Why is Hyouka never properly regarded as a masterpiece on the same level as Neon Genesis Evangelion, Utena, Madoka, LOGH, Shinsekai Yori, etc?
Why is Hyouka never properly regarded as a masterpiece on the same level as Neon Genesis Evangelion, Utena, Madoka...
Because it is not a masterpiece?
>masterpieces
>Madoka, Shinsekai Yori
Because having best boy Satoshi lose the Orekibowl to a vapid whore and then shoving him to another vapid whore as a consolation prize is not the formula for winning.
because its boring
Is Shinsekai Yori considered a masterpiece? It is a really great anime, but it gets some criticism for really shallow characters and the clumsy exposition device info dump
It had great fashion, that is for sure
What did Hyouka excel in exactly?
Also the garbage direction, animation and CG.
Arthouse avant garde visual direction that far surpassed anything in the medium to date
Not at all. OP is just trying to slip in his shit taste while people argue over KyoAni.
>Arthouse avant garde visual direction that far surpassed anything in the medium to date
Nothing that Dezaki didn't already do better 20+ years earlier.
yeah if your a faggot
Everything, basically.
1. It's not because it isn't and 2. neither are most of those.
I especially appreciate dialogue and characterization.
Truer than life itself.
The characters
deep as fuck
>any Kyoani show
>arthouse
>avant garde
Top fucking kek. They make the most polished, broad appeal shows of any studio, and that's including Hyouka. Try to learn what words mean before you use them
>avant garde
i don't think you know what this means
NEVAR 5GET
KyoAniggers think just because something looks good it should be regarded as a masterpiece
DUDE LAZINESS LMAO
I watched 5 episodes just waiting for it to get better. It was honestly the most boring anime i've ever tried to watch. I couldn't give a damn about any of the characters.
What are you objecting to? Hyouka gets overrated plenty.
The poor man's Yahari with tedious "mystery" tacked on. Pass
Looks like the poor man's Kyon to me
The animation is nice. That's about it really.
First few eps were the strongest ones in the series by far.
>poor man's Yahari
Yahari's even worse than Hyouka on pretty much every level though.
Exactly, poor mans kyon. When are we gonna get an MC like that again?
its pretty banal compared to those
When Tanigawa stops procrastinating and writes
Because it's shit.
Watch Oreimo
>Yahari's even worse than Hyouka on pretty much every level though.
Except for having an actually interesting main character and being fun to watch. The second season was shit but it was still miles ahead of "nothing happens: the animated series".
No one unironically thinks Madoka, LOGH or Shinsekai Yori are masterpieces or even great
Unfortunately, a lot of people do.
With all this talk about masterpieces, haruhi is one of them.
>Neon Genesis Evangelion
>Masterpiece
When will this meme end
of all the shows OP named off you pick Eva?
Found the shit taste.
Yes
Yes, but sadly a dead one.
run of the mill light novel garbage
Cause it's fucking boring as shit. I won't deny it looks nice but damn the fucking snoozefest it is.
>Actual Masterpieces
Evangelion
Utena
>Very Excellent
Shinsekai Yori
>Quite Good
Madoka
Hyouka
>Overrated Garbage for Childish Idiots
LoGH
Switch logh and shinseki
Someone doesn't have to be DEEP to be a masterpiece, it just has to be very high quality and famous/important. Something like Girls und Panzer could easily be considered one.
I don't think anybody really considers G&P a "masterpiece", just a good and fun show.
It's Hyoukafags that seem convinced that their show is the best thing put on film since the Seventh Seal.
It's too intelligent for the uncultured masses.
*to
I guess it would make sense for you to think that, considering you put Madoka and Shinsekai Yori up there. There are good, but they are not masterpieces.