AMSP General

What do you honestly think of this album?

>Favourite track?
>Favourite Radiohead albums ranked 1-10
>Favourite band member

Get in here faggots

Other urls found in this thread:

thelineofbestfit.com/reviews/albums/radiohead-a-moon-shaped-pool
twitter.com/NSFWRedditVideo

OP back at it again with a cheeky self bump

Fave track

>Burn The Witch

Albums ranked 1-10

>OK Computer
>Kid A
>In Rainbows
>The Bends
>Hail To The Thief
>Amnesiac
>The King of Limbs
>Pablo Honey (kind of obvious, still enjoy the album though)

>Fave member

Thom, but Jonny is a real muthafuckin' G

Identikit

Kid A - 10
Ok Computer - 10
A Moon Shaped Pool - 9,5
In Rainbows - 9,2
Amnesiac - 9,2
The Bends - 8,5
Hail To The Thief - 8
The King Of Limbs - 7
Pablo Honey - 6


I like Collin, he is a fucking beast on this new album.

ah shit I forgot to include AMSP

new list

>OK Computer
>Kid A
>A Moon Shaped Pool
>In Rainbows
>The Bends
>Hail To The Thief
>Amnesiac
>The King of Limbs
>Pablo Honey

>Favourite track
Ful Stop

AMSP - 10
Kid A - 10
OKC - 10
In Rainbows - 9
Amnesiac - 8
The Bends - 8
HTTT - 7.5
KOL - 7.5
Pablo Honey - 6

>Favorite band member
I love Johnny.

AMSP is just perfect imo. Ful Stop is my new favorite Radiohead song.

Solid 9/10

>Decks Dark, no, Ful Stop.
>Albums ranked
Kid A
In Rainbows
AMSP
Amnesiac
HTTT
OKC
TKOL
The Bends
PH
>Band member
Jonny Greenwood

The Numbers sounds like it was influenced by Zero7's In the Waiting Line. Really similar riff and downtempo ambience

Fave track
>Glass Eyes

Albums ranked
>Pablo honey 6 (thanks to blow out)
>The bends 8
>Ok computer 9.5
>Kid A 10
>Amnesiac 8
>HTTT 7.5
>In Rainbows 10
>King of Limbs 7.5
>A moon shaped pool 9.5

Fave member

>Thom

the whole album sounds inspired by yeah ghost

Fav track
>Burn The Witch

Albums
>Kid A
>OK Computer
>A Moon Shaped Pool
>In Rainbows
>Amnesiac
>Pablo Honey
>The King Of Limbs
>Hail To The Theif
>The Bends

Fav member
>Jonny, no question

Glass Eyes

HTTT
Kid A
AMSP
OKC
Amnesiac
IR
Bends
TKOL
PH

Jonny

> Bends lower than PH

I can let the others slide but this one makes absolutely zero sense to me.

My fucking christ, this album is wonderful.

Ful Stop

Kid A- 10
OK Computer- 9.5
In Rainbows- 9.5
A Moon Shaped Pool- 9
Amnesiac- 9
Hail To The Thief- 8.5
The King Of Limbs- 8
The Bends- 8
Pablo Honey- 5
Fav member is Jonny. What a lad

Decks Dark or Identikit

Kid A - 10
OK Computer - 10
A Moon Shaped Pool - 9.5
In Rainbows - 9.5
Hail to the Thief - 9
Amnesiac - 9
The Bends - 9
The King of Limbs - 8
Pablo Honey - 4

Jonny

AMSP has genuinely blown me away. FUCK

> Ful stop
> This is the first one I've listened to in it's entirety
>

>all these contrarians picking jonny over thom

>implying jonny's string arrangements and guitar licks aren't GOAT

Wow, I would not have recommended starting with AMSP but I started with TKOL so who am I to talk?

I think its alright

>Favourite track?
Glass Eyes/Daydreaming
>Favourite Radiohead albums ranked 1-10
TKOL - 10/10
Amnesiac - 9.5/10
In Rainbows - 9/10
Kid A - 9/10
OKC - 8/10
HTTT - 7/10
Bends - 6/10
Pablo - 5/10
>Favourite band member
Thom/Jonny idk one of the two

>Fav Track: Present Tense

In Rainbows
Kid A
Ok Computer
A Moon Shaped Pool
Amnesiac
Hail to the Thief
The King of Limbs
The Bends
Pablo Honey

I tried listening to Kid A few months ago.

Stopped at The National Anthem because a radio station that I listen to uses the instrumental as a bed for live commercials that they do. I didn't even know that was a real song.

Totally killed it for me. I should probably listen to the rest though.

Noticed I forgot a moon shaped pool

Put it in between OKC and HTTT 7.5/10

You should listen to the rest of Kid A, its literally perfect

>fav track: Identikit

Kid A - 10
OKC- 10
AMSP- 9.5
IR - 9.5
Amnesiac - 9
HTTT- 8.5
TKOL- 8.5
The Bends- 8
PH - 7

wew lad
thelineofbestfit.com/reviews/albums/radiohead-a-moon-shaped-pool

Needs more Colin

Why does everyone so into The Numbers? Guitar riff is literally a stairway to heaven knockoff

>Favorite Track
Identikit
>Radiohead Albums
Kid A > Amnesiac > AMSP > TKOL > IR > HttT = OKC > The Bends > Pablo
>Favorite member
Jonny

You're definitely starting on the deeper end of things but yeah, definitely finish Kid A.

>Fav Track: Decks Dark
This song is incredible. So underrated.

In Rainbows - 10
Kid A - 10
OK Computer - 9.5
AMSP: 9.5
The Bends - 9
Amnesiac - 8
Hail to the Thief - 8
The King of Limbs - 6
Pablo Honey - 9.5

>Fav Track: Nothing really stands out for me

The Bends - 10
Pablo Honey - 7.5
In Rainbows - 7
OK Computer - 7.5
Kid A - 8.5
The King of Limbs - 9.5
AMSP: 5.5
Amnesiac: 6
Hail to the Thief: 5.5

Present Tense

Kid A - 10
In Rainbows - 10
OK Computer - 9
A Moon Shaped Pool - 9
Amnesiac - 9
Hail to the Theif - 8
The Bends - 8
The King of Limbs - 6
Pablo Honey - 4

I still want a Radiohead shugazi album

Not really. Colin's actually been pretty on point these last 2 albums.

Today it's Decks Dark.

Kid A > AMSP > IR = OKC > Amnesiac > HTTT = TKOL > Bends > Pablo

The Numbers

PH - 5/10
The Bends - 8/10
OK Computer - 9.5/10
Kid A - 9/10
Amnesiac - 9/10
HTTT - 8/10
In Rainbows - 8.5/10
TKOL - 8/10
AMSP - 8.5/10

Considering the layers and textures on AMSP that could be album #10. Also, I've wanted a shoegaze cover of Myxomatosis for some time now.

Switch amnesiac with in rainbows and this is me
present tense is also my favorite

>Favourite track?
Decks Dark (that build up towards the end... wew!)

>Favourite Radiohead albums ranked 1-10
Kid A - 10
In Rainbows - 10
OK Computer - 9
Amnesiac - 9
A Moon Shaped Pool - 8
Hail To The Thief - 8
The King Of Limbs - 7
The Bends - 7
Pablo Honey - 5

>Favourite band member
Jonny Greenwood

>Favorite song
Let Down

>Rank the albums
Kid A
OK Computer
Amnesiac
In Rainbows
AMSP
The Bends
Hail To The Thief
The King of Limbs
Pablo Honey

oh fuck forgot favorite band member lol

>Favorite band member
Phil

It's beautiful I love it.

>Present Tense

Kid A
OKC
In Rainbows
Amnesiac
AMSP
HTTT
The Bends
TKOL
PH

Honestly I'm kind of beating myself up that after four or five listens nothing's standing out. I could only give the vaguest descriptions of half of the songs- there's a couple of bits that stick in my head slightly ('broken hearts, make it rain'), but I couldn't actually tell you which songs they were in. It all just blurs into one.

Basically it makes me feel like a pleb. Also the cover looks way too much like a face.

>I love Johnny.
who?

>he doesn't like In Rainbows or Amnesiac

You know, you don't HAVE to like it dude, you don't have to like anything. That said I'm surprised Burn The Witch doesn't jump out at you, I love it so much, so dramatic yet brilliant

>You dont like Y just because you ranked X over Y

This thread feels reddity. Must be the positivity.

Really? I see a lot of distinction between the songs. I think they come together through the intricate layering of classical and electronic arrangements but in terms of sheer style the only songs that sound particularly similar are the folk rock stylings of Desert Island Disk and The Numbers. Every other song sounds like its own thing to me.

Oh yeah, that does, but then I'd already heard it- same for Daydreaming and True Love Waits. It's everything in between that smooshes together. It's weird- I don't think they've done an album which sounds so samey since The Bends.

>Favourite track?
True Love Waits

>Favourite Radiohead albums ranked 1-10
Kid A - 10/10
In Rainbows - 10/10
A Moon Shaped Pool - 9/10
Amnesiac - 9/10
OK Computer - 9/10
The Bends - 8/10
Hail to the Thief - 7/10
The King of Limbs - 7/10
Pablo Honey - 5/10

>Favourite band member
Jonny

>favorite track
Climbing Up the Walls

>rank the albums
Kid A - 9.5
OK Computer - 9.5
In Ranbows - 9
Amnesiac - 10
A Moon Shaped Pool - 9
Hail to the Thief - 7
The King of Limbs - 8
The Bends - 8.5
Pablo Honey - 5

I would rank AMSP even higher if it had some fucking grooves on it.

jonny

So basically the two singles and the 20 year old song stood out. Huh.

Identikit

Kid A 10
Okc 10
A Moon Shaped Pool 10
The Bends 10
In Rainbows 9.5
Amnesiac 9
Hail to the theif 8.2
The King of Limbs 7.9
Pablo honey 5.5

Thom with Jonny a close second

Honestly I really liked it on the first listen and just seem to like it more with every additional listen.

The first 3 tracks for me are just fantastic, with Glass eyes and the present tense being my other favourites. Least favourite track is probably Desert Island Disc or The Numbers currently.

I'd say my listing goes:
OKC > IR > AMSP > AMNSC > KID A > HTTT > TKOL> Bends > PH

Favourite band member is probably Jonny, seems pretty funny from interviews and certain tweets. Also one of, if not, the most talented and important members of the band.

>if it had some fucking grooves on it.
>what is Identikit
>what is Ful Stop

>fave track
Present tense

>albums
Kid A - 10
In Rainbows - 10
Amnesiac - 10
OK Computer - 9.5 (fuck Electioneering)
HTTT - 8.5
TKOL - 8
The Bends - 8
Pablo Honey - 2
(AMSP is growing on me, already higher than TKOL)

>Fave member
Ed, the only man crush I've ever had

Now,

>top 5 radiohead tracks
>least favourite song from AMSP
>favourite b-side

Imagine pretentious and relentlessly self-indulgent Coldplay. That's what this is.

Very good, but different, maybe too different for some people.
>Favourite tracks
Identikit, Present Tense
>Favourite Radiohead albums ranked 1-10
1. OK Computer, Kid A, In Rainbows
2. A Moon Shaped Pool
3. Amnesiac, Hail to The Thief
4. The King of the Limbs. The Bends
5. Pablo Honey
>Favourite member
Colin.

Imagine a pretentious and relentlessly self-indulgent faggot. That's what is.

too calm/slow/ambient/folky/bland for me... not their worst, not their best, the present tense is fucking beautiful th

>they fucked up identikit and true love waits

>Favourite track?
Ful Stop and Tinker Tailor Soldier Sailor Rich Man Poor Man Beggar Man Thief
>Favourite Radiohead albums ranked 1-10
OK Computer - 10
Kid A - 10
Amnesiac - 9.5
The Bends - 9
Hail To the Theif - 9
King Of The Limbs - 8
In Rainbows - 6.5
Pablo Honey - 6
>Favourite band member
Jonny

What does everyone have against Pablo Honey?

Just get drunk while listening this shit, 10/10 experience guaranteed, just don't get too sad.

because is their worst album

>Favourite track?
Either Glass Eyes for the relatable feels or True Love Waits for the stunning subtle layered instrumentation in the background, especially near the end.

>Favourite Radiohead albums ranked 1-10
Amnesiac 10
AMSP 10
In Rainbows 10
OKC 9.5
TKOL 9.5
HTTT 9
The Bends 9
Kid A 9
Pablo Honey 7

>Favourite band member
Dunno. I love Johnnys influence on the sound of this album but I was also always a fan of Thom Yorkes vocals/lyrics and artistic style. I think the whole band created this masterpiece and none of them should be the "best"

>listened to it twice
>most of it is completely forgettable
>nothing remotely provocative, just redundant Radiohead
>fav tracks: Present Tense and Identikit (if I really had to pick)
>sounds like they had better things to do (which they probably did)

I honestly don't get what's so pretentious about the music? It's gllomy, sure, but it's sincere. In fact, I've never understood that descriptor when it comes to applying it to music.

Clearly their weakest album. I still listen to some songs from time to time though.

yeah but i can enjoy literally anything when i'm drunk, evena fucking grimes album

This is the objectively correct order.

>Favourite track?
Decks Dark or Identikit
>Favourite Radiohead albums ranked 1-10
Kid A: 10
The Bends: 10
In Rainbows: 9.5
AMSP: 9
OK Computer: 9
Hail to the Thief: 8.5
The King of Limbs: 6.5
Amnesiac: 4
Pablo Honey: 1

>Favourite band member
Thom obvs

>Favorite track
Present Tense

>Albums ranked
In Rainbows
Amnesiac
OK Computer
A Moon Shaped Pool
Kid A
Hail to the Thief
The King of Limbs
The Bends
Pablo Honey

>Favorite band member
Jonny Greenwood

It's fucking good. Heard tired and didn't enjoy. Now seeing how good it is.
Fav track: Ful Stop.

Amnesiac is such a weird album, almost all electronic songs are so heavy, cold and depressing, but more jazzy ones are so great and fun to listen, it confuses me.

>top 5 radiohead tracks
Nude
Climbing Up the Walls
I Might Be Wrong
There There
Present Tense

>least favourite song from AMSP
Desert Island Disk

>favourite b-side
Go Slowly

>favorite track
Present Tense
>albums ranked
Kid A
In Rainbows
A Moon Shaped Pool
OK Computer
Hail to the Theif
Amnesiac
The King of Limbs
The Bends
Pablo Honey

just meme words

o shit forgot /10

Kid A - 10/10
In Rainbows - 10/10
A Moon Shaped Pool - 9.5/10
OKC - 9.5/10
HttT - 9/10
Amnesiac - 9/10
TKOL - 8/10
The Bends - 6/10
Pablo Honey - 4/10

this nigger gets it

>Desert Island Disk

Amnesiac
Kid A
AMSP
OKC
IR
Bends
TKOL
HTTT
Pablo

>Favourite track?
Ful Stop

>Favourite Radiohead albums ranked 1-10

Kid A
A Moon Shaped Pool
In Rainbows
Ok Computer
Hail to the Thief
Amnesiac
The Bends
The King Of Limbs
Pablo Honey

>Favourite Band Member
Thom Yorke

>True Love Waits
>In Rainbows 10
>Kid A 10
>Amnesiac 9.5
>OK Computer 8.5
>A Moon Shaped Pool 8
>Hail to the Thief 7
>The Bends 6
>The King of Limbs 4
>Pablo Honey 3
>Thom Yorke ya fucking kidding me wanker

>Top 5 tracks
Come on, I can hardly rank those albums, and you ask me to pick top 5?
>Least favourite song from AMSP
Long name one.
>Favourite B-side
4 Minute warning

Do you guys really like AMSP that much?

I mean damn I'm enjoying it but it's far below Kid A, OkC and In Rainbows.

For me, the dust has not really settled with this new record. I really do enjoy listening to it, but it feels like at least a part of that enjoyment it due to the buzz, and hype I have build up around the mere notion of a new RH-album.

The times I actually do process the nature of the record, I find it to be quite spotty songwriting-wise. The production is great, and there's a clear 'sound' resonating throughout the piece, but I find some of the tracks lackluster.

>favourite track
prob Identikit

>rankings
Kid A
In Rainbows
Ok Computer
A Moon Shaped Pool
Amnesiac
Hail To The Thief
The Bends
The King Of Limbs
Pablo Honey

>fav band member
Thom

>kid a 10
>tkol 6.5
>amnesiac 4
>pablo honey 1
pretty cliche bro

Light 9. Would've liked something closer to Laughing Stock as it seems hinted at throughout, but they seem have played it quite safe

present tense

kid a > in rainbows > AMSP > amnesiac > HTTT > OKC > TKOL > the bends > pablo honey

Johnny

I need some recommendations on albums with an overall Decks Dark sound

>Favorite Track
True Love Waits
>Favorite Albums
1. OKC
2. IR
3. Kid A
4. The Bends
5. AMSP
6. Amnesiac
7. TKOL
8. HTTT
9. PH

>Favorite Member
Selway!

this is the way it should be

>AMSP above Amnesiac
>putting PH last
shit taste

Some AMSP tracks remind me of The Good, the Bad, and the Queen's ST.

I'm kinda hoping fandango gives AMSP a 6 just to watch the average opinion of Sup Forums change instantly from "it's really good" to "it's shit aside from a couple tracks"

>PH anywhere but last

He gave it a decent 8