Define a genre with 4 albums

I start.

Post Punk

Other urls found in this thread:

rateyourmusic.com/genre/Post-Punk/
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

-Closer (Or Unknown Pleasures for that matter, just not 2 Joy Division albums)

+Entertainment!

Also, made one for "Indie" Rock.

Post-Punk for the cool kids
(Swans - Children of God could also be in this chart)

garbage

>2 albums from the same band

OP here

Good chart m8

Kill yourself.

Better, but having both Pere Ubu and The Pop Group seems slightly redundant. Swap out the latter for something by Chrome or This Heat

This chart is better than Stop trying this hard.

Post-punk for tryhards

>tryhards
back to plebbit

Death metal

please tell me whats wrong with being a tryhard?

Fuck off poser

Fuck off pleb

>how dare you strive to find interesting music

Get out

I would do it differently
Gang of Four - Entertainment
Sioxsie and the Banshees - Juju
This Heat - Deceit
The Chameleons - Script of the Bridge

Fuck off contrarian

I actually thought about Deceit while making that chart

Consider suicide.

Fuck off drone

>no wire
Bad!

Only two of these are actually Post-Punk, and these are by the same band.

"Noise" Rock

Post-Hardcore

this desu

Fucking stop you're really bad at this

Thats all the same genre. Rock.

He says define a genre by using 4 albums
Not define genres that have only 4 albums u dummy

>no 154
>no Real Life

so many plebs in here

Shoegaze is Loveless, Souvlaki, Nowhere and...
Whats the fpurth album?

Guilty of Everything

Sweet Trip - VDC

How about Jesu's S/T or another more modern album? It's important to have both the origins and the evolutions when looking at a genre.

I would replace Entertainment! with Unknown Pleasures and Metal Box with Remain In Light and you're good to go.

Television is not post-punk, and it's pointless to have two albums by the same band in such a versatile subgenre of music.

>no Minutemen

eat shit

>this thread

Hip hop.

((Im not certain about my choices, I considered switching out a couple)

I have no idea what I'm doing
sludge

JAZZ

Are you guys making these bad on purpose as satire?

I wish all of you non-jazz fan dickheads would stop discussing this album.

Most of you probably listen to Radiohead, Wilco, or some other 4 chord rock. Or hip-hop. Or K-pop. Or whatever shit you like - it's all boring to me. You have no right to talk about jazz, especially not anything bebop or free jazz related. If you dislike this album so much, you shouldn't be fucking listening to it in the first place, should you? Fuck off, and get out of my face.

>not putting Pink in a noise rock chart

Holy shit what a pleb

>bitches brew
nice

t. p4k drone

>The Epic
>Kind of Blue
Listen to more jazz, you fucking faggot.

That's a shit chart, there's no need for 2 Joy Division albums
You just picked the top 4 albums from
rateyourmusic.com/genre/Post-Punk/
didn't you?

>Television is not post-punk
It is. Just listen to the sound and the lyrics.

I'd do
>Unknown Pleasures
>Marquee Moon
>This Modern Dance
>Chairs Missing
My favourite Post Punk albums would be a different story though

At least try to form your own tastes and opinion, OP

Would get rid of the bottom two for maybe an Outkast album (for the South sound) or Wu Tang/A Tribe Called Quest.

SONIC YOUTH IS NOT NOISE ROCK GODDAMIT AT LEAST PUT SOMETHING THAT ACTUALLY HURTS TO LISTEN

You dont get rid of madvillainy. No fucking way. And Outkast shouldnt be in the discussion. Either Wutang or ATCQ

"Music"

In terms of 'defining a genre' Madvillainy is a bad choice.

If this were just putting in the 4 best albums then sure. But it's not. Outkast symbolizes a huge part of the sound of hip hop.

This

noise rock

I was actually considering swapping Madvillainy for Stankonia and Illmatic for either Midnight Marauders or 36 Chanbers

I think they're supposed to be good albums dude

>4 rock albums define all of music
i'm not even one of those faggots who complain about "rockists" but literally what

they are

I dunno, looks right to me.

industrial rap

...

>2 Miles
>K Baitington
We should really consider Jazz subgenres
Fusion:
-Bitches Brew
-Red Clay
-Head Hunters
-Karma

>populism
(You) earned this one, bud.

rym drone

sporkcore

>industrial hip-hop
>clipping and pop-era death grips
>fucking yeezus
wow you really do know your shit pal

thanks man

>No West-Coast Hip hop

Oh boy. You fucked up.

Isn't that what the thread is?

>muh 2pac
>muh NWA
>muh Dre/Snoop

Fuck off.

Industrial metal

>Defining a genre while leaving out 1/3 of the sound.

3 East-Coast Rap albums is stupid.

god i hate this pepe stop posting him

...

It's a great album, but no that does not represent the genre as a whole.

Hiphop is a wide genre. Having three east coast albums doesn't really represent the genre as a whole, which is what this thread is supposed to be about.

Post Rock

Didn't put any Swans because of reasons.

Whirlpool

Horrorcore

Juggalo

Duran Duran- Rio
XTC- English Settlement
The Cure- Disintegration
The Human League- Dare

New Wave

Fuck off embryo

Vaporwave

>no EARL

whats the bottom right one?

what's the last one?

>no eccojams
what the fuck are you even d o i n g

Do Make Say Think - Winter Hymn Country Hymn Secret Hymn

Learn2google

>tfw I'm literally listening to Wilco right now after having listened to Radiohead

the perfect prescription

>putting that piece of shit vaportrap album on there
>instead of eccojams

End yourself.

fake and gay

should've had Ornette

you guys got le joked

>eccojams was literally made as a joke album
wew

Kill yourself my dude
Washington is the memest jazz musician of all time

does it matter?