Was his character a better drummer than Neil Peart and John Bonham?
Was his character a better drummer than Neil Peart and John Bonham?
Luis Wright
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtu.be
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
drummerworld.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
Kevin Carter
no
Brody Morris
No.
Logan Hernandez
>neil peart is good meme
Brandon Phillips
>Neil Peart
No, Neil is an immensely talented and highly trained drummer specialized in his style. It's very difficult to play like him with as much power with as much consistency and accuracy live.
>John Bonham
Technically, yes. Bonham isn't a technical genius, what Bonham had was groove, feel, and power. But there were a lot of drummers that could do more than him stylistically. It's also not that hard to learn how to play like Bonham (Except nobody can really match his power).
There's your answer.
Dominic Hughes
Nice bait
Joshua Wood
On top of that
>buddy rich is the ultimate meme
You know who one of the legitimately best drummers of all time is, Phil Rudd.
Isaac Johnson
He wasn't even good enough for his amateur college band. The teacher kicked him out.
Hunter Harris
most jazz dummers are better than memes like neil peart
Nicholas Anderson
I just came here to say this movie is pure awesome reality. This is it, folks. If you want another one like this, watch Moneyball
Austin Wright
Buddy Rich IS a meme but there are so many valid reasons why he's considered the greatest of all time. Influentially and technically. If you do some research on how he played and how he was different you can see that he was beyond so many other people, it wasn't just speed.
Julian Thomas
Only when you compare like for like. He wasn't a pro or anything. Better than a rock drummer of his own calibre sure, and a professional jazz drummer will usually outclass Neil Peart, but in this case it's not really a fair comparison.
Nathan Gonzalez
Joseph Brooks
Zach Hill
Alexander Cox
Wasn't the whiplash guy already hanging with the best?
Elijah Williams
reminder that drummers are the dumbest musicians
Aaron Perez
Neil Peart has more artistic creativity with rhythm than most highly skilled jazz drummers. Every Rush song that you will listen to is a very individual and catchy drum track that stands on it's own merit. Not to mention Neil has a lot more influence from traditional African rhythms than a lot of drummers, kind of like Ginger Baker.
Most modern "jazz drummers" will usually just play really fast and do some flashy 1 handed drum rolls here and there or maybe play some complex time signatures. It's all nice and smooth but it's also really really really fucking boring once you are used to it.
It's not just about being fast and capable of highly technical "moves".
Jace Watson
I can't think of a bigger drumming meme than Zach Hill at the moment. He's every 16 year old Sup Forums kids answer as the "best drummer". Kind of like how that drummer from blink 182 was "the best drummer" in the early 2000s.
Carter Hall
Alright, but was he better on drugs than Moon?
Luke Moore
Apples to oranges. Repertory jazz drummers aren't improvising their parts or really doing anything creative like drummers in popular music do.
Levi Cruz
Why are the drum tracks on DG studio albums so boring compared to the live stuff?
Alexander Reed
Drumming doesn't actually require talent
William Diaz
>leave drumkino to me
Austin Ross
now where did this meme come from?
Evan Powell
she has mediocre looks except for her perfect tits
Jackson Lee
This. I always preferred Damon Che anyway.
Luis Phillips
On a technical level most top tier jazz drummers are of equal or better level than Neil Peart. Its just that Neil has the advantage of know his band's repertoire inside-out and similar skills of memorizing written drum parts.
Jazz drummers might be more used to the spontaneous nature of improvisation that trying to play a drum part the exact same every time might not come as easy, but really they can play rhythms of similar competency on the cuff anyways.
Anthony Baker
How would Sup Forums rate John "Drumbo" French?
Adam Ramirez
I agree with you, I'm just tired of the meme especially inside of a meme as fuck movie.
Liam Bennett
the only correct answer is Billy Cobham
Asher Campbell
this
Jack Johnson
Reality
Matthew Price
I like Philty Animal (rip)
Kevin Butler
I like Jack White's drumming, but the baby's first drum beat shit Meg was doing in the White Stripes fit that shit well.
6:12 for this nigger's drumming
youtu.be
Kevin Jenkins
complete travis barker meme drummer of the decade
Jaxon Russell
Dave Grohl
Gabriel Kelly
>leBonhamtripletface.tif
fuck outta here with that shit
James Flores
I don't know if he or Kurt wrote the Nirvana drum parts, but I cannot stand how stiff and lifeless he is in that band. He would use the same one drumfill for an entire song
Thomas Butler
>He would use the same one drumfill for an entire song
He probably wrote the drum tracks, but he still does the same fill for every song. Queens of the Stone Age, Tenacious D, , every fucking time Bonham triplets.
Sebastian Torres
You're an immensely retarded faggot. Please go back to your mother's basement and kill yourself you pathetic piece of shit.
Levi Bennett
Piano is the patrician, scholar, educated man's instrument.
Jaxon Allen
This desu
Jason Ross
the best part of was the keyboard at the end desu
so you're right
Jackson Wright
lmao stay angry friend
Wyatt Wood
>>John Bonham
>
>Technically, yes. Bonham isn't a technical genius, what Bonham had was groove, feel, and power. But there were a lot of drummers that could do more than him stylistically. It's also not that hard to learn how to play like Bonham (Except nobody can really match his power).
I agree. A great example would be Dave Grohl, IMO. Although I think he's a great drummer, his style is basically John Bonham Lite.
Chase Roberts
Wrong. John Bonham only ever had 2 mics on his drum kit, because he could dictate the volume while playing. Nobody does that.
Liam Hill
Dave Ghrol is not even close to Bonham in style. Dave Ghrol is mediocre standard alt-rock drumming.
How does that make me wrong? It seems like you are just proving my post right. Power and feel.
If you read interviews about Bonham's style he could bring out a hefty sound in any drumset including his son's kid set. He even broke Bill Ward's drumset when jamming with Sabbath.
Noah Moore
who here /StewartCopeland/??
Luis Richardson
what the goddamn fuck is this shit ?
Asher Morales
...
Ayden Peterson
Thomas Parker
COOP3RDRUMM3R
Connor Miller
>He even broke Bill Ward's drumset when jamming with Sabbath.
Holy shit, I didn't know about that kek
Isaac Sullivan
Rock drummers wish they could drum with this much precision, finesse, and intricacy.
Austin Thompson
Rock drummers wish they could drum with this much precision, finesse, and intricacy.
Brayden Kelly
You're an idiot. He used only two mics on a few tracks because it led to the sound he wanted. He wasn't some magical fairy wizard drummer.
Angel Harris
>I can't think of a bigger drumming meme than Zach Hill
Joey Jordison
Christopher Morales
keith fucking moon
Hunter Diaz
Rock drummers wish they could drum with this much precision, finesse, and intricacy.
Aiden Watson
He's a god.
Not only did he play all the weird anti-rhythmic stuff Beefheart wanted him to, but he also translated all of Don's musical ideas into actual notation for the other band members to use. Don wasn't really a musician, so he couldn't do it himself.
Jose Kelly
I think it's because in the studio he mostly drums along with Andy's production (except in NOTM, where he's actually playing the beats). Live he improvises more.
Dylan Rogers
The amazing thing about Buddy Rich is that he almost always wore a suit when he played. Drummers today are half his speed even without wearing restrictive clothing.
Aaron Morales
He couldn't even keep in time, it became a meme
Anthony Gomez
take this discussion to Sup Forums pls
Andrew Barnes
>or really doing anything creative like drummers in popular music do
You sound like you've never heard a jazz drummer doing anything at all, considering that's all rock drummers listened to
Asher Murphy
suck my dick
Eli Russell
>Drummers today are half his speed even without wearing restrictive clothing.
Quite literally.
youtube.com
Eat shit, cunt.
Connor Martinez
awesome Jazz/Fusion drummer thread time?
youtube.com
Luke Lee
Yeah, Bonham was a beast
The overall sound from the drums, specially from the bass drum, was insane
Justin Fisher
Pic and link related
youtube.com
Caleb Jackson
>being this big of a pleb
Kill yourself.
Adam Phillips
holy shit yes
Zachary Davis
I fucking love Jon Theodore. He's the best thing about early Mars Volta.
Ethan Perry
This is one of the many reasons I want a new QotSA album. Jon only wrote one drum track on ...Like Clockwork. I want to hear some new shit from that crazy bastard.
Cameron Kelly
Anthony Martinez
Same. A QOTSA album full of his work will be fucking great, I'm sure.
Jackson Butler
forgot the master youtube.com
Samuel Watson
Who /artblakey/ here?
Caleb Richardson
>drummers can literally be replaced by computers and no one can tell the difference
What a shitty instrument.
Parker Sanchez
2/10
Nathan Gutierrez
(you)
Gavin Rogers
how late is too late to get into drumming?
Jordan Morales
you can replace literally every instrument by computers you fucking retard
Cameron Taylor
It's never too late, anonfam.
Grayson Roberts
>this is what dumb people think
Easton Long
Thiz iz not true, bythaway
Christopher Green
yes. those guys are shitty meme drummers
Leo Evans
Too late to be one of the greats? Maybe, depending on your age. But it's never too late to learn an instrument, and I recommend that everyone does so at some point in their life. Play whatever the hell you want, it's one of the most satisfying hobbies out there.
Hunter Baker
Where do I even start?
Evan Rodriguez
what instrument ?
Andrew Flores
Well you're gonna need a drum probably
Jeremiah Anderson
What do you call a guy who always hangs out with a bunch of musicians?
a drummer
Elijah Diaz
>drumming with two hands
>good
talk about easy mode
Noah Adams
>beating your wife with two hands
>good
He showed how to do that hard mode too.
Anthony Garcia
Please fuck off. He's not a better drummer than John Bonham you fucking cocksucker
Adam Hill
Oh, I see you were born in the wrong generation too!!!
Camden Sanders
Drumming God Ginger Baker speaking the truth about shitty drummers
WARNING: THIS WILL TRIGGER ZEPKEKS
youtube.com
Logan Rogers
best drummer itt tbqhwyfam
Jacob Martin
>the truth
Baker is a senile jazz purist asshole
Ayden Mitchell
baker jelly as fk lmao