Which makes the most sense?

Which makes the most sense?

Snes and playstation

who cares

I prefer the Xbox/Dreamcast layout. A to agree, B to bisagree.

Works for Nintendo too but the accept button should be the lowest damn it.

PlayStation since the buttons are always in the same position, whereas there are four different ABXY layouts

same. i like sonys to but it isnt consistent at all, its annoying how the yes and no options are swapped in japan. also playing early ps2 titles where triangle was no is annoying to

Four? More like two.

Actually three, I was thinking of how many layouts had an X button
>SNES
>Dreamcast/Xbox
>GameCube

The Xbest controller One

xbox tha GOAT

SNES. Rhombus > Square

why the fuck is it ABXY instead of ABCD

Nintendo, and japanese Sony.
A/O is the accept button. Your finger is always on it.
B/X is cancel button. You can easily roll your finger there.
X/Δ is view/info button. You need more info to confirm something, so it's comfortable to use together with A/O as middle of your thumb rests on it when you reach for top button.
Y/□ is options button. You have to reach for it, but not as much as you need for start/select.

How small is your hand that your thumb rests on A/O instead of B/X?

this. Nintendo is the only acceptable answer and jap playstation is basically Nintendo.

It's the same as ABCXYZ except they chopped off C and Z.

>A X user instead of B Y
What is wrong with you?

...

All of them except the Nintendo one. Emulating Nintendo shit with "context" shit is fucking annoying.
>Do I need to map for button position? So Nintendo A means Xbox B or do I map for when context shit shows up like in Mario party so Nintendo A means Xbox A.
That and the letters should read left to right, not right to left, fuckin gooks

so why is it abcxyz instead of abcdef

As someone that plays mostly Nintendo games, the Xbox layout makes the most sense. The letters flow from A to B and X to Y, X is on the X axis and Y is on the Y axis, A is green (Accept) and B is red (Back).

Primary Buttons: AB (and later c in various form such as the c-stick)

Secondary Buttons: XY (and later z as the trigger buttons)

This.

Why does everyone in the industry always copy Nintendo?

...

Top to bottom, right to left. Read a motherfucking book in Japanese.

grasping at straws

theyre exactly the same you fucking autists

Bottom to top from the middle out alternating left+right. Read an fucking Italian novel

If it were top-to-bottom then it would be
...A
B....X
...Y

...

I'm still upset about how blatantly Microsoft ripped off the Dreamcast controller and buttons. No creativity whatsoever, Microsoft is truly the most braindead tech company. And people complain about Apple, kek.

My thumb rests over Y/□

the shapes on the playstation controller are the shapes they are to represent the things the buttons are meant to do, like accept, back, viewpoint, and menu

>shit d-pad
>joysticks in the wrong position

Blank buttons.

because A, B, X and Y all have phonetically different sounds. Where as B, C, and D all sound similar.

That's my guess anyway.

Top kek. You don't even realise how dumb you are, do you? You might as well say Nintendo copied pocket calculators for their Gameboy console you retard.

Which is autistic. It shows you how similar all Japanese games are to one another that Sony pushed for every game to have the same control scheme.

The dreamcasts button colours somehow look more natural than the xbox ones.

I like snes, specifically the US design

X360
t:PCfat

playstation because im a visual person and shapes are easier for me to follow than letters

知るかボケ。

Whatever you're used to.

It's offset for for ergonomics.
X A
Y B

Best solution honestly. on the switch when ever its letter prompts i will sometimes fuck it up until i memorize. but when it uses position prompts i never have an issue. i own all 3 consoles and a PC and this is by far my favorite and what i wish every game had

>ABXY
>Not ABYZ

Neo Geo because dude it's A B C D E F G H I J K not A B X Y F U C K Y O U

SNES all the fucking way.
Anything else causes my Golden Age muscle memory to go haywire.

How do a bilabial stop, an alveolar fricative/velar stop, and an alveolar stop sound similar?

Because Nintendo does it correctly, as shows, Ninty has to be there to correct everyone's fuckups.

How do we make them understand?

I'd prefer the right, except spread out the top and bottom buttons instead of pulling in the left and right buttons.

>except spread out the top and bottom buttons instead
I see you're a man of taste, such as myself.

>Not posting the obvious GOAT

this scheme is a contradiction of reality, it looks like it would be shit, but it just feels so fucking right.
Switch adapter for GC controllers and smash 5 when?

this was only good for the games that were designed around the controller aka the exclusives. i couldnt imagine playing something like tony hawk on it.

Inb4
>But you can't press all buttons at the same time
That's why most fighting games let you reassign buttons and very, very often use the shoulder buttons as 3+ macros.

Racing Destruction Set wasn't a kart racing game.

I would be so happy if the Y and X buttons were different shapes.

blasphemy

They already are, relative to your thumb.

This. There's no fucked up muscle memory with it.

They all rhyme, whereas abxy do not rhyme,

Bee
See
Dee

You can already use the Wii U GC controller adapter with the Switch.
It lacks a bunch of buttons (ZL, -, Home, Screenshot plus the clickable sticks), but for games that don't need those extra buttons like Mario Kart it works great.

is that so? good to know. one more positive for future possibility of buying the console.

Objectively the best controller ever created.

>Smash-style combat game
>THE OUTFOXIES
every time

The GC controller works great with Mario Kart, but not so great with Odyssey. The fact that you can't remap buttons is such a shitty thing that Nintendo sadly refuse to remedy.
The L/R buttons on the GC are automatically mapped to L/R on the Switch, which are both used to center the camera. In order to crouch/long jump/ground pound you'll have to press the Z button and that feels awkward.
There's also the fact that the GC has no clickable joysticks, so you can't go into first-person. I don't get why they had to map that shit to a stick button, but have every other action mapped to multiple buttons.

eh, I guess I'll just wait for smash. hell even a port of 4, SOMETHING