Okay, so in hindsight I should have taken into account of replies that weren't votes & repeat song suggestions, I see that now.
So, how we are going to do it now is this:
Rule 1) Name a song that you think deserves to be in a list of greatest songs ever.
Rule 2) Be sure to use [Artist - Song] format.
Rule 3) If you see a song that you agree to be in the Top 100, reply to it with a "1", to confirm your vote for it.
Rule 4) In order for a song to qualify to be considered for the top 100 list, a song now must have at least 5 votes. If it has less than 5 votes, it doesn't even qualify to be considered.
Rule 5) If a comment includes more than one song, reply to that comment with a 1 and the song that you think deserves to be on the list.
Rule 6) I will do this two more times (when I'm not working of if another user want to help me out) collecting about 500 songs in total, after there will be votes for the songs in the 500 of which to be in the Top 100.
Rule 7) Please try to not duplicate songs, the votes no longer equal points but rather qualify it, having the same two songs doesn't earn it a higher place, it just means it's still going to be on the list.
Song's voted in the last three threads that had more than 2 votes:
>21 Pilots - Stressed Out >A Tribe Called Quest - Excursions >Aesop Rock - Gopher Guts >Alice Coltrane - Journey In Satchidawanda >American Football - Never Meant >Animal Collective - Alvin Row >Animal Collective - Brother Sport >Animal Collective - Fireworks >Animal Collective - In The Flowers >Animal Collective - Penny Dreadfuls >Aphex Twin - Rhubarb >Beach House - Sparks >Ben E King - Stand By Me >Bjork - Unravel >Black Tambourine - Throw Aggi Off The Bridge >Blue Oyster Cult - (Don't Fear) The Reaper >Boards of Canada - Music Is Math >Bob Dylan - Like A Rolling Stone >Bon Iver - For Emma >Bon Iver - Re Stacks >Boris - Flood >Boston - More than a Feeling >Bruce Springsteen - Thunder Road >Burial - Archangel >Burzum - Dunkelheit >Candy Claws - White Seal >Car Seat Headrest - Beach Life-in-Death >Car Seat Headrest - Stop Smoking >Comus - The Herald >David Bowie - Heroes >David Bowie - Lazarus >David Bowie - Life On Mars >David Bowie - Sound & Vision >David Bowie - Station to Station >Deafheaven - Dream House >Death Grips - Beware >Death Grips - Guillotine >Death Grips - Hacker >Death Grips - No Love >Death Grips - On GP >Death Grips - Up My Sleeves >Deathconsciousness - Earthmover >DMX - X Gon Give It To Ya >Doors - Light my fire >Duster - The Landing >Earl Sweatshirt - Solace >Elliot Smith - Waltz #2 >Elliott Smith - Angeles >Feotus - Di-1-9026 >Fleet Foxes - Helplessness Blues >Frank Ocean - Pyramids >Fugazi - Turnover >Funeralopolis - Electric Wizard >Funkadelic - Maggot Brain >GODSPEED YOU! BLACK EMPEROR - Sleep >Have a Nice Life - Bloodhail >Higgs Boson Blues - Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds >Husker Du - Reoccuring Dreams Interpol - NYC >Jim O'Rourke - Eureka >Jimi Hendrix - Little Wing >Joanna Newsom - Only Skin >Joy Division - New Dawn Fades >Joy Division - She's Lost Control
Gavin Cox
>Kansas - Carry On Wayward Son >Kanye West - Dark Fantasy >Kanye West - Devil In A New Dress >Kanye West - Gone >Kanye West - Gorgeous >Kanye West - Power >Kanye West - Runaway >Kanye West - Ultralight Beam >Kate Bush - Running Up That Hill (A Deal With God) >Kendrick Lamar - m.A.A.d City >Kendrick Lamar - Sing About Me, I'm Dying of Thirst >King Crimson - 21st Century Schizoid Man >King Crimson - Epitaph >King Crimson - Starless >LCD Soundsystem - All My Friends >Led Zeppelin - No Quarter >Led Zeppelin - Stairway To Heaven >Led Zeppelin - The Song Remains The Same >Lou Reed - Perfect Day >Lua - Bright Eyes >Mac DeMarco - Salad Days >Madvillian - Accordion >Madvillian - All Caps >Marvin Gaye - What's going on >Mercury Rev. - Fritter >Michael Jackson - Billie Jean >Modest Mouse - Dramamine >My Bloody Valentine - Only Shallow >My Bloody Valentine - When You Sleep >Nas - Memory Lane >Neutral Milk Hotel - Holland, 1945 >Neutral Milk Hotel - In the Aeroplane Over the Sea >Neutral Milk Hotel - Oh Comely >Neutral Milk Hotel - The King of Carrot Flowers Pts. 1, 2 and 3 >Neutral Milk Hotel - Two Headed Boy Pt. 2 >New Order - Ceremony >Nick Drake - Things Behind The Sun >NINA SIMONE - SINNERMAN >Nirvana - All Apologies >Pink Floyd - Another Brick In The Wall >Pink Floyd - Dogs >Pink Floyd - Echoes >Pink Floyd: Shine On You Crazy Diamond >Pixie - Where Is My Mind >Pixies - Hey >Poison Oak - Bright Eyes >Primal Scream - Loaded >Radiohead - Fake Plastic Trees >Radiohead - How to Disappear Completely and Never be found >Radiohead - Karma Police >Radiohead - Let Down >Radiohead - Motion Picture Soundtrack >Radiohead - Nude: 11 >Radiohead - Paranoid Android >Radiohead - The National Anthem >Radiohead - Weird Fishes / Arpeggi >Radiohead - You And Whose Army >Red House Painters - Katy Song >Red House Painters - Medicine Bottle >Sigur Rós - Ágætis byrjun >Slayer - Raining Blood >Sleep - Dopesmoker >Slint - Good Morning Captain >Slint - Washer >Slowdive - Alison
Luke Perez
>Slowdive - When The Sun Hits >Smash Mouth - All Star >Smashing Pumpkins - Mayonaise >Songs Ohia - Farewell Transimission >Sonic Youth - Teen Age Riot >Sufjan Stevens - All Delighted People >Sufjan Stevens - Impossible Soul >Sufjan Stevens - John Wayne Gacy Jr >Sufjan Stevens - The Predatory Wasp Of The Palisades Is Out To Get Us! >Sun Kil Moon - Carissa >Swans - Avatar >Swans - Helpless Child >Swans - Oxygen >Talking Heads - Once In A Lifetime >Talking Heads - The Great Curve >Television - Marquee Moon >The Avalanches - Since I Left You >The Beach Boys - God Only Knows >The Beach Boys - Wouldn't It Be Nice >The Beatles - A Day In The Life Of >The Beatles - Eleanor Rigby >The Best Ever Death Metal Band In Denton - The Mountain Goats >The Flaming Lips - Race For the Prize >The Microphones - I Want Wind to Blow >The Olivia Tremor Control - I Have Been Floated >The Pecan Tree - Deafheaven >The Rolling Stones - (I Can't Get No) Satisfaction >The Smiths - I Know It's Over >The Smiths - There Is A Light That Never Goes Out >The Smiths - William It Was Really Nothing >The Trapeze Swinger - Iron & Wine >The Velvet Underground - Heroin >The Velvet Underground - Venus In Furs >Toto - Africa >U2 - Where The Streets Have No Name >Van Morrison - Madame George >Violent Femmes - Add It Up >Ween - Ocean Man >Why? - Good Friday >Wilco - Jesus, etc >Wilco - Poor Places >Wu Tang Clan - Method Man >Yes - Close To The Edge >Young Thug - Best Friend >Yung Cheezy - Twerk
Hunter Garcia
1 song per band
Levi Davis
I'm making two lists, one that includes multiple songs by the same band, and one that doesn't.
Nathaniel Phillips
Big black - Fish fry
Christian Cox
ok cool. do we get to vote on the second one ??
William Bennett
Pavement - Gold Soundz
Easton Reed
Yeah, what I'll do is I'll take any songs by the same band an make a strawpoll & people can vote on their favorite song by the band.
Once the votes are counted and all the remaining songs are single bands, the voting for the position on the Top 100 will commence.
Nathan Harris
Talk Talk - After the Flood
Chase Sanders
of Montreal - The Past Is A Grotesque Animal
Aiden Edwards
The doors - the end Arcade fire - here comes the night time The national - pink rabbits Bruce springsteen - bobby jean
Adrian Campbell
Reckoner - Radiohead
David Sanders
>Queen - Bohemian Rhapsody
No matter how much you hate queen Sup Forums. Bohemian Rhapsody is still a top 100 songs of all time.
>Smash Mouth - All Star I dunno man seems like a pretty good list to me
Aaron Johnson
Nine Inch Nails - Hurt
Samuel Cruz
>Smash Mouth - All Star
This is never going to work, is it?
Cooper Murphy
1
Samuel Cook
1
Cooper Gray
>just as many Death Grips songs as David Bowie songs
Jesus christ this board is cancer
Jason Morris
The Smiths - How Soon is Now?
Evan James
ミドリ - 5拍子
Josiah Green
Spiritualized - Ladies and Gentlemen We Are Floating in Space
Eli James
Modest Mouse - 3rd Planet
Angel Torres
PEARL JAM - JEREMY
Henry Rogers
1
nickelback - animals
Anthony Kelly
1
Samuel Garcia
1
goo goo dolls iris
Luke Lopez
1
William Murphy
sugar ray - FLY +1
Parker Gutierrez
1
Wyatt Smith
1 1 for Pot
Brody Bailey
1
Camden Campbell
1
Easton Reyes
Loaded - Primal Scream
Matthew Morris
The Beach Boys - Surf's Up
Lucas Brown
1
Asher Reed
Public Image Limited - Public Image
Jace Cox
1
The Shop Assistants - Safety Net
Henry Sanchez
Elliot Smith - Alameda
Leo Butler
The Rolling Stones - Gimme Shelter
Gavin Gomez
1
Ayden Parker
1
Nicholas Gonzalez
1
Lucas Watson
Blur - Coffee and TV
Thomas Reyes
Elvis Costello - Watching the Detectives
Austin Myers
1
David Clark
The Beta Band - Dry the Rain
Landon Reed
Adolescents - Amoeba
Jordan Turner
Boredoms - ↑
Brody Reed
Linking Part - In the end
Juan Watson
1
Oliver Cook
I must have listened to it a thousand times.
Ian Nelson
>>Lua - Bright Eyes You serious?
Daniel Ward
1 for the best of radiohead
Carter Taylor
+1 Was this anybody else's childhood song? >that cute milk boy
Juan Sanders
>ミドリ - 5拍子 1
Ryan Ward
1
Caleb King
The fact that there's so many for animal collective, david bowie, death grips, kanye west, neutral milk hotel, and radiohead shows how much of a circle-jerk this board is. Also wheres the variety in genres?
Jack Long
1 for the knife
Ian White
i know myman. the 1 song per band list will probably have a hard time reaching 100
Gabriel Ward
Neil Young - Ambulance Blues
Jaxson Lewis
Radiohead - Weird Fishes/Arpeggi
1
Isaac Wilson
Jai Paul - BTSTU
Grayson Stewart
Pantera - This Love
Brody Reyes
At the Gates - Blinded By Fear
Jaxson Ramirez
1
Wyatt Green
The Beatles-Tomorrow Never Knows
Charles Fisher
Canned Heat - Going Up the Country
Noah Nguyen
Entombed - Left Hand Path
Eli Phillips
Dearhunter - Desire Lines or/and Helicopter
Julian Rogers
Tim Buckley - Song to the Siren
Luis Baker
Animal Collective - In The Flowers Car Seat Headrest - Beach Life-in-Death Death Grips - Beware Death Grips - No Love GODSPEED YOU! BLACK EMPEROR - Sleep Have a Nice Life - Bloodhail Kanye West - Power King Crimson - Starless Madvillian - Accordion Neutral Milk Hotel - Oh Comely Nick Drake - Things Behind The Sun Pink Floyd - Dogs Pink Floyd - Echoes Red House Painters - Medicine Bottle Sufjan Stevens - The Predatory Wasp Of The Palisades Is Out To Get Us! Talking Heads - The Great Curve The Beach Boys - God Only Knows Yes - Close To The Edge
all these 1
1
Levi Mitchell
Radiohead - Kid A Sonic Youth - Teen Age Riot King Crimson - Epitaph GYBE - Monheim
Zachary Allen
1
Brandon Gutierrez
1 1
Who cares man, it was obvious that this list is going to be highly representative of Sup Forums, if you want an actual best songs ever list compiled by critics look somewhere else. This is just Sup Forums having a bit of fun, circlejerking is not a necessarily bad thing.
Anthony Perry
1
Björk - Jóga
Tyler Gutierrez
Outkast - Hey Ya!
1
Evan Ward
1
Gavin Davis
>Comus - The Herald >Elliott Smith - Waltz #2 >David Bowie - Life on Mars? >Sufjan - Impossible Soul >Nina Simone - Sinnerman >Modest Mouse - Dramamine 1
Adding some things to vote for Boston - Foreplay/Long Time New Order - Bizarre Love Triangle Elliott Smith - Needle in the Hay Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here Billie Holliday - Strange Fruit
This is a trainwreck lol
Grayson Wood
...
Dylan Peterson
The Beach Boys - Good Vibrations
Austin Hernandez
To add some variety and some well established "classics" to vote for so our list doesn't suck ass:
Chuck Berry - Johnny B Goode Sam Cooke - A Change is Gonna Come Bruce Springsteen - Born to Run The Rolling Stones - Gimme Shelter The Kinks - Waterloo Sunset Jimi Hendrix - All Along the Watchtower Jimi Hendrix - 1983..... Stevie Wonder - Superstition Stevie Wonder - Higher Ground The Beatles - While My Guitar Gwntly Weeps The Who - Won't Get Fooled Again
Strange Fruit +1
Brody Foster
Jack J - Something (On My Mind)
Connor Smith
1 for a tooth for an eye.
Ryan Ward
1
Panda Bear - Bros
Bentley Collins
Gimme shelter has already been said in the thread
Julian Martin
Husker Du - Pink Turns To Blue
Zachary Wilson
Animal Collective - The Purple Bottle
Bentley Martinez
Posting some GOAT house that is definitely deserving.
Fatima Yamaha - What's A Girl To Do Omar s - Thank U 4 Letting Me Be Myself Liem - If Only Ross From Friends - Talk To Me You'll Understand