is this the first post-punk record?
Is this the first post-punk record?
Jack Mitchell
Other urls found in this thread:
Luke Richardson
it's cans monster movie
Tyler Perez
television - marquee moon
Ryder Long
came after this
listen to starless
you may be right with ege bamyasi
Liam Reyes
there's literally nothing post-punk about it
Landon Baker
looked up folder.jpg.
I don't think you have a solid argument here.
Brody White
No.
No.
No.
No.
Yes.
Evan Hughes
listen to starless
Easton Wood
truly no, not even close
Julian Torres
No, this is.
Dominic Collins
listen to starless
Jackson Sanchez
tell me what you think is post-punk about Starless
Jordan Howard
the song
Tyler Ramirez
xD
Lucas Moore
This is actually pretty good, never heard about them before.
Jonathan Fisher
ignorant fuck
the guitar sound is quite harsh and reminds me of many post-punk albums. it also reminds me of Swans nondrone/nonnoise songs, that are post-punk
Logan Jones
This is proto-punk or garage rock
it is not post punk
Devo were probably the first post-punk band if you listen to their very early demos
youtube.com
Henry Lee
Literally the only proto-punk post-punk is This Heat out of a technicality when they recorded music before punk and released it after, only to have it be categorized as post.
Owen Gray
Discussions like this prove that attempting to pidgeonhole records into genres (especially historical ones) is pretty futile.
Take If this had been released ten years later, it would be classified as post-punk. As it stands, this is impossible because punk wasn't even really a thing then. But the sound signature is there. What is more important when determining historical genres, sound or chronology?
Evan Edwards
How can it be post-punk if it predates punk itself?
Jason Morales
just like marquee moon
Luke Nelson
Is this a new meme?
Eli Butler
I'd say a better argument could be made for sound, because classification of any type of artwork should be based on it's content, rather than the era it was released. Not to say that the context or era the albums released on isn't important, but if you had to choose one, I think the sound takes priority.
Ryder Price
post-punk cannot begin until punk dies
and everyone knows punks not dead
Jaxson Wilson
punk died within the first few years of it's inception, once everything in it became derivative of itself.
Jackson Cooper
no