Album fight thread

Album fight thread

post two albums which are comparable in some way and anons argue about which one is better

going to start with what should be an interesting comparison

Deepchord Presents Echospace - Liumin

vs

Voices From The Lake - s/t

battle of 10's ambient techno

tago mago


fuck

how the fuck is tago mago the same as hosianna mantra

who the fuck said it was the same? they're comparable because they were released within a year of each other and they're both experimental rock bands from germany

Sup Forums's 3 favorite albums

then why not compare it to german oak?

Loveless > Spiderland >>>>>>>>>>>>> meme

stop being autistic

Loveless>Meme>Spiderland

not an argument

Spiderland > ITAOTS > Vacuums

you also have no argument as op never claimed them to be similar ("the same")

...

Loveless>ITAOTS>>>>>Spiderland
Loveless>Souvlaki>>>>>Nowhere

its a lame comparison and you know it. reason why everybody is voting on this instead

>Hosianna
>rock
Your a retard

How is it lame? They're both widely acclaimed, well-known albums from a similar region and time period. the reason more people are replying to that is because it's literally the 3 most popular albums on Sup Forums and everyone has an opinion on them

what is it then?

...

>what is it then?
Neoclassical new age with elements of ambient, modern classical, and chamber music

>tfw no gf vs. tfw gf

More like krautrock with elements of neoclassical

kek you just copied rym

dont get so hung up on genres anyway

>They're both widely acclaimed, well-known albums from a similar region and time period
using this logic it'll be okay to compare
nirvana - nevermind
dr.dre - the chronic

both widely acclaimed,well - known and from a simiar region

How are they wrong tags exactly? user asked what the album is

>it'll be okay to compare
go ahead and compare them nigger this is a fucking anime imageboard take it easy
i would say tago mago and hosianna mantra are a lot more similar than those two but literally who gives a shit

you have autism

You're awfully angry

why are you throwing insults at me because you made a terrible comparison?
the results speak for itself with nobody bothering to compare them.

>post two albums which are comparable in some way

>nobody bothering to compare them

not an argument, nobody's bothering to compare these either

Nobody's bothering to compare any of these albums (besides the Sup Forumscore choice, because, y'know, Sup Forumscore) because this thread has become a needless shitstorm.

fine
tago mago
liumin
itaots
loveless
freewheelin

More interesting album choices would help

>More interesting album choices would help
be the change you want to see in the world

Said the retard who can't use contractions

...

Hosianna. Peking O is trash, fight me
ITAOTS > Spiderland > Loveless

all 3 are masterpieces
Loveless > Souvlaki > Nowhere

I prefer Going Blank Again honestly
freewheelin
Hounds of Love >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Devo >>>> So >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Oingo Boingo

for originality, hosianna mantra
for how it sounds, tago mago

loveless

ride is fucking britpop
loveless

wish you'd fuck off for good

devo

wish you'd fuck off as well

you still post here? dam

hah what did I do

very occasionally. i don't get much free time. i'm an adult, working to become a photographer/illustrator/artist in my spare time, and then most of my spare time is walking the dog, with my girlfriend, or working extra shifts (i want to self publish my first book). i feel like i'm way behind on Sup Forums culture and i don't really have anything to say about anything on here anymore

NORMIE GETOUT REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

bump

Tago Mago is better

Liumin is better

Loveless is the best one out of thouse

Loveless wins

Townes van Zandt

Bush, Kate

you sound a little tryhard desu

tough one, both are a 9.3 for me. In the end I gotta go dummy. Good picks

Thank you tripfag. I'd say Mezzanine is better though.

I respect that. They're the definitely the two best trip hop albums

Which would be the third one then? I'd say Blue Lines.

Tricky- Maxinquaye for me. Blue Lines is dope tho

Dummy, cuz roads

...

Left is superior as a direction to right, so Pet Sounds.

Pretty sure ITCOTCK is Sup Forums's favorite album

nah, most people here shit on Moonchild, and rightfully so

>Shit on Moonchild, and rightfully so
You sound dumb right now

People who never leave their computers have a harder time appreciating moody ambient music

here's another for u

Its pretty universally agreed that Cop was a strong conceptual step up from Filth

heh, this is probably accurate, though I think Moonchild is poorly done and I like a lot of free improv stuff and jazz, am not on the computer much, and ambient is one of my favorite genres(not that Moonchild is categorically ambient)
if you have a good understanding of timing, theory, and chemistry, it becomes quickly apparent that the performances on Moonchild, especially the drums are shaky at best

...

>universally agreed
I think Cop is a better album but your statement is not true. For example on RYM Filth has a much higher ranking than Cop does.

Thats understandable, Filth is more accessible, but doesn't achieve as much

They sound nothing alike. I personally like Bowie more than Zappa though.

I can see people liking Filth more cause it's unintentionally catchy as fuck

Brian Eno

TM&A

right wins

...

Cop but let's be honest, it really gets a lot of points for Young God

Now that's hard. I've probably listened to LC more so I'd go with that.

...

...

boris

Filth

VEESHAN
CREASHAN
NEWSUUUM

...

...

Here's a more interesting one.

SJ

pretty much equal to me. spiderland is excellent at points but kinda uninteresting to me at others. loveless is very upbeat and fun to listen to on good days but lacks an essential heartache. itaots is interesting for the first handful of listens but then it loses its appeal and goes wacky.
souvlaki>loveless>nowhere
hard but probably dummy
feedbacker

SJ > STGSTV > ST = MPP

...

Loveless > ITAOTS > Spiderland

ST>STGSTV>MPP>SJ

...

OK Computer if you like rock. Kid A if you like electronic.

Tago Mago

Loveless

Low

MM Food

Kid A by far

Joy of a Toy

Spirit

goslings without a doubt

Hot Rats for sure
M&A by miles
London Calling but Double has higher highs. Both are incredible
Take Me To Your Leader is a 10/10 and MM Food is a 9.5
Boredoms
STG: 9.5
ST: 3/10 that album's fucking obnoxious, Winter's easily the best song
SJ: 8/10
MPP: 5/10 overrated
Madcap. Had it been Barrett this would be a different story
FD > Ege > Tago

Future Days is their magnum opus for sure. The atmosphere on that album is ingenious
HANL
respectable
OKC by far
sweet trip, close tho. I need to relisten to goslings
BoB

Aeroplane
havent listened to souvlaki but loveless>ride
cop
MPP (10/10 underrated on Sup Forums t b h) > Spirit (9-10 perfect for the hype on here t b h) > Sung Tongs (9/10) > SJ (8/10 a bit overrated on here t b h)
Future Days>Ege Bamyasi≥Tago Mago
Ok Computer


pic related is Replica imho

Spiderand=Loveless>ITAOTS
Loveless=Souvlaki>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>the shitty brit-pop one

hope some anons know both these albums
they're both great but I wonder what ya'll think

evening star's a lot better. Fuck, the melodies on Evening Star are beautiful. No Pussyfooting shows much less chemistry between the two

DEFINITELY evening star

No Pussyfooting has nothing interesting happening. And dont tell me "I just dont get ambient" because it's my favorite genre. I can respect what it did for ambient music but that doesnt make it good

OPN's not vaporwave so I'm kind of confused by this comparison. Replica's the best album there though

I don't think No Pussyfooting is that bad, but it's certainly not as alluring as Evening Star in my playlist. It only works for a very specific mood.

Here's a spicy one, I encourage that any who reply try to elaborate rather than just picking one or the other

he used to make vaporwave and replica has some vaporwave ish sounds on it, so I just decided to throw in R+7 and GoD too

I can respect that, I don't think it's a bad album but Evening Star is a masterpiece. Also RiL by miles for me. There's something so strange and otherworldly about RlL that just keeps me keeping back. It's catchy, it's fun, it's esoteric, it's eccentric, it covers a wide variety of moods. I used to think it was overrated but with every listen it only rises higher on my rating system. It's at a 9.2 now and will probably only go up
gotcha. Ya you're right Replica's easily the best one. That's pretty much the be all end all for OPN's discog for me

Popol vuh a best

last one I'm posting, really pushing that obscurity factor now

Mezzanine