Give me 10 good reason why Communism couldn't work in 2018

Give me 10 good reason why Communism couldn't work in 2018.

>degenerate anime fag
That's why. Saged and reported

Communism is itself the reason it does not work. No need to give 9 more.

>mad because his ship got RUSKIED
Heh.

It hasn't worked in 2017, and before

Ward

The number of products and the complexity of the production chains today is unmanageable by a central power. There are no classical workers as there were 100 years ago.

niggger

Afghanistan (1978-1992)
Albania (1946-1992)
Angola (1975-1992)
Benin (1975-1990)
Bulgaria (1946-1990)
Cambodia (1975-1989)
Congo (1975-1992)
Czechoslovakia (1946-1990)
Ethiopia (1974-1991)
East Germany (1949-1990)
Hungary (1949-1989)
North Korea 1948-1992
Mongolia (1924-1990)
Mozambique (1975-1990)
Poland (1945-1989)
Romania (1947-1989)
Somalia (1969-1991)
Soviet Union (1922-1991)
North Vietnam (1945-1975)
South Yemen (1967-1990)
Ukraine (1919-1991)
Yugoslavia (1945-1992)

Because people are greddy

Because it is full of communists.

It never worked

Sage

The rw would murder all of you and the finance niggers would just infiltrate the Politburo and become the technocrats. It didn’t work the first time at all. we need to start over user with extreme measures taken to get there

Give me one reason why it could work.
Also if so many others tried to create communism and failed, what makes you think that you can do better? Maybe the idea of state controlling distribution of wealth inevitably leads to creation of dictatorship, when people in power take wealth for themselves stead of sharing.
You claim that capitalism doesn't work because of inherent human greed. You fail to see that this system foreseen greed and uses it to its advantage. Yours didn't. Even if (by some miracle), you create a system when majority decides how to distribute wealth (direct communist democracy), it'll dissolve into lower 51% deciding how much wealth they steal from upper 49%.

Ruskies are subhuman, so the anger is justified.

this exactly. complexity is the enemy of any central planning. if the world was too complex for communism 100 years ago then there's a snowball's chance in hell it would ever work today.

consider an iron ore mining operation in michigan. before you can even extract ore from the ground you have to have at least one machine that is the product of a chain involving over 50 separate companies, each one as complex as the ore mining operation itself. you couldn't map even 1% of a modern economy even if you had 10 lifetimes so how do you plan on organizing activity on that same scale?

1. its a shit system
2. its a shit system
3. its a shit system
4. its a shit system
5. its a shit system
6. its a shit system
7. its a shit system
8. its a shit system
9. its a shit system
10. its a shit system

in conclusion, its a shit system

You don't need reasons, it simply doesn't work. Millions of literal communists and they can't even run a proper commune; their comrades always skip out on rent.

Communism doesn't work because communists aren't interested in using communism to become richer, they are interested in using Communism to work less. That is why the best Communists end up being fastidious capitalists (such as the Amish.)

I don't need to. I'm sure it could work.

I love it when Poland chimes in to say something about Russia, it never gets old

give us a single reason how comunisim could work at all
>Protip you cant

Says a poleling!

wanna be a communist? join a commune

Nice resolution there

Name me a successful communist nation in 2018

You can't.

yeah ik i just got a bigger one for my collection

It's hard to create a working communist society after being thrown out of a helicopter.

Then do it. Replicate communism at the smallest level. Start a religious organization where everyone lives at the church building. Pay nothing in taxes, collect will full contributions, and then provide for everyone's needs.

Communists can't make this work. They have all the potential to be as rich as they want but can't cooperate long enough to get the job done.

There's not a lot of incentive to work in a communist system. No one wants to clean out a dirty sewer for 8 hours only to get nothing.

People still need to eat thats why.
/thread

shitty topic, good thread.

Sociopaths exist and just like when we were tribes of hunter gatherers they will always end in positions of power and people will always willingly go along with them and they'll stay there until dead.
This is an inherent problem that exists in every system of governance and economy humans attempt, especially anarchy.
Until it is common practice or even a requirement to scan someone's brain before they are given a position of power every system humans build is destined to fall.
Everyone who is mentally ill in any shape or form should be purged or at least kept poor and weak.

There's been a hundred million reasons and faggots still can't grasp that the only thing it's good for is filling mass graves that can be seen from orbit.

the eastern european rivalries are truly something to behold

Also the labor theory of value is bullshit. Image a guy with a shovel and and a guy with an excavator. Both work 8 hours. The first guy worked considerably harder and burned way more calories than the second. But the guy with the excavator managed to excavate 1000 times the volume the first guy has. Do they get the same work value or does the first guy get more because he worked harder or the second because he produced more results?

you need food to work.

Because it didn't work in 1918

When will you commie fucks realize that your shitty ideology never worked, doesn't work and will never work? Get it through your thick fucking skull. Communism is literally the nigger of ideologies, retarded, lazy, requires assistance to even feed itself and it's still unsuccessful in every possible way. Fuck you commies.

First guy gets minimum wage cause literally anyone can do it, the amount of work he does is immaterial as long as he meets minimum. He won't get anything for going above and beyond.
The second guy gets paid more for not only knowing how to operate the excavator, the amount of work he does is also immaterial as that amount of work was expected for him to do.

That's nothing but you projecting, thinking everyone is a lazy loser like you. Untrue and wrong, simply.

> Communism working
Nice b8 m8
I prefer not to starve

Id quit my job as a pharmacist and just work as a cashier because its easier.

See that's the problem with communism and socialism. They don't acknowledge that work it self has no value if it's disconnected from the product and the (market-) demand placed on the product and the availability of specialized knowledge and tools to effectively create said product. Otherwise we could solve unemployment by having 500,000 people dig holes and have another 500,000 fill them up. In a capitalist system the value is zero in a communist it's non-zero despite only keeping 1,000,000 people busy and not adding value to the society or the market but just draining energy from the workers.

Niggers
Jiggaboos
Spear-chuckers
Porch-monkeys
Coons
Sambos
Darkies
Spooks
Gollywogs
And Kikes

Samefag

Jews

10 good reasons? We need far less than that to get to the point.

Reason 1: There are no reasons why it would work. Like, the entire proposition of communism rests on societal conditions that do not exist in our reality.

Reason 2: Communism defaults to totalitarian tyranny because the only mode under which it can operate ethically is a mode wherein every single individual in the system agrees to have no ownership of their own labor. This is inflexible and naive.

Consequentially, communism will try to reinvent the human condition before it will try to reinvent its nonsense-utopia. Historical example: 'The New Soviet Man'.

3. Because communism dismantles the separation of powers and the legal system of a nation. All it really takes for it to fail is a single clever statesman going full Stalin.
The state makes itself unnecessarily fragile by dismantling the very institutes that would otherwise make it robust. Ergo, communism in practice is a self-defeating state of affairs.

Reason 4: Communism inevitably leads to a Gulag State. It has no incentives for the advancement of human rights, consumer protection or favorable working conditions. Especially not in an era where population figures are larger than the demands of the workplace. People are a disposable resource, and when a group of farmers or whatever disagrees with the policies of the state. Then there are no democratic systems in place for these farmers to voice their professional opinions in politics. Instead they will be replaced with people that are more willing to listen to the party line, or in the absence of that, people will be forced into the work because someone has to do it.

Reason 5: You can easily redistribute wealth in a communist state. But can you generate it?

Ultimately, Communism is a rather laughable deconstruction of civilization when you present it before a western, industrialized nation. Like, what does it actually offer in exchange for everything it tears down?

To some it up:
for(i=0;i

because communism a retarded fantasy ideology that can't work in real life--regardless of the year in which it's implemented. how's that?

Not an argument