Fate

If these two characters ever encountered one another in combat. Who would be the one to come out on top?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=k7NhP0k2iIs
youtube.com/watch?v=AjyVyahn9n8&feature=youtu.be
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

Is Shirou in autistic sword mode? If so, he wins.

If Sig can use cs to transform then he would wipe the floor with Shirou

Shirou would fall in love with Astolfo and Sieg stabs him from behind.

(with his penis)

how about EMIYA vs siegfried,This would make more sense

EMIYA should have knowledge on all servants so he could just one shot Siegfried using caladbolg

caladbolg is not a oneshot deal. There is armor of fafnir.

Of course somebody would post this kind of thread.
Sieg
>Armour of Fafnir: anti-unit np, basically a damage calculation reduction np. B rank and below attacks it received are negated. A rank attacks are subtracted into AoF which is equivalent into E rank, it also gained additional defense value of B+ when facing an Np attack.

it shut down literally most of Emiya's projection since the highest rank he could attain is B rank. Any sword projections he made are reduced by 1 rank.

>Balmung: anti-army np.
The clash between Balmung and Clarent(CS boosted), Mordred admitted that she would probably died is she were few step closer during it's clash. While clarent describe as a lightning beam, balmung is a curve like crescent moon falling guillotine. A few diatances shorter than clarent.

> StreBe gehen: Sieg's magecraft, it cause destruction of matter by analysing it's property. Use it to escape glass tank, almost eat up Gordes's heart, destroyed a tree, bullets, use against Amakusa

>During transformation mode he fought Mordred, Adam, Achilles and Karna. Specifically Karna, it shows how Siegfried's capabilities as a servant, managed to withstand damages from Karna's divine spear, Bramastra Kundala, mana burst, lightning spear like projectiles, np nuking.

his last battle though would probably be the best since he's going to fight Amakusa.

It's a one shot because EMIYA would know exactly where to hit Siegfried using it.

Would Shirou win? If he’s full Redman then yeah. Otherwise, yeah.

youtube.com/watch?v=k7NhP0k2iIs
This one.

Shirou. He can't be killed even if he dies.

You keep using that word, but you don't know what it means.

There's no way Emiya can't win.

Fuck Off, Gudao could easily defeat them at the same time.

The best one

Shirou could trace a Gay Bulge and one-shot Sieg.

The answer is Shiki as always

fuck FGO is better than FSNshit and APo trash, and Gudao is better than Shiroushit and Siegshit

>literally selfinsert fag
kys

>FGO retard
Kill yourself

Shirou kills Dragoncuck

Sieg gets annihilated by Shirou

End of Apocrypha sieg is a literal dragon, There is no way shirou can match that.

...

>traces Ascalon/Balmung
gg no re

But those are projections, clearly inferior in performance compared to the original.

>it shut down literally most of Emiya's projection since the highest rank he could attain is B rank. Any sword projections he made are reduced by 1 rank.
This is not entirely correct. Through BP and certain weapons Shirou can make A+ and rarely A++ NPs.

The fight itself is unfair though as Sieg got WAY more unjustified wank than Shirou and is basically two servants at once, with none of their drawbacks. Shirou is not strong enough to beat servants.

The only way to make the fight a proper comparison would be to use EMIYA or a much older Shirou that had mastered his abilities.

Why is he fucking a pillar?

Because Gudako gets to fuck Mashu so he needs the next best thing to an impenetrable shield girl

who cares about an actual fight? what I want to know is which one wins a denseness competition

Sieg still has part of the AoF's invulnerability due to his heart and blood, remember that bullets shot at his chest simply bounced off. His body was also strengthened when he got the heart and he is a first-rate magus that is basically a mana tank that could supply Balmung spam. In a "defenseless" battle, the most Shirou has is Kanshou and Bakuya.

Which Shiki are we talking about?

>Sieg still has part of the AoF's invulnerability due to his heart and blood, remember that bullets shot at his chest simply bounced off.
Stop making shit up. They didn't bounce off, and you'd know that if you read the LN. They actually hit his heart, but he flexed them out and healed himself. He gets no benefits from Armor of Fafnir while untransformed.

Shirou, because everyone his sucking his dick while Sieg had to fight both faction with one shitty servant and still won.

Sorry. Last time I read the novel for some godforsaken reason the translators jumped one volume, so I know little of the novel after Caules and Chiron talk

Are we talking about UBW sword autist Shirou or HF broken arm transplant Shirou?

Can shirou not do the broken phantasm thing EMIYA can as a servant? The explosion counts as 1 rank stronger no?

The entirety of volume 4 is translated, which is where that scene happens. They jumped because two translators are taking care of it and one of them just doesn't give a shit but won't let anyone else translate it instead.

Who says a copy can't beat an original?

...

Is this a fucking meme or something that I just don't get? How deluded do you have to be to say that Sieg was the one that had to struggle and didn't have half the fucking cast tripping over themselves to help him?

As much as philosophy you want to input, actual performance in reality really is inferior.

it's just some siegfag on twitter who shits up every fate thread on Sup Forums.

youtube.com/watch?v=AjyVyahn9n8&feature=youtu.be

>it shut down literally most of Emiya's projection since the highest rank he could attain is B rank. Any sword projections he made are reduced by 1 rank.
This is untrue, we know from Archer's fight with berserker that he can get pass Godhand at least 6 times and none of Berskerer's wounds seemed to be from an broken phantasm explosion.

Manaka wiped the floor with both of tem

Now that is a MEME.

Manaka stinks!

Sig is servant tier. By Nasu words Shirou without World pact, even at his peak is below Bazett tier. He don't stand a chance

I've always wondered, would fragrach activate when UBW was invoked?

Probably. It's technically his trump card. Bazett was said to be able to use Fragarach at any time against Berserker Hercules because his trump card is the always-active God Hand dove he can't use Nine Lives. It would either be against UBW or the best NP he could pull out.

He's trying to lift it off Mashu.

Mashu>Mathew>Mash

Mashu is best name because it's an Epic of Gilgamesh reference to a mountain with a tunnel down the middle, so it's a breasts joke at the same time

Sieg if he goes servant mode, no contest.
Why the fuck does everyone always overestimate ubw?

Try to even compare a German product to a Chinese bootleg?

>What is Broken Phantasm?

...

>Shirou is not strong enough to beat servants.
So we're just gonna pretend he didn't whoop Gil or kill Herc multiple times when the average servant would be lucky to do it just once?

Ever heard of circumstances and the stars aligning? One, Gil being incarnated was MUCH weaker than normal, and two, Hercules was weaker when he got corrupted and shirou couldn't successfully kill him unless Herc gave up.

>One, Gil being incarnated was MUCH weaker than normal,
Nice headcanon

There is a specific text during shirou and gil's fight where shirou noticed how much wekaer gil was, I don't have it but can anyone provide it please?

They're clearly both bottoms

Shirou won because he was going to get married.

Nasu, is that you?