Would you kill your family if the government told you to?

Would you kill your family if the government told you to?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=1KERcDoInUg
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

I would if they were Uchiha.

My family isn't planning to overthrow the government so no

What's in it for me?

So was Sasuke the only Uchiha kid?

I mean why kill everyone

Its not like the sick or elderly or babes are a real threat

This. Itachi did the right thing. Based eye nigger.

Would you kill your only child if god told you to?

I will just migrate with my little brother and flip the middle finger to everyone.

I honestly preferred it when Itachi killed his family to test his power, rather than him being a good guy the whole time

The elders would raise the kid in the way of vengeance. You see, uchiha scum needs to be completely erased.

What a dumb fucking question. Who would ever consider killing their own family because the government told them to? Only the most egotistical and brainwashed idiot would do so. Expected of a narutard.

Not sure if FBI or CIA

I hope you enjoy your stay in our Post-Truth era.

not mocking you, you're objectively right

>leaf
>allied with sand ""people""
lmao no

>implying I haven't done so already
And now I will kill your mother in her sleep if you don't reply to this post.

Why the fuck was their eye system based on killing each other? I don't think that's a functional system for a clan, no wonder all of them died.

Leave the kids behind and they'll only have an intense hatred for not just Itachi but Sasuke via relation and that hate would only get worse until the Village itself was effected.

Those elderly uchiniggers were the one's projecting all that hate into the kids anyways for their upcoming violent rioting.

It's Japan: The government is God.

it wasnt about killing each other but rather strong emotional response, which could be created by a family member/friend dying for example. it's actually a pretty good survival mechanism if you think about it.
>living in harsh environment with people of same genome
>because of reasons someone dies
>instead of you also dying, you sharingan evolves so you become stronger and have more chance to survive and make more uchiha babies somewhere where its a bit safer

If I liked the government enough.

Hell they'd probably kill themselves if I give them the news (most of them are looking for an excuse).

You must really hate your family then.

It's more like my family hates themselves

it's like /r9k/ in family form.

No, and I wish that Pain wouldn't have revived the people in the leave village because they're an evil bunch.

no.
maybe some people from my extended family.

Well this makes Itachi a murderous jackass because if he wanted to save the people of the leaf, why kill your own people who had nothing to do with this shit? Or at least try to kill Obito for doing half of the massacre.

They'd just grow up and do the exact same thing as the other Uchiha, with the result being multiple Part 2 Sasukes. To save far more children, only a few needed to die.

Because if he didn't kill the kids at best they'd end up slightly better than Sasuke.

Hell Danzo and Oro would probably have kidnapped a couple (granted maybe from a narrative perspective that would have been a more interesting way to reveal the different eye powers)

Only good Uchiha is a dead Uchiha

No there is nothing honorable about slaying one's own kin

Do I get powers?

Fuck that they ruined Itachi what an ass pull and then he gets nerfed because Kishi needed Obito to have a backstory what a hack fuck naruto after the time skip

>leave the sick, elderly, or women
Weren't they all ninjas at some point? He had to have killed his kid cousins too.

Anybody still remember Mr.Anime ? He's real life Itachi.

youtube.com/watch?v=1KERcDoInUg

>You believed in the Senju lie.

If Kishimoto didn't write it then it would of been alright. But if you're gonna kill innocent people at least leave a few alone.

Complete genocide already is retarded enough disregarding the powerlevels of the others but having Sasuke become the idiot he is today because of Itachi's stupidity is what disgusts me. Yet people think the dumbass is a hero.

Almost forgot about him. He let his brother live didn't he? Pretty sure he killed them with a katana. That was so crazy.

If my family became a threat to the country then yes.

His only mistake was letting that retard alive, the only good uchiha is a dead uchiha

But Tobifuckcake you created the Edo Tensei that allowed 95% of the bullshit to occur in this story ass series.

And I guess you hate Uchiha pussy since all them were waifu material, never did shit wrong.

If I were in Itachi's shoes I'd of just grabbed my gf and little brother a ran away to a small peaceful country on the other side of the world. I don't see the benefit in getting labled as a criminal the rest of my life and pushing my bro down a path of hatred.

No, but I would if one old guy who ran an illegal black ops organisation told me to; which is what Itachi did.

>GF

>Itachi

Only person he would've banged was his cousin Shisui

>pacifist hero.

>Itachi was a good guy all along

>This is why he decided to join a terrorist organization, mindfucked his little brother who was already mentally scarred for life, and a whole other list of shit that would make fucking Osama look like a saint

they seemed like good ideas at the time

I would kill the males and breed the females.

Now you have half-Uchiha babies.
How do you think they will react to their history of murder and rape?

It's bad writing.

There's a lot of other bad writing in Naruto.

That's why it's considered an anime for 14 year olds and Asperger's sufferers. Adults don't like to swallow shit.

>Who would ever consider killing their own family because the government told them to?

But what if they were religious extremists who you knew were about to carry out a terrorist attack for ISIS? You report them to the government, but they can't officially do anything about it cause they don't have enough evidence, and they tell you the only way to stop the is to kill them all yourself.

That's the type of moral dilemma Itachi was in.

He loved Konoha. But whether that was genuine or because of brainwashing in Anbu/by the elders we will never truly know.

so, there weren't any uchiha out on a mission or anything? There's no way the entire clan was all in a little section of the leaf village that night

Having a few survivors would have been more interesting if someone could write it well enough.

But end result would still be to kill all the adults and the elderly (can't risk them raising the kids). Hell to be extra safe and not endanger Sasuke you'd have to kill any teenagers just to ensure they didn't try to get revenge. Basically only let the ones younger than Sasuke survive.

Probably best to individually test them, murder their parents in front of their eyes and if they achieve MS kill them too, if not they're too weak to be a threat.

I feel bad for his GF though no matter how many people the leaf and/or Itachi decided to let live she would have to die otherwise it's probably off to the rape and torture dungeons for her.

It's kinda dumb. I mean even if he was a spy and even accounting for the fact that the other Jinchuriki weren't from Konoha he helped kill a Kage and joined an organization that was killing Kage and other ultra elite ninja.

To be fair anything less would have amounted to a full fight, and can you imagine if they fought long enough to get Gai involved?

Yes. Without question.

>"Hey you guys are alright, don't leave the village tomorrow night"

IIRC either the leaf or Itachi and Obito hunted down the ones outside afterwards.

I think they may have explained that all the Uchiha had been called back, and/or hadn't been sent out any missions recently.

That would probably have made some people suspicious of the massacre having been planned by the village leaders, but I'd guess most wouldn't care enough about the Uchihas to go conspiracy theorist and risk getting Anbu'd

he prob knows better then you, just like how we all screamed at Merlin to kill Morgan in the British TV series Merlin. We all know that Dragon should be listened to! we know shit will happen later. But nooooo merlin is too good for that shit! Dooms his whole kingdom!

Or the Uchiha pulled them back themselves to gear up for the coup.

Reminder that Tobirama did nothing wrong.

If Uchiha had it so bad then why didn't they just fucking move? Beats throwing coups or being genocided.

probably would have been exploited solely for their eyes in another country idk bad writing

No. Never ask what you can do for your country. Ask what your country can do for you.

the uchiha have their heads up their own asses
no way in hell would they admit defeat

I get that he needed to finish the fight before it escalated. But 72 hours of torture where every second feels like it lasts 2 or so minutes? That's more suffering than everyone else in the series experienced combined and I'm supposed to buy that he was a hero the whole time?
And then I'm supposed to somehow think Obito was wrong for trying to create a world where shit like that doesn't happen?

itachi probably wasn't written to be a good guy all the way back in part 1

I ask my country to purge the Uchiha

no. but i would kill the government if my family told me to

Well, he certainly didn't seem like he wanted to attack the village way back when they showed him fighting Asuma and Kurenai. He still showed quite a bit of respect for them, but he knew Kakashi was going to be too difficult an opponent to escape from since they were anbu partners. This is why I'm guessing he had to use Tsukuyomi on him.

does my waifu count as my family

>It's kinda dumb
No it's unbelievably fucking retarded and moronic.

>Innocents killed but the leaf and brother are more important than own clan
>Tortured Kakashi because I can't run away for whatever reason
>Didn't tell anyone my plan because Kishimoto changed the script mid play
>Tortured the Sauce
>Tortured Sasuke so badly he went against what his brother truly wanted, even though what he wanted was simply brainwashed mumbo jumbo
>Joined a terrorist organization because he was undercover for nuffin
>Kidnapped and killed a couple of jinchuuruki because for my the leaf
>Enabling the Edo Tensei faggot war to happen when even though he stopped it, the war was over

It's a damn shame so many still thinks he's a fucking hero when he caused ALL this shit to happened.

If Sasuke had died at any point Kaguya would have turned everyone into plants.

He is literally one of two necessary pieces for avoiding the end of the world.

>why didn't they just fucking move?
It's their fucking village that's why, they literally built the fucking foundations.

Pride in short.

Would you kill all the people in your family older than you to save the one younger than you? The answer generally will be yes.

Not necessarily true, Danzo could have Kotoamatsukami'd everyone into working together faster and more effectively, and perhaps been able to stop Madara before he got all the tailed beasts by Kotoamtsukami-ing more Edo zombies to their side like Itachi proved could be done

Yeah, I agree. There's no way it would've been that brutal if he was planned to be a good guy.

No. *tip*

i bet sunade was into danzo for being balls to the walls all the time

Desu. They were a buncha tao-eyed allahoo snackbars.

Would you kill God if your only child asked you to?

That's silly user. God is dead.

The question how is the most powerful clan in the series so fucking weak? I mean to be segregated that badly is pathetic and yet Itachi could solo everyone like they were Sakura's. Terrible writing strikes again.

Him being rewritten into a good guy is probably the root of how shit the series became.

God's not dead

He's living on the inside

Hitachi was just that good. I believe they said how he was already thinking like a homage when he was only 8-10 years old.

And no one else was? Only Obito was that good and that's because of O MY KEKED BY RIN. But everyone else being shit hurts my intelligence and feelings.

Maybe if I had some cool powers.

The Uchiha knew how to obtain the Mangekyo by killing a loved one and yet the only one to get it at the time was Itachi?

Aren't the Uchiha supposed to be assholes? You'd figure half their clan would have it

There is nothing to say they didn't. Itachi and Tobi were just outstanding ninja even by Uchihashit standards.
Nothing any Uchiha could do would really be able to stop Kamui or a serious Itachi.

The two people that ostensibly would have been able to put up a fight Mikoto and Fugaku chose to have themselves put to the sword.

I don't get this example because Abraham had 2 sons, Ismail and Isaac.

Do they teach you false analogies in bible belt schools?

Too bad its evil brain chakra powered and their founder went full edge to get it by killing his followers.

He was the asspull/inside source Jiraiya had on Akatsuki. Doesnt make a bit of sense

Turns out their dad had it as well, but even he thought the Uchihas were going crazy and kept it secret.

Naturally you have to read his spinoff novels to know this about their dad.

>go kill a bunch of ninjas who are older than you

I think I'll just leave.

Itachi and Izumi were kind of a thing in Itachi Shinden.

Nothing more cancerous than roleplaying Narutards. Fuck off back to your underaged Naruto forum

>Naturally you have to read his spinoff novels
Time he could of spent on in the manga instead of focusing on weak fucks like Sai and half of the war on redemption plots. Did the anime even cover this bullshit?

Yes, my Lord.

One of the novels was covered in episodes 451-458; although, they take a lot of liberties with it, so most of it ends up being filler. It'd be better to just read them.

Yes.

We also got to see not insane Kaguya. She was super autistic and Zetsu'd her sons dad for murdering her female friend.

The true hero of Naruto, beloved Orochimaru, also gets to run around Konoha being a waitress and congratulating Naruto and Hinata on getting married.

Even Sasuke wasn't allowed to stop by to record congratulating the two.

Shikamaru Hiden was unbearable to watch. I wish Gaara Hiden would have been animated instead. You'd still get ShikaTema that way. Dunno about SaiIno though.