Battle Shounen Tier

>God Tier
HxH
BnHA
One Piece
Air Gear

>Top Tier
Nanatsu no Taizai
Medaka Box
Soul Eater
Toriko

>Mid Tier
Yu Yu Hakusho
Bleach
Naruto

>Low Tier
Fairy Tail
D.Gray-man
Saint Seiya

>Shit Tier
Akame Ga Kill
Katekyo Hitman Reborn
BDZ

Where is JJBA? Also, I'm curious why D.Gray-man is low on your list. I personally enjoyed it.

Move BnHA, OP, Toriko and FT one tier down, move YYH,one tier up. Original DB top tier.

>Battle shounen
>God tier
Oh, man, this'll be a good thread.

>Air fucking Gear
I'm dying here.

I'd say YYH belongs in top tier and FT in shit tier.

God tier
HnK
DB

Acceptable tier
HxH
JoJo
FMA

Shit tier
Everything else

This is already off to a fun start. None of the shit in god tier is actually good. HxH might be if youd scrap the ant arc, so 50% of the manga. One Piece is repetitive as hell by now. The original Naruto manga was actually good, should probably just split between time skip and that. And why in gods name is this list one, if not the best battle shonen manga of the last decade in form of Noragami?

>toriko in high-tier instead of shit-tier
>soul eater in high-tier instead of low-tier
>fairy tail not being in shit-tier
>air gear in god-tier
>bnHA in god-tier

Air Gear is battle shounen? How the fuck, do they fight people on rollerblades or something?
I thought it was more about racing.

>Where is JJBA?
JJBA isn't a battle shounen
>I'm curious why D.Gray-man is low on your list
They basically don't do anything until japan arc

There is someone who doesn't know about the disaster that was Air Gear? Are you new or something? It starts off as kids competing to see who could do the best roller-skate tricks. Then it suddenly turns out that half the characters are secretly superhuman experiments with magic powers who are waging outright war against each other (with US backing) to obtain the code needed to use the rollerskates for world domination.

It's fucking terrible.

>JoJo
>acceptable
It's Bleach for pseudo intellectuals and gays.

SE was mid at worst.

Noragami is meh-tier.

>JJBA isn't a battle shounen

Jojofags actually believe this.

>God Tier
One Piece

>Good Tier
HxH
JJBA
FMA
Rurouni Kenshin

>Decent Tier
Soul Eater
Dragon Ball

>Meh Tier
Dragon Ball Z
Bleach
Naruto
One Punch Man
Toriko
Hitman Reborn

>Shit Tier
Fairy Tail

That's a weird list. Why does Hero Academia deserve a spot amoung the top?

One Piece anywhere near that high is immediately disregarded as a troll post

That sounds great actually

Noragami is mediocre

What the fuck is JJBA then? It's one of the most iconic and influential battle shounen series out there. That's like claiming that Spider Man isn't a super hero comic.

>Low Tier
>Fairy Tail
>not underneath shit tier but fappable

It's really not. It turned a sports series into a convoluted battle shounen.

>I don't agree so he must be trolling

>BnHA
>Air Gear
>god tier
My fucking sides.

It's objective that One Piece isn't good anymore. It's been proven with clinical research. Only thing it's good for now is doujins and porn

>God tier
HxH

>Top tier
FMA
Jojo

>Mid tier
One Piece
Mob Psycho
Dragonball

>Low tier
Rurouni Kenshin
Yu Yu Hakusho
One Punch Man
Boku no Hero Academia

That isn't true, and even if it were, the user who made that list could still rank it in God Tier because of how great the earlier arcs were. He doesn't just have to base his ratings off how the series is currently.

One piece has been subpar since the timeskip. Robins "I want to live" scene was the peak.

>>God Tier
>BnHA
>AIR FUCKING GEAR

My sides

The MC is the only one who fights in parts 1 and 2
The parts 7 and 8 are seinen

Stop putting the Z in Dragon Ball, fags. The manga is all DB.

JoJo was a battle shonen for 6 1/2 parts, are you retarded?

You can tell this post was made by a redditor

When did you stop reading? You'd be right if you stopped in Dressrosa but Zou and Whole Cake Island are the best arcs since MarineFord

Only reason One Piece is barely above passable now is because Oda absolutely will not make any changes whatsoever. Do't fix what ain't broke I suppose, but it long since has plateaued and stagnated for years now. Only the most hardcore and delusional will say otherwise.

Redditors actually like DBZ

>Mob Psycho and OPM
>battle shonen

This whole thread is filled with retards

I don't get why BnHA is so beloved. I've been reading the series since the first chapter, and it's pretty good, but it's not anything special. Yet all the threads are people going crazy for it and talking about how amazing it is. It's a 7/10 series that everyone seems to be treating as a 9, and I can't understand why.

Am I just old?

>The MC is the only one who fights in parts 1 and 2
I'm not even sure that's right, it's been many years since I read it, but I remember Caeser fighting in Part 2. But regardless, how does that disqualify it from being a battle shounen??? It's still a series that focuses on battles and is aimed at a shounen demographic. And there are multiple people who fight in Parts 3-6 anyway.
>The parts 7 and 8 are seinen
Yes, but Parts 1-6 are shounen. They don't retroactively stop being shounen becuase the series switched demographics years later.

Swap Nanatsu and Academia places.

Yes you're probably just getting older and outgrowing shounen + there's no other good battle shounen running except for OP(depending on who you ask) and HxH and the latter fucks off whenever it wants to.

If they put the Z in it, then obviously they watched the anime.

>Not even your grandchildren will see the end Tier
HxH, OP

>Saved only by one intresting character Tier
Medaka Box

>Will inevitably turn to shit but let's be hopeful Tier
BnHA, NnT

>Started good, ended shit Tier
DB, Naruto, Bleach, Soul Eater

>Was never good, but fapped anyway Tier
FT, AGK

>Not even fapworthy Tier
KHR, D. Gayman, JoJo, SnK, Toriko, Saint Seiya

The show just made the fights and emotional scenes way better which blew some people's minds.

>he doesn't like Oh Great insanity
embarrassing

>>God Tier
>Air Gear
I don't even have words for how retarded Air Gear was.

>how does that disqualify it from being a battle shounen?
Because if not for that reason each shounen could be qualified as battle shounen

Unironically this. I like JOJO myself, but don't get all the hype.

You realize that there's a fuckton of shonen series that have nothing to do with fights whatsoever, right?

>every shounen has the MC fighting people
Not him, but you're completely and hopelessly retarded.

>Because if not for that reason each shounen could be qualified as battle shounen
Death Note? Every sports manga?

I wasn't being literal

...

>one piece
>bnha
>air gear
>GOD TIER

I think it's very underwhelming. The modern-day-like setting and focus on the characters being school children really holds back its creativity, and Horikoshi doesn't even really explore that setting and these characters to their maximum potential anyway. We still have barely any info on how the whole super hero system and business works, all we know is that "Heros stop villains, also money is involved and some off screen heros might be corrupt but you don't get to see any evidence of that." The most ineteresting characters so far have been Todoroki and Shigaraki because of how their pasts are results of the way the world is, but all we've been given is vague explanations of what those pasts were like without proper bacsktories or explorations of them as characters.

I think the series really leans on people rooting for Deku as an underdog and how spectacular (in the literal sense) the artwork is, and that if there were more long running, adapted series still going at the moment, it wouldn't be 2nd in popularity.

I think it's dumb and unfair to use the inferior anime or just the "Z" parts of Dragonball when ranking it quality wise but okay.

Air Gear is probably on my top 5 shonen manga because I loved Oh Great drawings and Kogarasumaru. and even I know its not god tier.

>Medaka Box and Soul Eater on Top Tier
>Naruto below Toriko or even on the same tier as Bleach
>D.Gray-man and Saint Seiya that low
>FMA,Magi,World Trigger, Kinnikuman,HnK,Shaman King,Kenshin, Black
Cat and many others not even on the list
>putting a Z in Dragon Ball.
overall, shit list.

MHA is shit. Bait thread reported.

Waifus pretty much carry the manga. The frog is what gave it such a huge boost on Sup Forums in the first place. It's incredibly mediocre. If I had to chose a "new" Shonen manga it would be Nanatsu no Taizai. Even that manna is nothing special but it's far more than BNHA

>If I had to chose a "new" Shonen manga it would be Nanatsu no Taizai
>new
>300 chapters

It started in 2012. Most of the stuff on the list is at least a decade old.

I stopped during Dressrosa and just recently caught up.

Whole Cake island is only good because of the Big Mom stuff. Half of the arc (the Sanji stuff) is complete garbage. The straw hats should've been way past the shit that Sanji pulled and it was completely forced drama. We already knew the "I WADDA COOK" stuff was coming.

Dressrosa, Fishman Island and a majority of Whole Cake Island is irredeemably bad.

Where would you put Negima?

This. What the fuck?

NnT already had it's "lackluster arc" and it wasn't even that bad, just underwhelming fights. We've seen the worse Nakaba can do and it's nowhere near Kubo, Kishi, Hiro tier.

Punk Hazard is shit too

Dragon Ball, One Piece, Jojo, Yu Yu, HxH, and Beelzebub are the only good ones

It had a short drop in quality right after the timeskip.
It's been back to it's old glory since the Dressrosa arc though.

Surprisingly, I actually liked Punk Hazard. I'm a smokerfag and Vergo wasn't too bad of a character.

Why do you guys think Dragon Ball is good?

I bet you liked the Yeti Cool Brothers too fag.

Fantastic fight choreography, simple but fun plot with simple but fun characters.

Exchange Naruto and Bleach with D.G-m and Saint Seiya, and move DB to Mid Tier.

NnT was a lot better before they introduced flat out number power levels to gauge people's strength

I don't.

Good. I miss DB days when there were detectors.

It changed nothing and they are barely brought up anyway.

Not to mention, NnT's power level system is pretty neat. It measures physical strength along with magic and will power. It's more like a JRPG stat system and fits well considering Nakaba is inspired by them.

What's wrong with following the concepts upon which it was built?
Exploration, sailing, helping random folks. Sometimes long battle parts, other times it's just the crew exploring some island or relaxing on the ship.
Better than throwing things around after a few chapters and making it another battle series that takes itself too seriously, like Reborn or Bleach.

>One Piece pre time skip
Wow, this island is incredible, how can this be real?
>One Piece post time skip
Pirate alliance

im alright with this desu
dunno why soul eater always gets mid tier when its trash though

wait put ares in top tier and we ok

there is nothing redeeming in NnT, and i have no idea why anyone watches it other than the waifus

>watches

this guy gets it

>ctrl+f "Gash"
>0 results
OP is retarded, but everyone else in this thread is also dumb for not pointing out his second biggest mistake

After placing Air Gear in God Tier, of course

>not reading NNT to praise the sun

>wanpiss
>god tier

reddit out in full force

where tokyo ghoul at

Escanor is basically a double cuck. Arthur is the 'son of his waifu' and the guy his waifu chooses instead of him at the same time.

Nowhere. Sorry, but we couldn't come up with a catchy name for a tier below shit.

biggest shounen in the history of shounens, i thought manchildren would know this

is the manga that much better because i dropped the show thrice

Sasuga Diana

100 chapters were crammed into 24 episodes with pretty vital parts cut out that would flesh out characters and better foreshadow future plot points. Plus shitty animation. Manga is more cohesive and has much better art.
But if you dropped it because of the plot or characters, you won't like it in the manga either.

>I only watched the first season from the anime
Noragami has some of the most meaningful, fluid battles in shonen manga

Lower BnHA a tier. Lower Toriko two tiers. Lower Fairy Tail a tier. Increase Reborn two tiers. Remove all of this not battle shounen shit. Add JoJo. Then the list would look okay.

>Air Gear
>God tier

Good taste my friend.
Nanatsu no Taizai is shit though

Bleach is really good if you enjoy direct battles and bullshit shounen powercreep techniques. I reread the last 100 ch of bleach before the final chapter was released and by god that was some good shounen.

>One Punch Man
>Battle Shounen
Are you retarded

> the last 100 ch of bleach
> by god that was some good shounen
Jesus Christ.

>HnK
>God-tier

I don't think its terrible but please elaborate

One Punch Man is Seinen
Also your list is shit