>fma had a terrible anime that didn't follow the manga
>got a remake that did it justice
>jojo got a non chronological OVA that was pretty ok but didn't satiate fans
>got an amazing revival
>Soul eater got an anime that didn't follow the manga at all
>??????
Bones you are sitting on a money pile. Do something.
>Still no bones adaptation of Lucifer and Biscuit Hammer
Also fma 2003 isn't terrible
it paled in comparison to fmab but you're right. i just want soul eater to be given the justice it deserved. the manga was too good not to be followed. this new jojo resurgence just gave me new hope for a soul eater brotherhood like anime. (soul eater resonance?)
The original FMA anime was better than the remake.
Close adherence to source material does not make an inherently better animated adaption. Anime is first and foremost visual medium, so it should primarily be judged on it's animation, aesthetic, shot composition etc.
The original was better than the remake on all those counts. I personally think the characterization and pacing was better in the original too, but that's my subjective opinion.
i respect your opinion and it has made me see the older anime in a newer light. it wasn't that bad but i just wanted to highlight that soul eater could have a chance at redemption if given a true to the soul (no pun intended) remake.
does no one feel the same way about soul eater?
Not really, heard the manga ended up just as average as the anime.
>The original FMA anime was better than the remake.
This is how you immediately discredit yourself.
the price of the Jojo revival was neo jojofans
I think part 5 is really gonna bring out the worst in them
FMA was an amazing show with mature themes and directing, and a very satisfying ending that didn't pander to viewers expectations.
FMA:B is shonen-trash with a bunch of cringey humor injected.
>Muh matuuuure animu for real mature adults like me
Im 100% sure that everyone that likes 2003 FMA are all EVAfags that think it's better because nothing ever get's fucking explained in it and the ending is shit.
There is no way you can justify liking and unfinished and badly written product other then to protect your ego.
Anime is literally advertisment 95% of the time. There is no profit to be made from a new Soul Eater. Jojo´s and HxH are ongoing, FMA remake was tied to the manga ending.
No, i love kill la kill and cromartie high school and all kinds of silly anime.
FMA:B tried to be mature and failed. The humor is particularly offputting, the pacing is rushed, and the story is much less interesting and ambiguous than the 2003 version.
>using EVA as a bar for bad taste
>being this contrarian
>thinking that the anime original ending is bad just because it doesn't hold your hand like the manga version
Could you be any more of a pleb?
No, it's called being right. And he is. Everything down to the animation style and plot was overall better in the 2003 version. Manga FMA be damned.
how so?
>We will never see the boob moon animated
>we will never see the Soul/Maka/Blair threesome animated
>we will never see the piano scythe animated
It hurts, anons, why won't the pain stop?
>soul/maka/blair threesome
i don't remeber that
but yeah fucking how to make soul eater popular again
...
why the cat be triflin?