In order to have a polite society, the option for deuling must be on the table. When men are driven to an ideological impasse there is no other reasonable option.
Bring Back Deuling
Matthew Kelly
Other urls found in this thread:
Robert Reed
>killing people because they hurt are feelings
lol
Camden Sanders
ISRAEL #1
Juan Howard
No, not feelings. Ideology.
Wyatt Gray
>men agreeing to mutual combat to settle differences
Lincoln Brown
this can come back when the honor of women is worth defending
Gavin Moore
How is a call for mutual combat jewing?
Have you ever been in a fight?
Carson Gomez
agreed
Jackson Hernandez
Women have no place in the business between two men.
Easton Bailey
Shills have been spamming that same line in all threads all day.
Isaiah Mitchell
ismt america just a giant running gun fight at this point?
Parker Roberts
aren't niggers doing just that all the time in your country?
Ryan Mitchell
Shilling for a thread on dueling?
Retard.
Michael Evans
No Hans, dueling comes from a long line of european heritage. Mutual combat that is governed by agreed upon terms is not the same as a nigger shooting someone in the street for the color of the shirt they're wearing.
Joseph Cook
I'm not advocating for random killings.
Deuling is no different from boxing or tennis in my mind.
Ryan Sanchez
>Whether it [monomachy—duelling] is good or evil (as I am inclined to think), it is surely ineradicable in a society such as ours, which must for its own survival hold the military virtues higher than any others, and in which so few of the armed retainers of the state can be spared to police the populace.
>Yet is it evil?
>Those ages that have outlawed it … have replaced it largely with murder—and with just such murders, by and large, as monomachy seems designed to prevent: murders resulting from quarrels among families, friends, and acquaintances. In these cases two die instead of one, for the law tracks down the slayer (a person not by disposition a criminal but by chance) and slays him, as though his death would restore his victim’s life. Thus if, say, a thousand legal combats between individuals resulted in a thousand deaths (which is very unlikely, since most such combats do not terminate in death) but prevented five hundred murders, the state would be no worse.
>Further, the survivor of such a combat is likely to be the individual most suited to defending the state, and also the most suited to engendering healthy children; while there is no survivor of most murders, and the murderer (were he to survive) is likely to be only vicious, and not strong, quick, or intelligent.
(Ch.27, ‘The Shadow Of The Torturer’ (1980), Vol.1 of The Book of the New Sun by Gene Wolfe)
Kayden King
I advocate for dueling on the premise that it makes for a better society.
If a man has the option of fighting another man to the death, on whatever terms they agree to, men will treat one another with deeper respect.
Christian Fisher
good idea
if niggers can't have weapons
Carson Martinez
Yes, let's bring back dueling.
Hudson Stewart
I need a copy of that book. My statements only stem from my political ideology. The internet doesn't give very much on the subject during a cursory look.
Christopher Jackson
Any man is allowed to enter onto mutual combat. Should we not allow niggers to box?
Brandon Hernandez
I vote we bring back spelling first.
It's spelt dueling.
For real user, spelling 'ideological' and 'impasse' correctly, but fucking up 'duel' and 'dueling'?
Nolan Davis
Shit. I've spelled it correctly since though.
It's Friday night and I'm a couple of drinks in at this point.
Jaxon Diaz
> spelt
Jaxon Stewart
>fat Sup Forumslacks
>thinking they can duel
lol
Logan Mitchell
Fuck off dot flag.
Jaxon Rodriguez
>dont like individual X
>kill him
>place weapon in hand
>"Oh... it was a duel."
Isaac Barnes
filename
Jackson Roberts
silly thing to be illegal along with suicide.
feelings are required to care about an ideology
Jace Wilson
duels have witnesses from both parties and often go through official channels historically for a reason.
Isaac Perry
So am I, but I still know the proper spelling.
Jayden Torres
>He wants to cross swords with the men who defeated and subjugated his whole country.
Didn't work out well for you last time nippon.
Jace Long
>duel-scene.jog
>"deuling"
user I...
Samuel Wilson
This is really what is interesting to you about the thread?
No thoughts on dueling, asshole, just typos?
Dylan Morris
Both of my hirelin.. COUGH*, witnesses say it was a legitimate action.
Kevin Myers
fight me motherfuckers
Austin Myers
Jaxon Taylor
Isn't that what getting drunk and starting barfights is for?
Jackson Peterson
Justin Turner
dueling only works in a place (or time) that has a sense of honour and a code of conduct.What do you do when people agree to the terms of a duel, and then shoot you int he back? When you live in a society that has "I dont give a fuck" as a common phrase-you know old world dueling would never return.
Jacob White
I mean that if you've got a conviction, you shouldn't be able to even touch a pistol
Jacob Sanchez
Dueling wasn't for "ideological impasses" idiot. It was for muh personal honour. Muh name. Muh respect.
Jeremiah Hill
Shooting someone in the back is murder.
Dueling is mutual combat.
Dominic Cooper
Think of dueling as boxing. Instead of puting on gloves, you pick up a pistol or sword, or any other terms agreed upon proir to the contest.
Jace Murphy
It's such a boring non-issue that I... yes.
The answer is yes.
Grayson Wood
White men will never have the ability to defend their honor again. Git cucked whitey.
Angel Ramirez
...
Colton Price
and how will you prove it? you are dead. Tyrone shot you in the back.
The fact is this society will never bring back dueling because no one cares about honour.
Alexander Gray
...
Jason Edwards
I've always had this idea :|
Luke Watson
Only in a white society, niggers will just break the rules.
Jose Adams
Well then, fuck off.
Hunter Gutierrez
>told
Asher Foster
What's wrong? Afraid to die, huh?
Joseph Taylor
Make me? Or maybe you'd prefer to 'deul'?
LOL
Blake Howard
Think of boxing, mma, tennis, chess, etc.
Any activity that has agreed upon terms to participate in.
Nathaniel Parker
It is pretty fucking insane how we actually did that at one point.
that, gladiator combat, all of that.
It's entirely within us to find that to be normal. Just goes to show you how fake our beings are in this modern society. How animalistic we actually are
Anthony Collins
Gladiators were compelled, I'm talking about mutual combat.
This is a fundamental difference between third world shit holes and true civilization.
Jace Clark
no one boxes, does MMA, tennis, chess or any 1v1 sports for personal honour- not anymore. they do it for money, fame, and the fortunes that come along with those sports. get real, you cannot compare these types of 1v1 sports with dueling, because there is no honour to be lost in sports like it can be lost in dueling. But really your comparison means nothing because like i said before, honour doesnt exist in this society.
Andrew Sullivan
Says you. Your characterization the motives of men engaged in any 1 on 1 is a narrow perspective.
My original point is that dueling makes for a polite society.
Tyler Russell
You make the false presupposition that one should only engage in such over honor. I do not.
Grayson Morales
I'm really disappointed with /pol.
Only criticism I've received is over a typo and those who can't understand what mutual combat is.
Jack Fisher
>My original point is that dueling makes for a polite society.
Dueling is a bi-product of a society that views personal honour as something worth defending. we don't have that society anymore. why should dueling exist then?
please, keep ignoring the fact that dueling wont work in our society because honour is no longer important. No one in this world sees honour as something worth fighting/dying for. those days are gone user. Im sorry
Wyatt Bennett
>You make the false presupposition that one should only engage in such over honor
where did I say that? all Im saying is that honour, in the way that you are describing it- is no longer seen in society as something worth fighting/dying for. Personally, I would love to see dueling brought back. but I know it will fail and be politicised as racist or elitist because these are the times we live in.
David Moore
>pistols instead of fencing or using swords
absolute pleb
Henry Johnson
You don't have to accept a duel it's only your honor at stake. If you wanna be a cuck and cannuck that's your choice.
Adam Butler
You imagine dueling as something that only exited in fairytales. As something that can only take place when honor is involved.
Fuck honor. It has nothing to do with two men engaging in mutual combat. Men can fight over any terms that they agree upon.
Tyler Rogers
>the virgin Lionhart
>vs
>the chad Andrew Jackson
Fuck off cunt
Eli James
so what you want is not dueling then. You want mutually agreed upon sanctioned/legal combat. Glad we cleared that up
all I have to say about that is good luck with the niggers and backstabbers
Brayden Taylor
killing valuable males en masse and social media being used to arrange this is a really bad idea
Zachary Cox
(((lawyers))) killed dueling so disputes would have to go through the (((courts))).
Chase Long
You brought up honor:
I only have advocated that society is a polite society only when dueling is on the table. When men are allowed to engage in mutual combat over any terms that they find agreeable.
And by extension of that, it is the only way to resolve an ultimate ideological impasse.
Dylan Rogers
based purtoguese familiar with deciet from low trust social arrangements, blessings upon you
Colton Gutierrez
I have a good Latin background and amateur interest in etymology and even I struggled with some of the vocabulary.
Great book though.
Brody Price
>mutually agreed upon sanctioned/legal combat.
aka dueling. C'mon my dude.
Wyatt Brown
>honorable people die fighting in duels
>dishonorable people refuse to fight duels and live
This is dysgenic as fuck.
Tyler Taylor
Wow, all these "I'm so coward and proud" posts come from Canada.
ساتھی
Ryder Ross
Most duels were not to the death. And even deaths were due to wound infection due to limited medical care.
Robert Cooper
You're right to a degree. There's always someone else who wants to get between two men.
Restoration of pure mutual combat is the primary goal.
Sebastian Torres
I guarantee that if we lived in a society where dueling was legal, your edgy ass would just back down from every confrontation like the bitch you are. Kys
Eli Cook
> its better for people to not get hurt.
Ok, grandma.
Joseph Fisher
love it
Jackson Hill
Ad hominem.
Still disappointed that this is all that /pol has to offer.
Landon Taylor
I've been toying with the concept for a while. Thought I'd see what might stick here.
Nathan Moore
>I only have advocated that society is a polite society only when dueling is on the table.
I generally dont disagree with you. If men fought for what they believed in, beliefs and opinions would start to be more meaningful. you make fine points. I just dont see it happening in our society. What happens when a person breaks the contracted terms of your duel, and you getting shot in a mutually agreed upon knife fight? I mean, the dude goes to jail or gets mercy killed or whatever, but what about you?
mutually agreed upon sanctioned/legal combat vs mutually agreed upon sanctioned/legal combat based on a code of honor.
which of these definitions describes dueling better? to spell it out for you- why did people even duel back then? to suggest that it was only used to settle disagreements is wrong
Nolan Collins
>one requires actual skill and practice
or
>random ass pistol that's basically down to luck
kys gunlet
Logan Foster
OP, you realize in the duel in your image Eugene Onegin was a degenerate Chad that killed a /bro/?
Lucas Stewart
also, bring back the good ole domestic violence. smack my bitch up. take my picture.
Noah Hall
>I just dont see it happening in our society.
Every mighty oak tree grows from a tiny seed. This is probably the most you've ever thought about this subject.
Again fucking forget about honor for 5 minutes and think about what I'm advocating.
I don't care about your romanticized notions of what transpired in the past represented. Do you imagine the works of Shakespeare to be biographical?
Noah Clark
It was just the first pic that looked nice on jewgle.
Educate me.
Logan Brooks
Dueling should never have stopped to begin with. It just goes to show how weak our societies have become.
Hudson Price
William Gray
How would you know it's a duel and not murder?
Ethan Price
I'm not sure its actually illegal, just out of fashion I'm sorry to say.
Justin Bailey
Funny enough, last legal duel was in France in 1967 where 1 politician insulted another so they settled the argument with swords, "first" blood Best of 3.
youtube.com
Now we import sand niggers en masse, dafuq happen'd...
Jaxson Wright
this.
Not an user on here can stand up against my Trap deck.
Blake Perry
What's the difference between a street race and a sanctioned one?
Logan Phillips
FPBP
Dueling is not compatible in modern Christian society.
Neck yourself OP
Levi Johnson
Also fun fact, legal dueling IS still recognized by US courts.
Pretty sure it just has to be overseen by an officer and both parties sign a notarized document.
Brody Morales
Here is what I don't understand- Why even follow the mutually agreed upon rules of the duel? now, I'm trying not to talk about honor anymore, but what if one person just wants to kill the other one, mutual agreement or not? if what i just described is murder, how is it any different from what you are suggesting?
it seems like the lines between murder and dueling tends to blur.