.

First novel is just shorts and the plot happens at the end. So the anime adaptation is just episodic and the plot happens at the end.

>forgetting Free!

They all suck in their own special ways.

Humanoid phantoms don't exist in the LN
All forms don't have spirals on their bodies either there, hence the difference in the title designs

Can't comment on anything else though, haven't read the books.

>ishihara
>free

What was Yamada's intention with this character?

>redditposter
Adds up.

A L to go with the T.

?

I did forget that Utsumi was actually Kyoani's best director. I can't believe they let her get away.

>Haruhi
>Euphonium
>God tier Kyoanis

Bait.

How come Utsumi never showed her face

A character living in the closet. Tamako Market is a story of unrequited love if you look at Midori and that guy who was in love with the onsen girl (And maybe Mochizou if you only use the tv version as a reference but the tv anime wasn't supposed to feature romance at all) which is funny since the anime keeps saying "everybody loves somebody"

I love Midori!

Midori is my favorite Tamako

I know there are Hyoukafags in the thread and I'd bully these nerds if they were in front of me

Does this mean what I think it means?

Maybe.

Was Ai a mistake?

That whole show was a mistake, and that episode is probably one of the worst anime episodes I've ever seen. It was an insult to life itself.

That episode was hilarious

KyoAni doesn't make mistakes

that episode saved the show

Kyoani makes anime, and anime is a mistake, THEREFORE...
But seriously explain literally all of their works except K-On and Nichijou.

This.
It was really offensively bad.

Nichijou is a complete waste of time and effort. Awful trash.

I 愛 Ai!

Yamada for cute SoL female focused cast with heart warming scenes and arthouse films

Takemoto for Drama with heavy focus on personal character conflicts and Comedy with crude materials.

Ishihara for accurate adaptation and RomCom.

Ishidate action and nothing much as of now. Too early to tell. However he is one of the best Episode Directors who pull off subtle dramatic episodes.

KnK's action was trash.