Yuki-chan

>take best girl
>make her worst girl
Why is this acceptable, Sup Forums?

Every Yuki everywhere is acceptable

Because to be the main girl you have to be the worst girl.

Haruhi became better when she was a side character

>Take literal Rei Ayanami clone
>Make her a likeable human being.
>REEEE muh character is different and not emotionless.

People like you need to die.

It's not and it wasn't. Fuck this show and manga. Although the biggest problem wasn't Yuki, it was Kyon.

But user, some main girls are best girl.

Maybe acceptable, but out of Yuki-chan's cast, she was nowhere near bestgirl.
I 100% can agree with this. Asakura takes the cake though.
But Disapparance movie Nagato was great and had real emotions and was a likeable human being. TAKI Nagato was a nuisance.

Pic unrelated.

I don't know. Recently finished it too, it has no right to exist.

I legit think this was a ploy by Kadokawa to scuttle the franchise.

>implying main girl must be worst girl

...

real best girl is here

This show was cute and fun. Canon Yuki is a shitty retard Reiclone. Yuki-chan is cute and likable.

...

...

It had fun moments, but it's just a mediocre slice of life borrowing too much from the main series to not make you kill yourself. Throwing out literal same lines here and there with plenty of references to the main series makes it even more soulless. Yuki and Kyon changed way too much. A meeker Yuki like from Disappearance might have been better despite it being explained how current Yuki wasn't this much of a blob at first. Kyon on the other hand doesn't work at all in this setting and borrows too much from the status quo MC making him into a subpar character.

user, last time I read a manga where main girl was best girl, it was a truckwreck. Being main girl and best girl at the same time is dangerous

Is the manga any good?

They should've adapted that Digital Lover doujin series instead.

At least that was kind of in character.

No.

It had the best iteration of Haruhi. That's the one thing that saved it from being a complete disaster.

Main Haruhi is best Haruhi. This Haruhi is mighty fine too.

Then have best girl be the protag.

Asakura and Haruhi are OTP in this.

Anatolia

Haruhi was worst girl

>likes Kyon
>doesn't hinder Kyon's relationship with Yuki
>worst girl
Mikuru was by far the worst girl.

Right!? The manga's pretty good too. I really thought they nailed the ending.

>rei
>emotionless
kill yourself extrovert

Rei is a curious case where she actually has emotions, just nonexistent social skills & ability to express them. NGE also did a bit of exploration on how uncomfortable & unhealthy such a mental state is.

Type Moon proves the point with Fate. Saber is worst in her own route ,Sakura is worst in her own route.

But user, Fate Saber has undercovers handholding and cuddling

Well Arcueid does get cut to bits by Shiki.

Nasufags why.

Waifuwars.

This. スモークチーズ is best girl.

But user, she's the most impregnable

Kyon kun denwa

>take worst girl
>make her best girl
Why is this acceptable, Sup Forums?

these three made the show

It drags on a bit and the art goes through some pretty radical changes, but there are some really cute Yuki moments and the side characters are all fun.

But Shirou is best in his route.

Why is she so obsessed with Turkey?

Hey guess what?

This iteration of Yuki is the best iteration. Why? Because the character was allowed to grow and take initiative. Additionally the rest of the supporting cast were granted enough screentime to almost fool the audience into thinking they were actual characters with their own motivation. In the original animu the supporting characters were permitted only enough screentime to serve a direct purpose to the plot, nothing more. Ask yourselves this; if Haruhi season 3 is really a thing do you think any personal growth of any characters would be permitted aside from possibly haruhi or kyon? Disappearance of Yuki is obviously fan-service in its origins and in most of its execution, but a more fallible and relate-able cast of characters were created from the original molds.