They both went about it the wrong way, but who had the right idea?

They both went about it the wrong way, but who had the right idea?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/gy7tipWusyY?t=11m9s
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

The Captain. Stark was such an emotionally unstable driven cuck in this movie.

I hate capeshit but I enjoyed it.

who gives a shit?

Seriously who puts this much thought into watered down filler Marvel movies? Who cares? You saw Spider-Man shoot some webs and you saw Captain America throw some punches. Stop trying to deconstruct the movie, it's embarrassing.

Zemo

This guy does:

Tony

Cap, the government only fucks shit up and a hero revealing themselves would only put them and their family in danger. They don't reveal the identity of spies or special ops soldiers for this reason.

Tony was right, but for the wrong reasons. Steve was wrong, but for (relatively) more admirable reasons.

literally the only reason anyone got off their ass in this movie is because a personal death motivated them..even the fucking villain

>letting the government tell you what to do because some normies got the shaft

Cap all the way. Tony is just acting like a pussy liberal coward by trying to give up his rights whenever something bad happens. In a war against criminals, aliens and supervillains, did they really expect there to be no collateral damage? Do they really think government registration will put an end to collateral damage? Registration will make them more accountable apparently. But then what, will Scarlett Witch face manslaughter charges for accidentally killing those people? How will putting her in a cell help anyone? Half the avengers work for the government in some shape or form anyway, so its not like signing some accords will change anything. SHIELD already knows all their identities.

If a superhero starts killing innocents then registering them won't make a difference because by then, they would be super villains, and they don't care about the law. Registration is just a futile attempt to control something that can't be controlled.

The jew who makes these

What was the point anyway? The danger of civilian casualties will always be there, Stark just wanted to have the "well the government sanctioned this" card to fall back to for the next time someone inevitably dies during a fucking alien invasion or super AI lifting a whole city in the air and crushing it down. Like what would change if the countries agreed to the operations? The enemies would be less threatening? The aspiring world-conquering villains would be less deadly?

That's the common theme. Everyone wants vengeance for what they've lost and they want the ones responsible to pay the price.

Who would honestly think Cap was wrong? National leaders do way more damage to their people than the Avengers ever do.

Thank god the avengers were directly and personally involved otherwise they would just watch that shit on the news while sitting on the couch bantering apparently.

Hey man, if you cant stop flying invading alien leviathans with absolutely 0 casualties maybe you should just stay at home, ok?

I literally cannot see why anybody would ever side with captain america

Whoops, fixed the link. These guys get Tony's bullshit.

youtu.be/gy7tipWusyY?t=11m9s

Ironman was right that he himself needed to be put in check. Cap was right in the big picture.

That is why it should have been an Avengers movie.

They also were thwarted in an attempt to nuke the city. topkek, you don't need anymore reason for why Cap was right

Cap. The only motivation Tony had was muh registration, which would put the jurisdiction over superheroes on bureaucrats who would use them for their own interests and corrupt their entire point of being there to serve the interests of the citizens.

Iron Man's point of view: If we don't have restrictions, we're no different than bad guys

Cap's point of view: muh friend dindu nuffin

>that Stevie Rogers

Stay in your lane.

obviously cap'n america was right

they didn't need to be put in check like that, certainly not by a corrupt world govt -- if the government of mcu is anything like ours

if heroes can't operate outside the law then it makes little sense. that's also why i found superman being brought to court a bit funny

norway got it right

Tony was right.Apply Caps logic to religious extremists and ask yourself if it still applies.