Is this a vast improvement?

Is this a vast improvement?

It would be an interesting story to see happen
Doubt we ever will though

Can't tell the difference

make rin a delinquent with a ponytail and a harem of hypnotised lesbians
and sakura should be the school princess, complete with everyone calling her 'tohsaka-hime'

in such a scenario there wouldn't be a sakura route since she isn't a terrible person and would have rescued her sister the moment she was able to and would also feel guilty enough to let her have shirou no matter how thirsty she got

Except Rin never knew what was happening to Sakura. Why would it be different the other way around?

because sakura being a good person would take the minutes out of her day it would take to stay in touch with her sister

My dick gives it the seal of approval

...

Because Sakurafags don't care about the story other than serve their whiteknight tendencies.

way to confirm that you know nothing of nasuverse

I'm kind of wondering how Sakura would've reacted to the events of Fate/Zero if she was the one who stayed with her family.

Kotomine Kirei would've been giving Sakura the dick the entire time she served as the resident Magus of the region.

Rin would've become the purple devil who twists many men to her whims using her lewd body.

>Sakura grows up normally
>Rin gets wormed but at least doesn't get raped by Shinji
>UBW doesn't happen since Sakura wouldn't ally herself with Shirou because of muh family rules
>HF doesn't happen because Rin doesn't hold a grudge towards the whole world and tries to save herself instead

>change a character's entire lifestyle and history
>their route doesn't happen now

No shit.

Why would Rin not get raped by Shinji?

I dunno, Sakura only didn't interact with Rin because she knew how hosed she was and felt alienated because of being used as an experiment.

Her personality as Tohsaka Sakura is a whole different thing. She was attached to Rin at the hip, so I don't think she would be as "obedient" to Tokiomi as Rin's was. You can call it Sakura being undisciplined if you want, but she would probably still try to talk with Rin. It would be Rin that would likely try to push her away, either for protecting her, because of the same shame regular Sakura felt, or both.

But I'd say with this setup they would likely talk more as sisters than as "the Tohsaka's head magus and the Matou head magus", since empathy is Sakura's main charm point, which Nasu highlights.

dont you dare touching rin ever again

Nasu does say in Complete Material 2 that if Sakura treated Shinji like dirt, her life would be better. Rin in this situation might not sympathize with Shinji, so he might be brought to heel and get straightened out that way.

Basically, Shinji was/is a brat, Sakura was too soft, and he took advantage of her feeling bad about "taking his place", leading to canon FSN events(which makes drill sergeant McNasty Sakura in Hollow when the two bums bleed all the kindness she has out, and she can't stand Zouken and Shinji's shit anymore even funnier).

With Rin, Shinji's brattiness will probably cross a line and she'll treat him like trash, which will probably both delight Zouken and make him cross. Sadly, it's the only thing that straightens the boy out is harsh treatment it seems.

But since she probably wouldn't endure the experiments as well as Sakura, it would be quite different. Likely a very pissed Rin all the time and a cowering Shinji.

Sakura still looks like shit, so no it isnt.

Why Rider and what the fuck is Miyako doing there?

People theorized long ago that Sakura's "assets" we're a result of the experiments, instead of the fact she has a quarter Finnish blood. So in this comparisons, sometimes people draw the supposed "Matou Rin" with huge knockers.

Ironically enough, Rin will get huge knockers later in life.

No, THIS is a vast improvement.

Matou Rin would break long long ago

If Rin had been started as a kid she'd have sucked it up too. Kids are much more adaptable than grown ups.

No word of god is she would have found a way to kill Zouken she would have broke.