My classmate literally wrote a paper called "abolish whiteness"

Her thesis is that whiteness is a construct that keeps non-whites down, and that white people can exist without "whiteness". How do I argue against this in class?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=WsCSAEdxXMc
youtube.com/channel/UCXqpN_lZoZU4FR3vIZXCJiA/videos
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

Why bother?

Tell that nigger she has to go back

Argue that if whites have "whiteness" removed but "blackness" is allowed, whites must have at least some form of "whiteness" otherwise we are being denied something that others have which is by definition unjust

I know you dont want to hear this, but it is my duty to do twhat i am about to do.

BRRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAP

She's Asian American. American exchange student here in Italy. Fucking Americans spreading their garbage in other countries.

>How do I argue against this in class?

You don't. Don't tell them any of your opinions, it's a waste of time and will paint you as a target. Welcome to university, just nod your head and go along

None of this stuff is surprising, anymore. Just another dumb, brainwashed sheeple.

write paper comparing the most successful white country vs the most successful black country over the last 3000 years and tie in all the redpills into the explanation of why

Make a paper about Abraham Lincoln and his hatred for niggers.

Argue that there is no such thing as whiteness because "White" is not a race. There's Irish, German, Scottish, British, Anglican, Australian, Russian, Slavic, Latvian...

Make sure to include historical references to extreme racism against Irish people, since they were treated as bad as blacks back in the day.

>most successful black country stacked some bricks into a geometric shape
>most successful white country defined the standard of what being a successful country means in the modern age

>american student in Italy
Tell her to stop insulting your culture, clear and simple, make a stand for yourself without sounding angry.

>implying she won't just say yeah but whiteness is bad and blackness is good

tell her that the minorities that she are defending think Asians are as bad as whites. and that asians actually more discriminated than whites in college acceptance programs

Asians also have a hierarchy of skin tone. That's why you see Chinese women always under a parasol. They fear getting tanned. Focus on how the idea of light skinned being better is not Western, but universal.

Literally true.

You might think this is nonsense, but that's only because you're historically illiterate. "Whiteness" has always (and will always) mean whatever those in power want it to mean. In Nazi Germany it meant anyone of Germanic descent. In 19th century America it meant anyone of Anglo-Saxon descent (except the Irish, who were not white). In modern-day America, it means "any group who statistically and consistently votes Republican".

Reword everything she says about whites, to be about blacks. It's just a simple matter of pointing out the hypocrisy. Wont matter to those hardcore bluepilled, but those in the middle will start to see how insane it is.

Argue that "Whiteness", "Blackness", "Asian" and other such groupings of races are all constructs made for less educated people to understand race, which is very complicated. Talk about the different races that are white (Nord, Slav, Celtic, etc) and black (Bantu, Pygmy, Abbos, etc)

What's the deal with Asian Americans, Ameribros? I thought they were the put-your-head-down-and-work kind. Are they big on SJW rhetoric?

Redpill me on face sitting. Is it worth it?

gooks are pathetic, if she hates white people so much why doesn't she move back to china? i bet $1000000 shes an iphone owner aswell

What are you, a college freshman? It literally doesn’t matter.
Just write a paper on why Italy must reclaim its land.

fuk that nigger

Why do we tolerate caucoidphobia?

Tell her if race is s construct then you can't be racist because it doesn't exist.

>Reword everything she says about whites, to be about blacks.

I tried that earlier in the term. The counter was that you cannot apply the same standards when it is a case of historical injustice, because it would be like "having the same tax rate for the rich and the poor" (literally her words).

>Allah isn't real, so there's no such thing as Islam.

Obviously, you turn it around.

"Blackness" is a construct that keeps non-whites down and that non-whites can exist without "blackness." My favorite way to phrase this argument is

>You have to make a place for people before you can put people in their place.

She doesn't hate white people, she's just an excellent student.

I am convinced that white girls are growing up and they hate their fathers, and they are turning this hate of their fathers into a hatred of white men in general.

I guess it's all an effect that so many white girls grow up in households where the parents are divorced, there is no father figure at all and if the white father is at home - he is overweight and watching NFL games around the clock, addicted to smoking or drinking or casino gambling, or is just unpleasant to be around.

The wave of feminism they witness on the radical college campuses only works on them because they already had seeds planted into them in their childhood that white men (their fathers) are grumpy drunks.

We will never be able to save this country, white women hate us and they will gladly hand over the keys to this country to Jamal or Rafael, they don't care that their towns are now littered with Dollar General stores and EBT Welfare Food Stamps signs on every glass window of every store, they don't care that the country is now a 3rd world country, their hatred for their own fathers is so intense that they hate the country in the most vile warped way to get back at their fathers.

Not true. The trick is to agree with them, and bring you conclusion to demonstrate contradiction - eg. once whiteness is gone, you could argue that blackness/w/e will fill the power void, leading to a reversal that will bring historical justice (oppression) to elevate previously oppressed populations to the fore, at the expense of previously oppressive regimes. This means all whites in the West will be impoverished and justly so! you shout, as the mostly-white students nod in approvement, while some of them notice their white skin and the implications.

>You're not aiming for ALL, you're aiming for SOME.

The reply would be "are you saying that blacks are inferior?"

Heh, you said duty

I don't want to abolish "whiteness". That sounds like some bullshit copout white guilt liberalism. They're trying to escape their inevitable oppression and punishment.


I want to abolish/erase the white race, not just whiteness. I want less than 1 million white people in america and we get to keep them in reservations or as personal slaves for our leaders.

youtube.com/watch?v=WsCSAEdxXMc


Until We live, so does the European Blood and the Civilization Torch.
Elevate and improve yourselves, train your bodies, better your minds, clean your souls.
Focus on whats is good and honorable.
Your Family, Your Brothers and Sisters, Your Craft, Your Skills.
It is not all lost until the last European draws the last breath.

Many fought for us, many died for us.
Let us continue this way of life, this culture of peace, manners, culture, family, country and god.
Do not quit, uncover and pursue the truth and only the truth. We are all living in a lie, an old lie that they keep pushing too far and too fast.
Our patience is ending.
Better yourselves and your Brothers and Sisters, mentally and physically, so one day, we are capable of fighting back properly.
Preserve the Light that so many of our own ancestors and blood relatives sweated, cried and died for.
It is a cause much greater then us, to keep and protect centuries of discover and evolution, centuries of love and death.

You are cozy in your home, away from any threat searching the internet to stop your boredom not because of money or privilege.
Because Trillions of People like you and your Mother and Father sweated and died to keep and protect the light, the fire that is our civilization.
Make sure your grand-grand-grandsons themselves are cozy in their homes reading their history books of how their grand-grand-grandfathers FOUGHT AND DIED to once more, KEEP AND PROTECT the LIGHT AND FIRE OF OUR GREAT HUMAN CIVILIZATION


Unlock the TRUTH that was HIDDEN from you by your own enemies, the same enemies that ended your ancestors for GREED

youtube.com/channel/UCXqpN_lZoZU4FR3vIZXCJiA/videos

It's funny because italians aren't even white

Read her paper out loud to the class replacing the word whiteness with jewishness.

She's Asian American.

More liberal than the Italian far left.

bait

>roleplaying a black supremacist
come on m8...

She is correct, whiteness in the american sense is a construct entirely based on racism and the exclusion of the "non-white" groups.
It's a false identity built around the institutionalized racism in the US.
It only exists outside of the US due to their cultural imperialism.

Multicultural - every culture is great except european

This. "Whiteness" isn't her thesis, it's just an assertion. Her thesis is that whites can exist without whiteness - so why is that different from blacks existing without "blackness" or Asians existing with "Asianness"?

Then you call her a racist, vehemently and frequently, without stating any of your own opinions. Make her play by her own rules.

Can't suggest anything without having more to chew on.

Sounds like its pointless to argue the point since progressive politics auto-wins. But if you argue around semantics i.e. how does one define "whiteness" and how accurate is or can this definition be?

Then you might have a chance. I don't know what the fuck she's talking about when she says "whiteness" keeps non-whites down. If white-ness is a race thing then why are the people in appalachia/rural areas so downtrodden?

If its a class thing then why call it "whiteness" instead of classism? It seems like a meaningless term that serves to be a placeholder for whatever she wants. If she says "whiteness" is the belief whites have that they're more trustworthy etc you can bring up in-group preference which is universal characteristic of human societies and an integral part of our evolutionary psychology.

My race is not a fucking construct.

Ask her why she’s so full of hate for people who aren’t like her.

"if whites are so oppressive, why do nonwhites keep flooding into white nations?"

Literal commie jew came up with that idea

Tell her that "whiteness" and all her shitty theories about it (that she just copied from the internet) aren't relevant in Europe and that she should stop spreading her american bullshit here.

Actually explains a lot: Asians after 1 generation turn into complete sluts in the US. The only group that really retains any semblance of traditions and honor are the spics

Thier parents are hsrd working sorts. Thier americanized kids are pure trash, mostly because unlike white immigrants they have clearly identifiable physical traits that mark them as foreigners so the education system primes them up for thier whole childhood on how special and unfairly treated they are.

tis not a duty, but an obligation

>implying she will do something more than get up on the desk and scream while throwing her feces at OP

This
The only possible way that you're going to win the argument is by taking her side and then taking it 30 steps too far. Talk about getting rid of white people entirely, putting them in camps, and using their skin for rugs and such, but continually reference toxic whiteness as the reason for doing it. Use her as a shining example of what the world should be.

define whiteness, they never have an answer, it's always a feeling
ask them how do measure whiteness, see above
ask how do you abolish whiteness without murdering white people

Asian Americans are often raised in ultra liberal cities like San Francisco, NYC, and Seattle. It's that simple.

> role-playing

visit east flatbush with you maga cap at night once, please

I'm not white I'm Slavic.

>I'm not white I'm Baltic.

>I'm not white I'm Scandinavian.

there are two types of Asians in North America. The immigrants, first generation ones.... and it goes downhill from there.

Everyone wants a piece of the white man's hegemony.

The only people who argue this are people who virulently hate whites, so that well has been thoroughly poisoned. All anti-white arguments are simply veiled forms of genocidal racial hatred.

>Make sure to include historical references to extreme racism against Irish people, since they were treated as bad as blacks back in the day.
I treat them worse than blacks. At least the niggers don't suck off the pope and then commit terrorism like trying to blow up Maggie Thatcher.

Nazi Germany didn’t care about “whiteness” you uneducated ameripleb.

Anyway abolishing “whiteness” doesn’t really invalidate European ethnic nationalism so it’s irrelevant.

You don’t argue with these people. She, as an interloper, is saying her host doesn’t have the right to an identity because it harms her as an interloper. The only response is to tell her to fuck off to asia.

This is like saying your cousins aren't part of your family because they're not part of your nuclear family. lrn2 cladistics.

Don't give up whiteness as a category. That's what the kikes want us to do. As if germans and french have no more in common with each other than they do with somalis

The old Jonathan Swift “turn the Irish babies into food and gloves” approach

>Find NAZI era arguments that make the same argument she does - except against jews
>Dont reveal the source until the end of the argument to make your point stick

Show how racist and NAZI she actually is - and that her arguments have been made before, and it resulted in the deaths of 6 gorillion jews...

Also if shes asian american you could find out which "asian" and show historical arguments against that... its not like Early America welcomed or thought high of Asians 100 years ago.

You're more likely to get fucked with for having jewelry or an iphone flashing than a MAGA hat.

Fucking gook students are the fucking worst, there is this chink fag at my uni complaining 24/7 in class that France is homophobic and transphobic (he's a legit fag with painted fingernail and shit).
I want to ruin that faggot saying that if France is so shit he can go back to China and act like the huge fag he is, I have the strong impression that he will finish in a mine doing forced labor for life.

Hate those stupid pieces of shit that come to another country that welcome them but complain when their actual country is worse


tl;dr nuke foreign students.

>How do I argue against this in class?
You can't. If postmodernists listened to logic and reasoning, they would have been defeated a long time ago.
Just find anyone who is silent when your classmate speaks. Chances are, the silent ones also see the insanity of it all but are too afraid to speak out in fears of grade revenge by the professor.

>arguments Progs are expecting and have a ready-to-go retort for

Use these and expect to be called a white supremacist neo-nazi scumlord who should have been aborted to purify humanity. Don't bother attacking her on eugenics, either, they don't understand the hypocrisy there without deprogramming.

the gal of that bitch to insult the natives like that

Also tell her that her race is the most privileged in America (asians make more money than whites and are more educated), and that one proof of this is that she's the one who can be an exchange student in Italy, and not some hood Shaniqua or white trash kid.

Use here liberal double think against her bc thats whats going on here. Shes mid mental backflip just help her slip when she completes the landing.

you should kill her after class
its literally the only solution

>implying I own a maga cap
We're not all from /ptg/ newfag

Anyhow I highly doubt a black supremacist (still cannot type that with a straight face) visits Sup Forums, you're a roleplayer, likely a white roleplayer... or an american indian

BASED OOGA BOOGA

It's a self defeating fucking argument. If you refuse to classify a section of the population as white then can't argue that whiteness is a construct to keep non-whites down.

>having the same tax rate for the rich and the poor
This is so unfair. Poor people disproportionately use government services more than rich people and should pay more.

All i know is that dogs are people

>Hispanic girls aren’t sluts

Lol

Go to Latin America and see how desperate they are for white dick, it’s pathetic.

>Use these and expect to be called a white supremacist neo-nazi scumlord
Well you shoud expect that in any case user

This is going to be current year +1 soon

I DON'T UNDERSTAND IT!!!! How can whiteness be a 'construct' and at the same time exist: minorities and racisme?????? If whiteness is a construct that means all those other things are too???

She's say white people need to abolish any kind of tribalism or unity in order to make room for everyone elses. Why? Because we are the dominate force on planet earth, not even being the largest people. We are top dog.
So the lower animals spout all manner of bullshit. Like this.

She wouldn't be where she is if whites didn't exist

tell her she wouldn't have future prospects or even a program to write a thesis in without whiteness.

Tell her to take her 5 year old looking chink as back to China and try writing that shit over there.

Tell her Asianness is a social construct to keep non-Asians down
Don't take these people seriously. Fight their retardation with your own retardation.

Just tell her to stop insulting Italians with her American garbage

Also this.

Were it not for the British, French, Spanish, Portuguese and Dutch trade empires then she'd still be picking fucking rice for the local warlord.

Tell her that this "whiteness" concept only exists (if it even exists) in America because all american whites are mongrelized thus they have no other signifier than their "whiteness". Tell her that this shit is irrelevant in Europe since we don't identify ourselves as white, we identify ourselves by our ethnicities and nationalities. Tell her to fuck off back to America with her irrelevant shit.

>RACIST FACIST NAZI!!!!
>an argument

lolno

Just say, "Whiteness is just a social construct."

Fundamentally she is right, in that "whiteness" as some kind of Pan-European (+) identity is clearly a social construct which has been malleable over time. Many historical arguments over who was what; are they Irish white, are Italiand white, are Jewd white. It only has meaning because people believe in the concept. Same as a "black" categorization as an umbrella for everyone of African descent. An ethnic Scot and a Russian have as much in common linguistically and culturally as an Ethiopian and a Haitian or a Jap and an Indonesian. That is, not much.

But, in pragmatic contemporary consideration, the other anons are right. No one blasts blackness as a concept in the way they aim it at whiteness (even though, actually, maybe a Celt and a Slav are closer than East/South Africans). Whiteness is an evil construct and blackness a good one to them. As long as only collective whiteness is trying to be crowbarred apart, it represents an advantage to those identifying with (or seeking political gain in the name of) other pan-ethnic social constructs.

Tell her whiteness is a Jewish trick. There are no whites only celts, anglos, , ect.

Argue that "blackness" can only be structurally defined in its contrast to "whiteness", and go into how the abolition of "whiteness" would necessarily strip African Americans of their cultural identity.

Haha. I think I'm going to use this.

It sure would be a shame if she revealed her name to the world

Tell her to get a job and some dicking

Bring up the Jewish question

White people as an identity cannot exist if white identity is abolished. Something that exists can only exist if it is allowed to exist. If that something is destroyed, then it can no longer exist.

Argue using the Socratic method. Drill down into her logic until her ideas have no logical backing and her agenda is revealed. Seriously, just ask 'how' and watch her entire narrative fall apart.