Album Showdown

Lads... This is a hard one but... Which one is better?

Also album showdown thread
Post 2 albums, reply each post with your vote/make strawpolls whateva

Other urls found in this thread:

strawpoll.me/10780132
strawpoll.me/10780209
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

Sure

In Rainbows, not even close I think

In Rainbows

Blonde on Blonde vs Rain Dogs

In Rainbows by a mile

...

AMSP by just a little bit

fuck.... ummm.... Heaven or Las Vegas...? I love both

Blonde on Blonde

In Rainbows, but by a small margin.

in rainbows

A Moon Shaped Pool as a album in whole
However, In Rainbows has much higher highs (Weird Fishes, Reckoner) but has lower lows than AMSP (House of Cards, and arguably Videotape)

Both are really good tho

...

In Rainbows

Heaven or Las Vegas

Music Has the Right to Children

i agree with this t b h.
in rainbows isn't as consistant as moon shaped pool but has overall better songs

In Rainbows
Heaven or Las Vegas
Geogaddi
Black Metal
Fleet Foxes

In Rainbows

Heaven or Las Vegas

Exuma

Music Has the Right to Children

s/t overall but The Shrine is GOAT

Name a weak track on In Rainbows. Protip: you fucking can't, faggots.

Pinkerton

literally named 2 in my post

I said name a weak track. When will you deliver?

Love 'house of cards', one of the most beautiful radiohead songs

Ye I still like the song, I just find it underwhelming. It might just be because it's sandwiched in between two of my favs from In Rainbows

Black Metal

The Glow pt 2

strawpoll.me/10780132

...

Black Metal

MHTRTC, Geogaddi is 2SP00KY

self-titled

This one has always been a hard one for me... But I guess I like Blue Album better

ITAOTS

SILY

Strange Mercy

SILY

Garbage taste kill your self black metal is not metal what does ITAOTS SILY MHTRTC mean explain ya doofus

FIGHT

In Rainbows
Heaven or Las Vegas
Black Metal
Pinkerton
The Glow Pt. 2

Blue Album all the way.Anybody who unironically says Pinkerton is better is either a weeb or has some bad inner demons.

Both ass, so irrelevant.

Apples to oranges with this one.

Rain Dogs isn't boring as fuck so that.

>meme avant folk
Both music that's really for those with short attention spans

Geogaddi since it's not baby tier ambient

>frontier
Autechre - elseq 1-5

Pinkerton. The rest of Weezer's discography is ass. If idiots were smart enough to notice the brilliance of Pinkerton we wouldn't si many albums tryna ape the inferior of the first two albums.

Who cares? Garbage band

>muh special snowflake folk
Real music>>>this garbage

Hmmm...watered down sampling vs electro swing...that's a tough one

I'm DJ Shadow

Laughing Stock

Garbage taste

geo
sily

You're trying to hard.

I think the instrumentation is allot better on Pinkerton than it was on the blue album, I also really like the production on Pinkerton i like the not so polished sound.

In rainbows not by much
Music has right to children
Blue Album
ITAOTS
SILY

jenny

niggas on the moon eaaasy

...

strawpoll.me/10780209

homo

holy shit this is one of the most cynical responses I've heard on this board

blue
the glow pt2

>SILY over Endtroducing

(You)

IDLSIDGO it's not even close

satan speaks the truth

Two albums for two different moods. Since I personally could enjoy In Rainbows at any given time of the day, I'd have to say that.

How about Ride The Lightning vs Master of Puppets? (this may have been done in this thread I just haven't looked)

IR

Exuma, not even a contest

MHTRTC

Redeemer

ILYHB is superior to both

Weezer is Nickelback for hipsters

is this a joke? ITAOTS

SILY, not even close. Wildflower, Donuts, Dispepsi and Eskimo better than both though.

only her first album is good

honestly can't decide on this one

xDDD so funny

NOTM by a mile, they are not separate albums though idiot

Homogenic

they're both awful

this isn't even close, blonde on blonde is one of the most important pop records of all time

In Rainbows
???
Blonde on Blonde
Comus
geogaddi
Black Metal
Helplessness Blues
Blue album (Pinkerton is complete shit. But that's for another time)
ITAOTS Because at least it doesn't sound like a shitty demo tape
Endtroducing
None. To be honest. (Maybe her sel titled if i had to pick)
Laughing stock
woo hoo album
Niggas on the moon
None. (Maybe homogenetic)
I Don't Like Shit, I Don't Go Outside.

Since I Left You

Jenny Death

Self-titled

Don't make me choose

Hard one, but TMR because there's more.

In Rainbows, it's really close though

Geogaddi

Helplessness Blues and it's not close at all

Pinkerton

The Glow Pt. 2

Endtroducing and it's not close

Strange Mercy

Spirit of Eden

NotM

Homogenic

IDLS is one of the best rap albums of the decade so that

>mad

>Putting Joanna on the level of Bob Dylan

HOOM
Faust

>t.mad

Damn a shit ton of you prefer SILY to Entroducing...? Surprised desu. My vote still goes to Dj Shadow

In Rainbows
Heaven or Las Vegas by a hair
MHTRTC by a landslide
Helplessness Blues
hard one, but I'm gonna have to go with Pinkerton
ITAOTS
SILY
Strange Mercy by a hair
Laughing Stock
NOTM, I can't imagine why anyone would say otherwise
Faust

Because most of them are closet homosexuals with shit taste. this is the same board that loves David Bowie and animal collective.

wew
jenny death, notm is overrated as fuck by this board
Entroducing

There is only one right awnser.

In Rainbows
Exuma
Geogaddi
Black Metal
Fleet Foxes
Blue Album
ITAOTS
Endtroducing
Strange Mercy
Spirit of Eden
Blur (Parklife is better than both)
ebin :D
Boys on the Moon
Homogenic
Goblin is a guilty plessure
MBDTF

There can only be one

Cardiacs, it isn't even close.
NOTM

>I can't imagine why anyone would say otherwise
maybe they like nu metal

IR
pinkerton
ITAOTS, but I should probably listen to the glow pt. 2 a few more times
Can't decide, both amazing in their own ways
Spirit of Eden
NotM is goat dg
Homogenic
Blonde on Blonde is probably a greater artistic accomplishment, but HoOM is an easy top 5 for me

AMSP
HoLV
Exuma
MHtRtC
s/t
Blue
ITAOTS
Endtroducing
Laughing Stock
13, this isn't a contest
NotM
IDLSIDGO
Blonde on Blonde
TPAB

The actual great debate

13

Kid A

To anyone who picks OK Computer: fuck you

...

dude endtroducing gets boring as fuck sometimes. Same drums with reverb and meme patterns.

In Rainbows easily
Heaven or Las Vegas
Exuma
thats hard but i'd say Geogaddi for the concept about it. they are both 9/10 to me.
Black Metal but The Redeemer is his best song
Helplessness
Pinkerton
The Glow
Damn... I cant choose sorry
both garbage so its irrelevant
Spirit of Eden
13
Kida
Niggas on the Moon
Homogenetic
I Don't Like Shit
Blonde On Blonde. Why is this even a question?
Faust

Ok computer.

...

>boring
It feels good to know that these are the types of listeners that dislike Endtroducing. I've never seen a legitimate criticism made against that album.

Hvis Lyset Tar Oss easily.

Filo
Ok Computer
Bee Thousand
Contemporary movement

Ok Computer has better individual songs compared to Kid A but from an album perspective Kid A wins by a mile

Kid A

MBTDF
Mr. Bungle
Stratosphere
Bee Thousand
Kid A. Ok Computer doesnt deserve all the hype.
Illmatic.
Filosofem

Which one wins?

Illmatic, not even close. The gap between Illmatic and every other hip-hop album is pretty damn big besides maybe 36 chambers.
>boring
lol

In Rainbows

Blue Album tbqphm8

The Glow pt 2

Endtroducing

Strange Mercy

Niggas On the Moon

Homogenic

IDLSIDGO
Goblin is literally the worst album I've ever heard

Blonde on Blonde, are you fucking serious

MBDTF

Kid A

Illmatic

>The gap between Illmatic and every other hip-hop album is pretty damn big
>besides maybe 36 chambers.
Stop these normie memes

this is a really fucking hard choice but I think I like Faust just a teeny smidge better. I've cried to both before though.

MBDTF

Kid A, OKC is for fedoras

Illmatic, if you like The Infamous more literally kys

Kid A. Who says OK Cmputer is a faggot
Filosofem
Double Nickels on the Dime
We Have The Facts

we have the facts

Spirit Of Eden, LS a shit

>if you like The Infamous more literally kys
The infamous is a more complete and better version of illmatic.

>MBDTF over TPAB
I hate it when 12 year olds speak their crappy opinion.

AMSP
Blue
SILY
NOTM
MBDTF
Kid A

...

i dont even like MBTDF but Kendrick's voice is irritating as fuck.

>using fantano as an argument
go away

pic related

I'm 22 and TPAB is a cringefest

>THIS DICK AIN'T FREEEEEEE
>BOO BOO
>WASH YO ASS NIGGA
>muh le wrong generation Tupac pandering
>here let me literally explain the entire album to you on the last track because apparently my fan base is too stupid to understand it based on the lyrics

f a infinity