Essential scarufficore

Essential scarufficore

...

...

robert wyatt

>Anything by Bowie
>Scarufficore

pick one

I don't really get scaruffi's reviews. The only time he gives an opinion is if he strongly likes it or doesn't like it. Reading many of his reviews he just sortof describes the songs track by track while giving very little of his own opinion.

His "reviews" are an extension of his huge collection of notes. That's why some rock albums just get lengthy descriptions of their sonic qualities, why jazz albums tend to have a summary of players, their contributions, etc. The stuff he has more to say about are the ones he has a strong opinion on.

You can generally tell how he feels about something by the words he uses.

>rates 60% of albums 5.5-6.5
>good critic

What's wrong with that user

I was surprised by how much he liked Marry Me

What's the problem with this?

He gave it a 7.5

>he just sort of describes the songs track by track while giving very little of his own opinion.
And that's exactly what I want from a music reviewer.

It's really great, her best album.
Thought it was a 7 last time I checked.
Nvm then.

...

...

>what did he mean by this?

He doesn't rate 95% of album 8+, he must be shite lole

...

>7.5

Thats like a 6.5 on his old scale.

best

This is GOAT though.