Why does every other P.A Works production pale in comparison to Uchouten Kazoku?

Why does every other P.A Works production pale in comparison to Uchouten Kazoku?

It's their passion project, directed by the cofounder of the studio.
Just looking at the difference in production values between this and Sakura makes it clear which they prioritize.

I'm glad it doesn't have the typical PA Works sameface and bland color palette/aesthetic.

Absolute classy madman

Looking at shows like Sakura Quest and Shirobako is frustrating because, while all the males and side characters are allowed to have unique designs full of expressiveness, all the girls MUST have the same fucking face, unless they aren't moe uguu~ enough.

Good source material.

There's too much going on in those backgrounds, the color and lighting is all fucked up, dull and monotone, It's like whoever is storyboarding this doesn't know what composition, framing and flow are.

...

...

...

Yeah the filter they use looks really bad. Wish the art was painted instead. It'd be sweet if the art in this show was good enough to match the story.

...

They're adapting a (supposedly) pretty good book and a lot of their talented animators and staff work on it

I wish more anime adapted books.

No one in PA flops is really talented

The animation isn't really that good, though.

They do

Light novels

>Light novels
Please no

There's plenty of good LN adaptations from this season alone. Also, 'light novel' is a pretty broad term.

There are 0 good LN adaptations across all history. That is a fact and I have the sources to prove it.

Go ahead

I could prove it if I wanted to, but I don't feel like it right now.

>There's plenty of good LN adaptations from this season alone
No, there aren't.

Light Novel is Jap for Young Adult Fiction which all 100% trash.

>There's plenty of good LN adaptations
Yes

>from this season alone
No

>muh realism
Fuck off. There's nothing wrong with the storyboards, color or lighting.

>Yes
No

Book adaptions are some of the best. Uchouten Kazoku, Welcome to the NHK, Tatami Galaxy, Shinsekai Yori, World Masterpiece Theater anime, LoGH, 12 Kingdoms, Shiki are all high quality while almost every LN adaption is straight garbage.

Though it does help that book adaptions tend to be a complete story rather than LN adaptions which are basically just ads for the LN.

Where did he say anything about realism?

>Shiki
Ya blew it.

If you're going to complain at least post an example of what you're talking about.
That girl in the middle is showing some serious sideboob.

Yes

...

muh

Yasaburo please

Just mention how all the light novels that come to mind are otaku pandering.

My biggest issue was whether or not S2 would have as great an OP or ED as S1 but after a couple weeks I've decided I really love both. Glad to see Uchoten Kazoku back.

That was your biggest issue? Well it's good that both of them are fantastic.

...

A bad series can be justified if it has a good OP and ED. A truly great series has incredible OP and EDs while also being good on it's own right. People tend to belittle how important OPs and EDs are in anime. Not all, but some anyway.

God, Shirobako was infuriating because of this. It's not even just design (which was bad enough) it's characterization too. All the men were interesting, flawed, they could be selfish, mean, lazy, cause conflict and it was all the more satisfying when they grew from it. The girls were all perfectly nice, with perfect work ethic, and any conflict they were involved in was watered down so that none of them seemed anything but cute and sweet. Most of them were a waste of space who added nothing to the show except being cute.

>There's too much going on in those backgrounds

what THE FUCK did he mean by this

LNs are Japanese versions of serialized fanfiction

>A bad series can be justified if it has a good OP and ED
what

Do you judge how great a book is by its cover art?

No. Fuck you. Thoughts like this lead to fat girls in anime, and that's terrible.

This post is all kinds of retarded. OPs and EDs have no relation to the quality of the show.

No. Fuck you. Thoughts like this lead to moe shit where every girl has a copy pasted face with the distinctive characteristic being their hair, and that's terrible.

You don't have to be fat to avoid sameface.

>moe shit
AKA anime Sup Forums likes.

Take the fat guys out of anime too and then that's fair. Get rid of the old and ugly ones too, and make sure they all appeal to fujos because that is the equivalent of what you're saying (that design should be about fap material alone).

No it leads to expressive or unique character designs which are more attractive than girls having the same cutesy face all of the time.

>Take the guys out of anime too
FTFY.

>distinctive character designs that allow you to identify a character without relying on hair style/color are bad!
Retard.
The reason sameface is so rampant is in 99% of cases because a bunch of characters that look the same are much easier to draw and animate.

Expressive designs don't have to mean ugly ones.

The only way it could appeal to fujos is if they are slightly gay. You are just bringing in girls at that point.

Ironic since Maid Dragon is so rampantly posted there.

What are you talking about?
Shirobako is better than tanuki soup.

I wouldn't know.

You need to go back.

Not really. And it certainly doesn't look half as good.

Seems like you would since you have that image saved.

Apparently Maid Dragon gets posted on other boards as well. Did that show trigger people or what

>A bad series can be justified if it has a good OP and ED.
A bad series can be identified by it's OP and maybe it's ED on the first episode. With the right amount of attention span you can see how the story goes, where it's set and how it's characters will interact with each other. The song rarely has anything to do with the show.

What you said is retarded.

It was AOTS. Of course it got posted on a lot of boards. It was popular because it was very good.

KyoAni shows always seem get tossed around between all the boards.

It was really good. I agree with the flaws that people point out about it but overall the warm family vibe I get from it makes up for it.
It seems especially so with this one though. Kanna probably has something to do with that.

KyoAni is by far the most skilled anime studio and it's painfully obvious to all. Of course they get posted on all the boards. They're popular because they're very good.

meme thicc loli
there is literally no reason to watch Kyoani other than memes