Which movie was better?

Which movie was better?

Other urls found in this thread:

strawpoll.me/13042183
twitter.com/NSFWRedditVideo

Keit-Ai.

KnK
Yamada wins by a huge margin over Shinkai.

>Kimi no Na wa
Obnoxious music insertion, amv tier storytelling, sensationalist garbage dependent on muh earthquake incident, 1-dimensional characters, nonsensical plot, mediocre character animation, half-baked thematic delivery, hackneyed dialogue. Overall it's pretty much the worst anime film of the decade
>Koe no Katachi
Great storytelling, very delicate direction, careful use of sound mixing, complex imagery, actually grounded and realistic except for that one moment, memorable characters, meaningful themes, meticulous character acting. 2016 AOTY.

I still haven't seen Your Name.

Both where shait, fampai.

Koe no Katachi could have been great but it was to much off a bit cryfest without actually saying something.

Katachi had a way more compelling plot for the first half and then almost fizzled with the melodrama bombs, but managed to pull through by ending better than the manga. Speaking of that, a lot of fat was trimmed from the manga for better or worse. The movie subplot was dropped at the expense of some development of side characters, but the movie was framed as Shouya's journey so it's not too big an issue.

Your Name was fantastic, but its just a remix of 5cm and Voices of a Distant Star with a happier ending for the sake of theater viewers. Unlike 5cm, theres no lasting impression or feeling after you've finished watching. It's undeniably a good movie, but nothing about it really sticks in my mind, and unlike other Shinkai works like Garden of Feet, theres less pretty scenery porn to look at.

What do you mean it didn't say anything?

Your Name was a good movie, and A Silent Voice was a good film.

Shinkai
>Premiere screening in AX garnered a standing ovation
>Kimi no Na wa becomes a blockbuster hit
>Actually a well paced movie
>Technically impressive in visuals and huge upgrade from his past films
>Satisfying end and memorable protaginists
>Gets screened in many theaters worldwide.
>Blockbuster hit in Hong Kong
>Blockbuster hit in Korea
>9/10 rating from audience
>Becomes the contender for Oscar Nomination

Yamada
>Pre-screening event in Japan got vocal KyoAni twitter fanbase say good things
>Upon proper screening it was just so-so
>Koe no Katachi gets the scraps of Kimi no Na wa audience
>Gets few more screens but fails to get anything and falls off into obscurity
>8.3/10 rating from the audience
>Lost all the meaning because of unrealistic and unnecessary drama
>Lots of disatisfied manga readers
>Pretentious ending
>Overdone faux-cinematography to make it seem "technical" when in fact it barely added anything to the movies narrative
>Said "cinematography" is actually nothing special and could be done easily in a properly budgeted TV anime
>Gets forgotten by people a few weeks after
>Director doesn't get any awards

Kizumonogatari.

He ran out of ritalin and couldn't pay attention for 2 hours straight.

Koe no Katachi. Shinkai is a lousy director.
Kimi no Na wa had better animation though.

oh right that still exists

Was the box office for Koe no Katachi good at least?

I can't help but feel bad for KyoAni and their lousy revenue.

4/10 post, barely worthy of a (you)

but it's all true though, people liked Kimi no Na Wa better than KnK

>kyoani
>lousy revenue

KnK beat Kimi no Nawa as Best Animation of the Year in the 26th Japan Movie Critics Awards
Kyoani already got money and the movie rights from MEXT

Yes it does. And it was the best of the three.

That it was more popular is the only true thing there.

Shaft's Fireworks.

KnK >>> Kizu > Your Name

Absolute, unadulterated pleb taste right here.

Your Name -- 7/10 (competent Disney-wanabe popcorn flick)
A Silent Voice -- 9/10 (teen kino)

Yamada
>Smothers everything in bloom and chromatic aberration to hide mediocre animation

Yeah, Kara no Kyoukai was pretty good.

Also

>Shinkai
Makes a huge hit with completely original story

>Yamada
>can't do the same even with famous and award winning source material

>Your Name
>mediocre character animation

How so?

Blame was better than both because it had better VAs

Well it's not that it didn't say anything.
But there were so many emotional moments and they were all so similar.
I fucking love the beginning of the movie.
But a lot of what happened felt kinda pointless and messy despite it looking so beautiful.
I just don't like how it was all presented.
>muh guilt
>muh change
>muh friends
They were all crying about the same bullshit for an entire hour.
I realize that the characters are actually kind of nuanced but since the movies runtime didn't give them much time to explore everyone, so they all felt kind of flat to me.

Again, I liked the movie but it was certainly flawed.
It's hard to put into words, maybe it was the dialogues too.

they didn't even share a kiss in neither movie so they both suck

>it's hard to out into words
I can tell

P L E B (

the bodyswapping was a metaphor for sex

"Yamada Bingo" when? Someone suggested it in another thread?

It's alright. Shinkai's best movie easily.

Kino no Na wa > Blur and Chromatic Aberration The Movie

That's not saying much

Threadly reminder that Sha*t is a Pierrot-tier poorfag studio with delusions of grandeur after they got lucky a couple times. Fortunately audiences are starting to catch on.

Their cuck fans are probably the """"people"""" who start these pro-Shitkai threads.

Koe no Katachi had better girls, better animation, better music, and a better story.

strawpoll.me/13042183

I'm tired of having this argument everyday. Can't we move on?

No kimi no nawa had better animation and music

Can we have a non-bait Kimi no Na Wa thread for once?

Better girls sure. animation is definitely a no. Music I guess so, it was at least somewhat fresh, KnNw was good but generic

So good things about knk are the only things you'll listen to? Okay you baby.

She's like a recent film school grad who just discovered the latest effects and can't help stuffing them in everywhere.

Maybe someday she'll make a professional-looking movie, but not today.

>cuck
>"""people"""

You need to go back.

Nobody likes stale pasta.

That post doesn't even list good things about Your Name you twit. It's just >it sold a lot repeated a bunch of times.

Kimi no Na wawas more captivating experience but I'm already forgetting it just 2 hours after viewing, just like it's main characters were forgetting about their dreams.
Koe no Katachi wasn't that impressive but it's on my mind constantly for 5th day now and I'm now exhausted from reading every appearing thread about it.

It's a normalfag anime on par with Naruto or Shingeki no Kyoujin, so the answer is pretty clearly and emphatically: NO!

We can't. Knkfags are way too salty.

Point 1,3,4,5,9,10 are valid points.

It's a shame Koe no Katachi's BDs aren't selling all that much. Contrary to what some lickers and ultimatebetamax want to believe, they did not make much profit from the theater screenings, it was the BDs they had a hand on and also rights to some merch.

The screenings more than doubled the production costs. You have no idea what you're talking about. Kaguya Hime only cost 30 million dollars to make, for example, and that one was clearly a lot more expensive than the average Ghibli film (which in turn is more expensive than the average anime film.)

Screenings profit went to Shochiku not KyoAni.

>Kaguya Hime only cost 30 million dollars to make
50 million. The Wind Rises cost 30 million.

KyoAni didn't shoulder the whole cost either. Screening profits are split between the production companies and the publishers.

Shinkai is much cuter than Yamada.

Not split evenly, Shochiku was in charge of distribution of the film. KyoAni covered costs for production and had rights to BD sales and merch.

koe no floptachi sucks

>2016 AOTY
Implying there's been anything close to it in the last decade, not that that says much.

Which main girl was cuter?

KyoAni wasn't the only company on the production committee. Stop spreading shit that is plainly untrue.

That's why it's only "alright"

Every year has an anime of the year, dumbass.

Being on top doesn't mean you have control over everything or spent the most of every detail of the film's production.

I mean, you can tell who had control over the film's theater run when it was Shochiku that cut screenings almost in half by the third week, despite the movie picking up pace. Koe no Katachi would've definitely grossed over 3 billion if not for that mistake, and it was a mistake on their part since it was their highest grossing film that year.

Then you're only remembering it because of the threads. Kyoanifags spam their shit threads to make that garbage movie more relevant.
The topics are from the most asinine and emptiest things, mind you. Like this one for example "hurr i wanna be bullied DURR"
Even its first post pointed that out

Does KnK count as 2016's or 2017's film in the West? Does it still have a shot at the Oscars or was that already last year? Not that it has any actual chance against Disney

>Implying there's been anything close to it in the last decade
I'm pretty sure there have been many others 5/10 anime in the last decade.

I can't wait for the In This Corner of the World BD to drop and BTFO both of these overrated mediocrities.

There's no need to be upset. Lurk more and you'll get used to it newfriend.

>In This Corner of the World
It's garbage. Another nationalist apologetic piece.

Artless craftsmanship. Your name has nothing on par with webm related.

>muh pretty effects
>muh watercolors
>muh calque background animation
Pleb.

Is there anything you didn't like about it besides on moral grounds? I wish I could see it too.

That's not particularly impressive.

Apart from the lack of hair pulling this actually looks like a fight between brats.

It's a tepid retread of previous Katabuchi films like Ushiro no Shoumen Daare. Nostalgia bait.

Both.

KyoAni and Keit-Ai are established way-finders.

How did they make it look so realistic? It's amazing.

Pearls before swine, as usual I see. It must suck having autism.

kizumonogatari

>Yes it does. And it was the best of the three.

At this point ~monogatari fags are just sad.

You're trying to prove a point and when someone can't see it you insult them is that the usual Kyoani fan way of arguing or just yours?

It's based off a meme. It was doomed from the start.

If it's realistic, it's rotoscoped.

>implying

SHAFT has the BEST backgrounds.

I'm not a kyoani fan. I'm an animation fan. That scene has amazing character animation. I'm not going to pontificate about it to every random retard on Sup Forums who claims they're unimpressed (especially when there's a high chance they're just shitposting.)

see Photography finds a way.

I've only seen Kiki's Delivery Service, Princess Arete and Mai Mai Miracle. Is it anything like those? Can't say I care for Mai Mai Miracle, but I love the other two.

Doesn't look rotoscoped.

I enjoyed Kimi no na wa more, but Koe no Katachi seemed like it would've been a lot better if I had read the manga.
Though I guess if it can't appeal to people who don't already have context, that makes it a less good movie in that respect.

No wonder it flopped.

He's clearly shitposting, stop replying.