Violet Evergarden

To continue with last thread's discussion. Will Kyoani demote or fire Ishidate after the blunder that Violet Evergarden is setting up to be? Why did they decided to change the superior structure of the light novel? Do the original characters add anything to the series?

Other urls found in this thread:

strawpoll.me/14912076
strawpoll.me/14907851
strawpoll.me/14912076/r
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

It's time to settle this: strawpoll.me/14912076

Go on dude, keep wasting the precious hours of your life in here sperging daily about a studio you dislike.

Is Kyoani even Sup Forums's favorite studio anymore? Feels like every year there's less Kyoani fans on Sup Forums

strawpoll.me/14907851

>Do the original characters add anything to the series?
No. Not so far in any case. Episode 2 was a point for point retread of all the "development" in episode 1. It added nothing to the story nor, more importantly, to Violet's character.
>Will Kyoani demote or fire Ishidate after the blunder that Violet Evergarden is setting up to be?
I doubt it, because office politics are more important here than how successful VEG will or won't turn out to be.
Personally, I wish he'd never get close to the director's chair ever again and just stuck to storyboarding and effects animation.

>he keeps making threads about a show he doesn't like
It has to be a fan of nardo and bordo. There's just no fucking way it's an adult behind this.

Which one of you made him this angry?

People said they wanted a source material reader's perspective on the adaptation so I picked up the LN again, then remembered why I dropped it in the first place. Repetitive descriptions and extremely predictable stories. Every time Violet appears, the novel spends like a page describing how beautiful she is and detailing what clothes she's wearing, as if anyone gives a fuck.

The author said that she wrote it while imagining what it would look like if KyoAni animated it and it shows. The anime is already a lot better than the LN so far.

They grew up and watch Kyoani shows with no expectations, and they rarely come to Sup Forums. And the few active ones are still waiting for Haruhi some good series that remind them Kyoani's glory days.

That's the prose not the structure. The plot structure in the ln is superior since Violet isn't bland and one dimensional like in the show.

A friendly reminder: if votes weren't stuffed, you'd expect a unimodal distribution of scores. Right now the distribution is bimodal, so someone is stuffing the votes.

They wanted to elevate tv anime to an actual art form, and thought tha hyperrealism was the best way, and could get normalfags interested. I think that's the explanation for everything, for why they choosed a story like VEG, why they did a partnership with Netflix, why they changed the story structure to one easier to follow. They wanted to appeal to the masses and get them interested in animation.

Realism is shit. Bring back surrealism.

Also,
IPs in thread = 7
IPs in previous thread = 115.

If this goes significantly north of 200 votes, there was rigging going on. Right now it's pretty obvious someone is proxy-voting "great" a lot.

>make one of the most well animated shows in a long time
>hide the screen behind tumblr filters
no excuse for this

The 'great' proxy voting is real. Sad that VEG fags would stood so low

Yeah. If the "great" votes were genuine, you'd expect there to be a lot of "good" votes as well, but the next peak is at "mediocre". People are either voting "great" to troll, or some VEGfag is proxy-voting.

What can we expect for episode 3? If it isn't better than the first two people will be dropping the show left and right.

That sounds like bullshit. A topic could just be polarizing, or only passionate people are bothering to vote.

>Legacy Captcha no longer supported
Fuck everything.

I haven't watched this yet, can someone tell me what's up?

This will be the next episode.

That's not how a distribution from "polarised" voters looks. If people were truly polarised, you'd expect a bimodal distribution with peaks at "bad"/"awful" and "good"/"great", and not a whole lot of "mediocre" votes.

Just disable script paptcha. The noscript image one is easy.

Why haven't anons been lewding Violet? I hardly see any Violet lewdposts

Realism has to hit peak before people do that. It's how history goes.

She seems like an odd character to lewd? But they do that with everything, so who knows.

She's so bland it isn't worth it, there's barely any fanart of her too

>if votes weren't stuffed, you'd expect a unimodal distribution of scores
no, wtf

She is hard to draw in general. Those who can draw her in decent quality preffer to show off real artworks to public rather than post porn to pixiv.

>lewding an autist

You're wrong. It's basic statistics user.

who here /veg + ito junji/

>SHOUSAAAAAAAAAA

RIP Sup Forums.

>Is Kyoani even Sup Forums's favorite studio anymore?

That hasn't been a thing in YEARS, not that it was ever a thing really.

>She's so bland it isn't worth it, there's barely any fanart of her too
Litterally the show this season with most fanart. Haters are braindead.


VEG 690
Franx 586
Shogiloli 500
Citrus 381
Yurucap 230

PTE and CCS not counted, since they had shitload of art before anime.

>not tricking Violet into all sorts of kinky sex by pretending it's what Gilbert wanted

...

VEG is a 3 year old series, try filtering the results to fanart that has been made this season, retard.

Still more than Franxx, majority of art was done in period since July to January, with spike only after prescreening in japan in December. Same time Franxx was promoted. Fuck off imbecile, you probably did not even visit pixiv to check for your shitpost.

Will the major ever give Violet some sweet loving?

>Still more than Franxx

Not even close

COLD EMOTIONLESS HANDJOBS WITH VIOLET

some of us love kyoani but sometimes they do some really stupid shit

Left side is VEG.

Silly kids.

I like the way you lie

mecha handjobs are PAINFUL

I'm just waiting for the doujins of confused Violet not understanding what the words of the major "I want to cum inside you" meant. I'll be patient.

What does VEG stand for?

...

...

Violet Everbudget has way more art than franxx

SHIRITAI NO DESU

I found about 3-5 images, but they fucking suck.

damn saber looks beautiful

is this new low of Sup Forums?

>cant read
Typical franxx idiot.

The relevant period is not since 1st January. VEG was shown and promoted in July, and so was Franxx. VEG still leads.

"SHIRITAI NO DESU" this is the most KAWAII thing i have ever heard!!!!! I've been looping that shit

...

What an incredibly cute catgirl.

the new low for Sup Forums was hnk and kemono fag threads

Happens all the time.

I want to headpat Violet and ruin her hair!

>The relevant period
Nice try, but VEG is an ongoin series, that period of time puts Franxx on a disadvantage. It is more fair to compare them from the begining of this season, and Franxx has more fanart

Just look how desperate & pathetic VEGtards are
>strawpoll.me/14912076/r
'Great' & 'Good' choice are keep getting bump every fucking seconds

What does Violet's breath smell like?

Disappointment

Shousa dick.

Is all this talk about it being bad just people trying to screw over Kyoani? Or is it actually literally unwatchable tier?

...

It's painfully mediocre. People were expecting more, also the gray filter is awful

why is she not wearing a helmet?
unprofessional as fuck.

doesn't everyone

such a mystery!

She gets special treatment because she's basically the grim reaper.

Shousa told her to take it off

roses

>has bayonet on riffle
>pummels people over the head with it

But why?

Driven snow

I want to dress up Violet as maido!

It's Mediocre as fuck. On the same level with seasonal trash, story wise.
But, Faggots keep hyping it like second coming of Jesus. So, a lot of people are shitting on it & making fun of it non stop.

Mostly the former. It's not terrible by any means. A bit slow, maybe.

I want Maidragon S2 not this melodramatic trash

2nd episode's quality was pretty bad compared to first.

>Has a musket with bayonet
>doesn't shoot.
>doesn't stab.
>uses it as club.
The point of this elludes me.

> clubbing and kung fu-ing the soldiers instead of using the bayonet

>no new IP
oh

It's antichristplex smear campaign

...

Oil

The way her lips are colored often makes it look like she's sticking her tongue out. That alone makes the show worth watching for me.

Animation is the best we have ever seen with the exception of a few fuck ups. Story is better than re zero. Dumb fags on irc have been trying to screw over kyoani for weeks. There are lots of other show airing this season that deserve way more critisism but Violet Evergarden seems to get all of it. Couple shows this season were LITERAL CANCER. Overlord looks even worse than the first season and the first season looked like literal horseshit. Franxx is OK. Grancrest senki is OK. sora yori is the ugliest thing i have ever seen with the exception of berserk 2017 and that didn't come out of polygon.

>It's not terrible
Seriously? When you pick serious melodrama genre, story is the main concern; not its polished visual.

Shit, because no one cleaned her mouth while she was in the hospital for months

Why are fans of this show, heck, kyoani in general, so thin skinned?

because she CAN. because she DOESEN'T need the bayonet

Does Claudia get a good ending or is all about Violet/Major?

SHIRITAI NO DESU

Overlord threads are not so cancerous anymore. You can actually criticize Overlord now. Back in pre S1/post S1 times any harmless criticizing or doubts about Ainz plans and behaviors will got you being crucified by mob.

>Story is better than re zero
What a very low standard you got there
>Dumb fags on irc
MUH boogeyman, amirite?
>Sora yori is the ugliest thing i have ever seen with the exception of berserk 2017 and that didn't come out of polygon
Jelly much? People like Sora Yori because of its characters interction & story. People hate VEG because of its shitty story & direction too.
In the end of the day Story > Visual.

AISHITERU WO

SHIRITAI NO DESU