Is a 6.5/10 from Scaruffi a good score?

Is a 6.5/10 from Scaruffi a good score?

why do you care?

Because he gave that score to my favorite album

>takes critics that seriously
lurk moar fledgling

10=best ever; 9=a masterpiece; 8=buy it now;
7=buy it eventually; 6=buy it if you are a fan

so yeah kinda

Ratings: 10=best album ever; 9=rock masterpiece; 8=buy it now; 7=buy it eventually; 6=buy it if you are a fan

yes

Yeah, there are a lot of great 6.5 albums

5/10 is an average

yeah it actually is, as others have posted it means he thinks it is good enough that if you already like the artist it is worth your money.

>taking scaruffi seriouly

Hate him or not when he rates an album 9 or more it's usually a masterpiece

more like over an 8 is a masterpiece

Less than half of them are, that's not really a good track record...what's much more interesting is going through individual years and picking out some of the gems in the 7-8 range

What the fuck type of bullshit rating system is this?

what's wrong with it?

stop caring about scaruffi nothing he says about music matters

What is your problem

a good one

same thing, same second, one digit from eachother
wow

when there's a shit ton of music and you're using a critic to figure out what to listen to... it does exactly what you need

Sup Forums is a hivemind

My god..