Would you support communism if it promised establishing a white ethno-state?

Would you support communism if it promised establishing a white ethno-state?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=DcfEAY-Gt7E
youtube.com/watch?v=XxIbq7HkalQ
dailysignal.com/2017/05/10/ugly-racism-karl-marx/
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proletarian_internationalism
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

yes. then plot to overthrow it to install national socialism.

No. That's a perfect recipe to round up all the good whites and kill them all.

Better plan: black commie ethno-state.

no
communism is still basically contrary to just about every value the white ethno-state is supposed to preserve

Pass. Honestly, I'd rather deal with niggers than deal with communism. Growing up I had a neighbor that fled one of the eastern bloc countries. Fuck all that.

No

USSR was basically a slav ethnostate and it was a mass starvation gulag-happy shithole that collapased under its own retardation

so no

why do you keep posting that bulge?

Yes.

No. I'm not white. And before you ask, again no.

No.

I live in = probably one of the most diverse spots on the planet. What was once our humble grain farm outside of Calgary is now the middle of a neighborhood full of poos and donair ninjas and Vietnameese menonites (wtf).

And realistically, they just annoy me when I look at them. They've never actually caused me any problems or taken anything from me. And I suppose that they did make me a millionaire in a roundabout way.

All of my problems with them are really intangible and philosophical/ideological.

But communism would fucking ruin everything on day 1. The immigrants are annoying and unnecessary. Communists would actually get in my way and actually cause me strife.
I'm not a little kid, I remember the cold war, I grew up in it. I was born in '70, I met plenty of people who fled it, polacks too.
If you think that you want communism, you're wrong.
Commies imprison/entrap people whenever they have trouble managing labour, and then they work the "prisoners" to death..

Like I said, I'm not a little kid. Watching people die by order of the state is a lot worse to me then seeing a brown person at the mall.

If genuine communists ever gain power here, well there's no point in saying what I'd do. I'd be among the first in the field.

If I had absolute assurances that it would be a white ethnostate, then perhaps.
But that would go against the whole ethos of communism, ie equality, so it would never happen.

"HEY GUYS WOULD YOU SUPPORT [IDEOLOGY] IF IT WASN'T [IDEOLOGY]?

>replace socialism with socialism

Communism makes a lot of promises.

Then you've never experienced dealing with niggers. I grew up in St Louis, and it isn't obvious to me that Id've had a worse childhood in the Soviet Union, bad as it may have been.

Soviet union: dismal consumer life, but had better science and military than the US.

Would I support (((communism))) if Jews promised it would be an amazing white only ethno state? Fuck no. Never trust Jews.

Never, communism is anti-thetical to white identity and private property is the most important principle out there.
Without private property how can I tell niggers and jews to fuck off?

Explain why Gommunism/socialism is anti-white.

lel poland haven't you learned anything? Communism promised to feed it's people and free them from their opressors. communism will always be against the white ethno-state. It doesn't matter if it's a democracy, monarchy a fascist state or whatever. communists are the scum of the earth and should be shot at sight

>believing anything (((they))) tell me

Being non-Capitalist is mandatory for an ethno-state, so yes

It would deliver on no such thing, it would liquidate its supporters for being useful idiots.

I'm ready, comrade
youtube.com/watch?v=DcfEAY-Gt7E

Marty Robbins is always right.
youtube.com/watch?v=XxIbq7HkalQ

It proclaims the equality of all peoples, including races, and as a result declares nationalism a spook.
Reconciling ethnonationalism with communism is like trying to square a circle; it's just not possible.

after WWII basically no one in the USSR starved to death.

This is a clear bait thread
>1 post by this ID
>sage

We had "white communism" here in the East.
It did not work.
Still, I would rather be poor than "enriched".

I hope that those of you with at least half a brain can spot this attempt at subverting hard line white nationalists who probably already have a slightly negative view of capitalism into becoming communists or national bolsheviks.

Anti-communism is one of the main reasons for having a white country.

>The white race
>Gommunism

I choose death. If whites were to live like destitute slavic niggers, then it'd all be meaningless.

>It did not work.

>first man into space
>everyone had a job, house and food
>prisioners were slaves
>culture was preserved
>people were preserved
>no degeneracy
>no crimes

No because it would lead to the decline of the white race

no fucking way. solviet russia was may as well have been a white ethno-state and it was a total shit hole.

Nature abhors communism and thus it is doomed to fail.

...

Jewnigger slide thread fuck off.

Communism is purely Jewish in outlook and practice. Kill all Leftists.

This is bait, but I'll bite anyway because there are some young idiots on here who will actually take this post seriously.
>first man into space
And the Americans got the first nukes, so what?
Science has nothing to do with ideology. This point is null.
>everyone had a job, house and food
Statistically false. There was unemployment in the USSR and there were multiple famines, absolute bullshit.
>prisioners were slaves
How exactly is this a good thing?
>culture was preserved
Again, simply not true. Russia's culture was heavily religion-oriented and also very pro-Tsarist and just overall traditional. The Bolsheviks threw that right out the window with murdering the Tsar and forcing atheism upon people. The devils.
>people were preserved
I don't even know what you mean by this.
>no degeneracy
Atheists have no morals, degeneracy is a product of immorality and nihilism. The USSR was in fact one of the most degenerate immoral shitholes in history.
>no crimes
False, and impossible. There has never existed a state with no crimes, ever.

No cause your "ethnostate" would be a puppet of jew politburo. "Communism" is impossible without the jews.

NONONONONONONONONONO

I'd prefer African Islam to Communism

Communism is just the left wing ideology counterpart to national socialism (nazism) and they are both simply the authoritarian version of the poles.
Also you can't establish an ethnostate without brute force so it would be the only way.

>Trusting (((pinko scum)))
Stop insulting our intelligence

>he fell for the capitalist/jewish propaganda
lmao

>communists are the scum of the earth and should be shot at sight
this. commies are just a group in society that wants to rob the fuck out of everyone else. Immediately after the revolutions there are new classes set up,based on how high you rank in the party

Brainlet. Ethno comunism? You mean national socialism? Ffs.. fucking state of Sup Forums

Screw communism and white nationalism.

Absolutely not. Communism goes against Western values

well an ethnostate would be nationalist and the gov would be socialist so a communist ethnostate would be nationalist socialist.

>Keynesian economics and Marxist economics are the same thing
At least educate yourself before you start talking your retarded lolberg shit.

Socialist Yugoslavia was ethno.

>including races
>dailysignal.com/2017/05/10/ugly-racism-karl-marx/
>For example, Marx didn’t think much of Mexicans. When the United States annexed California after the Mexican War, Marx sarcastically asked, “Is it a misfortune that magnificent California was seized from the lazy Mexicans who did not know what to do with it?”
>"It is now completely clear to me that he, as is proved by his cranial formation and his hair, descends from the Negroes who had joined Moses’ exodus from Egypt, assuming that his mother or grandmother on the paternal side had not interbred with a n—–. Now this union of Judaism and Germanism with a basic Negro substance must produce a peculiar product"
>"What is the worldly religion of the Jew? Huckstering. What is his worldly God? Money. … Money is the jealous god of Israel, in face of which no other god may exist. Money degrades all the gods of man—and turns them into commodities. … The bill of exchange is the real god of the Jew. His god is only an illusory bill of exchange. … The chimerical nationality of the Jew is the nationality of the merchant, of the man of money in general."

Communism is inter-nationalist.

Communism is Globalism in disguise, what the fuck are you smoking.

>communism is globalism
well then no surprises how cultural marxism came to be, just tinker with the narrative and leave the capitalist system alone to attack intuitions first.
Annnd I forgot to mention an axiom: All commies should be shot

Yes if by white you mean no Jews either

>>>/plebbit/

no

>Would you support communism if it promised establishing a white nigger-state?
NO.

What's the point in having an ethnostate that's gonna fail?

What's with the pic?
It looks like a boob.
Not a dick, wtf man?

>trusting a communist

no

no

>furry

>communism
>white ethno-state

kek

no.

>some limited amount of socialism within a nation state that also had economic freedoms and private property?
yes.

Only if Russia admits solutreans were first Nations and not Siberians.
Russia pushed the entire native American propaganda.

>le look at me le epikly trolling le XD XD XDDD!!!

that's a big bulge

Yes totally

what the hell is the pic related

Oh, I've experienced dealing with niggers. Hell, I have to deal with niggers daily now. Thing is, under a capitalist system, I'm able to live in a nice, gated, nigger free neighborhood. When I'm out shopping or doing stuff, yeah, sometimes I see niggers chimp out. But truthfully my economic position insulates me from most monkeyshines. We just don't run in the same circles.

Sure, Id rather there was a world without niggers, but for me personally if the cost of getting rid of them is also losing my comfy upper middle class lifestyle, then the cost isn't worth it.

Yes.
Only if the Union is segregating every SSR ethnically and doesn't migrate tons of russians, niggers, amerimutts and rest of bunch into that SSR in the name of internationalism.

Communism is international and seeks to destroy both national identity and its salience. Since the beginning Marx talked about an International Revolution. Lenin made this possible with Communist International

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proletarian_internationalism

degenerate jews are afraid of this

Only if they have a satisfactory solution to the economic calculation problem.

Absolutely. Honestly I'm getting tired of capitalism. The more I experience it, the more I realize it's just a fabrication that Jews use to extract power and money from the goyim. Think about it, how did the Jews get all their power, from swindling the goyim within the capitalist system. I'm surprised there aren't more Sup Forums flavored communists on this board.

Nice try jew.

Bc they imported food from the us. Also,the famine of 46.

I don't care about the economic system as long as it's prefixed with "national". I'll take national communism without all the marxist bullshit over liberalism and democracy any day.

that's called national-socialism. Maybe you've heard of it?

yes. capitalism is what led to the decline of the ethnostate
>muh (((economy)))

wow, someone with half a brain cell on /pol. i'm surprised

You called?

No because communism can't establish a successful state.

I feel that Bolsheviks can't be trusted though.

another one with half a brain. wtf, when did /pol get good again?

No because I'm not a moron. Why would they do such a thing? Answer: They wouldn't.

What made you think that?

So all the white people can starve together. Great plan.

.....moar bulge pls

No because then whites would starve to death anyway while niggers steal what little food we have and keep living.

>implying capitalism is successful

you do realize the economy is one massive bubble built on unsustainable debt right?

Capitalism is globalism.

nvm, this board still sucks

This is simply not true. All you need for an ethnostate to be established is a certain set of pro-natalist, anti-immigration laws oriented in favor of the original ethnicity of the nation. It requires no more "brute force" than establishing multiculturalism does.

Yet it has aided in establishing successful states without manufactured famines, blood purges, show trials or gulags. And I never said I think capitalism is the way things should be but good job falling for the false dichotomy.

If communists sought to destroy national identity there would have never been a Latvian SSR.