The great debate

The great debate

BnH is cuter so is better.

BnH has actual girls so is better.

HxH

One Piece.

Are HxH, My Hero Acadaima, One Piece, Yu Yu Hakusho, Gash bell, and Jojo the only good shonens?

There's no debate.

Take out Jojo and yeah pretty much.

But in full seriousness, Jojo should barely count as a shonen

>There's no debate
>Literally doesn't argue for either side
Wow you just blew my mind.

Bleach

Jojo is shonen until part 7 like it or not

But I'd still take it out of the list because while the stands are very creative as self-contained stories, the overall writing is terrible, especially the character writing.

>Yu Yu Hakusho,
HAHAHAHAHAHA

Why would I argue when there's no debate to be had?

>pow pow pow

Kimetsu is bretty good.

Yep, HxH is clearly superior.

He's right though, there's no notable debate going on for these particular series. They aren't in direct competition with each other, BnHA is too new in comparison.

I don't know user, I feel like terrible is a wrong word to describe JoJo's writing. If Araki tried to make things sensible I feel like the manga as whole would be really tame and boring. Being outlandish and over the top is what JoJo is all about. Same goes for the characters. They're full of cheesy one liners and quirky traits, but that's what makes them good.

HxH

What about the FMA manga?

>Gash bell
user, I like you.

Don't fucking consider fma as a shonen
... It isn't

BnHA is not bad, even if it seems like it has ran out of ideas recently, but HxH is one of the very few manga I'd call genuinely brilliant.

It's published in a shonen magazine, therefore it's shonen

HxH fags are the worst.

So manga from the 90s vs manga that started less than 3 years ago? Seems fair!

It was published in a fucking shounen mag, user.

>less than 3 years ago
Wow, feels like longer for some reason.

Its a shounen, and not even a massively unique one. Bretty good though.

How is this even a debat?

One of these is the most well-crafted and consistent shonen series of all time.

The other is just a reskinned version of almost every other Shonen Jump series, down to having the exact same themes and writing tropes.

What does age have to do with it?

It'd be hilarious if Boku no Hero Academia will have more chapters than HxH

>being this buttblasted your shit shonen isn't being wanked off

>consistent

Depends on the definition

Well, HxH is garbage, but other than that you're right.

O

Shonens worth reading/watching : HxH, Hero Academia, Karakuri Circus, FMA, One Piece until CP9 as the manga literally decreases in quality after this

The rest is either absolute garbage (Fairy Tail, Black Clover,Reborn) or poorly executed (Bleach, Yu Yu hakusho)

If there are knowledgeable shonensfags who can enlight me in this genre I'll gladly accept to try what you'll give me

MY

>These are the shounen I liked
>These are the shounen I disliked
>Any recs?
Yeah, fuck off.

RUBBER

>Black Clover,

I dropped BC but picked it up again and it's pretty likable. Beginning is ofc the issue for most but it finds it's own way after a few chapters.

BnA is about as standard as you can get. It plays it so safe that you aren't going to expect any left curves or any risky writing decisions. All the characters are what you'd expect, a classic underdog story and the main conflict is the same old good vs bad.

As it is, eh it's fine. Good designs and good action. And an okay protag.

DICK

DUCK

My Hunter x Hunter Academia

I want to bone the devil

>No Rurouni Kenshin.

user...

Sure the OVA was good but the original manga is shit

>naruto 2.0 generic trash against hxh an actual good battle shounen
yeah, some great debate. really makes me think.

only chimera ant arc is good
hero academia is shit in general

They're both pretty shit, but HxH has the more obnoxious fanbase, so I'm going to go with Right.

Shonen implies ignorance and Power ups and new enemies... Seems legit user-kun

>less than 3 years ago
And? It's at 14 volumes, that's way more than enough to judge.

Gon-san could fuck up All Slight at max.
Gon-san is still better, because the mindbreak was glorious.

Here comes the "Derr boof shitto" anons with every comparison thread.

Not that it makes this thread valid but whatever.

...

I wouldn't consider FMA a battle shonen so I didn't list it

I forgot to includes (g)oldies in my post

why Sup Forums?

MHA has become pretty boring so I'm going with HxH.
Too bad you can't discuss neither on here because the threads are a huge shitfest

OP and Karakuri are only like two years younger than Kenshin.

Fullmetal Alchemist and Magi are the best.

>Magi

Magi would have been good if it hadn't given up on the adventure and went full on politics.

If you do not like the arguments that Magi treats does not mean it's ugly. Let's leave personal tastes, we judge for what it is. Politics / Economy is one of the elements that distinguishes Magi from the majority of the other shonen. (And in fact it is an element present from the beginning, for example the Balbadd arc)

Which one has cuter girls? It's obviously HxH.

Who's a better mc Gon or Deku?

Gon

Gon.

>girl

This is like comparing dance and architecture. You can't compare these two things.

Also has Togashi redrawn all the parts he obviously half assed? I want that chapter where Kaito is talking with the koala hitman to be as good as it can be. I love that shit.

One Piece is shit, but you're right about the others.

Why is this even a thing? they are both different shonen that do there own thing. No need to compare the two in a pointless debate that will only encourage shitposting

Hero Academia has better art and far better character design to the point where every single girl is best girl. It may have a generic storyline, but it's an generic storyline that is expertly done. HxH is great too, but it is weighed down by hiatus after haitus and bad art.

Do we count Kenshin as Shojo or Seinen?

Deku. He's more relatable and down to earth as far as shonen protagonists go.

>pointless debate that will only encourage shitposting
but why else would we be here?

not really fair for me to compare since I have seen all of HxH(that will happen) and only the first season of BnH.

That said I like BnH more on the mere principle that it hasn't been ruined for me yet. If I had only seen the 99 HxH I would have probably said that it was better though.

>only arguement to defend BnHA is about the art
Not even a contest.

>can´t compare animes for having different genres
>can´t compare anime for having the same genre
>can´t compare animes at all
what´s next

She's a girl dummy.

How in the blue hell is deku relatable?

>consistent
HxH is all over the fucking place in terms of quality.

>speedreaders
Slow down and read it

>art

BnHA is literally just soft porn with garbage 90's b-movie action while HxH is picasso tier art with Predator/alien/commando tier action.

...

I like Deku more than Gon

but Gon isn't some pussy who keeps damaging himself trying to do basic shit with his powers.

...

You forgot Gash Bell

Can we even consider Magi a shounen now? This final battle is so groundbreaking its funny. In one chapter we have a final antagonist, the next we have diplomacy but at the end of the chapter one guy has signs of turning antagonist, then next chapter we learn thats a ruse and he joins in the conversation too, then next chapter a previous villain emerges, and then the one after that he's taken out.

More like moder art , cuse some of art in HxH sure was drawn with the ass,

What's funny is the previous villain was taken out by the first antagonist whose actually him or at least similar to him

Probably hasn't even watched the movies.

There's tonnes of lesser-known but good shonen. Lurk more and you might hear about them.

This.
I may be more attached to HxH because I have been following that manga for longer but I like both.

The Fullmetal Alchemist being good meme again

Hori is one of the biggest westaboo in Japan.

His pixiv, before it was deleted, had a bunch of art he drew from western cartoons/comics and his studio is filled with 100's of Marvel and DC figurines

One Piece

all day everyday

Hunter x Hunter is the most overrated battle manga of all time

you literally, simply can not prove me wrong

He is a moneyboo hack.