Meta thread: sadpanda discussion

As much as I hate having to do this (meta threads are usually full of retards who think you can strongarm the boards to fix them) we need to talk about sadpanda threads.

As most Sup Forumsnons are aware, mods or janitors have been pruning sadpanda threads for a couple of months now. They have not stated why they are being deleted, what rules they break, etc etc.

In spite this there has been many anons who want the threads to be allowed. As per Hiro's orders, this thread will serve as a means for anons to discuss whether mods should allow sadpanda threads to be posted on Sup Forums.

I'd like to ask all anons to remain respectful and courteous, and to (try to) provide constructive ideas for whether sadpanda/exhentai/doujinshi threads should be allowed on Sup Forums. I'd also like to ask mods to take the time to listen to the userbase, and to at least provide reasoning for their final decision on the acceptabability of sadpanda threads

Also remember to report shitposters. Do not engage shitposters. And be respectful.

?

Why try to fix something that isn't broken?

Fuck off.

I think the discussion is tuckered out
Please give it a day before making another thread.

Not again. Didn't the last thread have enough shitposting?

Are people posting NSFW images? If not and they're only providing links, then the janitors should fuck off.

Fuck off.

This shit is way too old

here we go for another 12 hours

>sadpanda and other "generals" getting purged
>Threads threads are perfectly fine

...

...

The image OP is using dates back to 2016, why are the mods allowing this thread to stay up?

>"discussion" centering around "muh dick" should be allowed for some reason
What's the problem?

We just had an 850 post thread about this.

Saged.

Exactly what we were talking last thread.
That shit should just be on

Make /ag/ - Anime Generals

Since when are weeklies generals?

This is getting fun. Sadly though, i won't be able to partake in this one, but will leave my contribution from the other thread:
>Everyone was happy about it
>It broke no rule, as the threads were always about links, not porn images
>The argument about being a general is fallacious, as Sup Forums is literally filled with much cancerous generals that never get deleted, such as 3x3 threads, Shinka threads, EVA threads and so on
>It can't be compared to rec thread, as the only reason recommendation threads aren't allowed is to keep lazy newfags away from the board, and Sadpanda is actually a good filter for newfags because they can't get past the panda and even if they could, it would still attract less newfags than simply lewd images that are posted everywhere on Sup Forums, as a link is less flashy than a image
>Moving to /h/ is a bad option, because Sup Forums has much more traffic, the userbase there is cancerous, the threads always belonged on Sup Forums and there's no reason to change that
>Purging sadpanda actually normalizes Sup Forums more, which is a bad thing

Does that covers everything? I think it does.

We don't need a second thread.

>one thread par boards to talk about the board
>this shit again
Fuck off and kill yourself, the Rules & Regulations general was one of the worst bouts of cancer I've seen in years.

so daily reminder to report this kind of shit on Sup Forums because it's really sad at this point

That thread is a weekly so your newfag is showing

Again, Eva threads are not generals you daft cunt.

They being generals or not is not the point, they have their own flavor of cancer anyway.

Yeah, because there is a lot left to talk about Eva.

What you said was really misleading

I have a better idea.

How about we fix Sup Forums first?

UMARU GET

Not him, but they are just as cancerous anyway.
>Same posters
>Same posts
>Same images
>Is posted everyday
All this fit the criteria of being a general and is cancerous on its own right. I don't care how much you try to be autistic about it and twist this around

This user speaks the truth.

If the mods are reading anything let them sift through the last one first, saged also.

A general refers to people talking about an anime with no set topic, they just talk about whatever they want.

Most Eva threads have a set topic.

I didn't know Monday is a part of the weekend, because those "weeklies" always ends on fucking Monday night.

The mods always enjoy these threads.
I remember a meta thread on /jp/ where I said that and was the only one who got banned in the whole thread.

Well none of that is true.

We have Eva threads frequently and often about the same topics but it's not a general. How can you be this autistic

Just make /ag/ and move all the garbage generals there.
It might end up being even more autistic than /vg/ though

>Most Eva threads have a set topic.

>LOL REIFAGS BTFO
>ASUKA BEST GIRL
>why is ___ so perfect?

Look at the thread creation date and stop embarrassing yourself OP

Ban all the pedophiles.

>Otaku
Every goddamned college student who watches even a little anime uses that word to describe themselves

PLEASE delete template threads like "What did s/he mean by this?" or "Who was in the wrong here?".

So the idea was to not use Sad pandas anymore, instead made Sharing Adult Mangas, to discuse H-Mangas

>has case study of why his idea is bad
>still posts it
Why?

Eva keeps on giving worthwhile discussion to this very day. Fuck off.

Meta threads are good but only in small doses. This is just excessive.

>A general refers to people talking about an anime with no set topic, they just talk about whatever they want.
So, sadpandas aren't generals? As they have a set topic, which is the discussion and dump of h-manga and doujins.
It's the same thing being discussed everyday, which fits the criteria of being a general. Also , the same thread being posted every time, like it happens a lot with EVA, is already shameless shitposting and motive for the threads to be deleted anyway.

So you support endless shitposting until the "last thread" before 12:00 Hawaii time (because that's a thing too) and then casually bump the thread from page 8 so your slut can get drawn?
Look at last weekend's threads, because that's exactly what happened.

Even if you don't like them, they aren't generals since the discussion is usually limited to waifufagging or talking about whether or not Shinji's gay. You're not going to find anyone asking about Gendo's plan or the Dead Sea Scrolls in an Asuka thread.

You could make a case for some of them belonging on /c/ though, especially the ones that have absolutely no discussion at all and are just short of image dumps

Good to see a thread that was not a general turned into one by said general's usual inhabitants.

I thought weeb were the hot cool nerd word.

Oh boy, is this the shitposting general? As I remember the last time we had chain of meta treads under the same excuse in OP's pic were basically that.

>sadpanda threads have a set topic
No they don't

...

...

>weekend waifu draw thread
>Not cancerous as fuck regardless of anything
>Not a general
Yeah, right.

THIS

Yep, over ten thousand posts of spam and retardation. Looks like we're headed for that again.

At least it goes away from here. /vg/ is a shitstain but its influence doesn't reach Sup Forums

They do, the discussion about h-manga and doujins, this is a fact.
>but they get offtopic sometimes
Like EVA threads then?

They do, we talk about releases, scanlations, artist, translators and scanners

Why not use /h/ for a catch all sadpanda thread, that way you can post the actual pages.

answer me this OP, why do you give a shit about sad panda? because thats the reason you started these garbage threads.

Labels are cancer in almost every context. Saying "I like anime" is more than enough.

kys pedo shitter.

shota/loli not allowed

Not him, but sadpanda threads were quite comfy and were the only place that we could actually discuss obscure h-manga.
>discussing porn
Yeah, I know. I take my fapping seriously

>le super elite porn club site xD

Im glad this shit general is gone.

Why not /d/ then?

Sadpanda threads belong on

Might as well so this dies.

If you're a newfag and/or normalfag who doesn't even know what the original word actually meant, sure.

I hate it

Don't worry bro, you're just posting links.

>Since when are weeklies generals?
Never mentions quality, you're retarded; quit trying to twist what people say into your autistic headcanon.
And yes it is not a general, it is a weekly.

Good. As someone who has been here since 2006 I'm glad this has happened. Any community that has threads that last more than one day deserves to get banned.

theres a fucking board for that shit regardless how comfy it is.

Not OP, but only in Sup Forumssadpandas I could talk about some h-mangas that are not allowed on /h/ also /h/ doesn't discuss

This guy shares the same views as me.

Your body belongs on the nearest highway, preferably when you are asleep.

you don't browse those boards, right?

I'm not even OP, and I don't give a fuck about sad panda, but if it's going away, then do away this other cancer too.
The WWD isn't even anonymous anymore. It goes way beyond Sup Forums itself, it's Tumblr at this point.

>implying there are highways in my country

wait a fucking minute, /h/ doesn't allow certain h-mangos?

enlighten me on this

Just a warning, one of the reasons why DJT was banned is because one BR decided to be extremely persistent with remaking threads all the time. Please don't become like him, limit yourself to one thread per day at most if you want to keep pressing on this.

Porn discussion is cancer no matter what and I don't understand why Sup Forums are mad at this. Don't you guys take pride in your elitism mindset and telling newfags to fuck off? Porn is literally the most entry casual level shit you can discuss.

It doesn't help that most fetishes threads turn into 3DPD and normalfags blogging. Find me a milf or a tomboy threads that doesn't turn into 3DPD blogging.

There is none.

because it's a thread that belongs on Sup Forums and mods haven't said why they're banned

>Any community that has threads that last more than one day deserves to get banned.
All has that all the time.
See >>Moving to /h/ is a bad option, because Sup Forums has much more traffic, the userbase there is cancerous, the threads always belonged on Sup Forums and there's no reason to change that
Give me one good reason why we should change something that worked fine until now for no apparent reason.

There's also a board for drawthreads, yet they are allowed on Sup Forums.

fuck off newfag, quit pretending to be an oldfag

he's probably the monkey himself

No loli or /ss/ for starters.

Sup Forums* has that
It seems I'm really tired

I wish mods would just delete meta discussion from threads about particular series. In particular, trolls who kill all discussion by shitposting about people doing things they don't like. I don't understand how the shitposting is allowed but telling them to stop is something that warrants a ban.

>No shotas
>No lolis
>No guro
>No rape
>Nothig close to /d/

Reminder to report shitposters.

If I do one thread a day, then people who come at different times won't see it. Last thread was way too fast so anyone who wasn't here for those ~2 hours would just miss it.

Let's hope that's just the first step. This place is little more than /e/2.0.

What a fag.

Do you? As /d/ does have discussion threads that also reference some vanilla stuff and there is no rule about loli or shota.