Why does every character in this manga acts as if helping someone selflessly is the mark of a true hero while being a...

Why does every character in this manga acts as if helping someone selflessly is the mark of a true hero while being a hero is a paid and reglemented job?

morals

>Why does every character in this manga acts as if helping someone selflessly is the mark of a true hero
That's because it is.

Yeah, but it's weird how "hero" is just another job now.

But I guess that was Stain's reasoning.

Its a kid's manga, dude.

meh Iida should have been the mc

>Why does every person in the world acts as if helping someone selflessly is the mark of a true hero while being a firefighter is a paid and reglemented job?

So?

>it's weird how "hero" is just another job now.
That's just the job description.
In their world, hero is both the idealistic concept that we have, and a profession.

>while being a hero is a paid and reglemented job?
Because the society is hypocritical aka the entire fucking Stain arc

That's the point of the whole mango. Did you read the Stain arc?

It's just a matter of morals. It's not like you can dismiss the paid heroes who are in it for fame and money, so long as they're doing a good job at it. But if you spot someone who has the morals to go through with risky stuff, all for the sake of wanting to help someone, then you know he's a "true hero" in the sense that he does so despite not needing to be paid.

It's not like he'll get to live only with that, so he will get paid too, but if you need someone trustworthy then that's the person. The problem is that Stein's mentality was too tunnel visioned and he couldn't see beyond that, and wanted everyone to follow the exact same example.

It bothers me that the author introduced Stain and basically made nothing with him once the arc was done. Like Deku still want to support the system and becomes the #1 hero.

And yet for some reason Bakugo almost never gets called out for not having any heroic inclinations whatsoever. Dude has never tried to help anyone his entire life, yet All-Might is his idol?
His teachers are doing a shitty job at instilling heroic values in him basically, and almost never punish him for his more unheroic and selfish acts.

being a hero is actually a state of mind

Only Huntards like Stain.

>Huntards like the best villain yet
Why am I not surprised?

>best villain
Literally a retarded mongoloid.

t. fake "hero"

You're thinking of the kid with the hands on his face, Stain is the guy who could paralyze people.

He told Deku to not try and save him from the VA so no one else would get snatched. He also didn't waste any time 'rescuing' people not actually in trouble during the preliminary license exam, in order to rescue those who actually needed it. They flunked him, of course, because they're petty like that, but he's got more awareness of helping people than you give him credit for.

Because those are the virtues the author has.

>He also didn't waste any time 'rescuing' people not actually in trouble during the preliminary license exam, in order to rescue those who actually needed it. They flunked him, of course, because they're petty like that,
The exam was a simulation for the real thing. There's no way it would be good to act like an ass towards civilians; stressing them out is bad.

True heroism is dead in the setting, it's all bureaucrats and lawfag mutants.

may be it's exploring already existing professions like being a soldier or a policeman
both risk their lives in some cases and are getting paid for it
most of us do not view them as heroes, but there are some who does
it is a good dilemma to base your manga's main premise on

they should be called "helpers" or something else instead of heroes. Stain did nothing wrong.

Jobs and licensure can have ethics clauses that maintain the integrity of the practice. Get a real job user.

user stop apply western understanding of "Hero" to mongolian cartoons and comics. Asians have different mentality in many aspects compared to us.

Just think about it the same as you would a doctor. Some people are in it for the money and feeling of superiority while others genuinely want to help people and even give services pro bono.

Because Stain was full of shit.

that's the point.
that's the question.

stay tuned and find out what the author thinks

>But I guess that was Stain's reasoning.
obviously.

Because it's a manga about fake heroes.

Why are they fake?

Because none of them act like heroes, it's like they are playing a game.

Because in this setting hero is government subsidied job. If you want "your" heroes then read western capeshit.

Or read a manga about real heroes.

Stain was gay

Like?

...

Suit yourself, this manga is unknown and untranslated.

>Eightman is unknown
>he needs manga to be translated

"Reasoning." Think you mean his psychotic obsession.

Great user, you can speak eleven, that so convenient.

I hate how they preach about being a hero coming down to morals and respectability and spirit but then brainwash the kids into trying to turn their name into a brand product.

>Why does every character
you mean the all 3 of them?

stain did nothing wrong

Stain's wrong thing was literally fucking killing or crippling people. I mean that's just retarded.

Fake heroes aren't people.

>job for one
>retarded video game references autist
>O, Verhaul
stain is the best

every area he did that in crime decreased. Obviously he had a point.

Why didn't you post this in the actual general?

It's to trick Japanese kids to aspire to enter their workforce and not become NEET losers.

>Japanese kids to aspire to enter their workforce and not become NEET losers.
Deku is a bad role model because he was a skinny manlet who dreamed big but didn't do actually do anything to work towards his goal except jack off to his heroes. Power just fell into his lap.

Because everyone who isnt Deku is a normal human meaning they arent mindlessly altruistic and help you for their selfish reasons.

because the conflict of ideal and reality is the theme of the series (that and legacy)

>mom I posted it again!

>what is character development

Because its true. In the BnHAverse, being a hero is a job. In a world where Quirks are the norm and heroism is a profession, its kind of an easy conclusion to make, you know?

In a few more gens heroes in BnHA will be bigger corporate whores than heroes from Tiger and Bunny

And surprise surprise, the quirkless charactet idolizes the job and sees it as we see heroes

> is just another job now.
except it's not
the vast majority of quirks aren't suited for combat, and the ones that are aren't guaranteed to give you a significant advantage.
the hero academy isn't just another academy or high school, it's a specialist institution for the people who want to become registered heroes.
everyone else gets day-jobs and normal careers like in real life

Regular people see heroes as we would too, they’re just not as big of fanboys as the biggest.

It's a high prestige job, which will lead to many people entering the field for the money and status, just like in real life.

>implying Stain wont break out of prison

>Ignored the 10 months of hell and intense training he did before All Might would even allow him to have the power.


Alright user.

I hated how even after all that he still scored so poorly on the physical tests soon after the entrance exam.

It was shortsighted on Hori's part considering a good chunk of the class had quirks that didn't really help them that much in the tests.

10 months of training is nothing.

It makes sense though. All Might stated that even with all that training, Deku wasn’t nowhere near fully prepped to use OFA. He was barely good enough to obtain the quirk.

>nowhere
Anywhere

It's the root of Stain's autism.
At the end of the day, the only thing that matters is results. Do you think most paramedics and doctors truly love their jobs? That they wake up in the morning and go "oh golly gee I hope I see someone painted across a road or have to go into some forgotten hoarders home where they've decayed and rotted in their own filth and need to be taken to a hospital".
Shit is rough. It's depressing. And it has to be done, society demands it. And because society demands it, we pay people to do the job. Years of training, school, etc. whatever necessary. Ideally, we want them to have the right morality and be motivated 100% by helping others. But if that isn't the case, who the fuck cares so long as the work is good?

The biggest joke about Stain is ultimately what breaks the spirit of these optimists, people who want to protect and help everyone regardless of the paycheck - is faggots just like Stain. They look and see this cunt running around killing innocent people, people with families, people with loved ones, people who spent years of their lives training to do their job. People exactly like themselves. And now that person is dead over a meme ideology for underage idiots. They eventually stop wanting to send criminals to jail or some fucking mental asylum and start wanting to send them to the chamber.

>That they wake up in the morning and go "oh golly gee I hope I see someone painted across a road or have to go into some forgotten hoarders home where they've decayed and rotted in their own filth and need to be taken to a hospital".
Actually lots of psychopathic surgeons literally hope that people get badly injured so they can make a quick buck.

>retards actually think stain had a point

if he didnt have a point his method wouldn't have worked.

Obviously killing is not the way to go about accomplishing it and it makes your cause harder to achieve but his actions accomplished what he set out to do one way or another.

That means there is definitely an inherent flaw in the way the hero system operates now

what he did was cause a massive spike in crime thus causing a reaction

The reason why Stain was liked was because he was the first person that acted as if he had something going on.

He wasn't a fucking VA faggot and he HINTED at something that seemed like common sense and would have been really cool.

ALL OF THE HEROES ARENT HEROES AND HAVE THE WOOOL PULLED OVER EVERYONES EYES BLARGRAGAAAGAAA

That would have been good. That some of the heroes were in fact just evil and were toeing the line for money fame power and convenience. And because allmight and men and women and...others would come down on them like the angry fist of god if the stepped out of line.

But no. He's just a lone nut and the author used it as a way to build up that boring handsey faggot and used it as a way to bring in a collection of boring edgey twats and then procceded to WASTE them in a terrible unhype battle.

The fuck dude...

>boring handsey faggot and used it as a way to bring in a collection of boring edgey twats and then procceded to WASTE them in a terrible unhype battle
ye, no
Shiggy has a way better goal even though we don't have a reason for it yet, only hints - to expose how fragile society actually is, how people pretend nothing can hurt them yet a man who can just tap whiles you are walking on the side walk and you die. Everything about Stain is retarded, from autistic screeching over semantics, to aligning himself with shiggy el communist style just dismantle with no agreed upon end game. In fact the only reason he was so dangerous was because of his OP quirk, which just gets countered easy. Whats worse is this piece of shit will be praised as one of the best motivated heroes in the series despite (not even memeing) Moonfish having better motives just by following his psycho mentality and his cannibalistic tendencies.

Leave Shigaraki alone! ;_;

I want to believe that he's on his way to becoming a better villain than Stain.

>the real thing
Triage always trumps kindness in real settings.

...

Getting healed by recovery girl uses your stamina

>being a hero is a paid and reglemented job?
>Yeah, but it's weird how "hero" is just another job now.

I wouldn't be a firefighter or paramedic for free. Even volunteer firefighters get paid.

Why? Because dying on the job is a very real possibility.

>his method wouldn't have worked

His method worked becaus he has an ezmode quirk. It's easy to beat people when you can paralyze them.

I am not talking about the fighting aspect.

I meant his culling of specific heroes. It lead to a decrease in crime in every city he did it in.

Even Stain wasn't completely consistent. He didn't have a hateboner for All Might despite the hero having the same basic principles as all the rest.

That's ignoring what the Vigilantes story says about his character, too.

He also murdered the fuck out of villains and other people he deemed bad too.

Because more heroes popped up to counter him. Not because the killed heroes weren't doing their job.

The point is would you rather a sociopath surgeon that performs flawlessly, or a kind surgeon that botches the job but sends flowers to your grave?

Firefighter and paramedics are not heroes. A hero fights evil, and the system that controls heroes in this manga is evil.

The Stain arc was one of the only times the story had any self awareness over how stupid it was, I wish it went somewhere more than just being a setup for more LoV bullshit.

>firefighter, a person who will literally risk their lives for your survival
>not a hero

Lemme guess it's because they don't have individual costumes and call out attack names right?

I pity your feeble mind.

stop reading fanfiction Toga, it isn't healthy

>twice asking toga to marry him
>toga putting her handkerchief to wrap his exposed head

How can one manga have so many best girls?

Bakugou's intent and insight were correct. That doesn't change the fact that his method was wrong. When in a crisis, people would get emotionally distraught and would be more prone to irrational thoughts; this applies to all regardless of their degree of injury. Acting like an ass to even those w/ little to no injury would just cause panic and can further risk the operation.

It's garbage made for 12 year old gook kids. Try not to think about it and if you want a mature story for adults then I recommend watching Hunter x Hunter (1999)

What I find somewhat ridiculous is that the world is set up to only allow professional heroes to do heroic deeds. Using your quirk in public without a license isn't even allowed, a pro bono hero is basically an outlaw. Which makes sense to a degree, like we have specialized police officers and paramedics to take care of disasters, and any random dude trying to defuse a hostage situation would likely make it worse, in their world, where disasters are amplified by people having superpowers, any random trying to help without knowing how to act would just risk everybody.

Why would this decrease crime in not a fictional universe? Every hero he kills is another one he takes off the streets, and he's shown that he has an insane standard of purity. Even the best cop in the real world has a balance of how much he values saving others versus making a living. Making heroism just another job is one of the best things you can do to promote a safe society in their world.

BNHAfags DESTROYED